Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to not want to discuss my private health with doctor receptionists

232 replies

Jasmine00 · 14/12/2021 12:08

I'm so sick of calling my doc surgery and having to explain to the receptionist my ailments especially as they are mostly endometriosis related. Sometimes they even try and give advice back. Arggggg I hate it.
Doesn't help that I live in a small village and these are the people I see on a daily basis either

OP posts:
bratzybaby · 14/12/2021 17:59

*implied nof applied

bratzybaby · 14/12/2021 17:59

@Letsallscreamatthesistene purposely misunderstanding the point😴 as a pp put it into better words than I did, I'll repeat what they said. 'It feels like common sense that non specialists (which GP receptionists are) won't know the range of applicable medical terminology to describe all conditions.' Is that not true??

I don't mean big words as in 'oh let me say I have an excruciating headache' instead of a standard headache so they get the point. No I mean let me use the correct medical terms so I get can passed on to a GP quicker instead of receiving advice that doesn't apply to me. Nowhere did I say the receptionists were 'silly' either and that's not what was applied. I know MN loves to purposely misunderstand things but give it a rest

Peaseblossum22 · 14/12/2021 17:58

Actually this thread has reminded me that the receptionist actually told my MIL that I was pregnant with ds3 . She was mortified and apologised to me afterwards but apparently it ‘just slipped out’ it was fine, one of those things but it might not have been.

Natty13 · 14/12/2021 17:53

@Jasmine00

In a city yes you are right the receptionists don't care what you have, but in smaller settings I can assure you that they most definitely do and I've seen unprofessional behaviour mamy times with local midwives and other health professionals sharing info they really shouldnt have been, it is how it seems to be here and I'm just venting as it's annoying!!
You need to report this each and every time it happens. To you or others. It's normalised because people are letting the staff get away with behaviour that is not only unprofessional and disrespectful but likely illegal depending on the circumstances.
Jasmine00 · 14/12/2021 17:48

In a city yes you are right the receptionists don't care what you have, but in smaller settings I can assure you that they most definitely do and I've seen unprofessional behaviour mamy times with local midwives and other health professionals sharing info they really shouldnt have been, it is how it seems to be here and I'm just venting as it's annoying!!

OP posts:
Slipperoo · 14/12/2021 17:47

The receptionist doesn't give s shit.

Jasmine00 · 14/12/2021 17:44

@VitalsStable

So your feelings about them hearing about your gynae problems come from where? If not how they feel about them?
As I've said before I'm in a small village and separated from my husband a few years back so having one of my mums church friends ask if I'd had any new sexual partners after me reporting pelvic pain wasn't the best if you see what I mean?? Because the answer was yes I had and I'm then assuming she's judging which she 100% would have been- can you see where I'm coming from now?
OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 14/12/2021 17:34

Why would I expect a GP and receptionist to have the same standards with respect to privacy?
Because neither give a shit about your medical conditions. They've heard it all. They really really couldn't care less.

I really don't get this 'I don't talk about my medical issues with receptionists'. What makes someone think they are so important the receptionist is going to care and get excited at the idea of sharing the info any more than the GP?

NeverDropYourMoonCup · 14/12/2021 17:29

@Peaseblossum22

I do think this is particularly difficult for older patients and many will just give up on trying to be seen. It makes me sad, so many people I work with were brought up in the era when you didn’t question the doctor , they hate bothering people and these systems whilst completely understandable are another barrier for the introverted and private. This generation were not brought up to advocate for their own health. On the other hand it’s a gift to the ‘worried well’ who are more than happy to gas onto the receptionist about their suspicious symptoms.
Hardly worried well when you can call at 11.30am, say 'I've found a lump' and get an appointment during the lunchbreak when there are no routine appointments for the next month and all the urgent ones went by 8.02am.

Or my DP could call at 12.06pm to say my DB was in hdu after having his brain turned to mush by a car and he thought I needed some help as I hadn't slept for 52 hours and had just got back from the hospital after the organ donor conversation. Got called by the GP five minutes later to say how sorry he was and did I want help/something to help me sleep/a referral.

BorderlineHappy · 14/12/2021 17:24

I'm in Ireland and I have to say my Drs surgery and the receptionist are amazing.
So kind and have went above and beyond for me.
And I don't pay as I have a medical card.

Slipperoo · 14/12/2021 17:21

I always wonder if people would feel the same if GP receptionists were predominately male. Personally I don't see why you think you're interesting enough for them to lose their job over.

ReeseWitherfork · 14/12/2021 17:15

on what basis do receptionists have medical qualifications they shouldn't be triaging!!!!!

@milly74 do you seriously think A&E receptionists have medical qualifications? Or 999 call handlers? They have necessary training, just like anyone triaging in a GP practice will. Some of them aren't actually triaging, they're just putting down a sentence for the GP. Mine always ask after they've booked the appointment, so they're definitely not even pretending to triage.

Mushypeasandchipstogo · 14/12/2021 17:15

I totally get your point OP. I have been waiting in my old doctor’s waiting room very close to to the receptionist on the phone. The receptionist insisted on repeating out loud the name, date of birth and medical condition of the patient-it happened to be someone I knew. Some receptionists are very poorly trained and some discuss patients confidential information to their friends. It does happen, although it really shouldn’t! Fortunately, my new GP’s surgery is much better.

Peaseblossum22 · 14/12/2021 17:01

I do think this is particularly difficult for older patients and many will just give up on trying to be seen. It makes me sad, so many people I work with were brought up in the era when you didn’t question the doctor , they hate bothering people and these systems whilst completely understandable are another barrier for the introverted and private. This generation were not brought up to advocate for their own health. On the other hand it’s a gift to the ‘worried well’ who are more than happy to gas onto the receptionist about their suspicious symptoms.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 14/12/2021 16:53

@KeepApart

Well exactly *@dreamingofginocloxk*

If you've for someone who says 'I'm coughing up blood regualrly' and someone who says personal problem you are going to book in the coughing up blood. Although there's a chance personal problem needs to be seen urgently, we 100% know patient 1 needs booking in, and you cant just guess that person 2 has something seriously wrong. They could just as easily have thrush

The best thing as patients we can do is advocate for our own health and tell the receptionist why we need to be seen. Not trick them or over exaggerate, just clear couple of words.

Totally agree. They're part of the medical team. People need to understand this.
newyearsresolurion · 14/12/2021 16:47

They're part of the team

milly74 · 14/12/2021 16:46

@KeepApart

No *@milly74* they are collecting the info for triage
that's semantics is that how they get away with doing an unqualified role?
Letsallscreamatthesistene · 14/12/2021 16:45

[quote bratzybaby]@Auntieobem how is that patronising? GP receptionists are not doctors, this isn't a secret. In my surgery, when you say your issue they'll try to give advice they think is suitable. When I'd say I'm suffering from the effects of my spinal headache, they'd often say 'have you tried paracetamol/ibuprofen' just because they've heard the word 'headache.' Yet a spinal headache is caused by low pressure in the brain, paracetamol/ibuprofen does nothing to help that.

They're clearly trying to help which is appreciated but they don't understand the condition because they're simply not doctors. That's not patronising at all[/quote]
You've assumed the silly receptionists dont understand big words. You sound like a dick.

Chouetted · 14/12/2021 16:43

I had an argument pre-Covid with a receptionist who didn't want to let me book an appointment for an MMR I'd missed out on as a child.

Finally she booked me an appointment so that I could argue with the nurse instead - who obviously just gave me the jab I was entitled to.

Some receptionists are lovely, some are dreadful.

KeepApart · 14/12/2021 16:43

No @milly74 they are collecting the info for triage

KeepApart · 14/12/2021 16:42

Well exactly @dreamingofginocloxk

If you've for someone who says 'I'm coughing up blood regualrly' and someone who says personal problem you are going to book in the coughing up blood. Although there's a chance personal problem needs to be seen urgently, we 100% know patient 1 needs booking in, and you cant just guess that person 2 has something seriously wrong. They could just as easily have thrush

The best thing as patients we can do is advocate for our own health and tell the receptionist why we need to be seen. Not trick them or over exaggerate, just clear couple of words.

milly74 · 14/12/2021 16:42

@KeepApart

But equally *@peaseblossum22* health professionals are mind readers. They can be good at getting information out of worried, anxious people. But if they never opened up to the health care professional then the GP can't do anything

Lots of people will put off going to the GP if they are worried they have cancer, whether they are able to tell the receptionist they have a suspicious mole or not. But in order for the NHS to work efficiently it has to have a triage system and they cannot have GPs answering the phones. Fortunately some medical knowledge is used in triage and your father was triage by his GP appropriately. Your father was seen because they Gp had an appropriate triage system and part of this is being able to tell receptionists what's wrong

You are conflating someone being anxious about their health and not being able to tell the receptionist a rough idea of what they need. This has nothing to do with their GP listening to them, or vague symptoms. It's just that its more helpful for everyone if people can give some info so they can be seen appropriately

If not and you just book everyone in on a first come first served basis your father might not have been able to be seen by his GP because a load of ingrown toenails and verrucas were booked in ahead of him.

on what basis do receptionists have medical qualifications they shouldn't be triaging!!!!!
StPaulandTheBrokenBones · 14/12/2021 16:38

I have had some health issues recently and had some blood tests. The receptionist rang me to say there was a problem with my liver and I needed to book an appointment. So I saw my GP a few days later and she said said there was no problem with my liver, I just had a bacterial infection at the time which had affected my liver test. She was not sure why I had been given an appointment, as she had already prescribed antibiotics for the infection.

I have also just been put on HRT. When I saw the nurse to have my blood pressure checked and to weigh me she said to book a telephone appointment when I had one packet of the pills left. So I did as she asked and the receptionist argued with me that I didn't need this and she could just put the tablets on a repeat prescription and I needed to wait until I had a weeks worth of tablets left before she could do this. I asked her whose advice I should take on this, her advice or the advice of the nurse. She went away to talk to someone and then came back and booked me a telephone appointment to speak to a nurse.

And finally my mother's sister was a receptionist at our surgery. She looked at my medical records and told my mother certain things about my health. Things I did not want my mother to know about. So I wrote a letter to the surgery and she was sacked. Harsh, but fair.

Receptionists are human beings, the same as the rest of us. They are just as capable of cocking up and they are just as capable of gossiping and breaching confidentiality.

The problem with this system is that if a receptionist makes it difficult for someone to book an appointment then that could have serious consequences for that patient. I have clients that would not push for an appointment and these same clients do not want to discuss personal matters with the receptionist. So they end up not booking anything, as they don't want to "put the doctor out". I am talking about older people in their late 80s and early 90s.

This system is not fair on the receptionists, because if someone dies, or becomes seriously unwell, as a result of not being seen then they are going to feel awful. It's also not fair on patients who want to discuss their personal medical matters with their doctor and not with someone who is sitting in an open plan waiting room.

DreamingofGinoclock · 14/12/2021 16:37

Above was in reply to @milly74

KeepApart · 14/12/2021 16:37

But equally @peaseblossum22 health professionals are mind readers. They can be good at getting information out of worried, anxious people. But if they never opened up to the health care professional then the GP can't do anything

Lots of people will put off going to the GP if they are worried they have cancer, whether they are able to tell the receptionist they have a suspicious mole or not. But in order for the NHS to work efficiently it has to have a triage system and they cannot have GPs answering the phones. Fortunately some medical knowledge is used in triage and your father was triage by his GP appropriately. Your father was seen because they Gp had an appropriate triage system and part of this is being able to tell receptionists what's wrong

You are conflating someone being anxious about their health and not being able to tell the receptionist a rough idea of what they need. This has nothing to do with their GP listening to them, or vague symptoms. It's just that its more helpful for everyone if people can give some info so they can be seen appropriately

If not and you just book everyone in on a first come first served basis your father might not have been able to be seen by his GP because a load of ingrown toenails and verrucas were booked in ahead of him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread