Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you put up with this from friends on your 40th???

181 replies

mila0 · 14/12/2021 19:24

I have a certain group of about 6 girlfriends and we all go back to uni / early 20s. We lived together (pre- husbands etc obviously). Most of us still live in London, but two have moved out some years ago.

Anyway, I am the last to turn 40, but we’ve all turned 40 in the last year. None of them did anything for their 40th. My husband did send us on a break to Italy some months ago, which was lovely, but also some aspects of that annoyed me (but that’s another thread).

Anyway, for my birthday I didn’t want a massive party so I thought I’d see different groups of people and either have them over or take them out over the next few months. Two of them were ringing and ringing me for weeks about my birthday - “What are you planning? When do I pencil you in? Can’t wait!!!” All this kind of thing. So in the end, I booked and we went out for dinner somewhere really nice. However, these are my issues -

  1. Of the 5 of them, only 2 brought a gift. Bearing in mind, I got them all (what I think) were really lovely things on their birthdays. One friend actually showed up, made a big drama about how she’d left my gift in her car but it was miles away, and then proceeded to give me a bottle of Prosecco in an M&S carrier bag she must have just bought in the tube! Another said the post hadn’t come. Another said some other waffle.

  2. One of them made a toast - but essentially, she made it all about her! Also they all were making out that this was a celebration of “our birthday year.” Which it kind of was, but if it is that, why am I footing the whole bill then?

  3. One in particular, kept saying TK
    Me whenever the water was lurking, “I’ll have anothec one if you are” - i.e. champagne at £22 per glass and I hasn’t even intimated I was having another anyway. Then, when the waiter said, “any more ladies” she said, “probably easier to get a bottle.” She did this twice and it was just under £200, just for that. No intention of paying - (fair enough it was my invite) - but I personally would just never do that! Not after giving Prosecco in a carrier bag to one of your oldest friends on her 40th! This is what annoys me.

AIBU to be rethinking some of these people? I don’t want anything from them, but it’s the attitude of one or two that has got me upset. AIBU?

OP posts:
TheHouseElf · 15/12/2021 00:10

Not to sound unkind, but these people are not your friends. They've made no effort, they've taken you for granted, they've used you.
Bin them off and find new people who appreciate you.

Nowomenaroundeh · 15/12/2021 00:01

No. This is deeply unpleasant behaviour from the friend(s?) who -

Pretended to have a gift but hasn't bothered to send it
Ordered champagne by the bottle
Claimed it was a group birthday

I wouldn't mind the prosecco in the crumpled bag though. Let's say she did forget the real present, it's better than arriving empty handed.

I think it's normal for you to pay for dinner if that's the way it works in your circles. But you've been a lovely host, it's reasonable to expect gratitude, to feel special and not taken advantage of.

You said this particular friend never pays for herself. Is she just like this with you or in general.

You sound very generous. I am generous too and enjoy treating people. I'm not wealthy like you but it's irrelevant, I move in different circles and it's all relative.

However I have a long-term friend and she sucks the pleasure out of generosity. She will always push a bit further when I've treated. It is clear she doesn't appreciate it and leaves a sour taste in my mouth. So now I end up behaving in a very unnatural way of always being careful I don't end up paying for her (I inevitably end up paying for something however). It's not nice.

I don't think you should have to tell your friends either but if you decide to I'd go the honest route - I was hurt by your behaviour on my birthday night; you referred to it as a shared birthday, you never followed up with a present, you took the proverbial ordering bottles of champagne.

workshy44 · 14/12/2021 23:59

I've been here. The problem is if you are wealthy and generous it can be a very bad combination. It goes from gratitude to acceptance to expectation to entitlement lighting fast in my experience. People can't help themselves. I have seen it in every walk of life even in work.
Its not about the presents and I too understand why you paid but the lack of gifts and the buying of multiple bottles of champagne without even the offer of contributing is shocking.

AbandonedCharacter · 14/12/2021 23:23

YADNBU. As others have said, it sounds like they were keen on you celebrating your birthday just so that they could enjoy a free - and expensive- meal.

Do they ever get in touch and arrange low-key events, like a catch-up over coffee? That would be quite telling.

I hope you managed to enjoy your birthday despite this.

BoredZelda · 14/12/2021 23:03

This all sounds a bit glass slippers are too tight.

Anyone who orders 100 quid bottles of champagne on my tab would be dealt with sharpish.

SRS29 · 14/12/2021 22:48

OP I'll be your friend 😬, but seriously in life there are givers and takers...you sound like a giver....and many of them are takers...sometimes you can tolerate it because of their circumstances etc but sometimes it's time out.....move on and focus time on friends who really are, well, friends x

mila0 · 14/12/2021 22:46

Also I would not describe them as ‘paupers’ by any stretch.

OP posts:
mila0 · 14/12/2021 22:44

I didn’t mean to rub anything in their faces. I guess they were ringing me and wanting a date to come into London as it gets busy at this time of year. I hardly drink and I don’t go out much in general life.

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 14/12/2021 22:38

I said YABU but only because you are clearly loaded and bitching and moaning about gifts is a bit much. Wealthy people can be intimidating for us paupers. I wouldn't want to spend hundreds just to keep up with the kind of gift you can afford to buy me.

But absolutely drop these bitches. They are using you and taking you for granted. I can't imagine getting taken to Italy and out for a dinner with £200 champagne and not giving a gift or giving prosecco in a bag. Cheek!

They could have clubbed together and got you a bracelet or something.

You can't exactly call them out on lack of gifts and guzzling £200 bottles of champagne. You'd lack class. Just withdraw quietly.

Be honest. When they suggest a meet up say. I'm sorry but I'm not up for this. So little effort was made over my birthday it's made me realise you don't care about me. If they protest say the holiday to Italy made you uneasy that there was no thank you. It makes you feel taken for granted.

Much smaller, poorer example but my DH bought me a spa day for two. I invited a uni friend. They aren't as well off as us and have a habit of taking without giving but we try and laugh about it as we won't change them and we like their company. I don't see them too often. Anyway it wasn't a very fancy spa and we had lunch at the spa and she let me pay. It was only £20-30 but I was a bit astounded she had the cheek to accept me paying for lunch, I didn't insist but it was brass faced.

mila0 · 14/12/2021 22:36

Oh I think they did something with their families. But also, we all went to Italy so they probably felt like we’d had a get together.

The way that happened was, my husband goes away with his friends (er, quite a lot) due to his hobbies, but I have never been away overnight by myself or with friends since I had out first DC when I was 29. So he had arranged this as a surprise for a group of us. But I don’t do that kind of thing often. Well never!

OP posts:
LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 14/12/2021 22:31

If it's normal for the organiser to pay....

...Now you know why they didn't bother doing anything for their 40ths.

user478932071 · 14/12/2021 22:30

You need rich friends or stop buying gifts from now on.

Onelifeonly · 14/12/2021 22:28

Maybe they did do something for their 40th birthdays? Or some of them, anyway. Perhaps you just weren't part of it. I'd say it's odd for a whole group to decide to do nothing. It might have been with family only or other friends or each other. Just not with you.

Not trying to rub your nose in it, but sounds unlikely to me.

justasking111 · 14/12/2021 22:27

Wow we have a similar set up friend wise. One of us always gets the calculator out and tells everyone to the penny what they owe which amuses me. The birthday girl never pays. That's something I pay as a birthday treat . We give cards and a little gift we're all on differing incomes much better off than we were years ago but we don't over do the gift giving

JohnStonesMissus · 14/12/2021 22:26

@Thegreencup

I get the impression you are the meal ticket of the group. Especially if you've taken them all away on holiday. They obviously wanted you to host and pay for a huge birthday shindig.

Personally I would drop them. Or only invite them to free events. See how long they stick around when everything isn't on your tab.

This No wonder they were ringing you to find out what the plans were weeks beforehand, I bet they thought 'yay another freebie! That's shit OP, really awful.
mila0 · 14/12/2021 22:24

I see what you mean cansu. I think I was most disappointed by the lame excuses. It felt quite insulting.

OP posts:
ScribblingPixie · 14/12/2021 22:18

@mila0

ScribblingPixie - Yes I can see how it might sound a bit odd, but I actually don’t know what her husband does. I’ve known him 20 years as well. It just doesn’t really come up. She’s never asked what my husband does either.
Wow, you have VERY different friendships to me or maybe I'm just incredibly nosy. But when you say your friends don't do anything for their birthdays it just sounds like you're where the fun and the money is, and over the years they've started to take that for granted and even lose sight of you altogether. I'd definitely focus on the nicer friends individually, and keep the grabby ones at a distance. Do personal not party.
cansu · 14/12/2021 22:16

I think once you get a bit older, the gifts thing is a bit beside the point. I see some of my friends infrequently. We are all different. Some of my friends are much wealthier than me; some less so. I think the important thing should surely be whether you had a good time. Don't spend more than you can afford. Don't give more than you want to. Enjoy spending time with the people you like. Ordering champagne sounds like crossed wires. If you throw expensive parties then you give the impression these things don't matter. Your post is a strange mix of annoyance about them taking expensive champagne and holidays from you on the one hand and then pique about them not seeing your 40th as a special occasion on its own and not bringing you a decent gift.
Are you annoyed they weren't properly grateful?
Are you annoyed they didn't buy you a nice gift?
Are you annoyed they didn't give your birthday enough attention?

Did you enjoy their company and have a laugh?

PaddingtonsHat · 14/12/2021 22:16

I think 40 is definitely a re-evaluation time for friendships. I’ve quietly let go some of my oldest friends recently as I’ve realised the only thing holding us together was memories of a carefree, fun and mostly drunken time. We don’t have the same ideals or principles now.
I would fume about it for a bit, then write it off and drift away

Offmyfence · 14/12/2021 22:15

@Rewis

I was just reading a thread where people were against op inviting friends to a pub lunch for her birthday if she was not going to pay. Now we are wondering why op is paying? This place is weird.
You can't see the difference?

A pub lunch

Vs

A trip to Italy, all good and drink, a meal out and £200 bottles of champagne?

Really??

VaizyCrazyDaizy · 14/12/2021 22:14

Simple answer - get new acquaintances - I don’t know what those people are but definitely not friends!

Rewis · 14/12/2021 22:14

I was just reading a thread where people were against op inviting friends to a pub lunch for her birthday if she was not going to pay. Now we are wondering why op is paying? This place is weird.

xprincessxjanetx · 14/12/2021 22:14

YANBU. I would also find this very upsetting. The no gifts wouldn't necessarily bother me but that coupled with the lame excuses and expecting you to foot expensive champagne bills certainly would!

mila0 · 14/12/2021 22:10

I know what two of the husbands do. I don’t really know why I don’t know what the others do. Something corporate, I think? Only one of these friends works, so it’s not as if they don’t have time to get to the Post Office!

OP posts:
Suzanne999 · 14/12/2021 22:07
  1. Very rude not to bring a gift. Downright ill mannered.
  2. They were invited for a meal that you were paying for. If you’re a guest and you want to drink £100 bottle of champagne, you buy that yourself, not add it to your hostesses bill.

Do they perhaps see you and your OH as the “wealthy couple” as you said your husband had paid for a group trip to Italy? If this is the case I think it’s a shame that they’re in it for the money ( benefits) and not, it seems, for your friendship.

Sorry they spoilt your birthday, sounds like you didn’t deserve their crap behaviour.