Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to struggle with husband weight gain

112 replies

loveisagirlnameddaisy · 14/12/2021 18:33

First, I should state that this isn't straightforward.

DH has struggled with his weight all his life. He finds it exceedingly hard to lose weight and has put a lot of effort into finding out why. He's seen a dietitian privately and spent thousands on tests and consultations. A conventional approach to dieting doesn't work. He's tried IF, low cal, low carb, exercised etc etc

We think it's hormonal and a gastro endocrinologist said the same, but without spending more money we won't know for sure.

DH lost some weight last year but it was hard won and took ages. He showed remarkable willpower to lose the weight he did, but given his excess weight it was baffling that he couldn't lose more.

This year he's had a lot to deal with, and he's put most of the weight back on. He tends to carry the majority on his tummy which I just hate. He looks pregnant and I find it such a turn off. But at the same time, I feel like a complete cow because of the context of the situation. If he were blatantly overeating and just couldn't be arsed, I'd feel more justified. But he's not.

So. Am I being unreasonable to resent the way he looks? And how do I deal with the way I feel?

OP posts:
Indoctro · 15/12/2021 17:49

Your husband is a secret eater and has a eating disorder

Slobberstops · 15/12/2021 17:45

As you look ahead focus on what matters. Qualities trump bodies - especially as we age. I look round friends now and we have some who have lost breasts, some waiting for replacement surgeries and limping through, a few are dead already. It rather focuses the mind on what matters. My partner is very ill and unable to work. I really could do with a dancing handsome fuck buddy but like Tim Michin once said - he would give anything to have an affair - apart from his relationship (prob just ran off with the secretary or similar) but it strikes me he is right. There may be other things we would like too but focusing on on the really important things does help. Invest emotionally and practically - what does he look best in? What do you enjoy most together - keep your focus there where you can.

loveisagirlnameddaisy · 15/12/2021 17:32

@Arkestra

You are not unreasonable to feel as you do - you can't help your feelings here!

My advice would be to be supportive without resigning yourself to your OH permanently having a lot of extra weight that they themselves are unhappy with.

I would really recommend getting a second opinion on the thyroid front: I know someone whose ability to control their weight was transformed when they started taking medication to adjust for impaired thyroid function. If this is something wrong that you can fix, it'll make a heck of a lot of difference, and you've already had a test indicating function at the low end of the range.

If your DH can face having another go at dieting I would recommend a slightly different tack to the one most people take: start off not dieting, but just weighting daily and tracking the moving average for a month. There are free websites that will work this stuff out for you, e.g. www.fourmilab.ch/cgi-bin/HackDiet/

This will show how much weight is going on/coming off. They can then define a diet in relation to that - 110 calories a day is about 1 pound a month. I suggest this because many people find it far easier approaching a diet as "adjust from my normal lifestyle" than "try to count every single calorie from scratch".

Good luck X

Thank you so much, that's definitely the place I need to be in - supportive but not resigning myself to this being the permanent status quo. Luckily, we communicate well, he's a very calm personality and doesn't fly off the handle when I broach the subject. Will look at the website you suggest.
OP posts:
loveisagirlnameddaisy · 15/12/2021 17:30

@newtb

Is there any possibility that he's deficient in testostérone?
He saw a dietician privately who ran loads of blood tests, I would have to ask him about testosterone specifically, but apart from mildly low thyroid, nothing stood out.
OP posts:
loveisagirlnameddaisy · 15/12/2021 17:28

@PermanentTemporary

Im afraid it looks as if he can lose weight, it's just miserable and difficult; tbh it is for most people. He did lose weight with MFP which shows it can be done. I'd agree that MFP is much too generous with exercise calories and if you eat all the exercise calories as well, you're going to struggle. It also encourages you to enter tiny bits of exercise like 'walked 10 minutes' or whatever to get 'given' enough calories for a custard cream, but that isn't as real as it should be. I reckoned if I ate about 10% of the serious exercise calories I entered, I could still lose weight. I've stopped bothering even with that now. Having a big barrier like achilles tendon problems is a huge issue and tbh if he's carrying all that excess weight round his middle (just like me), he's going to have more health problems as time goes on.

So. Youre left with a man who is overweight, struggles with it and you're finding that unattractive. You're then feeling shit because it's not nice to fall out of love with someone because of looks and ageing. It does happen but it's not supposed to, is it? We're supposed to love our partners' soul more than their bodies.

I would try to look for ways to showcase the things you do love about him. If you love that he's sociable or intellectual or whatever, try to maximise time where those parts of him are to the fore and minimise the 'did you take the bins out' drudgery interactions that most of us end up doing. Maybe have a break, go on a holiday by yourself or something to give yourself a chance to miss him?

I think you have to accept this is how things may be, how he is. Over time you may come to accept it or you may find you can't live with it. I think you are very proactive and keen to get on with improving things but you may just have to wait.

That's good advice, to showcase the things I do love about him. I can honestly say that apart from a few, very normal niggles, there's nothing that would make me fall out of love with him.

Your point about missing him is quite relevant - both at home together all the time at the moment so maybe that's part of the issue?

OP posts:
loveisagirlnameddaisy · 15/12/2021 17:26

@Emerald5hamrock

Would he consider surgery a gastric sleeve, drastic I know but if he has tried everything else.

My friend had it done 6 months ago she has lost 5 stone.

I understand how you feel about your DH's weight, my OH carries it mainly around the stomach, he looks pregnant with twins, it is unattractive and makes me feel like such a shallow cow thinking about him like that.

Sex is awkward, his portions are huge, instead of 3/4 small meals he eats 2 massive meals.

We also have a good friend who has done this. What interests me about bariatric surgery is that it claims to also 'reset' the metabolism/hormones that can be out of kilter after years of yo-yo dieting.

Definitely something we need to research further.

OP posts:
Grenlei · 15/12/2021 17:11

If you've never been overweight struggling to lose weight is something people don't really get.

I've been fat, thin, and all manner of things in between. My DP, who is also overweight but carries the weight well as he has broad shoulders, big arms, thighs etc, prefers me about 2-3st above normal BMI, because he thinks I look better at that weight, and because it's easier to maintain.

To get to normal BMI, I end up doing 4-5 hard gym sessions a week and rarely eating more than 800 cals a day. It's tough, and the more times you go through the gain and lose cycle the harder it gets.

It's difficult because I understand where the OP is coming from and physical attraction is important, but like a PP said, there are other aspects to it - dressing as well as he can, looking clean and presentable etc. Someone who was doing all that and trying to lose weight even if not succeeding would still be attractive to me I think. I'd have to acknowledge they were doing their best. And the thing is our physical appearance can change as we age or through illness anyway, things we can't control.

theemmadilemma · 15/12/2021 15:57

@soberclover

I have a husband who is very overweight. He has always been overweight. The only time he lost weight was when he was under incredible stress. It was horrible..

He eats too much and exercises too little. He does exercise but at a low intensity.

Anyway I have made my peace with it now (we have been together a long time) because:

He dresses really well and his personal hygiene is spot on. I couldn't cope with sweaty/smelly man with nasty hair/beard, crusty skin etc (sorry for the image)

It is literally the only 'thing' that could be improved. He is kind, funny, brilliant in bed, hard worker, never lost his temper etc etc.

So I genuinely find him attractive even though 20 year old shallow me wouldn't date him.

This. I never would have been attracted to my Partner years ago, and initially I struggled with reconciling seeing myself with someone overweight having always dated buff guys.

But my attraction to him comes from his cheeky smile, his twinkle in his eyes, the way he makes me laugh and all the other things I adore about him which make him absolutely the perfect person for me.

itwasntaparty · 15/12/2021 15:53

@DeepaBeesKit

If he is very inactive even at 6ft 4 1800 calories a day could still be not much below his basal metabolic rate, and if so he would not lose much weight.

Maybe get him to try 1500 a day and see if he loses consistently.

I'm willing to bet he is missing some calories from drinks or cooking ingredients like oil, and underestimating calorie intake.

I'm 5ft7 and maintain on 1800.
PermanentTemporary · 15/12/2021 15:42

Im afraid it looks as if he can lose weight, it's just miserable and difficult; tbh it is for most people. He did lose weight with MFP which shows it can be done. I'd agree that MFP is much too generous with exercise calories and if you eat all the exercise calories as well, you're going to struggle. It also encourages you to enter tiny bits of exercise like 'walked 10 minutes' or whatever to get 'given' enough calories for a custard cream, but that isn't as real as it should be. I reckoned if I ate about 10% of the serious exercise calories I entered, I could still lose weight. I've stopped bothering even with that now. Having a big barrier like achilles tendon problems is a huge issue and tbh if he's carrying all that excess weight round his middle (just like me), he's going to have more health problems as time goes on.

So. Youre left with a man who is overweight, struggles with it and you're finding that unattractive. You're then feeling shit because it's not nice to fall out of love with someone because of looks and ageing. It does happen but it's not supposed to, is it? We're supposed to love our partners' soul more than their bodies.

I would try to look for ways to showcase the things you do love about him. If you love that he's sociable or intellectual or whatever, try to maximise time where those parts of him are to the fore and minimise the 'did you take the bins out' drudgery interactions that most of us end up doing. Maybe have a break, go on a holiday by yourself or something to give yourself a chance to miss him?

I think you have to accept this is how things may be, how he is. Over time you may come to accept it or you may find you can't live with it. I think you are very proactive and keen to get on with improving things but you may just have to wait.

Arkestra · 15/12/2021 15:31

You are not unreasonable to feel as you do - you can't help your feelings here!

My advice would be to be supportive without resigning yourself to your OH permanently having a lot of extra weight that they themselves are unhappy with.

I would really recommend getting a second opinion on the thyroid front: I know someone whose ability to control their weight was transformed when they started taking medication to adjust for impaired thyroid function. If this is something wrong that you can fix, it'll make a heck of a lot of difference, and you've already had a test indicating function at the low end of the range.

If your DH can face having another go at dieting I would recommend a slightly different tack to the one most people take: start off not dieting, but just weighting daily and tracking the moving average for a month. There are free websites that will work this stuff out for you, e.g. www.fourmilab.ch/cgi-bin/HackDiet/

This will show how much weight is going on/coming off. They can then define a diet in relation to that - 110 calories a day is about 1 pound a month. I suggest this because many people find it far easier approaching a diet as "adjust from my normal lifestyle" than "try to count every single calorie from scratch".

Good luck X

loveisagirlnameddaisy · 15/12/2021 15:26

Thanks everyone who has taken the time to reply, I'm at work so not free to respond just yet, but I am reading and taking note.

OP posts:
newtb · 15/12/2021 15:10

Is there any possibility that he's deficient in testostérone?

MistySkiesAfterRain · 15/12/2021 15:08

I personally think you should eat your BMR (amount you need to sustain current weight) in calories, then burn more calories through exercise to lose weight.

Otherwise the body goes into 'ooh I will slow down my metabolism so I can sustain my weight mwah ha ha'. Bodies don't like losing weight, they want to sustain themselves.

If you do it through exercise (with a small post exercise snack) you burn some and speed up the metabolism for the next meal. Its also sustainable as the focus is never on cutting calories.

MatildaIThink · 15/12/2021 15:04

[quote loveisagirlnameddaisy]@MatildaIThink this is something that we've researched extensively and there's different schools of thought on calories in=calories out. I'm about to buy Why We Eat and i think that looks at diet and metabolism as being far more complex than just calorie deficits.

He used MFP most of last year when he lost weight, weighed and logged everything, was on about 1800 cals per day (he's 6'4") and some weeks lost nothing. Would love explanations for why.[/quote]
Without specific investigation I could not give you an exact reason, but in every case where there have been controlled trials into people who say they cannot lose weight regardless of what they eat, when in residential monitoring they either lose weight if sticking to the controlled diet, or eat more than they report eating of monitored.

There can be variations in base metabolic rate and with only calorie reduction and no exercise it will decline slightly, but even then you are only talking about a maximum of 5% variance.

The biggest factor is almost always poor estimates/measure of portion size, outside of specifically weighing every ingredient weight/volume is under-reported by 20-50%. Often the milk in tea and coffee is ignored or under-reported, especially as some people will drink more hot drinks to make up for lower food intake, many people ignore the fats used in cooking, those can add up. Finally there is alcohol, which many people either ignore or underestimate.

People also tend to overestimate the amount of calories they burn, activity trackers can bring that error rate down, but their accuracy rates are still +/- 10% and calculating calories from exercise is subject to other variables (total weight, muscle mass).

Nutrition and huger do play a large part, low carb diets tend to work well for many people not because of any magical trick, but because when removing carbs from the diet blood sugar tends to stabilise and vary little at any point, that removes one of the triggers of hunger (blood sugar levels falling lower than previously normal), there is in theory a tiny benefit to weight loss from ketosis, but it is not big enough to generate and substantial weight loss. Things like green vegetables to bulk out meals, as well as protein which takes longer to digest so leaves one feeling full for longer are also important, as is making sure one is properly hydrated, especially during weight loss.

From experience of friends and family I have always seen that men find it easier to lose weight through exercise rather than deep cuts to calorie intake. The biggest example is my brother, who is in his late thirties (and had not exercised since he was 14), last year, early in the lockdown he was just over 18 stone, he decided he did not want to be fat any more, so started exercising and with little else to do during lockdown the weight fell off him. By the end of last September he was 12st 0lbs and had a six pack, more than a year later he is still only 12st 6lbs and whilst not got the defined six pack he has a totally flat stomach. He was at one point eating 3,000 calories a day and still losing weight as he was exercising for 6-8 hours a day.

The issues with weight loss are rarely physical, they are almost always phycological and our own minds are our greatest assets, but they can also be somewhat of a liability.

soberclover · 15/12/2021 14:51

I have a husband who is very overweight. He has always been overweight. The only time he lost weight was when he was under incredible stress. It was horrible..

He eats too much and exercises too little. He does exercise but at a low intensity.

Anyway I have made my peace with it now (we have been together a long time) because:

He dresses really well and his personal hygiene is spot on. I couldn't cope with sweaty/smelly man with nasty hair/beard, crusty skin etc (sorry for the image)

It is literally the only 'thing' that could be improved. He is kind, funny, brilliant in bed, hard worker, never lost his temper etc etc.

So I genuinely find him attractive even though 20 year old shallow me wouldn't date him.

workshy44 · 15/12/2021 14:46

Every overweight person I know says they don't eat much. The reality is that in 99.9% of cases they do
A friend said she ate nothing couldn't understand why she was so bug, ate as much as us etc etc and got a gastric band and lost 10 stone in a year. If she was eating nothing to begin with she would have lost v little
Often if you are a picker you can rack up the calories without even realizing, having a dinner before dinner with all the tasting while cooking. I would recommend writing down every single thing he puts into his mouth, I would wager it will be enlightening

Caramellatteplease · 15/12/2021 14:45

When I was losing weight I would log half my exercise calories then eat half back. Exercise really has bugger all to do with losing weight and mfp has a tendency to vastly overestimate calorie burn.

Does he cook all his meals separately?

gunnersgold · 15/12/2021 14:42

See a private endocrinologist! I was told my thyroid was fine but private tests showed I have an autoimmune thyroid disease .
If he isn't secretly eating then something must be wrong , has he always been overweight! ?

DeepaBeesKit · 15/12/2021 14:40

If he is very inactive even at 6ft 4 1800 calories a day could still be not much below his basal metabolic rate, and if so he would not lose much weight.

Maybe get him to try 1500 a day and see if he loses consistently.

I'm willing to bet he is missing some calories from drinks or cooking ingredients like oil, and underestimating calorie intake.

EmpressSuiko · 15/12/2021 14:33

Some thyroid issues won’t show up on a basic blood test done by the gp so he may need a referral to a specialist to discuss this.
My husband has a hormonal stomach, he only gains weight on his stomach and no where else but he does have a hormonal issue causing the problem.

Dozer · 15/12/2021 14:24

Health wise, if he’s spent a lot on diet help, a bit more money on private GP for further thyroid tests and medicines would probably be good.

Emerald5hamrock · 15/12/2021 14:23

Would he consider surgery a gastric sleeve, drastic I know but if he has tried everything else.

My friend had it done 6 months ago she has lost 5 stone.

I understand how you feel about your DH's weight, my OH carries it mainly around the stomach, he looks pregnant with twins, it is unattractive and makes me feel like such a shallow cow thinking about him like that.

Sex is awkward, his portions are huge, instead of 3/4 small meals he eats 2 massive meals.

gamerchick · 15/12/2021 14:23

Or you can accept him the way he is or release him to find someone who will. It's no life.

gamerchick · 15/12/2021 14:22

He used MFP most of last year when he lost weight, weighed and logged everything, was on about 1800 cals per day (he's 6'4") and some weeks lost nothing. Would love explanations for why.

Not eating enough? Not eating enough protein?

Personally I think he should hook himself up with a personal trainer who does the eating part as well. Total overhaul.