Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate working with women

434 replies

HousethatChunkbuilt · 14/12/2021 18:27

I am a feminist and I think women are incredible. I am proud at all we achieve, having babies, periods, going through the menopause, the constant harassment, fear of violence, discrimination, sexism... the list goes on.
HOWEVER I find it incredibly difficult to work in all female teams. I have nearly always worked in all female environments in entry level jobs.
The bitchiness is unreal. Everyday comments lead to tears, meltdowns, refusal to come in. This has happened in every single workplace. The only place I haven't had this is in a shop where it was mostly men and other (quite mature) women. Oh and one place where we were all different nationalities, is cattiness a British thing?
It just takes so much time and effort navigating the various rifts, arguments, feuds and rivalries. I honestly think we'd rule the world if we could get rid of this shit.
I'm quite matter of fact and get frustrated that this taking up so much time!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
adrianmolesmole · 17/12/2021 20:27

I've not found this in all women teams but when I was a manager I found women much harder to deal with. When managing men I found that if I gave them a job to do they'd do it no question. With women it was often sighs and huffs and "atmosphere", gossip with others (talking about their boss (me) and leaving me out. Perhaps because I am a woman that it got to me so much. I probably noticed it more in a way a male boss might not. And I found the huffs and puffs hard to ignore, I found I was picking up on the slightest (pointed) sigh and it was really, really irritating!

With men sometimes you'd get banter, but everything just felt much more on the surface and straightforward to deal with.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/12/2021 19:33

Not liked! Piled!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/12/2021 19:32

Interesting about academia. I worked in schools as a teacher for 25 years. Bloody loved all my female colleagues. Kind and really supportive. All of them.

We used to have a ‘crying’ room. (Teens make you cry a lot) and if someone went in. One of the lovely team followed to sympathise and help. Often we all liked in for a group hug.

hivemindneeded · 17/12/2021 14:40

@Milomonster

I work in a female-dominated team in academia. Only one woman irritates the shit out of me by her constant need for drama and attention. She sucks the life out of me and I will actively avoid going to the office when she’s in. The others are wonderful, strong and smart women who behave with decorum. My overall experience of working with women has been a very positive and supportive one.
Same here. Most of the time I work alone from home but have a few projects that involve working in an academic team of women. They are such good people and I love my boss on these projects. She's so straightforward and easy to deal with.
Milomonster · 17/12/2021 10:13

I work in a female-dominated team in academia. Only one woman irritates the shit out of me by her constant need for drama and attention. She sucks the life out of me and I will actively avoid going to the office when she’s in. The others are wonderful, strong and smart women who behave with decorum. My overall experience of working with women has been a very positive and supportive one.

beastlyslumber · 17/12/2021 09:58

I've worked in more than 200 different teams (temping for many years) and the worst behaviour I've ever seen was from men. A male boss threw a jug of milk at my head once. Sexual harrassment. Stealing ideas. Undermining, deceiving, committing acts of fraud. Just general nastiness - all men.

I've encountered a few unpleasant women along the way also, but only one or two that were bad enough for me to even recall. Plenty of men were awful to the point of violence. I'd rather work with and for women any day.

Notenoughchocolateomg · 16/12/2021 23:36

Feminist here too buy from my own personal experience of working in retail the bitchiness was awful. I left in the end.

SammyScrounge · 16/12/2021 23:14

We were nearly all women in our department and worked well together. The most childish thing I ever saw was when a man teacher lifted a colleague's newspaper to read. Everyone knew the colleague hated his newspaper being wrinkled and messy. It had to be pristine before he would touch it. He saw his paper
all spread out on the table and he exploded with rage (real rage), pushed past the paper thief, seized his carton of goat's milk, and poured it down the sink. Then he stormed out of the base and slammed the door behind him.pUpils had to choose between j
The months rolled by and it was time to assign new classes for next session. PUpils had to choose between taking history or geography.Goatsmilk man was principal History and was shocked to see that hardly any pupils had opted for History. It turned out that the Head of Geography(still irked by his creased newspaper six months later) had been telling all classes that if they opted for his subject they could be pilots when they left school and make a fortune.
You cannot beat men for silly feuding.

Mirw · 16/12/2021 13:14

I get you. I have always worked in the Third Sector in equality organisations. When working in all women teams it has been a nightmare. Younger women declaring that I do not understand feminism, even though I have been a feminist for over 45 years. In fact, it has always been younger women trying to force their views on me then taking a strop when I don't agree with them... For example, in one team we all had to say that all men are bad as all men have the potential to be rapists. This was to be our mantra. I refused to take part as I live with a man, my dad is a man, as are my brothers. None would rape a woman. Result, nobody was willing to talk to me direct for 6 weeks. Project discussions all took place by email. When I took out my grievance on a completely different matter, I had a paper trail from the offenders, which wasn't fair either because I should have deleted all the emails after I had read them, against organisation policy...keep all emails 6 months, archive snd delete.
So it does happen and I am now very wary of joining all women teams.

DogsandCatsB4u · 16/12/2021 12:43

I’ve worked with a lot of women and I have had an issue with only a few

SallyWD · 16/12/2021 09:59

Op - I will say I have worked with several difficult and unpleasant women. It pains me to say that I've worked with more difficult women than men. However, my experience has been completely different to yours. These women were a small minority. I currently work in an all female team and it's been an absolute joy! We all get on brilliantly and support each other, socialise outside work etc. I've worked in other all females teams in the past and it was a similar experience. You seem to be saying that ALL your experiences of working with women have been awful. I find this bizarre and can only say you've been extremely unlucky. What industry do you work in to attract such awful women?

Darkpheonix · 16/12/2021 09:57

@Jayaywhynot

I work in what was a male dominated industry, seen lots more woman coming into the industry over the last 20 yrs, great stuff. I have to agree though as the only problems I've ever experienced is with the women, petty jealousies, undermining, cattyness, backstabbing, spite, tears if they don't get their own way. I know all women are not like this but this has definitely been my experience. I'm currently going through it now, new starter on the opposite team, I'm helping to train her on the less technical side of the role as she's straight out of uni, no experience in the industry and she's kicking off as I'm not teaching her my role and she feels undermined. Sorry but I can't teach a graduate a technical role that I've trained for over 25 yrs and condense all my experience down into a couple of zoom calls.
Do you really believe men never have that attitude?
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/12/2021 09:52

See, I’ve never met any really ‘bitchy’ womenConfused I’m 57. I’ve just gone through my life, and nope, no bitchy women.

O levels- lots of friends
A levels- less friends, but no ‘bitches’
Foundation course- lovely women
Degree ( female orientated) loads of fantastic young women. Lovely and supportive and funny
1st job-all men, horrible
2nd job. I think this may be where l met the only ‘nasty’ woman. The rest of the staff were great
3rd job-lovely women, made some great friends
4th job- again great friends
5th job “
6th job lots of amazing friendly women. Stayed for 26 years. Still miss my work family.

I think it’s about expectations.

ChipmunksInAttic · 16/12/2021 08:58

I’m working in an all men environment and would prefer working in a balanced team, it’s not great either.

Jayaywhynot · 16/12/2021 08:48

I work in what was a male dominated industry, seen lots more woman coming into the industry over the last 20 yrs, great stuff.
I have to agree though as the only problems I've ever experienced is with the women, petty jealousies, undermining, cattyness, backstabbing, spite, tears if they don't get their own way.
I know all women are not like this but this has definitely been my experience.
I'm currently going through it now, new starter on the opposite team, I'm helping to train her on the less technical side of the role as she's straight out of uni, no experience in the industry and she's kicking off as I'm not teaching her my role and she feels undermined. Sorry but I can't teach a graduate a technical role that I've trained for over 25 yrs and condense all my experience down into a couple of zoom calls.

hivemindneeded · 16/12/2021 08:04

@MammaMacgill87

Also as a side note, if you ever needed proof of in fighting, bitchiness or backstabbing all you have to do is read to the end of these comments and witness it first hand. All women commenting all turning against one another, going off tangent and getting personal pretty much proving OPs point. Just a random observation
Of course you never see a bunch of men on an internet forum doing this. Grin Grin Grin
hivemindneeded · 16/12/2021 08:03

@Bertiebiscuit

Women at work are exactly like men at work - some nice and supportive, some really not - I really a object to the "women /girls are bitchy" trope, it is sexist and demeaning - men can also be mean and gossipy, women can be cool, calm and professional - I don't agree with you at all tbh
I think this is the heart of it. If a man is bitchy and backstabbing, which plenty are, it's his personal issue. If a woman is, it;s because 'women' are bitchy.

On two occasions, I have witnessed an alpha female set a very positive tone in a team by overruling the group dynamic of 'let's leave X out' or 'let;s not train Y properly so they flounder because they are a newbie'. I've seen the popular woman that all the men fancy reach out to the new people (self included) and invite them to lunch and show them the ropes. By doing this from a position of power, these women shifted the dynamic away from manipulative into a cohesive team. If you think about it, I'm sure most people on this thread saying women are hell to work with could find similar examples but they choose not to remember them because it doesn't fit their narrative.

hivemindneeded · 16/12/2021 07:55

@risefromyourgrave

I would put money on the fact that men behave just as badly as women, but we let it slide because they are men, and most women have been socially indoctrinated from a very early age to defer to men.

Women in general are great, yes there’s some annoying ones, but that’s the same of any demographic. I have never been told to ‘cheer up’ by a random woman in the street, never been ‘helped’ to park by a random woman in the street, never been groped by a random woman, never been talked over in a meeting by a woman, never been told by a female co-worker that she masturbated over me the previous night.

Women should support and try to understand women, not use misogynistic words like ‘bitchy’ or ‘catty’, all you do is continue the male supremacy by doing this.

Well said. That's my experience too.
Bangolads · 16/12/2021 07:51

The same as @UltraVividLament said. Also I’ve think the OP has successfully displayed prejudice based on very little.

risefromyourgrave · 16/12/2021 07:42

I would put money on the fact that men behave just as badly as women, but we let it slide because they are men, and most women have been socially indoctrinated from a very early age to defer to men.

Women in general are great, yes there’s some annoying ones, but that’s the same of any demographic. I have never been told to ‘cheer up’ by a random woman in the street, never been ‘helped’ to park by a random woman in the street, never been groped by a random woman, never been talked over in a meeting by a woman, never been told by a female co-worker that she masturbated over me the previous night.

Women should support and try to understand women, not use misogynistic words like ‘bitchy’ or ‘catty’, all you do is continue the male supremacy by doing this.

RampantIvy · 16/12/2021 07:32

We had a couple of women in our team like that @Mummadeze. Fortunately our HOD had a good handle on their behaviour and it never escalated. One of the troublemakers handed her notice in and was told that she could leave once she had completed her handover so she ended up not having to complete her notice period. Basically the boss wanted to prevent her from spreading her poison around the office.

Then covid happened and some of our team were furloughed including the other troublemaker. She then got made redundant.

Our team now is brilliant and there is no bitchiness at all.

Watchamocauli · 16/12/2021 07:26

I’m fully on board with what you have said OP. My first job in this country was working with a top global IT co and my experience was ruined because of all women's team, they were quiet nasty. Fortunately I moved to a more mature mixed team in two years. And since never gone back to working in all women's team. and I’m a D&I champion at current workplace for women.

Darkpheonix · 16/12/2021 07:17

What a bitchy thing to say! That's exactly what the OP is referring to female bitchiness.

Let's say you think it was rude to say that. Why attach female to it? A female doing something doesn't make the action 'female'.

Do you think men never point put that if you keep finding yourself in the same situation, that you may be contributing to it?

Op isn't trying to navigate round it. Op admits to also doing it and contributing to it.

So the statement is not wrong is it?

Mummadeze · 16/12/2021 07:06

This has happened to me before in a situation where there was a bad egg who spread gossip, manipulated situations, riled up the other women and turned them against each other. She came across as sweet and butter wouldn’t melt but I saw her stir trouble in all kinds of situations quite subtly. One day one girl punched another and got fired, but it was actually the bad one’s fault who was nowhere near the action simply because she had instigated the situation. It was quite incredible to see how one person affected an entire dynamic of a team. If she hadn’t been in the team, I think all the women would have got along fine.

Dibbydoos · 16/12/2021 06:53

@hugr

Yeah not my experience either. Maybe it's you?
What a bitchy thing to say! That's exactly what the OP is referring to female bitchiness.

I personally have worked in male dominated industry, so not seem or experienced this though in local government, female bitchiness was fairly rife. Like the OP, you navigate around it, but some people are less resilient than others and get upset. My sister experienced this and was hounded out of a role in social services, so it does happen.

Personally OP I'd talk to yoyr manager and HR about it and see if there's an intervention that would be helpful.