Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry I'll be sacked for being sick

64 replies

Rosebel · 14/12/2021 22:55

Where I work if you are unable to come to work due to illness you (as in employee) must phone in and speak to a manager.
In itself this is a reasonable request except sometimes it isn't.
I have a rotten cold at the moment and had Monday and today off as I had totally lost my voice and speaking to customers is a big part of the job.
As my voice was totally gone my DH had to phone them for me which he did. Email this afternoon off my manager asking how I was and would I be in tomorrow. I replied I would even though I'm still rough and quite horse.
He responded and then said in my welcome back there will be an issue as I didn't follow the sickness policy (because I didn't ring up). I explained again that I'd lost my voice and just got a reply saying we'll discuss it tomorrow.
I'm really worried about it now and scared it'll be classed as gross misconduct meaning they can sack me.
I understand why the policy is there but surely common sense should be applied. If someone has lost their voice how can they phone in sick? Are they being unreasonable to give me a hard time? Would they sack me for this reason?

OP posts:
Asi1 · 16/12/2021 07:56

@Pamsresearch

No they won't sack you, but it's right that they have a discussion about the policy not being followed. Do people really ever lose their voice to the extent they couldn't make a short croaky phonecall?
Yes they do. I lost myself and couldn't say anything.

Its harmful to try and force it out and can do long term damage.

eurochick · 16/12/2021 07:54

I've completely lost my voice a number of times. Couldn't even croak. I suppose I could have video called and used interpretative dance to communicate. Luckily I have never worked somewhere with such a rigid policy.

Benjaminsniddlegrass · 16/12/2021 07:53

How ridiculous, when I lose my voice I literally lose it like I can't make a sound and that lasts about a week until it gradually comes back and I sound like a teenage boy with my voice breaking. Luckily I can just whats app my manager because we're grown ups and sensible and all they need to know is I'm not going to be in, when I think I'll be returning and what needs covering in my absence.
I manage a team and don't mind how they communicate with me as long as they do.

Cotswoldmama · 16/12/2021 07:37

They won't sack you for one incident, they might give you counselling about following procedure but you would very reasonably say you had lost your voice. I don't work in a supermarket but somewhere similar it's hard to sack someone even when they consistently don't follow procedures!

icedcoffees · 16/12/2021 07:27

I think I worked for the same supermarket you work for, judging by the language.

By an "issue" all your manager means is that they have to document that you didn't follow procedure and why.

I used to work with fresh food and once rang in sick in the morning (I wasn't due to start until 4pm) to say I wouldn't be in that day as I'd been throwing up. I was told it was too early to tell if I was too unwell to work and to ring back later Hmm

I did ask if they really wanted someone who was vomiting to handle fresh produce and they just said "you need to ring back within two hours of your shift to confirm you're not coming in". Hmm

Billandben444 · 16/12/2021 07:25

Your manager may well tell you your sickness record to date - have you no idea how often you've been off over 3 years? - but should only remind you of the phoning in process. For future reference, perhaps phone in yourself as soon as you're able to. I worked for the council and, as a manager, followed what were rather draconian sickness rules but they did deter the 'long-weekenders'.

PhilCornwall1 · 16/12/2021 07:08

They shouldn't if it's not something you do every time you are off sick. I've got someone in my team about to be issued with a final written warning for not phoning in, but they are a persistent offender and just refuse to do it.

The next time it happens, they won't be coming back.

Offmyfence · 16/12/2021 06:50

@Pamsresearch

No they won't sack you, but it's right that they have a discussion about the policy not being followed. Do people really ever lose their voice to the extent they couldn't make a short croaky phonecall?
Not in my experience they don't!
Theresomethingaboutdairy · 16/12/2021 06:36

All that will happen is you will have your ‘welcome back,’ there are quite a few tick boxes on it. They may tick that you didn’t follow procedure but then will write down the reasons why. You will then be asked if they can do anything to support your return to work etc and then told either no further action or you will he invited to an AR (absence review.) An AR is only conducted if your sickness is over 3% of your contracted (not flexi/overtime) hours over a 26 week period and/or if you have had 3 or more occasions of sickness in the last 26 weeks. If either of these scenarios apply to you you may get a warning at the AR. Really nothing to worry about, there are processes that need following and you will not lose your job if this is a one-off.

OnGoldenPond · 15/12/2021 13:09

In all the sickness policies I have seen in contracts the reporting requirements give a mode of reporting and deadline to report "unless not reasonably practicable". Having lost your voice should count as a reasonable excuse for not being able to follow the usual procedure in this case as you can't be expected to communicate by phone! Would love to see your manager trying to argue this point in a tribunal, he would be laughed at.

There needs to be this exception clause for the sickness policy to be held reasonable. After all, would anyone expect someone who is unconscious in hospital after being run over by a bus to pick up the phone and ring in sick ?? Confused

Fairyliz · 15/12/2021 12:41

Go in and have a long conversation with him. Hopefully you are still a bit infectious and will give it to him.
He started it by being a dick.

Cheerbear24 · 15/12/2021 12:25

I l’ost my voice last week with tonsillitis for 3 full days. Nothing came out at all not even a squeak. I’m still very hoarse, but most of soreness has gone. I think they’re nit picking if they pursue this with you.

CheesyFootballsAreEvil · 15/12/2021 12:20

@dropitlikeitsloth that is disgusting

YummieMummyof3 · 15/12/2021 10:55

Hi I used to work for a supermarket where you had.to phone in and speak to a team manager, when you are sick. I remember phoning in sick and spoke to a team leader as there was no managers available. There were some unhelpful comments in my return to work meeting.
If it's the supermarket I used to work for, there is a helpline you can phone to speak about any issues.
Hope y you feel better soonFlowers

dropitlikeitsloth · 15/12/2021 10:46

@CheesyFootballsAreEvil

What's their policy if you're interested coma or emergacy surgery?
If it’s anything like my old workplace, a colleague was disciplined for not calling in by 10am when she had been taken up to hospital in an ambulance and that the absolute truth.
CheesyFootballsAreEvil · 15/12/2021 10:36

What's their policy if you're interested coma or emergacy surgery?

dropitlikeitsloth · 15/12/2021 10:26

@LittleGwyneth

I cannot imagine what kind of workplace would fire someone who was good at their job because they reported their illness the wrong way. But then I can't imagine what sort of jobsworth manager would be such an arsehole as to set rules around how you report your own illness. Hire adults, treat them like adults.
I agree where I work now you just text your Team Leader, we are treated like adults and so behave as adults. My previous job used to keep you chatting for like 15 minutes while you’re ill, who has the energy? They don’t actually get any extra information by calling, it’s just done to check up on you.
LittleGwyneth · 15/12/2021 10:19

I cannot imagine what kind of workplace would fire someone who was good at their job because they reported their illness the wrong way. But then I can't imagine what sort of jobsworth manager would be such an arsehole as to set rules around how you report your own illness. Hire adults, treat them like adults.

flowerycurtain · 15/12/2021 10:18

I'm an employer and have this policy and would do exactly the same as your manager (although I wouldn't have emailed you). If your absence history is fine i would just reiterated the policy but say of course I understand you couldn't speak etc and it's fine.

If however you have a history of doing this and using your husband to get out of talking to me then I would be quizzing you a bit on it and possibly going to a disciplinary.

Managers (mostly) aren't stupid. I can normally tell when my staff are taking the piss. The policy is there to enable those taking the piss to be weeded out. Hopefully you are genuine and not
One of them.

Rosebel · 15/12/2021 10:12

@Theresomethingaboutdairy

Do you work for a well known supermarket OP? I only ask as you use the term ‘welcome back’ and, if this is the case, I can advise.
I do work for a well-known charity supermarket although I don't want to say which one but one of the big 4.
OP posts:
MissCruellaDeVil · 14/12/2021 23:47

Do you have a copy of your organisations absense policy?

lanthanum · 14/12/2021 23:37

Perhaps the next thing will be that if you've lost your voice, you have a zoom call so that they can see you trying to speak...

SequinsandStiIettos · 14/12/2021 23:23

I would have croaked or done a Tom Hardy in Batman and had DH interpret. As it is, what's done is done and if you are obviously croaky tomorrow then it should be clear you were genuine.

Starcaller · 14/12/2021 23:22

I lost my voice recently for the first time ever! I could make a weird frog sound but couldn't say a sentence. I had a phone appointment with GP and DH had to ring them to cancel. It was v weird! Only lasted a day thankfully.

DeepaBeesKit · 14/12/2021 23:21

I've lost mine a couple of times to the extent I could only whisper.

If you can breathe you should be able to whisper but tbf I dont know how well this would be heard down the phone.

It's an OTT policy but the reason they expect the individual to ring themselves is to prevent situations where someone has gone off on holiday etc and left a friend calling in sick for them. I think the key is always to attempt to call in, and follow up with a text or email if you really can't make yourself heard.

They probably are just being dicks and trying to scare you though. I don't think you can get the sack for one day sick.

Swipe left for the next trending thread