Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want to discuss my private health with doctor receptionists

232 replies

Jasmine00 · 14/12/2021 12:08

I'm so sick of calling my doc surgery and having to explain to the receptionist my ailments especially as they are mostly endometriosis related. Sometimes they even try and give advice back. Arggggg I hate it.
Doesn't help that I live in a small village and these are the people I see on a daily basis either

OP posts:
DreamingofGinoclock · 14/12/2021 16:36

Your a GP you have one appointment left ... One set of notes the receptionist has noted information that could potentially lead to a cancer diagnosis ...the other set of notes has nothing as the patient didn't want to note what the issue was ....which patient do you prioritize!

GPs / nurses can only triage using the info they have ...

ironorchids · 14/12/2021 16:29

@SometimesRavenSometimesParrot

Curious as to why people are saying GPs and receptionists are held to the same professional standards…GPs are registered and could be struck off for unprofessional, ruining their career. They’ve also probably trained for ten years +. Receptionists are not comparable - worst case if they gossip they get sacked
Exactly!

Of course you should say less to a receptionist than you would to a GP.

ironorchids · 14/12/2021 16:27

Why would I expect a GP and receptionist to have the same standards with respect to privacy?

Sure they're both supposed to keep stuff private, but what do they have to lose if they don't, and someone complains?

The GP on the one hand could get struck off, have their licence take away and have the years maybe decades of training and experience suddenly unusable to them from an employment perspective as they may then have to seek employment in a different field.

A GP's receptionist will lose what? Their ability to work in a GPs surgery? It's not the 7 years of medical school, years of clinical, years of exams to become a doctor, even all the investment before that to get the grades to get into medical school that they'd be throwing away.
They could become a receptionist in another field that is not medical.

A GP has a hell of a lot more to lose by disclosing medical details inappropriately than a receptionist does.

Peaseblossum22 · 14/12/2021 16:25

The point I'm making is that just because people don't feel confident talking about their health does not make their problem less serious. My father was seen partly because his fab GP realised that it was so unusual for him to visit the Dr that he must be worried.and could be serious. It was very serious but he just could not have brought himself to talk about it, the GP by the way was a women, (not from Church!) , but because she was a GP he felt confident that he could be open, its like she wasn't a person she was a Dr, if that makes sense.

ReeseWitherfork · 14/12/2021 16:19

@Peaseblossum22 can't reply as not really sure I understand what point you're making. But nevermind. The system clearly worked for your dad, and I'm glad he got seen.

milly74 · 14/12/2021 16:17

@TractorAndHeadphones

Sorry if I've missed something but why are receptionists triaging? What could they possibly know about medicine? I can understand them needing details to pass on to the doctor, or write in the appointment details but that's it. They should not be gatekeeping!
seems they are and if you don't give them your warts and all GP relegates you to bottom of pile. Its disgusting
Peaseblossum22 · 14/12/2021 16:15

@ReeseWitherfork and as you will see from my post the GP did see him and luckily was empathetic enough to understand that people often find medical things hard to discuss, especially men. My retired GP stepfather often said that it was only as they were leaving the room that they would finally tell you why they were really there.

Not everybody lets it all hang out, lots of people are very private and often scared. Goodness I am pretty confident and in my fifties but I still put off going to see a GP about a suspicious mole because I just wanted it to go away and because I was scared of wasting the GPs time and because it just might be something serious that I didn't want to think about. Seems silly but I don't think I am unusual. My friend felt odd and lost weight, she died 8 weeks after first noticing, of a rare cancer. How lucky she was that her GP took her vague and somewhat unconnected symptoms seriously, she couldn't be saved but she did get a couple of extra months to be with her young children. She could quite easily have been fobbed off with aspirin, she didn't like to make a fuss.

Mumsnet is full of people telling you not to waste the doctors time. Sadly I think the problem is that the people who often heed this advice are the very people who should see a doctor. In reality most GPs understand that it's not always easy for people to talk about their health, especially older people and that often people just have a vague sense that somethings not right . Is healthcare now only for extroverts?

KeepApart · 14/12/2021 16:12

@Peaseblossum22 but the GP could just as easily be a woman from the church.

Honestly the silent ones dont really need seeing anymore than people willing to disclose why they are coming in. They aren't more likely to have cancer because they are shy.

You don't have to go full out describing your symptoms on the phone to the receptionist. Just a couple of words, and medical terms may help. E.g. I am struggling with my endometriosis is fine.

No medical professional is a miracle worker and patients have to say what is wrong with them in order to get the best care. In order to get the appropriate appointment you have to say what is wrong to the receptionist, just roughly, just a brief couple of words. A GP receptionist hears hundreds of bodily functions everyday, I doubt they even clock that Bob is here is about his prostate when he's the 10th 70 year old man that day whose rung about his prostate.

SometimesRavenSometimesParrot · 14/12/2021 16:06

Curious as to why people are saying GPs and receptionists are held to the same professional standards…GPs are registered and could be struck off for unprofessional, ruining their career. They’ve also probably trained for ten years +. Receptionists are not comparable - worst case if they gossip they get sacked

Disfordarkchocolate · 14/12/2021 16:04

Receptionist really don't care what you have. They have heard it all and probably filed a letter about it.

GPs face massive problems with time wasters, if receptionists don't filter them out you will never get an appointment.

TractorAndHeadphones · 14/12/2021 16:02

Sorry if I've missed something but why are receptionists triaging? What could they possibly know about medicine?
I can understand them needing details to pass on to the doctor, or write in the appointment details but that's it. They should not be gatekeeping!

SometimesRavenSometimesParrot · 14/12/2021 16:02

I don’t discuss my medical history/needs with anyone not medically trained, in the same way I didn’t discuss my mortgage applications with the secretary of my broker/solicitor, or in the same way I wouldn’t discuss a safeguarding issue with a school receptionist instead of a safeguarding lead.

Absolute bear minimum provided, and I refuse to provide further details.

Having said that, you can’t actually get through to my GP unless you call between 8.30 and 9.30, when I am working, so I’ve opted for a private GP doing forward.

FrankGrillosWrist · 14/12/2021 16:01

Couldn’t you see a Dr outside the area? Villagers are so bored that unfortunately you become the nosy cunts entertainments.

godmum56 · 14/12/2021 15:49

@NeverDropYourMoonCupever
Grin

Siepie · 14/12/2021 15:48

I don't mind telling them what's wrong. I understand the need to triage. At my GP surgery we're told that the triage nurse decides whether to ring us back or if we need a doctor to ring instead.

I do mind them giving me advice. One recommended that I gave aspirin to DS (then about 4 months old). When I said that I didn't think you were supposed to give aspirin to under 16s, she said she'd "never heard of that rule" Confused

ReeseWitherfork · 14/12/2021 15:45

For the record there is no way my 70 something father could have brought himself to discuss this matter or even voice it to a ‘lady from church’ on reception goodness here could barely discuss it with his wife.

But the GP you were quoting said they'd still see your dad, just not urgently.

Unfortunately your dad is going to struggle anywhere he needs medical assistance. There's no front door to the NHS anymore where you don't have to speak to a non-doctor before a doctor. 999, 111, A&E... You'll be triaged first on all accounts.

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 14/12/2021 15:44

@milly74

love all the GPs and receptionists defending themselves!!!
And some of us even use big words. It was satisfying to both say and type 'Total abdominal hysterectomy with bilateral salpingooophrectomy'.

Still set up an autocorrect for 'tah' and 'ooo', though. More time for filing my nails and thinking about bunnies that way.

vivainsomnia · 14/12/2021 15:43

As other posters have said, that is shockingly bad treatment
Why is it shocking? What is so personal that can be discussed with a GP but not a receptionist who is bound by the sane rules of confidentiality? They couldn't care less what patient call for. You are nothing to them but a number. They've heard it all and going into some detail of what troubles the endemitriosis is causing them is not going to generate any views, or wish for gossip. They are doing their job and that's that.

If it's too much of an issue to even give a quick sypnosis of what the issue is, then it is not far fetch that it can't be that urgent.

Hillarious · 14/12/2021 15:41

@Hillarious not sure if you're just trying to find something to be insulted by but I meant bless them as in bless them for trying to help. The advice given may not apply but they mean well.

Not looking to be insulted, @Bratzybaby, rather you were questioning what was patronizing about your original message, so I pointed out it was possibly the use of "bless them". Bless you, though, for your response. i understand now that you meant well.

Peaseblossum22 · 14/12/2021 15:39

@pianolessons1

I'm a GP. About 5% of my patients refuse to say and just say 'personal', which is fine. But I prioritise based on what the receptionists say and 'personal' goes in with non urgent.
My problem with this is that these people who are too nervous, reticent, private to tell the receptionist are most likely it seems to me to have a serious problem. In my experience the time wasters can’t wait to give you intricate details if exactly how awful and how serious their problems are even if it’s a splinter.

The silent ones, the ones who don’t come to the doctors very often , who don’t necessarily understand how the system works because they haven’t been since they last needed a tetanus , who know something is wrong but are not sure what and who are possibly embarrassed or scared that it really is something serious are the ones who really really need seeing .

As my Gp once said to my father you haven’t been here for a decade so I knew there must be a problem. For the record there is no way my 70 something father could have brought himself to discuss this matter or even voice it to a ‘lady from church’ on reception goodness here could barely discuss it with his wife.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 14/12/2021 15:39

Receptionists are a core part of GP team, they are subject to same confidentiality rules as the GP.
No they aren't. Receptionists do not have professional registration. If they are sacked for breaching patient confidentiality they can get another job as a receptionist somewhere else (depending how stringent the somewhere else is about references).
Doctors and nurses have to adhere to professional standards or risk being suspended/struck off. The same rules do not apply to receptionists.
Of course most of us understand why receptionists have to ask the questions they do, but that doesn't alter the embarrassment if the receptionist is someone you are likely to bump into elsewhere. It's part of the problem of having large numbers of small primary care practices: they aren't big enough to employ triage nurses, so patients end up having to discuss very personal details with receptionists. But, of course, the trade-off to have larger practices is that they will be harder to access for many patients.

milly74 · 14/12/2021 15:37

love all the GPs and receptionists defending themselves!!!

LakieLady · 14/12/2021 15:34

@Jasmine00

It's harder because these receptionists I see at school, local shops and local places. Do I really want these people to have to know about my gynae issues, not really! In a city you are more anonymous so I don't think this would be such an issue
They're professional and understand the need for confidentiality. Just the same as I do about the health problems of clients who live in my small town (not to mention their criminal records, addictions, DV, the fact that their kids are on the at risk register, etc etc).
StrapOnSallyChasedMeDownTheAli · 14/12/2021 15:34

At our surgery different Drs have different areas of interests, medically, and by letting the receptionist know the reason for the call helps them to direct the patient to the Dr who may specialise in a particular area of medicine. We have a female Dr at the surgery who has a real interest in womens health, especially gynae issues, and is a real asset for women in the area. This isn't really advertised, so unless you made an appointment with her for that reason, or disclosed relevant info with the receptionist so that they can direct you to her, then you would maybe miss out on the expertise she has an this area.

Most receptionists are just trying to make sure that you see the right person.

tillytoodles1 · 14/12/2021 15:30

My daughter's SiL is our doctors receptionist and I always tell her why I'm ringing. Its her job and I'm 100% positive that she is only doing it because she needs to know before booking my appointment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread