Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do people keep voting in the tories?

946 replies

chaosmaker · 14/12/2021 11:19

I'd love it if tory voters could say why they vote the way they do given that there's ample evidence for how utterly incompetent they are (11 years). Especially in the last election. With that not-fit-for-purpose idiot in charge - edited by MNHQ
I also keep writing to my MP saying that if they are going to pretend we have democracy then they need to scrap FPTP.

AIBU that we should allow people with no sense to vote or
AINBU am I right in that people should have to factor history and rare sense into their decision making?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
XingMing · 16/12/2021 20:43

Brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr, yep, that's exactly what I am saying.

We do not have systematic inequality in the UK. Like every country in the world, we have some clever people, some ambitious people, and a lot that just want a peaceful, happy healthy life.

XingMing · 16/12/2021 20:39

You're focusing on the wrong place... Nigel Farage drew his support largely from the small tradesmen who work hard to do what their customers want (like my builder or plasterer, or the electrician who moved my light fittings). They think, having put in a full week's work from 7:30 am when they leave for work until 5:00pm, possibly plus Saturday morning, that they should have an input into how their taxes are spent, rather than politicians deciding they they know best. Their priorities are practical, and yes, they expect to earn enough for a decent life, with a holiday every year and food everyday. They expect the NHS to see their wives through breast cancer treatment, and the kids' asthma and appendectomies. Because they pay for it (possibly not all of it -- my glasses are NOT that rose tinted).

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 16/12/2021 20:24

“ Left wing fanaticism is a race to persuade most/many people to think they are hard done by and need the playing field levelled in their favour. ”

Are you saying that we don’t have systematic inequality in the UK ?

Which of the 2019 Labour manifesto pledges were “extreme left” ?

berryhead2013 · 16/12/2021 20:18

Just leaving this here

How do people keep voting in the tories?
How do people keep voting in the tories?
StoneofDestiny · 16/12/2021 20:18

We have a right wing Tory government - helped into power by Nigel Farage, who drew his support from defunct BNP and the EDL. Can't get much further right than those abominations.

XingMing · 16/12/2021 20:13

Left wing fanaticism is a race to persuade most/many people to think they are hard done by and need the playing field levelled in their favour. If work pays, then people will work. And it can be pushing water uphill if you are a widowed single parent with a disabled child who needs 24 x 7 care... but that is not the majority of the population: maybe 5%?

And whether you like it or not, the majority decide via the ballot box, and ATM the public mood is in favour of taking personal responsibility with family help, rather than increased public spending. No way would I be writing an open cheque to a political party-- of any colour. There's not enough in GDP to fund the NHS's wish list, even if the NHS got the whole pot, so someone, somewhere (Like all of us here) is going to have to be asked to choose our preferred balance between pensions and health and education and justice. You cannot have it all. So there will be some version of rationing the spend, somewhere in the system, whatever. Does your 85-year-old relative get the latest cancer drugs to extend life a few months at vast expense, or do you spend the same money rehabilitating someone of 50 who has had a heart attack, but who might return to decent quality of life; go back to work and continue to pay tax? Do we fund IVF or improve paediatic/neonatal care? These are choices we have to make for the NHS because it isn't possible to do it all.

pizz · 16/12/2021 19:52

@elodie77

if it doesn't impact on you

I live here but am not from here. It does impact me.

Extreme left Hmm This country has never had extreme left. And I am not extreme left. I like a well functioning, fair society with equal opportunities and good public services, reasonably priced housing and a good, egalitarian education system. But I can see that in this class obsessed country where it's all about one-upmanship people consider that 'extreme'.

Ha! There is an extreme left who shout loud and get nowhere
TooBigForMyBoots · 16/12/2021 19:44

Since the Greens, Lib Dems and Labour are fully in the self ID camp. A Tory MP Maria Miller started the ball rolling by not consulting women's groups AFAIK but at least the Conservatives have held back from putting it into legislation.

The trans debate came to prominence because in 2017 the Conservative Party decided to reform the GRA. The starting point for the minister in charge (Justine Greening) was TWAW @crosstalk.Xmas Shock

Beckert · 16/12/2021 18:53

This country has never had extreme left.

Much of labour is extreme left. It's not a popular position. That's why labour won't be getting in any time soon. It will take years for them to persuade people to have confidence in them again in any meaningful way. They haven't even started to try.

elodie77 · 16/12/2021 18:49

if it doesn't impact on you

I live here but am not from here. It does impact me.

Extreme left Hmm This country has never had extreme left. And I am not extreme left. I like a well functioning, fair society with equal opportunities and good public services, reasonably priced housing and a good, egalitarian education system. But I can see that in this class obsessed country where it's all about one-upmanship people consider that 'extreme'.

Beckert · 16/12/2021 18:40

Nah, not from here. We have a good Prime Minister I'm very proud of and can trust.

That's nice. Not sure why you're so obsessed about Boris then if it doesn't impact on you, but hey, that's the way of the extreme left isn't it.

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 16/12/2021 18:30

@Beckert

Left wing fanaticism

Exactly this.

Can you put that into words, what is Left Wing Fanaticism ?

Which manifesto pledges were fanatically left wing and would have been damaging to the country ?

mellongoose · 16/12/2021 18:20

[quote Octavia174]@mellongoose
If you're using the 'relative poverty' figure, please don't. By definition you will always have a large percentage relatively poor compared to the average

why not? why should we accept a large number of people so much worse of than the better off?

Absolutely poverty has gone down in recent years, although one child living in absolutely poverty is one too many. That is why there is a safety net of a welfare state

No it hasn't, 14% of the UK pop. live on below the amount the govt says they need & tell that to the parent trying to do the right thing but getting a benefits sanction, ending up on a credit agency, then stuck in a cycle of never ending debt.

Even then....parents are still responsible for ensuring their children are fed, clothed, sheltered, sent to school and taught right from wrong

What do you do when parents don't do this? do you realise that some people do not have the money to do this.

Some of the most deprived children I know grew to well rounded adults and ended up in fulfilling careers. Why? Because their parents, even though they had nothing, put their children's needs first and gave them confidence and ambition

..and plenty more don't regardless of their parents efforts, why is it Rashford had to make the Govt pay out for free school meals during hols time? do poor families get free food from Asda in the summer term?

I don't think you have any idea of some peoples struggles.[/quote]
Rashford grew up under a Labour government so his lived experience was not a conservative one.

elodie77 · 16/12/2021 18:09

Your prime minister too.

Nah, not from here. We have a good Prime Minister I'm very proud of and can trust.

Beckert · 16/12/2021 18:04

think that accusation could be much more accurately levelled at your Prime Minister.

Your prime minister too.

Labour helped create this.

Enjoy.

ParsleySageRosemary · 16/12/2021 18:01

And the problem with New Labour is that it stood and stands for nothing but Old Corruption: selling public goods off and giving public money away to the most vocal and powerful faster than the Tories ever did.

Octavia174 · 16/12/2021 18:00

@mellongoose
If you're using the 'relative poverty' figure, please don't. By definition you will always have a large percentage relatively poor compared to the average

why not? why should we accept a large number of people so much worse of than the better off?

Absolutely poverty has gone down in recent years, although one child living in absolutely poverty is one too many. That is why there is a safety net of a welfare state

No it hasn't, 14% of the UK pop. live on below the amount the govt says they need & tell that to the parent trying to do the right thing but getting a benefits sanction, ending up on a credit agency, then stuck in a cycle of never ending debt.

Even then....parents are still responsible for ensuring their children are fed, clothed, sheltered, sent to school and taught right from wrong

What do you do when parents don't do this? do you realise that some people do not have the money to do this.

Some of the most deprived children I know grew to well rounded adults and ended up in fulfilling careers. Why? Because their parents, even though they had nothing, put their children's needs first and gave them confidence and ambition

..and plenty more don't regardless of their parents efforts, why is it Rashford had to make the Govt pay out for free school meals during hols time? do poor families get free food from Asda in the summer term?

I don't think you have any idea of some peoples struggles.

elodie77 · 16/12/2021 17:57

Sad that people like you have ruined labour though and what it once stood for.

I think that accusation could be much more accurately levelled at your Prime Minister.

Beckert · 16/12/2021 17:53

Left wing fanaticism

Exactly this.

SexyNeckbeard · 16/12/2021 17:47

@elodie77

You all keep saying Corbyn. But what exactly is it about him that 'made' you vote conservatives?

Right wing scare mongering.

Left wing fanaticism
Beckert · 16/12/2021 17:42

@elodie77

Beckert you sound like a Daily Mail column - bot.
I won't say what you sound like. No point in sinking to your level. It's not complimentary though. Sad that people like you have ruined labour though and what it once stood for.
crosstalk · 16/12/2021 17:37

I think many people in the current government don't know what they're talking about. And yes some are venal and corrupt (though the biggest buy to let MP was Labour) and IMHO Boris is beyond forgiveness after he ignored Covid, care homes and supplies.

I fell out of love with the Labour Party when the only honest man over Iraq was Robin Cook. Their university fees was ill thought through. And the man who did more to undermine public funding and get hospitals and schools built by private funds was Gordon Brown. You now have wards closed because those hospitals can't afford the payback.

No party has come up with a plan for social care.

But my main issue is with self id and the damage it may do to women. We already have Police Scotland saying a man can rape a woman and self ID as a woman. Lesbians being harrassed by men self Iding as women. Men self iding and beating women at sports.

Since the Greens, Lib Dems and Labour are fully in the self ID camp. A Tory MP Maria Miller started the ball rolling by not consulting women's groups AFAIK but at least the Conservatives have held back from putting it into legislation.

I will be reading all the manifestos but not the rubbish they put through doors promising the world.

Alexandra2001 · 16/12/2021 17:35

@caringcarer

I could never vote for people like Corbyn, Abbot, Dodds or Starmer. I lived through many Labour leaders and believe me it was worse. Gordon Brown made benefits so high few wanted to work as would get less etc. Blair and his relentless warmongering.
Yep your a tory alright. Benefits that feed the kids of out of work parents... what an awful thing to do? I expect you were against the min wage too? (like the tories were too) why on earth would you pay people more? what an odd concept.

But in anycase, benefits in this country, whether under Lab or Con are terrible, many times less than working.

Tories supported the Iraq and Afghan wars and carried on the Afghan war for 10 years after they got into power.

elodie77 · 16/12/2021 17:26

Beckert you sound like a Daily Mail column - bot.

elodie77 · 16/12/2021 17:24

"Poor decisions".....in your opinion. That is all.

Can you honestly say that you don't think this government has made incredibly poor decisions? You seem to live in some sort of parallel universe...'sunlit uplands'? Grin