Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say her cat can’t come for Christmas?

184 replies

OneRuleForThem · 14/12/2021 21:39

Someone who is invited for Christmas Day at mine has said they are being their kitten. This is not normal behaviour, right, asking to any pet owners? I don’t know much about pets but kittens can be left alone for much, much longer than puppies can, I think and would be ok for one single day by themselves if pre planned. I don’t understand why she want to bring it with her just because it’ll be Christmas Day. AIBU to say it can’t come I don’t want it ruining things? Haven’t replied yet.

OP posts:
1FootInTheRave · 15/12/2021 22:43

You need a new dp.

MsJinks · 15/12/2021 22:38

I’ve not met a cat yet that is happy to go to new houses and just hang around in them, all I’ve had/come across are pretty scared in the unknown place and mostly they want to hide. Even visiting cats that go around several houses take their time mostly before they decide they can come in and own the place 🤦🏻‍♀️ Having said that the only kitten I had was fine so it could, just could be ok. I think it will be happier in a safe room but your sil should stay in there a bit with it so it feels ok. She could perhaps keep it with her, even carry it around, but doubt it would be ok with that all day. Even if it would settle/hide a bit in your main room with her there’s people it doesn’t know and it’s likely to get easily spooked so want to run off. Thing is cats take their time to learn where they are and understand the territory so can’t just adapt to changes in their space. However I’m not sure a cage will work, but maybe it depends how big it is, they’re not really fans of being caged but someone else might know better on that.
Thinking about it your sil should know her cat, how it might behave and what’s best for it - if you can bring yourself to discuss that with her? Perhaps she regularly takes it visiting and it’s socialised already 🤔

LittleOwl153 · 15/12/2021 22:37

Tbh if that was DPs attitude towards me then I'd tell him tomgo elsewhere... and probably stay there! That's just plain bullying. Hope there are no kids involved!

CheshireKitten123 · 15/12/2021 22:28

@MusicTeacherSussex

Poor kitten. You're all BU
Agreed.

But DP is being unreasonable by bullying OP into having the kitten when she doesn't want to.

Is he manipulative in other ways OP?

MusicTeacherSussex · 15/12/2021 22:20

Poor kitten. You're all BU

OneRuleForThem · 15/12/2021 22:12

Perhaps insist has to be kept in a cage in another room if it’ll wreck my house?

OP posts:
MsJinks · 15/12/2021 21:37

Bless the cat - it’s not going to enjoy it’s first Xmas. I think you’re right to put it in one room but be prepared for the devastation in there. It will scratch and climb more than likely and try to hide as it won’t know it will be left in peace, it will just be scared. It would hide probably wherever you let it go. I took my big, fat ginger boy to my daughters as we were staying 2 nights and he was very unhappy about it - he stayed in the kitchen as the only available space, and didn’t come out if the door was open or not (we ate at a different house) but couldn’t even hide well enough to feel fully safe - my daughter was also not happy with the litter tray 🤦🏻‍♀️
Whilst common thought is cats can be left for ages, up to date understanding is that it stresses them and they miss you - or are stressed at being unable to go out/roam about - and this one is still young, maybe still has 3 meals. There’s also quite a few accidents that could happen especially with a younger cat. So actually the cat shouldn’t be left all day, but probably not loads better making it stay elsewhere all day even if safer. And whilst I love cats I fully understand not wanting a visiting one especially on Xmas day.
Could she not cut her time with you down? Get someone to check on it? Visit home a couple of times?

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 15/12/2021 21:17

As long as the cat wouldn't end up homeless, eh OP [wink[

GCMM · 15/12/2021 21:10

What is wrong with people? Cats are not dogs, you don't take them out with you, they just aren't suited for it.

Scandisaurus · 15/12/2021 21:01

@Broads93

I keep my house like a show home, no way would anyone be bringing anything into my house without my say so, especially pets that just malt and have "accidents" everywhere.
Get to host many shows?
Broads93 · 15/12/2021 21:00

I keep my house like a show home, no way would anyone be bringing anything into my house without my say so, especially pets that just malt and have "accidents" everywhere.

DontKeepTheFaith · 15/12/2021 20:48

We have a rescue cat, been with us almost 2 months. She is 4 years but we still won’t leave her alone, she hates it, always follows so some around. It’s our family Christmas this weekend a couple of hours drive away but DH is staying behind to look after the cat😍 It’s what you do for loved pets, you don’t just cause them undue stress by moving them around.

I feel sad for the kitten. Christmas Day at home with no one else but a little kitten sounds bliss anyway🤣🤣

andweallsingalong · 15/12/2021 20:41

I think a lot depends on the cat. Mine came with me to my mums at Christmas every year and were no bother. Difference is, I asked first. I'd taken him for a visit a few times first. Then on the actual day took him straight upstairs as his base and he was then free to come down at will.

Only complaint I ever had was from an elderly relative who didn't like him "looking at her" and thought he should be removed from the room. Superstar dmum said she was welcome to sit elsewhere if she wanted.

Mine were older and rescues though so seemed more bonded to me than places. I could literally take them anywhere and they would settle straight away. First day was approx 3 yrs old when I got him and dcat 2 the same a couple of years later.

OneRuleForThem · 15/12/2021 20:33

@CheshireKitten123

If it's DPs sister why is she asking you and not him in the first place?
She didn’t ask me, she was invited a while back, then text me yesterday and said “me and XXXXX (cats name) are looking forward to seeing you” and I said what??
OP posts:
Scandisaurus · 15/12/2021 20:26

Poor kitten.

Iamanicepersonreally · 15/12/2021 20:21

I love cats, but it's say no to that. It's very unfair on the poor kitten

MabelsApron · 15/12/2021 20:19

I know it’s ridiculous but I’m getting vaguely upset thinking about the poor kitten…

2bazookas · 15/12/2021 20:19

@OneRuleForThem

my partner said i can’t stoo his sister from coming over for Christmas and if I say no then he will not be at home on the day and will spend it elsewhere, that’s how I’ve been forced into it.
If DP dumped me for a kitten (or his bitch sister) , he'd be down at the rescue centre for unwanted husbands.

Course, they'd castrate him before they tried to rehome him.

icedcoffees · 15/12/2021 20:18

@Scandisaurus

They only leave their mums at 12 wks old, and cannot be left alone for long if at all. Less than an hour anyway. Way less.
Of course they can be left. What do you think will happen to them on their own for a few hours?
icedcoffees · 15/12/2021 20:18

[quote OneRuleForThem]@icedcoffees
Is he going to deal with the kitten when it scratches your sofas and carpets, pees on the floor and knocks everything off the shelves?

Well I’m certainly not going to, so yes, or his sister will. But I have decided it won’t be allowed to walk around the house knocking things off shelves, it will be in one room witha the door closed[/quote]
In which case it will wee/poo everywhere, scratch up the floor and the door and ruin your paintwork.

It's a recipe for a very stressed and upset kitten. If you're going to give in and let it come, shutting it in one room really isn't the answer.

juice92 · 15/12/2021 20:13

One point I'd make is, kittens can't be left alone all day the same as dogs. When we first had my now adult cats my husband and I took turns when going out and we had probably had them for about 6 months when they were left on their own for a day.

That being said, neither puppies nor kittens should be invited to someone else's house by their owners

2bazookas · 15/12/2021 20:13

How cruel to the kitten; two car journeys,. a strange house and lots of noisy strangers .

He'd be far better tucked up in his own home with a hot water bottle, the radio on, plenty of food, peace and quiet.

(WTF does she do when she's working? Take him with her? )

CheshireKitten123 · 15/12/2021 20:08

If it's DPs sister why is she asking you and not him in the first place?

FlibbertyGibbitt · 15/12/2021 20:08

It will be fine on it’s own for the day, if they leave food and a litter tray. All it will take for it to get spooked and hide or even worse escape from the house ! (Cat owner for 30 odd years )

MabelsApron · 15/12/2021 20:07

Shutting the kitten away in a strange room in a strange house just sounds horrible for everyone, not least for the kitten - it’ll be frightened and lonely. At least in its own house it has its own things and smells around even if it’s by itself for a bit.

Suggest partner goes over to see his sister separately. She can’t have expected that she’d just be able to take a kitten everywhere with her?!