Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate working with women

434 replies

HousethatChunkbuilt · 14/12/2021 18:27

I am a feminist and I think women are incredible. I am proud at all we achieve, having babies, periods, going through the menopause, the constant harassment, fear of violence, discrimination, sexism... the list goes on.
HOWEVER I find it incredibly difficult to work in all female teams. I have nearly always worked in all female environments in entry level jobs.
The bitchiness is unreal. Everyday comments lead to tears, meltdowns, refusal to come in. This has happened in every single workplace. The only place I haven't had this is in a shop where it was mostly men and other (quite mature) women. Oh and one place where we were all different nationalities, is cattiness a British thing?
It just takes so much time and effort navigating the various rifts, arguments, feuds and rivalries. I honestly think we'd rule the world if we could get rid of this shit.
I'm quite matter of fact and get frustrated that this taking up so much time!

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 14/12/2021 19:28

What's strange is that individually the women are interesting, unique and intelligent. We just seem to have a real problem working cohesively with each other!

And you’ve decided that’s solely down to the fact they’re women. Confused

HousethatChunkbuilt · 14/12/2021 19:28

Casual ageism? I just mentioned mature, as an attribute rather than an age bracket.

OP posts:
Picklypickles · 14/12/2021 19:27

I've mostly worked in mainly male environments, I would occasionally get to move about and do things in different offices where there was another woman or 2 and it was (usually) so nice to have some female company for a change. I found the groups of men in my main office to be far more bitchy and also shouty and angry a lot of the time, not to mention the the occasional inappropriate behaviour and comments towards me.

After that I worked in care for a while with a fairly even mix of male and female colleagues, most were perfectly nice people and some were less so!

Capricopia · 14/12/2021 19:27

Do you think you might be the common denominator…? I’ve only ever worked in female-dominated teams and have never had the experiences you describe.

HaveringWavering · 14/12/2021 19:26

Everyday comments lead to tears, meltdowns, refusal to come in.

Sounds like you just work in a field that attracts juvenile, unprofessional people. Are standards in your industry very low? It’s true that women tend to be over-represented in shit, low paid, low prestige jobs. Maybe it’s the job that’s the issue, not the gender?

NeedsCharging · 14/12/2021 19:25

Not seeing how you can describe yourself as a feminist and then refer to the "cattiness" and bitchiness" of women.

Yeah I mean us feminists are all about using misogynistic language to describe how we prefer the company of men.
Did you not see the "how to do feminisim properly in 10 steps" in the last news letter etch tut...

Kanaloa · 14/12/2021 19:25

@legohurts16

I agree with the OP - I find there is so much bitchiness in an all female workforce - similar to an all girls school. I left my last job due to the petty behaviour and bitchiness that occured.- quite a small workforce 35 women and 2 men This probably doesn't happen in all female dominated workplaces but I definitely think that having male colleagues as well really does stop the competitiveness and bitchiness that goes on between women. I now work with in a 60% women 40% men industry and I am so much happier - I find men are so much easier to get on with at work because I think women in the workplace are always competing against each other.
It’s actually been proven that girls learn and achieve better in an all girl environment than a mixed one, while boys achieve poorly in an all-boy environment compared to a mixed one.

So all girl schools are beneficial to girls. It’s almost like girls and women aren’t inherently problematic like society would like you to believe.

HousethatChunkbuilt · 14/12/2021 19:24

Hello, back again.
For the record, I am British. Hence why I'm asking if it's a British thing as the Eastern European's and Spanish I used to work with just never seemed to be critical of each other in a catty way. I can remember the manager would tell us how amazing we were and gave us all great references if we moved on. I then I transferred to a different branch in the suburbs and it was completely different, very competitive for tips, promotions, shifts. Very dismissive of those with commitments etc.
I'm in admin now and at times it can be awful. I don't believe it's women in general as I see other all women teams and they seem to get on well. It seems to be generally environments where the jobs are quite dull and people might be doing them as a stopgap. I'm thinking of retail, catering, data entry, call centre jobs. Jobs that aren't really a 'calling'.
What's strange is that individually the women are interesting, unique and intelligent. We just seem to have a real problem working cohesively with eachother!
Example:
Person 1: can you help me out with this?
Man: no sorry I'm really busy
Woman: yes I probably can
That woman to other women: did you hear what she just asked me? Why can't she do it? What's she got on? If you ask me she can't be managing her workload efficiently. And she left early on Friday. I was here until 6!
Maybe men do this too, I'm not sure, I haven't had that much experience apart from in one job where everyone was quite honest, in a respectful way. That could be down to a multitude of reasons not just gender.
FWIW I have had loads of female managers and they've been awesome and great leaders.

OP posts:
bratzybaby · 14/12/2021 19:24

@WorraLiberty

I've only had one manager who was a woman who always acted professionally and she was gay.

@bratzybaby, what on earth does the woman's sexuality have to do with anything?? Confused

@WorraLiberty absolutely nothing, it's just something that was a noticeable difference between her and my previous managers. She was very masculine and didn't ever tap into that bitchiness side. That's all🤷‍♀️
Kanaloa · 14/12/2021 19:23

@PurpleDaisies

This has happened in every single workplace.

What do those workplaces have in common?

Grin

All these women I work with are awful! What is the commonality?

echt · 14/12/2021 19:22

Not seeing how you can describe yourself as a feminist and then refer to the "cattiness" and bitchiness" of women.

AlexaShutUp · 14/12/2021 19:22

Wow, no, I don't feel like this at all. I have worked in all female teams previously but have fairly recently inherited a senior team that is all male. I miss the women!!!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 14/12/2021 19:21

I find there is so much bitchiness in an all female workforce - similar to an all girls school

I did an all female degree course. They were all absolutely lovely. No ‘bitching’ never fell out. I’m still in touch with them years later.

thatsallineed · 14/12/2021 19:21

@bettys9thleg

I'm in a nearly all female team (1 man) and it's a lovely supportive atmosphere. We big each other up, commiserate when our kids are sick. Help each other. I know the sort of atmosphere you're describing but I have found it's happened more in mixed teams then all female ones. Obvs just my experience there though.
Same here. It has also come to my notice that in mixed teams, some women don't like it if other women get promoted.
Benjispruce5 · 14/12/2021 19:20

I work in an all female environment (primary school) and it’s a very collaborative, supportive environment 95% of the time. We are all over 40 though.

Mackmama · 14/12/2021 19:19

I had six months working in a retail environment when I was a student. I worked with all women and it was absolutely miserable as they were constantly bitching and moaning. I think the reason wasn’t because they they were women as I’ve worked in female dominated teams since and it wasn’t like that but they were so bored, once they’re reorganised the clothes into size order for the 45th time that day, there wasn’t anything else to do other than bitch and moan. It’s the only job I’ve ever had that I didn’t like and I’d really not like to go back there again.

Practicebeingpatient · 14/12/2021 19:19

Lol if you think this is exclusively female behaviour. I spent many years working in a predominantly male industry. I was normally the only woman and I saw very similar behaviour from men with the added bonus of the occasional bout of fisticuffs.

One cherished memory is two very competitive but not very macho men having a falling out over who was responsible for a very large and lucrative sale. Me and the manager watched open mouthed as they started to grapple with each other on the sales floor. Then, still struggling they very slowly and gracefully rolled backwards down the very grand, illuminated, spiral glass staircase. Luckily it was all on CCTV so we could replay it at our leisure when we needed a laugh.

Outdoorbeanbags · 14/12/2021 19:18

Is the difference here working environments which are competitive rather than collaborative? (Regardless of sex).

tapeandglue · 14/12/2021 19:17

My experience of working with women is it's generally fine at lower and middle management levels, but women right at the very top are awful, 9 times out of 10. It's as if they feel like they have to model stereotypical male behaviours to get there - they have no empathy, they push people under buses, they're aggressive... I could go on.

Like the OP, this really upsets me, as I've had very few female role models I want to emulate, and I'd really like to be able to champion women at the top.

LavenderAskew · 14/12/2021 19:15

@Nayday

Not a female thing. Team culture can go toxic, usually depending on the personality of the leader - and that leadership can be formal or informal (informal where that person isn't officially in charge but "rules the roost" type person by tacit agreement of the group.

In 20 years I've had the displeasure of working in only a couple of toxic teams - the common denominator wasn't women but the dynamic where there was an unofficial group leader - and they were awful. This led to bitchiness, back biting, one upmanship type stuff. The first was male, and he was just hideous, and the second female and she was just as bad. I've just realised they would likely have gotten along like a house on fire!

Yes - that is what I was getting at (just mine was more waffley!!)
2022TheYearofMe · 14/12/2021 19:15

I also work in a supportive environment, don’t like the role, but the people are fab irrespective of their gender/sex.

When I was much less senior years ago, and worked in a predominantly female area it was as you described. Bitchy, back stabbing and catty.

I now put it down to immaturity and too many young women vying for attention. As older women on the team doing different roles, we love each other.

legohurts16 · 14/12/2021 19:15

I agree with the OP - I find there is so much bitchiness in an all female workforce - similar to an all girls school. I left my last job due to the petty behaviour and bitchiness that occured.- quite a small workforce 35 women and 2 men This probably doesn't happen in all female dominated workplaces but I definitely think that having male colleagues as well really does stop the competitiveness and bitchiness that goes on between women. I now work with in a 60% women 40% men industry and I am so much happier - I find men are so much easier to get on with at work because I think women in the workplace are always competing against each other.

maddiemookins16mum · 14/12/2021 19:14

I’ve worked for over 40 years in various roles and levels. Never come across this.

MarleneDietrichsSmile · 14/12/2021 19:14

I have never experienced this

Thankfully

And I am 50 Grin

Waitwhatwhy · 14/12/2021 19:14

I worked in a predominantly female dept for years where everyone got on well on the whole, then they brought in four new staff at the same time and suddenly everything was drama and there was a lot of backstabbing, even amongst the original staff. Looking back two of the new women were very toxic and it all stemmed from them but spread due to their behaviour. I left soon after, I went from loving the job to hating it.