Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a bonkers idea - possibly leaving my family at Christmas to go to an adult child

196 replies

Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 14:00

Dd is a student. She had a dreadful 2020-2021 (she has autism) but since starting her new course is much better. She has a part time job in her university city and had to choose between booking time off before of after Christmas so she chose before. The plan was her shift will finish at 5pm Christmas Eve then she will drive home arriving around 11pm.

But covid is going mad down there. Her course went online due to so many coming down with it. She travels each day on packed public transport. She is public facing. Today her workplace had to close because too many people are ill. She is very likely to catch it (she is vaccinated and caught it last summer but even so).

I do NOT want dd to spend Christms alone in one room. I have discovered that for £50 I can book a Premier Inn 10 mins walk from her house (she has a room in a shared house). WIBU to book it and if she tests positive travel down to be able to see her on Christmas Day. I'd be leaving dh and ds back home. They can't come as dh has to be there for his elderly father who is facing the first xmas without mil at home.

The Premier Inn can be cancelled with no charge up to 12 noon on the day.

OP posts:
Randomgal28 · 14/12/2021 15:16

I get your point but if you go into her house while she has covid then drive 200 miles home you’re still putting a lot of people at risk - if you breakdown, get petrol etc etc. I get what you’re saying about when your son had covid you didn’t need to isolate but you couldn’t avoid living in the same house as him. You’d be putting yourself at risk going into her house if she does become positive 😟

Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:16

I understand about bringing her home. But me staying down there keeps fil away from her. He will be spending xmas day at our house.

OP posts:
Happy1982ish · 14/12/2021 15:16

@Bluesheep8

IF DD does catch Covid, in theory you wouldn't be able to see her anyway as she'd be isolating...? So she'd possibly be in her room alone, you'd be in the hotel alone and DH & DS would be at home?

This.

Bloody hell Autistic Depressed Alone

And isolating?

I’d step over a dying granny to be with her

Happy1982ish · 14/12/2021 15:15

Why you you just suck up the driving?
In most other countries, no one would bat an eye at 180 miles!

Booklover3 · 14/12/2021 15:15

You aren’t going to get a unanimous response on here. In fact you’ll probably get piled on.

Would I do this for one of my children? Yes. In a heart beat as long as I wasn’t putting anyone except our family at risk.

Bluesheep8 · 14/12/2021 15:14

IF DD does catch Covid, in theory you wouldn't be able to see her anyway as she'd be isolating...? So she'd possibly be in her room alone, you'd be in the hotel alone and DH & DS would be at home?

This.

Happy1982ish · 14/12/2021 15:14

If you were talking about leaving an 8 year old boy who really would mind about you not being there
I’d understand
But you’ve basically said you DS won’t care!
And your DH understandably wants to be there for his parent
If I were him, I’d actively want you to go

LittleMysSister · 14/12/2021 15:13

I'd sleep in the hotel Christmas Eve, go into her house on Christmas Day, then drive home. Ds had covid last month, we have a house big enough to facilitate isolation with own bathroom facilities etc

If you have this option then couldn't DD still come and use these rooms for semi-isolation/isolation if she tests positive at any point?

There is no guarantee she will get it, my sister's husband had it and despite living together and spending time together, she didn't. Better that you are all together over Christmas surely? Rather than leaving DH and DS to it.

Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:13

@IseeScottishhills

Assuming no bladder etc problems in which case I apologise. But why does she need to stop twice on a 180 mile journey. I regularly drive 360 miles and only stop once mainly because the dog wants to pee and as the driver I think it’s good to have a rest from driving even if it’s for 10 mins. But if I had Covid I would avoid stopping.
She's 20 years old and been driving less than 12 months. She needs to haver a couple of stops to stretch her legs, get some air and just re-focus,
OP posts:
Happy1982ish · 14/12/2021 15:11

180 miles? I’d just suck it up and bring her home and drive her back two days later

Or

I’d stay in the hotel

You son, also autistic, you’ve explicitly said he would be fine without you but not without his Piano

It really isn’t much of a dilemma. Either way, I’d be with me daughter.

Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:11

It's a higher education course that isn't eligible for student finance. Next September after she has done this foundation year she will be able to get a loan towards part of the fees as she will be officially enrolled onto the MA part of the course.

OP posts:
IseeScottishhills · 14/12/2021 15:10

Assuming no bladder etc problems in which case I apologise. But why does she need to stop twice on a 180 mile journey. I regularly drive 360 miles and only stop once mainly because the dog wants to pee and as the driver I think it’s good to have a rest from driving even if it’s for 10 mins. But if I had Covid I would avoid stopping.

DappyApple · 14/12/2021 15:10

@Changemaname1

I’m confused is this based on if she has covid ?

As it stands since she is off work and uni why don’t you just go get her and bring her home for Xmas ?

Yes I was thinking this as well.
titchy · 14/12/2021 15:08

If you're all happy to break rules, and the main issue is therefore her as an inexperienced driver doing the journey without stopping, it does make sense for you to therefore go an collect her.

As an aside how come she is not able to get a fee loan?

hivemindneeded · 14/12/2021 15:08

If her workplace has had to close, surely she'd be better cutting her losses and coming home now. She's a student, so she won't be working there permanently anyway.

If not, I'd do exactly what you suggest and would have no qualms about driving her home to isolate with you. Not enough consideration is given to MH issues surrounding isolation. DS2 was dangerously low last year and DS1's partner who isolated alone in a foreign country last year said it was the worst time of their life.

Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:07

@Happy1982ish

* She is very likely to catch it (she is vaccinated and caught it last summer but even so).*

She reel really isn’t “highly likely to catch it if vaccinated and has had a confirmed case a few months ago

She caught covid last June/July
OP posts:
Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:07

@JustJustWhy

I have a wonderful and loving family yet still for reasons that were out of everyone's control I spent one Christmas on my own. I've never felt so genuinely low and depressed in all my life - it shocked me to be honest because I never knew how bad I'd feel. Go to her. Don't let anyone be alone at Christmas.
This is my train of thought.
OP posts:
Happy1982ish · 14/12/2021 15:07

* She is very likely to catch it (she is vaccinated and caught it last summer but even so).*

She reel really isn’t “highly likely to catch it if vaccinated and has had a confirmed case a few months ago

Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:06

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

Can’t you go and get her as quickly as possible and if needs be she can self isolate in your house? If her course in on line and her work place closed?
It's only closed for two days.
OP posts:
JustJustWhy · 14/12/2021 15:05

I have a wonderful and loving family yet still for reasons that were out of everyone's control I spent one Christmas on my own. I've never felt so genuinely low and depressed in all my life - it shocked me to be honest because I never knew how bad I'd feel. Go to her. Don't let anyone be alone at Christmas.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/12/2021 15:05

Can’t you go and get her as quickly as possible and if needs be she can self isolate in your house? If her course in on line and her work place closed?

Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:05

@HatterMadeMad3

What are her flat mates doing for Xmas? Will anyone be in her shared accommodation? Has anyone checked this, because it might be fun to have Xmas there

Secondly, you said that she was having time off after Xmas
So can you all celebrate Xmas on Boxing day or New Year's day instead ?
That's what we have done (pre covid) when family members have worked over xmas

She has Xmas Day, Boxing Day and the Mon-Wednesday afterwards off. She is back in work on 30th.
OP posts:
Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:04

@BrocolliFloret

Even if you went to see her for a couple of days she’d still have to isolate alone for the rest of the 10 days, which sounds like a terrible idea if she is depressed already.

Maybe just ask her to come home as a precaution now, sounds like the workplace is not going to be open much anyway?

In reality I’d probably let her keep working, and just go and get her if and when she needed to do a pcr test, prior to the test. There are some very sturdy sealable blue potty bags available (not the kids ones).

She has done 3 lots of isolation back in the summer, it was hard, but it wasn;t christmas day.

She is testing daily for work anyway.

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 14/12/2021 15:03

@HaveringWavering

Is it not a bit dramatic to say that she would have to leave her course if she ever lost her part time job - that could happen for all sorts of reasons. Couldn’t she just find another one?

I mean, I can see why you don’t think that she should voluntarily put herself in a position that threatens her job just so that she can spend Xmas with family, but the whole setup sounds a bit precarious if her entire education is reliant on her getting shifts at Nando’s or whatever.

It's the best job she has ever had. it is incredibly inclusive in regard to her autism and it is related to the area she is studying. The hours work perfectly with her studies.
OP posts:
Happy1982ish · 14/12/2021 15:03

* He's 17,(also autistic though) he can cope without mum for a day or two, he can't cope without his piano!*

Well isn’t that your answer?
Of course you can go