Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Two - nationality families

192 replies

Mufasa1118 · 14/12/2021 13:54

Does anyone else go through this?
My background - my mum is Irish and my Dad is English.
I was born in England. My parents divorced and I moved with my mum back to Ireland when I was 7. My parents had a bitter divorce and my mother hates my dad, and really all things English.

I was born in England and I feel English. I just live in Ireland now.

Anytime that I am with my mother, she insults the English. She will openly talk with hatred about English people, she just hates them.
This seems to come from her upbringing where as a child in Ireland she was taught by her Irish relatives to hate English people. And also comes from her hatred of my English father now too .

For example, I just visited her today. She went on a trip to Wales last year. I asked her how it was and she said "oh they hate the English there, sure the English took them over, like the English took Ireland and Scotland over". She will also say things like "the Irish are well liked around the world and the English aren't".

I just feel so deeply wounded every time I talk to her.
I, her daughter, was born in England! I'm English, and my own mother constantly tells me how much she hates the English. It really wounds me and affects my self esteem. I'm not sure how to deal with her. I've told her before it upsets me but she does it anyway. She is 73 and will just ramble on

I know the easiest answer is to cut her off. But I think I would feel too guilty to do that.

I'm just not sure how to deal with her. Any advice?

OP posts:
Mufasa1118 · 15/12/2021 14:01

@trashypanda you said " So you are half Irish and have lived in Ireland for 20+ years, but identify only with your English heritage?

That’s sad."

Yes, I feel I am from where I was born. I have a friend here in Ireland, who was born in Australia and moved to Ireland at the age of 7. She still feels she is Australian. I have another friend here who moved to Ireland from England when she was 9, she still feels English.

A lot of our identity wrapped up in where we are born.

OP posts:
LexMitior · 15/12/2021 10:53

I don't think its too hard really - yes people who do this "I don't like your nationality" in a personal way are basically being very rude, obviously. Individuals aren't a sort of bag carrier for their whole society and history.

There is lots of international rivalry and adverse comment between neighbouring countries - that seems normal. Doing it in a family context is just rude.

Re Ireland and England, the links between the two countries also diminish due to Brexit. One of the odder things about Brexit is that it will prompt a real change in Britain away from Europe in every sense. Give it ten years and our diversity of people here will be very different, and look a lot less European and whole lot more Anglo and Asian. Interesting times.

JaneJeffer · 15/12/2021 10:51

She married an English man despite being brought up to hate the English. Sure Jan.

CounsellorTroi · 15/12/2021 10:42

@madisonbridges

I’m not anti English. I married an Englishman. I support the England football team.

Sorry, I misunderstood. You said he was more anti-English than you so I read that you were anti English and he even more so. But that makes me happy that you don't dislike the English because I used to live in Wales and made good friends there. You have a beautiful country.

No probs, I think England is a beautiful country too, we have always enjoyed our holidays there and have good English friends!
RuggerHug · 15/12/2021 10:40

Irish are Brits.....pardon?

Heruka · 15/12/2021 10:40

I wasn’t aware of that, @madisonbridges, sounds worth a bit more reading. I thought it was quite established, like here in the west of Scotland how the history of poverty, industrial work, alcohol all part of intergenerational increased propensity towards heart disease for example.

And I thought things like coeliac disease being higher in Ireland related to the dietary norms and I would connect that to the impacts of abuse of the nations resources by Britain? Apologies if that is incorrect though, interested in other information about it.

madisonbridges · 15/12/2021 10:38

And to be fair these things cut both ways. The Brits can be very unpleasant about the Irish/Welsh and French. (Not the Scots so much).
The Welsh, Irish and Scots are equally Brits. Are they saying bad things about each other?
And to be fair, the French are fair game. 😉

Ohnomoreno · 15/12/2021 10:31

@RobotValkyrie I'm guessing from your user name you also get the various "Auf der Insel" comments about the Brits. It's all so disappointing in both directions, just very glad my in-laws didn't vote for Brexit!

Practicebeingpatient · 15/12/2021 10:31

@LittleRoundRobin

Funny how some people find it so easy to be so massively insulting towards the English. The English get berated and slated and spoken about like they're shit, moreso than any other nationality.

Your mother is a disgrace @Mufasa1118 and I would go full-on 'no contact' if I were you.

I think it's just that you personally hear it more about Brits than you do people talking about any other country. It's traditional for there to be a rivalry verging enmity between neighbouring countries. For instance a lot of Burmese people have nothing good to say about Thais and vice versa. It's particularly strong when there is a history of war and colonisation and human nature being what it is there is always a history of war and colonisation.

And to be fair these things cut both ways. The Brits can be very unpleasant about the Irish/Welsh and French. (Not the Scots so much). My mum is Irish and my paternal grandmother constantly referred to her as a bog trotter or a papist. And that's what she said in my hearing!

HaveToSaySomethingHere · 15/12/2021 10:13

Just say "boring, booooorrrrring...." everytime and just quietly mooch off somewhere else for a while. Anything else is a waste of effort. You will NEVER get the last word. It's rude but she's being rude too.

Dontbekatty · 15/12/2021 10:10

Ugh all this anti-British/English thing really gets my goat. I get this a lot an a Brit in Ireland, its ingrained in the psyche here. Yet so many Irish choose to make their living in the UK. Where everyone is morally bankrupt and stupid. Anti Brit stuff runs through the media here and all life I’ve found. Sick of it, am trapped at the moment but waiting to escape. I miss the multi culturalism of the Uk. I have family that start the ‘800 years of oppression’ thing and I just get away and refuse to engage. Stop your mum ranting every single time op. Tell her you don’t want to hear it. Your mum is 73, if she can’t/won’t recognise what she’s doing, limit the time you spend with her.

You’re not alone op. Remind her that people are sadly risking their lives everyday to get into the Uk. It’s a great country.

madisonbridges · 15/12/2021 09:48

@Mushypeasandchipstogo

He really doesn’t care, he only does this jokingly!
Oh, I see. Sorry. That's good. I thought he was ashamed of you being English. I've got to stop early morning reading! Haha.
madisonbridges · 15/12/2021 09:43

I’m not anti English. I married an Englishman. I support the England football team.

Sorry, I misunderstood. You said he was more anti-English than you so I read that you were anti English and he even more so. But that makes me happy that you don't dislike the English because I used to live in Wales and made good friends there. You have a beautiful country.

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 15/12/2021 09:34

@madisonbridges My last comment was in reply to you!

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 15/12/2021 09:31

He really doesn’t care, he only does this jokingly!

Ohnomoreno · 15/12/2021 09:31

I get this constantly from my half sisters. Endlessly laughing at the Brits, how we're all so uneducated "on the island", how uncultured everyone is, how stupid our politicians are (yes, I agree!!), and the worst bit is that the only time they've even been here in their lives is to visit me for a few days - they only know what they've read in the papers. I try to meet them half-way on it, in the sense that I am also only half English and can see how a lot of things look to other countries and can see what bollocks journalists write about the UK. But sometimes I just turn around and tell them they're being incredibly narrow minded and prejudiced. It then stops for a few months.

TrashyPanda · 15/12/2021 09:26

So you are half Irish and have lived in Ireland for 20+ years, but identify only with your English heritage?

That’s sad.

luinagreine · 15/12/2021 09:08

@Fidgetty

This sounds bizarre to me. Have you lived in Ireland full time since the age of 7? And you're now presumably in your 30s/40s judging by your mother's age? It really doesn't sound like that... You seem woefully ill-informed about the cultural context of your mothers feelings, which would be pretty much impossible for a child raised most of her life in Ireland. Surely you're just as Irish as you are English after that length of time? Something about this doesn't ring true to me and seems like there's an agenda here, but if I'm wrong I apologise and my advice would be to accept your mother isn't going to change her views at this stage of her life and you have to decide whether or not your can tolerate it. If not minismise contact.
I agree with this. How can you have grown up here, gone to school here and still think that the 2nd world war happened around the same time as the 'Irish/English problems'? Like it was just a couple of years of history, like it was just a wee 'problem'.
CounsellorTroi · 15/12/2021 08:56

I’m not anti English. I married an Englishman. I support the England football team.

It does annoy me when people use England as though it’s interchangeable with Britain/the UK though.

madisonbridges · 15/12/2021 08:40

@CounsellorTroi. That's sad that you're anti English. Most of us quite nice really. 🙂

CounsellorTroi · 15/12/2021 08:36

My DH is English, I’m Welsh. He has lived in Wales for longer than he lived in England. If anything he is more anti English than I am! We have an arrangement re sport - he supports Wales at rugby at all times. I support England at football at all times except when they are playing Wales. Works for us.

madisonbridges · 15/12/2021 08:27

@Heruka. I think there's a lot of scepticism and pushback over the claim that, for example, famine can effect future generations. So although I don't know if Stairway is right or wrong, I do know that it's not right to say that they are scientifically inaccurate because not only has that claim not been proven, it's strongly held by most of the scientific community not to be true.

Heruka · 15/12/2021 07:40

Yes agreed, it is naive Stairway, and just scientifically inaccurate. Epigenetics show that the experiences of the famine can/have affected the genetics and lived experiences of subsequent generations.

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/12/2021 00:29

@stairway

MrsTerryPratchett so why is the OP an apologist, She hasn’t defended colonisation, just said it has nothing to do with her. I like to think we start a fresh, It might be naive because humans like to saddle there children with beliefs etc but it is society saddling the children as children are born a blank canvas.
You can think that, but it's not true. If you believe that the colonialism which caused the genocide in Rwanda or the residential schools in Canada lasts one generation, you are sorely mistaken.
stairway · 14/12/2021 22:35

MrsTerryPratchett so why is the OP an apologist, She hasn’t defended colonisation, just said it has nothing to do with her. I like to think we start a fresh, It might be naive because humans like to saddle there children with beliefs etc but it is society saddling the children as children are born a blank canvas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread