Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To fucking HATE bunions

117 replies

Pinkglitterglue · 14/12/2021 22:21

NC

Not really an AIBU sorry just a rant AngryI have 2 bunions and I’m fed up of how painful they are. Has anyone ever had them operated on? How bad did they need to be and what was the operation process?

I’ve heard horror stories about the surgery and was adamant I would never want it but my feet are throbbing every day and I’m waking up during the night with the pain now

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
NotaMary · 19/12/2021 08:35

I had both feet done at the same time on NHS via a private clinic. They were sore everyday and it was definitely worth it. I do get a wee bit of an ache after several miles of walking but never enough to even comment upon. Having feet done together was definitely preferable - one recovery time and (having concerns due to a very bad back) I was not tilting my pelvis while recovering as I was wearing 2 boots. Interestingly, my feet went up half a size when my toes straightened.

PerseverancePays · 19/12/2021 08:27

@WakeyWakey123

The root cause of problems like this is nearly always unresolved emotional issues. What’s been going on in your life OP?
Ha! Ha! ha! You need to water it down dear. Bunions are a predominantly European genetic fault.
WakeyWakey123 · 19/12/2021 08:18

The root cause of problems like this is nearly always unresolved emotional issues. What’s been going on in your life OP?

pinknsparkly · 19/12/2021 08:15

Do it!! I had mine done at 25 and 26 (each foot done separately) as I was in permanent pain and it was gradually getting worse. A lady admitted for surgery on the same day as me had both feet done at once so she only had one period of recovery, but that wasn't an option discussed with me. It was a fairly long recovery period and even now, a decade later, I sometimes get random shooting pains in the area. The surgeon also said that due to my age I'm likely to need the surgery repeating when I'm about 50/60ish. But honestly it changed my life as I couldn't do anything other than struggle through work each day loaded up on painkillers and then collapse on the sofa and not move all evening!

Aprilx · 19/12/2021 08:10

@Pinkglitterglue

Fully prepared to be told I’m being OTT/ unreasonable as I know it’s a tiny bump compared to some bunions! Honestly though it’s so painful anytime things touch or bump off it and it’s agony to walk on. I’m a shoe size 4 and giving it more space by wearing a size 5 didn’t help the pain either

Also excuse the black and white and the red lines over it- I have some patchy leftover fake fan and no amount of scrubbing is taking it off my feet🤣 had to draw over it

I have had bunions for quite a few years now, I would say mine are similar to yours, with yours being ever so slightly more pronounced.

I have never tried to get referred for surgery on NHS, but after doing some research, I don’t expect that I would be deemed severe enough for surgery, I could be wrong but I got the impression it was very much a last resort. I only know one person that has had surgery and that was enough to put me off, it looked awful to go through.

Have you tried anything else, like bunion socks at night? I have from time to time and it makes a little difference but hard to keep up on doing it long term.

LizzieSiddal · 19/12/2021 08:00

Explodingeyes your right bunion is how mine looked, and they were so painful.

HRT has been like a miracle for me, I didn’t want to take it as believed all the “it causes cancer” nonsense. I did a lot of reading (Dr Louise Newson’s website is so informative) and made the decision to try HRT.
Within weeks hot flushes had almost disappeared and I was getting 6/7 hours of uninterrupted sleep. Within a few months bunions had stopped hurting and I was much less achy and stiff, all over.

My only regret is not trying it years ago when all these awful symptoms started!

explodingeyes · 19/12/2021 00:25

Very interesting as mine have developed as I've hit menopause & hot flushes. @LizzieSiddal
I've always had vv wide feet.working at home with no shoes on also

To fucking HATE bunions
LizzieSiddal · 18/12/2021 23:57

I had bunions develop in my late 40s, they were so painful especially in the evening.

When I was 55 I went on HRT for severe hot flushes and working 3 months my bunion pain had completely gone. I was able to wear flip flops this summer which I hadn’t been able to do for years, as I was so afraid of the bunions hitting something.
I know this doesn’t help you OP as you’re only young but thought it may help older posters.

DonttouchthatLarry · 18/12/2021 23:45

I had 2 operations for hallux rigidus - similar to bunions but the bony growth is on the top of the joint rather than the side. I'll admit the recoveries were painful but it's a short time compared to being in pain every single day. I never regret having mine done and can now hike/run for up to 12 hours pain free.

Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 18/12/2021 23:31

@Pinkglitterglue I had both feet done done. 5 years ago. Three months apart. Yours is bad too and will only get worse. The pain for me was stomach turning. It made me miserable. Do it! My feet are pain free, they look nice and it's the best decision I ever made!

1idea · 18/12/2021 23:19

I use ibuleve gel to reduce the pain if mine, it doesn’t solve the problem but it reduces the pain of walking.

Gingernaut · 18/12/2021 23:16

YANBU.

I have an assortment of issues with my feet and bunions are a symptom.

Even soft, fabric trainers hurt like hell.

The alternative is a series of operations which would cut some bones, straighten and fuse joints and try to lengthen others.

I couldn't cope with that level of pain and the recovery time would literally knock me off my feet for months.

Pinkglitterglue · 18/12/2021 23:10

@LeroyJenkinssss

Looking at your pic you’d qualify for NHS surgery. You have pain, a significant deformity and have tried orthotics. That’s it. That’s the criteria which I don’t feel is particularly strict.
I think I had just heard so many stories of people having to go private that I convinced myself the referral criteria was very strict! I totally see what you mean though.

Thanks (everyone) for the help! Another question, I currently play a sport which involves a lot of physical activity and puts pressure on the bunion. This isn’t the reason it hurts, as it has been sore even when I’ve had months off playing, but the sport definitely doesn’t help. Painkillers help take away the worst of the pain, but it’s still extremely sore especially when anything touches or bumps it. Does anyone know if this would affect treatment criteria? As much as my feet hurt, my sport is my entire life and I can’t give it up, I know I’ll be off my feet for months which is fine because it’s worth it if I can participate without being in agony. But I can’t quit long term. Would that affect whether they want to do the surgery, as I’m not going to quit the sport long term and would they just say the bunion will come back if I don’t quit? Hope that makes sense😂

OP posts:
MissMarplesGoddaughter · 17/12/2021 20:51

Has anyone had their toe joint fused at the same time as bunion surgery? Please could you tell me about it?

Evenstar · 17/12/2021 20:42

I qualified for NHS treatment, as I had tried non surgical treatment and had pain and the joint was becoming arthritic. What I say to anyone who asks is that it is painful, the recovery is longer than you would think but if you have already have pain every day then that is only going to get worse.

I had mine done at the end of June and was able to wear normal shoes again by the end of September, I do get pain but I have screws and a plate which will be staying in and the cold seems to affect the toe because of that, but is a bit achy rather than the pain and sore skin I had before. I have attached a picture of before and about 2 months afterwards.

To fucking HATE bunions
To fucking HATE bunions
Concestor · 17/12/2021 20:11

The hospital suggested to me that I have them done together. The surgeon said that because the recovery is hard, if people have one done first they tend not to go back for the second!
I was unable to do anything for about a month, my husband really had to step up, but it was ok and really worth it. I had them done getting on for ten years ago now and they've been trouble free ever since.

LeroyJenkinssss · 16/12/2021 08:50

Looking at your pic you’d qualify for NHS surgery. You have pain, a significant deformity and have tried orthotics. That’s it. That’s the criteria which I don’t feel is particularly strict.

Pinkglitterglue · 15/12/2021 20:48

@Fontella

I never thought I’d be posting a photo of it either🤣 sorry you’ve got it too but it’s great you’ve not got any pain, hopefully it stays that way!

@Pinkglitterglue
Loads of celebrities have got them too and I often wonder, why if you were loaded, wouldn't you have them done?

Iman for example suffers, as does Christina Hendrix, Amal Clooney, Oprah, Naomi Campbell, Tilda Swinton and loads more.

I came across an article recently - "50 celebrities with bunions" which I initially found a bit weird, but then I thought even the rich and famous have a problem that effects us mere mortals, and many of them choose not to have surgery.

I guess it comes down to the pain aspect. If they are painful then an individual, rich or famous or not, would be far more likely to opt for surgery than those who suffer little to no pain.

Yeah I agree! I always thought the same as you, if you can afford it why wouldn’t you just get it fixed?! But having said that, I would want to avoid surgery at all costs so I don’t blame them! They’re just so sore and uncomfortable. I think the NHS criteria for treatment is really strict and most cases don’t qualify Sad I definitely can’t afford for private treatment either! 😫 I wish there was something in between orthotics and surgery as even if I did qualify for it, I’d rather avoid time off work and don’t like the idea of surgery if I can avoid it, but the orthotics clearly aren’t working anymore. So annoying! 😫
OP posts:
Fontella · 15/12/2021 18:46

I never thought I’d be posting a photo of it either🤣 sorry you’ve got it too but it’s great you’ve not got any pain, hopefully it stays that way!

@Pinkglitterglue
Loads of celebrities have got them too and I often wonder, why if you were loaded, wouldn't you have them done?

Iman for example suffers, as does Christina Hendrix, Amal Clooney, Oprah, Naomi Campbell, Tilda Swinton and loads more.

I came across an article recently - "50 celebrities with bunions" which I initially found a bit weird, but then I thought even the rich and famous have a problem that effects us mere mortals, and many of them choose not to have surgery.

I guess it comes down to the pain aspect. If they are painful then an individual, rich or famous or not, would be far more likely to opt for surgery than those who suffer little to no pain.

Pinkglitterglue · 15/12/2021 18:27

@Fontella

Never, ever thought I'd post a pic of my bunions but what the hell!

I am very fortunate in that I have no pain, and they have never got worse. They are just there, and to be honest they don't really affect any footwear either. I don't like how they look, but other than that, I have no problem with them (fingers crossed it stays that way) but my mum suffered terribly with her feet and I do sympathise so much with people who experience pain.

I never thought I’d be posting a photo of it either🤣 sorry you’ve got it too but it’s great you’ve not got any pain, hopefully it stays that way!
OP posts:
Blueuggboots · 15/12/2021 03:11

This is 20 years post surgery.

To fucking HATE bunions
PupInAPram · 15/12/2021 03:07

@OneRuleForThem

Yes you are being totally unreasonable, everyone else loves having bunions on their feet? 🙄
Comes on clearly titled thread, drop's nasty response, satisfied with self at job well done. I'm so baffled by people like @OneRuleForThem who pop into threads just to spew negativity. What do they get out of it? I'm genuinely curious about their mental process.
Blueuggboots · 15/12/2021 03:03

I had mine done 20 years ago. Mine was only on 1 foot and was painful and unsightly.
What I didn't realise was the reason I had a bunion is because I over-pronate when I walk (my foot rolls inwards which is the cause of my bunion). - had I known this before surgery, I would have corrected my over-pronation with insoles as the bunion has come back.
6 weeks non-weight bearing in a cast and 6 weeks out of cast but reduced weight bearing.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/12/2021 02:45

Are you in plaster after having them done & how long are you off your feet?

I had a soft wrap and a stupid looking post op shoe. I walked out of the surgery center. Weeks 1 and 2 were rough very little walking and painkillers. After that everything started to not hurt as much. After 2 weeks I was was walking a couple of blocks and driving. I think I was in a normal flat shoe after 4 weeks, and there was still pain.

Months 1-4 better… unless I did something stupid. Normal shoes/low heels at about 5 months.

I can’t wear a 3 inch heel for any length of time to this day or my foot hurts, but weirdly am fine with a 2 1/2 or 3 1/2. Admittedly don’t wear 3 1/2 inch very often, but it doesn’t hurt.

I know I’m some rando on the internet, but you really have nothing to lose by getting the surgery, if you’re in pain now at worst you’ll have more pain for a short amount of time but if you don’t have the surgery you will always have pain.

Nat6999 · 15/12/2021 00:54

I've got really bad bunions & flat feet as well, I would love to have both sorted at the same time. I suffer from really bad back pain & my chiropractor told me that my back pain stems from the way I walk, my flat feet, knees turn in & my hips are very stiff, I have arthritis in all my joints. Are you in plaster after having them done & how long are you off your feet?

Swipe left for the next trending thread