Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want to discuss my private health with doctor receptionists

232 replies

Jasmine00 · 14/12/2021 12:08

I'm so sick of calling my doc surgery and having to explain to the receptionist my ailments especially as they are mostly endometriosis related. Sometimes they even try and give advice back. Arggggg I hate it.
Doesn't help that I live in a small village and these are the people I see on a daily basis either

OP posts:
LittleRoundRobin · 14/12/2021 15:29

[quote bestdhever]@OnlyonemoresleeptilChristmas all the more reason why they should be seeing people. Or are they just THAT busy. All I see on here is that GP's are not taking people etc etc[/quote]
Agree with this. Unfortunately, many GPs in most surgeries don't seem to be treating anything with any urgency. They are the only profession who are still largely refusing to see anyone, and yet no-one seems to be doing anything about it.

Gazelda · 14/12/2021 15:28

I'm sure there are some gp receptionists who try to overstep their role. And maybe some who gossip.

But generally speaking, they are just like you and I. Doing a job. Trying to be helpful. Wanting every person they engage with through the day to be courteous. Worried about their risk to covid. Trying to be a Supportive team member to their colleagues who (again) had the rug pulled from under them on Sunday.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 14/12/2021 15:26

@Jasmine00

It's harder because these receptionists I see at school, local shops and local places. Do I really want these people to have to know about my gynae issues, not really! In a city you are more anonymous so I don't think this would be such an issue
I'm sure you wouldn't mind if they picked up on something that meant you needed to be seen urgently and you hadnt realised it was that important, though.

I used to take calls where after asking really gently, reluctant people would then give me exactly the information I needed to be able to override the system and rules set by on high to get them in within 24 hours. Or where management had banned overrides and overbooking altogether, to go and speak to the consultant and get them to add the patient onto the list for the next day.

Other times, it was the casual remark made at the end where I'd realise that they should actually be calling an ambulance/referred on a two week wonder/USC.

I never had any interest in sharing the intimate gynaecological workings of anybody I knew. I'd rather talk about films or running. And I preferred to be able to put people who actually did need an urgent appointment ahead of those with the gynaecological equivalent of an ingrowing toenail.

bestdhever · 14/12/2021 15:26

@OnlyonemoresleeptilChristmas all the more reason why they should be seeing people. Or are they just THAT busy. All I see on here is that GP's are not taking people etc etc

theemmadilemma · 14/12/2021 15:23

At our surgery it's clearly signed that the Receptionists will ask for details of your condition, they are trained to signpost you to correct care for your specific issue. It's also announced before you get through on the phone. Your GP is no longer your one stop shop and they are there to ensure they're only seeing the people who actually need a GP.

bratzybaby · 14/12/2021 15:22

@ClaudiaWankleman

It was patronising for the poster to suggest using “big words” that apparently a receptionist in a doctors surgery could not possibly know the meaning of.

It feels like common sense that non-specialists (which GP receptionists are) won't know the range of applicable medical terminology to describe all conditions. I think many people who are more highly educated than the average GP receptionist would struggle to understand medical terminology. It doesn't feel patronising to me - what sense of superiority is gained?

Thank you @ClaudiaWankleman you've put it into much better words but that's exactly what I meant. I'm just a regular Joe and if someone said to me 'I'm struggling with the effects of my spinal headache which has been caused by a dural puncture tap causing low pressure in the brain. My new medication isn't helping my migraines' (which is what I now say to the GP receptionists) I'd have no clue what that really means and what advice to give them. Hence me saying I now use big words so a GP can call me to discuss it.

All I meant was I don't dumb it down by saying 'I'm struggling with my spinal headache' because receptionists try to give advice which isn't applicable. That's all.

@Hillarious not sure if you're just trying to find something to be insulted by but I meant bless them as in bless them for trying to help. The advice given may not apply but they mean well..

LittleRoundRobin · 14/12/2021 15:22

@pianolessons1

I'm a GP. About 5% of my patients refuse to say and just say 'personal', which is fine. But I prioritise based on what the receptionists say and 'personal' goes in with non urgent.
@pianolessons1 As other posters have said, that is shockingly bad treatment. Shock I really genuinely hope this isn't true. Sad
LittleRoundRobin · 14/12/2021 15:18

@Jasmine00 As some people have said, the receptionists need to know (roughly) what is wrong, so they can direct you to the correct HCP. They probably don't want to ask anymore than you want them to! They shouldn't be giving medical advice though!

Unfortunately anyone here who is in a small village will know that this doesn't always work when everyone knows everyone. Eg receptionists congratulating women in playground when they have called in for morning sickness medicine etc you get the picture!

Really? Shock If this happens, that is very wrong, and deserves a written complaint. (Actual letter or email.)

godmum56 · 14/12/2021 15:17

@Jasmine00

It's harder because these receptionists I see at school, local shops and local places. Do I really want these people to have to know about my gynae issues, not really! In a city you are more anonymous so I don't think this would be such an issue
but to an extent, they will know, they will generate prescriptions, handle test results and consultant letters and from this they will have a pretty fair idea of what the problem is. I partially understand your issue. I live in a small village too and used to work in the NHS. I was on first name terms, although not friends outside work, with many of the GP's in the local practices. I have provided rehab services to my neighbours including advice on catheters and so on to both men and women but in those cases I offered them the option of seeing another staff member. When my husband was terminally ill it was the team I had managed who provided his in home treatment, again including the messy personal stuff. The other thing is that apart from the rare bad egg, we just aren't interested. Not to disparage patients and their concerns which are very real, but we deal with hundreds of people over a year. Most of them will have some kind of private issue. Nothing of your medical notes is likely to be amazing or unusual or worthy of note....and that's the truth.
RoastedParnsip · 14/12/2021 15:16

YANBU. I simply say "sorry it's private I can only discuss it with my GP and since your not a qualified health professional I'm not comfortable sharing."
Shuts them up. Grin

EssexLioness · 14/12/2021 15:16

@Sceptre86

There are posts like this every few weeks. They don't ask for their own amusement and you should put in a written complaint to the practice manager if receptionists are giving out unsolicited health advice when they are not qualified to do so. That is unreasonable! The information is needed to help triage your call. If you would rather not say state that and ask them to put on on your records so you avoid this every time you need an appointment. Receptionists don't make up the rules, they are told to triage calls. They are also bound by confidentiality and will rightly be sacked if they were gossiping about your health.
This!
RoseMartha · 14/12/2021 15:16

It is frustrating OP. I have to tell the receptionist detailed personal information of the problem to even get a phone consultation. Then to be told all appointments for that day have gone

You are not alone.

pianolessons1 · 14/12/2021 15:15

@girlmom21

really, shocked and appalled that could kill someone

You realise they just get dealt with later in the day, right?

How's the doctor supposed to know it's urgent if the patient doesn't say what the issue is?

It means they will get called maybe an hour or so later than they would do otherwise. How is that going to kill someone?
Elodeastar · 14/12/2021 15:14

While I understand your concerns (I have them too) it is essentially part of their job - it's not their fault they are asked to do this, so treat them kindly.

ReeseWitherfork · 14/12/2021 15:14

how can it be right what Gp surgeries are allowed to get away with
Get away with what? Not prioritising someone who won't say what the problem is? You realise 999 have very different response times based on the problem and they won't dispatch an 8 minute ambulance if you refuse to tell them what the problem is? Heck, they probably won't send an ambulance at all. Needing urgent life threatening medical help is not the time to be cagey and secretive.

IncompleteSenten · 14/12/2021 15:13

They ask because they are told to ask.
Giving advice is different. They aren't qualified to give medical advice and should be discouraged from doing so.

girlmom21 · 14/12/2021 15:13

@milly74 they have to call patients in some kind of order and they can only prioritise the ones where they know what the issue is.

What do you think they're 'getting away with'?

They ask what's wrong for a reason.

TroysMammy · 14/12/2021 15:11

@pianolessons1 the GPs in the surgery I work in would do the same.

milly74 · 14/12/2021 15:10

[quote girlmom21]@milly74 don't be so ridiculously dramatic [/quote]
i wish i was being
how can it be right what Gp surgeries are allowed to get away with

Alonelonelyloner · 14/12/2021 15:08

I phoned once to desperately make an appointment for my son who was suicidal - during covid and not easy to get appointments.
Goodness that receptionist was a beautiful human being who calmly spoke to me and reassured me and promised me that the GP would speak to my son and that we would together help my boy.

I am crying thinking about that receptionist.

But otherwise YANBU!

girlmom21 · 14/12/2021 15:07

@milly74 don't be so ridiculously dramatic

milly74 · 14/12/2021 15:07

@girlmom21

really, shocked and appalled that could kill someone

You realise they just get dealt with later in the day, right?

How's the doctor supposed to know it's urgent if the patient doesn't say what the issue is?

don't defend the indefensible
NandorTheRelentless · 14/12/2021 15:05

@TurtleBeach

I completely understand the need to gather information about the reason for my appointment request and would be happy to give it in order to ensure I am seen by the most suitable person as quickly and efficiently as possible. But, this system does not work in conjunction with the "must phone at 8am" system. At this time of the day, I have no private space to have the conversation. I'll often be with people I know but whom I don;t want overhearing something as vague as "gynae problems" or "mental health" issues. This is still private medical information and the reason why the actual consultations with the GP take place behind closed doors. Allow me to call at any time of day and I'll find space to give the receptionist any and all of the information they need.
Change your doctor then - if you cannot call at any time to make an appointment then change your doctor.

I can phone at any time (well, they ask you not to call for results at X time but apart from that)

triceratopsatemyhat · 14/12/2021 15:04

Sorry I think my post wasn't clear.

What I meant was, this is why there is a triage system. The Drs decide the order of priority, we don't triage ourselves obviously.

To be fair though OP if it's a gyn issue you're likely under the care of a specialist who you should be contacting?

girlmom21 · 14/12/2021 14:55

really, shocked and appalled that could kill someone

You realise they just get dealt with later in the day, right?

How's the doctor supposed to know it's urgent if the patient doesn't say what the issue is?

Swipe left for the next trending thread