Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a reasonable price for a christening cake?

96 replies

Sofiegiraffe · 14/12/2021 16:46

Asking because I genuinely have no idea about these things, I've never ordered a bespoke cake before.

I've been quoted £70 as a minimum price for an 8 inch one tiered cake that serves 25 people.

Does this sound about average?

OP posts:
SpeckledlyHen · 15/12/2021 13:24

@WouldIBeATwat

I’d be using over 750g sugarpaste on a 7” cake (around 4” high). Plus butter cream, plus good ingredients in the sponge. No way could I do that for £10.
I don't get it either. I would use at least 2 packs of butter (approx £1.60-£1.80 per packet), add in the eggs (4), vanilla paste, sugar, good jam, Fondant (£2-£3). Plus colourings, a cake base and a box.

With all the equipment I use, and the tools etc making a cake for £10 is literally giving it away rather than rounding up. I can only assume people using really bad quality ingredients and not proper butter to make a cake for less than £5..

itwasntaparty · 15/12/2021 12:01

I paid £120 for dts cake, I didn't even like it in the end. Now for birthdays I go to Waitrose and buy their plain iced cake for decorating, £20 I think, and then get on Etsy for decorations.

I am not artistic or a baker but they always look good. I did their first communion cake this way too.

XiCi · 15/12/2021 11:58

I'm in the NW and think £70 is very reasonable from your description

The Costco cakes are fine for small kids birthday parties but no way Id have one as a centrepiece for a Christening. They don't look particularly good and they don't taste nice. Unbelievably sweet and mostly icing. They're great when you have 30 schoolkids all needing a piece in their party bags though. We used to send them all home with that and have a nice cake at home later for the adults Grin

HunterGatherer · 15/12/2021 11:55

A christening is not the time for a Costco cake. They are utterly vile, smothered in thick ugly synthetic axel grease. No butter has ever been near that cake.
They are monstrous and yet my sister brings one to every gathering Confused bigger is not always better.

WouldIBeATwat · 15/12/2021 11:51

I’d be using over 750g sugarpaste on a 7” cake (around 4” high). Plus butter cream, plus good ingredients in the sponge. No way could I do that for £10.

WouldIBeATwat · 15/12/2021 11:47

@emmathedilemma

I priced up a 7" sponge cake with fondant icing and decorations recently and charged my friend £10 which was rounding it up to account for all the bits n bobs I didn't itemise. But I didn't charge for my time and I'm no professional. It seems quite a lot for sponge cake, I'd expect maybe £50 but depends on the level of detail in the decorating. The Costco cakes are vile, so artificial and sugary.
We’re you using proper butter, free range eggs and good flour/sugar there?
emmathedilemma · 15/12/2021 10:54

I priced up a 7" sponge cake with fondant icing and decorations recently and charged my friend £10 which was rounding it up to account for all the bits n bobs I didn't itemise. But I didn't charge for my time and I'm no professional. It seems quite a lot for sponge cake, I'd expect maybe £50 but depends on the level of detail in the decorating.
The Costco cakes are vile, so artificial and sugary.

SpeckledlyHen · 15/12/2021 10:48

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

Oh dear - you haven't made many cakes have you?

Or if you do and the ingredients come to less than a fiver I don't think I would want to buy or eat it..

NavigatingAdolescence · 15/12/2021 10:42

Assume you mean a 2 tier naked cake?

They’re a lot harder to do than they look, and they have to be done at the very last minute because the buttercream is so scant. Your baker may well have been up all night making that for you.

buckingmad · 15/12/2021 10:30

I had a bespoke two layer Victoria sponge with buttercream crumb for my wedding (to feed maybe 40 people) and it was £130 (south east)

DeepaBeesKit · 15/12/2021 10:15

Honestly, unless you are paying for fancy decoration that is beyond your skill set, a simple sponge cake is so easy to make!

For an 8inch cake you can get ingredients for a fiver and it takes all of an hour to make and bake.

VestaTilley · 15/12/2021 10:12

No idea but I’d suggest making your own.

Making a giant fruit cake (which will keep and feed a lot of people) will cost no more than £20 in ingredients and buying a big cake tin. It’s very simple to do, lots of recipes on the internet and you can buy ready rolled marzipan and icing.

I made my DS’s christening cake as we didn’t have enough wedding cake left over. It was easy to do and no way I’d pay £70 for a fruit cake! ...but I made my own wedding cake as well so maybe I’m a bit unusual...

DrCoconut · 15/12/2021 10:09

We used the rectangular sponge cake from Asda and decorated it ourselves. There are lots of nice decorations available online and you just need to put them on the cake, no complicated skills needed. I can see why bakers charge what they do but we didn't have the budget for that.

JustWonderingIfYou · 15/12/2021 10:00

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

Where do you shop... The 90s?

I read that as 8 inch high cake as 8 inch diameter wouldn't feed 25. Basic good quality ingredients and icing for that would be at least twice what you are saying. Plus the time of the baker and materials needed for baking and decorating.

CheesyFootballsAreEvil · 15/12/2021 09:59

[quote lap90]M&S do cakes to order online if that would fit your budget more.

Something like this: www.marksandspencer.com/personalised-celebration-sponge-cake-with-gold-ribbon-serves-30-/p/ckp21035342[/quote]
Ooh yes the m&s cakes are great

lap90 · 15/12/2021 09:56

M&S do cakes to order online if that would fit your budget more.

Something like this: www.marksandspencer.com/personalised-celebration-sponge-cake-with-gold-ribbon-serves-30-/p/ckp21035342

Iwantmyoldnameback · 15/12/2021 09:47

Sounds normal to me, have paid it recently for birthday cakes.

NavigatingAdolescence · 15/12/2021 09:19

Costco cake is horrible. Sickly sweet and no texture. (I make cake for fun and wouldn’t buy a Costco one if you paid me.)

CourgetteSeason · 15/12/2021 09:16

Just seen you are in the North East, I am as well.

CourgetteSeason · 15/12/2021 09:15

I paid £60 for a three tiered caked for my sons christening, so yes to me that seems expensive but depends on location I suppose.

lliitttlepiinkhouse · 15/12/2021 09:14

I think that's expensive; depending on how intricate the design is.

I pay £45-50 for an 8" birthday cake but always go for a simple design and buy plastic figures instead of having sugar paste ones made.

Sofiegiraffe · 15/12/2021 09:08

@ZenNudist

Id say £45-50, £70 expensive. Are you London?

M&S very tasty and they used to do a lovely noahs ark.

Not London - north east.
OP posts:
ZenNudist · 15/12/2021 08:36

Id say £45-50, £70 expensive. Are you London?

M&S very tasty and they used to do a lovely noahs ark.

flowersforbrains · 15/12/2021 08:32

Sounds about right. I see a lot of wedding/celebration cakes that are beautiful with clearly a lot of love and effort put into them.

The Costco cake just looks cheap and nasty.

There are always people who come on these threads and say they could knock up a cake in 20 minutes with £5 worth of ingredients from Tesco. I'm a florist and also see threads like this about wedding flowers using gold plated roses and tripling the price when someone mentions the word wedding. I'm of the opinion to tell them to crack on and do the work themselves. Having baled out a few brides over the years, I wouldn't recommend it.

tangyandsalty · 15/12/2021 08:18

@thatsallineed

I must be missing something here. The ingredients for a nice 8" sponge cake plus fondant icing would be not much more than a fiver.

I'd want gold leaf on it for £70.

You're paying for the hours the person will take to make and decorate the cake.
Swipe left for the next trending thread