Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say her cat can’t come for Christmas?

184 replies

OneRuleForThem · 14/12/2021 21:39

Someone who is invited for Christmas Day at mine has said they are being their kitten. This is not normal behaviour, right, asking to any pet owners? I don’t know much about pets but kittens can be left alone for much, much longer than puppies can, I think and would be ok for one single day by themselves if pre planned. I don’t understand why she want to bring it with her just because it’ll be Christmas Day. AIBU to say it can’t come I don’t want it ruining things? Haven’t replied yet.

OP posts:
AuntMargo · 15/12/2021 11:28

Absolutely not !

icedcoffees · 15/12/2021 11:13

@KittekatMP

Totally different for older cats, I have no problem leaving them overnight with someone popping in to feed them. That is very different from a small kitten you've only just got though.
Well, that kitten is nearly six now and she was absolutely fine on her own while we worked.

I do think many owners anthropomorphise their pets and then wonder why they can't be left or have behavioural issues.

Cats are not dogs. They're not companion animals who need taking to the toilet or walking regularly. They're absolutely fine by themselves for the most part.

Horriblewoman · 15/12/2021 11:12

Someone bringing their kitten for Christmas would be a dream come true for me!

We've taken ours to my parents a few times for Christmas and they are entirely unbothered by the change of scenery.

It is your house and your decision ultimately though

CheshireKitten123 · 15/12/2021 11:08

@OneRuleForThem

I text her and said no and have just recieved a reply saying I have ruined her entire Christmas, aibu to text back and say “and”? 😂 I’m just worried
I wouldn't reply, you're just encouraging her emotional blackmail.

If they are such a drama-llama just be glad they aren't coming !

TheCreamCaker · 15/12/2021 11:03

Cats generally like to be in their own environment. If left with food, water, dry food, somewhere warm and cosy to sleep, and a clean litter tray, a cat will be fine for a day.

Cat owner of 40+ years.

LindaEllen · 15/12/2021 10:58

My cat would hate to be taken to a strange house with strange people. She would much prefer being left at home to sleep, and would quite probably be in exactly the same position when we got home as she was when we left!

BungleandGeorge · 15/12/2021 10:42

Saying that you leave your fully grown cat for the entire day so she should leave a kitten is a bit like saying you leave your 24 year old so the 6 year old should be fine! If you take on a baby animal you need to look after it properly, but that’s not OPs responsibility. Personally think it’s far from ideal to leave an adult cat for a week with one visit a day. If they became ill, had an accident, had a fight potentially you wouldn’t know for 24 hours. That’s why some people get cameras I guess, to keep an eye on them.

KittekatMP · 15/12/2021 10:39

Totally different for older cats, I have no problem leaving them overnight with someone popping in to feed them. That is very different from a small kitten you've only just got though.

indiesearcher · 15/12/2021 10:34

Hmmm we took our kitten (4 months) to my in laws for Christmas once, but because we were there overnight and he seemed so little.

They were obviously fine with it and kitten seemed very happy indeed with all the fuss.

But it's your house and for one day I expect a 3 mo kitten would be fine at home.

icedcoffees · 15/12/2021 10:34

[quote Sunshineandflipflops]@icedcoffees When I go on holiday either my neighbour or mum pops in once a day and leaves fresh food/water so effectively she is alone for up to a week. She's always been fine when we've got back! This is why we've always had cats and not dogs![/quote]
Exactly!

I'm currently sitting for two cats who get one visit a day. I went in yesterday to feed them - one refused to come out from under the duvet and the other took a few minutes of fuss then fucked off Grin

Loyaultemelie · 15/12/2021 10:31

Just to say I have hand reared a kitten a few years ago who was unable to eat until 10 weeks and was still being hand fed tiny amounts of mousse at 12 weeks. I couldn't leave him for more than 2 hours because he was still bottle fed for the majority of his intake and needed help toileting, although I probably wouldn't have taken him anywhere I'd have just stayed home with him. I'm currently hand rearing a disabled kitten who is 6 weeks and can eat wet kitten food and "go" himself but can't lap so still needs a bottle, so again if we were planning to go anywhere we would have to cancel or take him if he was invited.

Snailhaterz2 · 15/12/2021 10:30

I've got a reasonably confident 7 month kitten who has spent a lot of time with me as I've worked from home since I got her, and I'd never do this. Every time I've taken her to the vet she's been unhappy in her carrier, reluctant to come out of it at the other end, and seriously cross by the time I've got her home. I've been away overnight a few times since I've got her and all the evidence is that she just ate, slept and played while I was away.

Prestel · 15/12/2021 10:22

*you said originally the kitten was 3 months, then changed that to no, she's had it 3 months because people were saying it's cruel to leave one so young.

I call bullshit*

Kittens are usually kept with the mother until 3 months, so if it's genuinely only 3mths old then the OPs friend would have only just adopted it and really shouldn't be taking it anywhere anyway as it's still getting used to its new home. The only solution in the case of a very young kitten would be for the friend to leave the kitten at home and shorten her visit to just an hour or two, so the OP isn't BU whichever age it is.

VestaTilley · 15/12/2021 10:09

Just tell her no. Kittens can be destructive, it’ll be fine if left for a few hours with plenty of food, water and a litter tray.

You don’t have to accommodate anyone else’s pet unless it’s a guide dog.

I have two DCats myself but I wouldn’t take them to anyone else’s house!

throwa · 15/12/2021 10:09

At 5/6 months they are absolutely fine to be left. We have always left ours from 8/9 weeks when we got them in the past (in the dim and distant past when people used to go to work in offices in the day time rather than working from home...)

A kitten shouldn't be going outside at this point as they may not be neutered yet, so so long as the litter tray is clean, they have water, have had a large breakfast and perhaps leave some dry biscuits down for them in case they fancy a lunch time snack, they will be absolutely fine until you return.

You may of course get some dirty looks from the cat for not being around... or they may not even notice.

icedcoffees · 15/12/2021 10:09

@user478932071

She should be able ti bring her young 3mth kitten, what’s the big deal?
Why should OP have to deal with the hassle of someone else's pet in her home?
Fatgalslim · 15/12/2021 10:04

you said originally the kitten was 3 months, then changed that to no, she's had it 3 months because people were saying it's cruel to leave one so young.

I call bullshit

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 15/12/2021 10:02

My family are happy to bring all of their pets to my house and mine to theirs, dogs cats, anything. When my DS stays for a week they always bring their cats and they are fine. I think a home without our animal friends isn't a home at all.

Hmumoftw0 · 15/12/2021 09:56

People are strange in 2021

LagunaBubbles · 15/12/2021 09:53

Is it a good friend?

ChampagneLassie · 15/12/2021 09:52

Pre covid when most people went out to work wouldn't most people leave kittens along all day? However I'm at home all time now and my cat has got so used to it I feel guilty when I go out for long stretches. But this is her problem. She shoukd have called and had a chat about it as bringing a kitten is bizarre ask. I reckon it would be much happier left home on own than strange place and travelling

Flowers500 · 15/12/2021 09:50

If it's your friend and it's in a box in another room, with her going in to feed it occasionally, why not?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 15/12/2021 09:46

Perhaps she should just come for a much shorter time and leave the kitten?

I can understand not wanting to leave it at that age, but bringing it to yours isn’t the answer either

MabelsApron · 15/12/2021 09:42

It's particularly cruel to a cat because they're intensely territorial - when they're taken outside of their home, it distresses them. Dogs are pack animals and as long as their pack is there, being in a strange house is OK, but cats aren't like that. Kitten needs to stay at home and owner needs to work around it.

Sunshineandflipflops · 15/12/2021 09:36

@icedcoffees When I go on holiday either my neighbour or mum pops in once a day and leaves fresh food/water so effectively she is alone for up to a week. She's always been fine when we've got back! This is why we've always had cats and not dogs!