Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two - nationality families

192 replies

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 13:54

Does anyone else go through this?
My background - my mum is Irish and my Dad is English.
I was born in England. My parents divorced and I moved with my mum back to Ireland when I was 7. My parents had a bitter divorce and my mother hates my dad, and really all things English.

I was born in England and I feel English. I just live in Ireland now.

Anytime that I am with my mother, she insults the English. She will openly talk with hatred about English people, she just hates them.
This seems to come from her upbringing where as a child in Ireland she was taught by her Irish relatives to hate English people. And also comes from her hatred of my English father now too .

For example, I just visited her today. She went on a trip to Wales last year. I asked her how it was and she said "oh they hate the English there, sure the English took them over, like the English took Ireland and Scotland over". She will also say things like "the Irish are well liked around the world and the English aren't".

I just feel so deeply wounded every time I talk to her.
I, her daughter, was born in England! I'm English, and my own mother constantly tells me how much she hates the English. It really wounds me and affects my self esteem. I'm not sure how to deal with her. I've told her before it upsets me but she does it anyway. She is 73 and will just ramble on

I know the easiest answer is to cut her off. But I think I would feel too guilty to do that.

I'm just not sure how to deal with her. Any advice?

OP posts:
madisonbridges · 14/12/2021 20:47

My sister married a Frenchman who hates Britain. They live in France with their children. He constantly goes on about how shit we are...

But does he not realise that he's telling his children how shit their mother and their grandparents are? I think that makes him a far bigger shit. But that's the French for you! (😉 Just joking. I have lots of friends from France and used to live there.)

Cyberworrier · 14/12/2021 20:46

Hi OP, I have family across the UK/Ireland too and have experienced similar, but I take it as light hearted teasing. I mean, Scotland's politicians and nobility were just as responsible for most of Britain's power/abuse of power as English ones so I take it all with a bit of a pinch of salt. From my family's perspective I take the Irish issue with England more seriously, but as you say it is not your personal responsibility, the terrible history. And groups with long term historical grudges are not helping the world. I'd try to just ignore, especially if there's the chance she's trying to actually upset you. With a few relatives I've told them it upsets me as I don't feel "properly" English as that's not my cultural frame of reference and none of my family are; they understand but it doesn't stop piss taking!

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 20:45

@RocketPanda I live in rural ireland.its not just my family. I was in a pub once here and there was an old man complaining about the English.
My friend said something like "hey don't say that, mufasa here is English".

The man came over to me, got right in my face and said "who the fuck let you over here, you English bitch". "English cunt". I've had similiar to this said to me several times in my life.

OP posts:
penguinwithasuitcase · 14/12/2021 20:44

@Mufasa1118 is she unpleasant to you in other ways?

Or is she mostly normal imperfect mother, with this deeply irritating habit?

All this chat about cutting her off / abuse sounds completely over the top to me unless there's a bigger context here (speaking as someone who's been NC with a genuinely abusive mother for the last 5 years, some of the immediate 'Go NC!' responses on here are really quite incredible)

chutneygirl · 14/12/2021 20:43

My in-laws love to slag off england and the English so much until I like to remind them, the reason why their life is so cushty is because of being in England and because their ENGLISH daughter in law pays their mortgage and if they don't like it, then go get on a plane back to Kabul...

Seems to be a conversation stopper!

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 20:42

@MrsTerryPratchett "English people still benefit from historical atrocities".
There you go - grouping English people as a homogenous blob.

We are all different, individual people.

I have never once benefitted from English atrocities .

Lots of people in England are a mixture of nationalities. You can't just say "the English".

OP posts:
Mushypeasandchipstogo · 14/12/2021 20:41

My DH is Irish , I’m British. DC have both passports but follow Irish rugby teams. DH pretends that I’m Welsh as I come from a border town. To be honest nobody cares what we are in his and my family.

RocketPanda · 14/12/2021 20:41

I know quite a lot of German people and there is generally a sense of shame when talking about anything to do with WW2. Not going around with their heads in the their hands type but a recognition of sorrow at what was done in their countries name. British and it seems especially English Pride and Self Righteousness is not even tinged with sorrow. Scotland has and continues for some of the population to seek independence, NI is all but forgotten and Wales is barely talked about.
I do wonder where in Ireland you are that people are saying they hate you. It's quite a multicultural little country now and there's plenty of English people working here and other than a one twit I know who thought we were all mucksavages I've never heard of any anti Englishness. Maybe it's just your family.

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/12/2021 20:38

Of course I don't. I was replying to you saying it was just the way the conversation went. It wasn't, you chose. Which is fine.

But it does rather muddy the waters. As an abused child you are absolutely without fault and deserving of understanding.

As an apologist for colonialism, you aren't. If you want to have that conversation, see my post of 20.35.

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 20:35

@MrsTerryPratchett what a weird response! Im allowed to reply to whoever I want to. You don't control me.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 14/12/2021 20:35

The Canadian government just set aside $40 BILLION for indigenous reparations. Recognising that what happened historically hurt First Nations people and helped white colonialists. English people still benefit from historical atrocities. They might not be to blame but just to say that history starts afresh when whole continents are worse off is a little self-serving.

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 20:25

@RocketPanda yes but still the current UK people didn't do any of that. I didn't do any of that. Just by being born in England doesn't make me responsible for any of that

I have to say Ive seen this attitude a lot in Ireland,. It's an attitude of "hate all the English ". I just don't agree with that

Being born in England does not make me responsible in any way for what people in England did before me.

I have a German friend here in Ireland. I would never say to her "you're awful and I hate you because of what Hitler did"
.
But many Irish people (not just my mother) have told me that they hate me just because I'm English. How is that ok?

OP posts:
PAFMO · 14/12/2021 20:23

OP- you have said on many many threads that your mother severely abused you as a child. You're on all the Arthur Labinjo-Hughes threads talking about it.
I don't think her having a pop at the "English" is your biggest problem tbf.

RocketPanda · 14/12/2021 20:21

Your mother is 73 so the legacy of the Irish struggle for freedom from Britain is in her living memory. The refugees from Northern Ireland are in mine and I'm a good bit younger than she is.
There's a wayside gravestone and famine cottages visible from my kitchen window and I live in an Irish speaking area of Ireland. The reality of the cruelty inflicted is still present today.

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/12/2021 20:20

You've only engaged with the stuff about colonalisation, not strategies about your mother.

You're deciding what to respond to.

People will be empathetic about your mum. But being an apologist for colonialisation which still affects billions of people? Not so much.

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 20:14

@MrsTerryPratchett threads are like conversations, they can flow from one topic to another.
I started this thread to talk about my mother's views about the UK

A different poster actually came on and talked about the UK colonising places. Which is related to the first topic. And then I replied to them.

That is how we are at the point we are talking about now. It was a natural flow

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 14/12/2021 20:04

You started this thread to talk about personal relationships. It does rather look like it was started in bad faith to argue some shitty point about colonialism.

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 19:59

@Cathy31 have you forgotten about world war two in Europe? That happened last century, and it happened around the same time as the Irish/English problems.

Germany invaded far more countries last century than England did. I would never hold the current German people responsible.

OP posts:
cunningplan101 · 14/12/2021 18:58

@Cathy31 I think you are wrong about Spain. There are elected right-wing politicians in Spain who still claim the Spanish empire was one of the greatest civilising forces for good in the world. I doubt any British politician, even Nigel Farage, would come out and say that? (Even if they might think it, or mutter it over a glass of port in the club)

The leadr of Vox recently said of Empire: "Asking for forgiveness is part of cancel culture, of destroying the history of the nations of which we are so proud." Link: www.nytimes.com/2021/10/09/world/europe/spain-conservatives-conquistadors.html

And that's not to mention Franco. Spain is a perhaps the only previously fascist country which has never really come to terms with its fascism - they just changed from a fascist state to a democracy while keeping most of the fascist politicians in power.

Does that mean we should hate all Spanish people?

If someone said it was understandable for the Polish to hate the Germans, would we think that was sensible?

MarshaBradyo · 14/12/2021 18:43

Say

Mum I’m English remember.. that’s insulting to me

happytoday73 · 14/12/2021 18:42

Mum stop insulting me...
.... Rinse and repeat...

ShiftingSands21 · 14/12/2021 18:37

My DH and DF who are both from different countries both have a bit of blind hatred for the English going on. I always pull them up on it, and describe it as the blind prejudice it is, but I also find it quite amusing on some level! I’m not even English myself but it’s just all extremely ludicrous and based on nothing. If you try to get them to justify it, they struggle to give a coherent explanation!

Cathy31 · 14/12/2021 18:22

If your my hates you, go no contact, of course. If your mum hates 'the English', and your identity as English matters more than your identity as her daughter, go no contact. I think that would be taking English national pride to a bit of an extreme, but each to their own.

I agree with @MrsTerryPratchett and @FelinaDaHousecat re the bigger picture here though. Spain And the Netherlands have come to terms much more fully with the atrocities committed in their names - there aren't many debates in those countries about benign empire, or about complex legacies, or 'at least we gave them trains '. Also, the Irish experience of 'British '/ 'English ' presence is a lot more recent than the nineteenth century (I think that's what you mean by when 'people were taking land everywhere'). Though, even back then, most people weren't 'taking land everywhere '. Mostly they were having it taken from them. Mostly by... Go on, OP, guess who... Wink

MrsTerryPratchett · 14/12/2021 15:59

A lot of countries colonised other countries. That is how it was in history. People were taking land everywhere.

And everyone is still dealing with the consequences, both good (for us) and bad (for them).

Regardless, that isn't the basis of your relationship with your mother, that's the point. I can politically have an issue but that shouldn't impact her personal relationship with you.

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 15:54

@felinadaHousecat.

The UK were not the only country to colonise other countries. The Netherlands colonised Indonesia. I used to work in Indonesia. And they told me how there how the Netherlands took them over and colonised them
Spain also colonised many countries.

A lot of countries colonised other countries. That is how it was in history. People were taking land everywhere.

And 2) it is not the Current people in the UK who did it. The current people are not responsible.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread