Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To fucking HATE bunions

117 replies

Pinkglitterglue · 14/12/2021 22:21

NC

Not really an AIBU sorry just a rant AngryI have 2 bunions and I’m fed up of how painful they are. Has anyone ever had them operated on? How bad did they need to be and what was the operation process?

I’ve heard horror stories about the surgery and was adamant I would never want it but my feet are throbbing every day and I’m waking up during the night with the pain now

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
10
onedayatatime73 · 10/05/2022 23:26

Hi. My right foot was really bad. My left foot not so severe. But I couldn’t wear nice shoes anymore. Yes - you come out “walking”. But it’s not easy. My children were small at the time and my partner was working full time. I shuffled them to school but I paid for taxis to go to work. It wasn’t fun but I’ve never looked back. I love wearing nice shoes or even just flip flops. No pain and no embarrassment. X

lively101 · 10/05/2022 23:15

@onedayatatime73 really interested in your experience. Im 47 with two young kids, and have really bad bunions on both feet so had read about Dr Nowak. Im in Ireland and the surgeon I had an assessment with said he wouldn't do both feet together and doesn't do the surgery Dr Nowak does. Can I ask how bad were your bunions? My are what Id class as severe (dr said hed seen worse) and throb constantly, so I need something done. Id rather both together as Im really fearful i won't go back for 2nd AND I can't have too much down time as Im on my own with kiddies. appreciate any guidance you can give

junglejane66 · 31/12/2021 15:54

My uncle is a chiropodist and his favourite flavour of crisp is 'cheese and bunion'

MrsFizziwig · 31/12/2021 14:55

@onedayatatime73 Thanks! That's very helpful indeed.

onedayatatime73 · 30/12/2021 13:31

[quote MrsFizziwig]@onedayatatime73 Yes please do tell more about this alternative surgery. All the details you can remember about the surgery and recovery! Surely it can't be as easy as the DM article makes out.[/quote]
I had this done in 2015 and have not had a single problem since. It was a while ago obviously so I can't remember all the detail but that's probably a good sign. It's not quite as simple as the DM says. You don't exactly come out tap dancing but you do come out walking. I had both feet done at the same time under sedation. When I came out both big toes had a tiny thin (but solid) wire in them. I couldn't see the wire as both toes were bandaged. I was able to walk / shuffle. Imagine a solid wire down the length of your big toe. So you can walk but not flex. I had one week off work but was able to shuffle around the house. That week I had my feet up mainly and cool packs. After that week I was able to shuffle the children to school and back and I returned to work (but had to go by cab). If WFH was a thing then it would have been so much easier. I was mobile but you wouldn't be able to do a job that meant standing on your feet all day. After 4 weeks the wires were removed and after that recovery was pretty quick. It remained swollen for a while (I was convinced it hadn't worked and the bunions were still there). So even though I was then fully mobile and able to wear trainers and walk around as normal, visually it wasn't the perfect result I had imagined, but it was just the swelling (which is what they had told me). I had the op in September. By Christmas i was in normal shoes and by the new year I was back at Zumba / aerobics. I have never had any issues. The only thing I have ever felt is if I wade through sea water there's a funny tingle sensation. Not painful just a tingly feeling. It has made such a difference to my confidence in summer to be able to wear nice shoes and flip flops! My private health care covered for it if that's of any help. Happy to answer any more questions.

Snorkmaidenn · 30/12/2021 06:29

I had my right bunion operated on at 24. They broke my toe joint and reset it. Never had a problem with it since. Perfectly straight.
My left bunion was operated on NHS in my mid fifties. Was just a scrape and bunion is now 3 times the size.
I now need to have a pin placed in joint.
Surgeons do not use the old method I had many years ago, even though it gave a far better result.
I really hate the thought of a pin in my joint so that I won't have any movement.
Just a complete and utter cock up!

MrsFizziwig · 30/12/2021 06:05

@onedayatatime73 Yes please do tell more about this alternative surgery. All the details you can remember about the surgery and recovery! Surely it can't be as easy as the DM article makes out.

GetOffYou · 29/12/2021 15:58

That sounded like I was still walking the dog … I’m not! Friends and family are doing it Smile

massiveblob · 29/12/2021 15:46

That's promising! I've seen people with far worse than mine on here!

GetOffYou · 29/12/2021 15:15

@massiveblob
I’m doing ok.
Pain is becoming easier to manage daily, and am sleeping better now.
I hobble about (heel walk) on crutches only if I have to, but sit with it raised as much as possible.
I have borrowed a shower stool which makes showering easier.
I’m usually out with the dog for 2 good walks a day, so he’s feeling a bit neglected I think, (he is still getting one a day).
All in all, recovery is easier than I thought it would be, but it’s still very early days.

onedayatatime73 · 29/12/2021 14:51

I've just realised that the surgery I had is the one that @zurala is referring to in the daily Mail article. The surgeon i had was Dr Nowak but it sounds like the same procedure. And it worked a treat. Never regretted it or had any issues since. Considering going back to have my hammer toe treated!

onedayatatime73 · 29/12/2021 14:43

I had both bunions treated a few years ago. I spent ages researching the op and was concerned about the recovery. So I had mine done at a place called the European Foot Institute based near Brighton. The surgeon comes over from abroad every month - think he is from Germany. It's a completely different procedure to the one the NHS offer. I can't explain it properly so you would need to research this but they don't cut the bone at all. You come out of the surgery same day and walking on both feet (sore, but certainly manageable) and the recovery was swift compared to my understanding of the alternative. The last time I posted about it on MN I was flamed for not being able to describe it properly or say exactly how much it was but it was covered on my private health insurance so I couldn't remember exactly. Anyway. Happy to say more if helpful to anyone. Best thing I ever did. I was back at Zumba a few months later and wearing heels for the first time in years.

LeaningJade · 29/12/2021 09:36

@Pinkglitterglue my friends 15yo DD had surgery on both feet in the last 18months (one at a time). The surgery was the ones with pins inserted is all I know. The girl is a dancer and has now been allowed to go “en pointe” in ballet so I’d say the surgery, especially at a young age like you, is well worth it.

massiveblob · 29/12/2021 08:38

@GetOffYou how's your recovery? I'm watching as I do think I'll have to get mine done in a few years. I manage them now as the thought of 6 weeks not driving with two DC needing lifts places etc is a nightmare. DH can't do it all. I'm menopausal and think hormones are playing a part as well as too much time wearing slippers etc at home not my orthotics. I have those Clark's shoes.. loads of people who work all day on their feet do ! Eg nurses. So comfy

stayingaliveisawayoflife · 28/12/2021 20:12

I had both mine done one before my wedding and one after! I was awake for both surgeries as it was a quicker recovery time. It was a long recovery but I had mine done at the start of the summer holidays so had six weeks off work. I also drank lots of tonic water to help the cramps at night.

Figmentofmyimagination · 28/12/2021 19:34

Shout out for the Clark’s unstructured range, recommended by my physio. I have these: www.clarks.co.uk/c/Un-Loop/p/20312837?cm_mmc=PPC_SHOP_SMART_GOOGLE--G_UK_PS_dA_SHOP_SMART_Womens_Shoes--Smart+-+Womens+Shoes-_-PLA&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI6eDd6Z2H9QIV2-3tCh3DwQCnEAQYASABEgJXWfD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

I absolutely love them. And they look quite Scandi on. I have bunions but also developed acute pain from working from home in my slippers since March 2020. I now where these shoes (wide fit) all day long. No more pain. My bunions look bad but (touch wood) no pain from them. I’m 58.

Ladylunchalot · 28/12/2021 16:56

I had my bunion removed 22 years ago and I'm so glad I did. Recovery wasn't easy - was initially told I would be off work for 8 weeks but it ended up being 16 weeks.
My foot is lovely and straight although I still have the scar. My tendon(s) in my big toe fused and I have next to movement in it so putting on shoes can be fun!
I've also broken that big toe 3 times in the last 5 years due to taekwondo sparring which hasn't helped my already limited movement in that toe Hmm
Still glad I got it done though as the pain was awful.

Pinkglitterglue · 28/12/2021 16:40

@Fontella

For those with not too bad bunions, one thing does does help is instead of wearing slippers around the house, wear flip flops with a toe pole between middle and second toes.

I know it sounds daft but it really does help. My son has a bunion on his right foot and it can be painful from time to time, so I recently got him a pair of flip flops to wear indoors and they are such a good design (Dunlop) that the strap actually sort of presses on the bunion a little bit and sort of straightens it, if that makes any sense. It just holds it in a better position.

Anyway, the upshot is that he is getting a lot less pain since he's started wearing them.

I'm sure it wouldn't make any difference for severe bunions, but in our case it has proved helpful.

Hey that’s a really good idea actually! I’ve been wearing slider-style slippers but I’ll get some flip flops. Thanks so much Smile
OP posts:
Fontella · 27/12/2021 22:58

For those with not too bad bunions, one thing does does help is instead of wearing slippers around the house, wear flip flops with a toe pole between middle and second toes.

I know it sounds daft but it really does help. My son has a bunion on his right foot and it can be painful from time to time, so I recently got him a pair of flip flops to wear indoors and they are such a good design (Dunlop) that the strap actually sort of presses on the bunion a little bit and sort of straightens it, if that makes any sense. It just holds it in a better position.

Anyway, the upshot is that he is getting a lot less pain since he's started wearing them.

I'm sure it wouldn't make any difference for severe bunions, but in our case it has proved helpful.

HereLiesBetelgeuse · 26/12/2021 23:01

My 10yr old DD has bunions in both feet (hereditary from my DM) and I think they are quite bad but she swears blind they don't hurt! She has form for being very stoic so I am not so sure if they maybe do hurt.
Hers are worse than a few photos on here and better than others so it's hard for me to tell if she needs them sorted or not. I do know however that they will get worse not better.
We'd be going private not NHS

Sarahlou63 · 26/12/2021 22:30

Just popped on to say I’ll be 5 weeks post op tomorrow and today has been the first day when I’ve not really thought about or noticed my foot. There a great FB page called “I survived a bunionectomy” that’s very helpful (despite the often rather gruesome photos!).

usedtobeboss3 · 26/12/2021 21:07

I had both mine done over 30 years ago (I was about 15 at the time) and had to stay in hospital, bed-bound, for two weeks; then plaster and crutches for about 6 weeks, i think. Not had any trouble as such since, but I don't think my big toe joints are as flexible as they should be. I'm sure things have moved on since then though!

littlepeas · 26/12/2021 20:57

Have a look at toe spacers (correct toes) and barefoot shoes (Vivo barefoot is prob the best). ‘Supportive’ trainers are just as crap for your feet as most other shoes.

OutbackQueen · 26/12/2021 20:55

Had left one done 10 years ago (privately) and never looked back. It was really painful and kept me awake at night like you OP. Well worth it. The other one didn’t hurt so I left it alone and now I’m lop-sided. Wish. I’d had it done at the same time but now don’t have private health cover and would have to wait years to have it done on the NHS.

Swipe left for the next trending thread