Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else financially support their in-laws?

111 replies

Olinguita · 14/12/2021 11:11

And if so, how do you manage?
Any positive stories??

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 14/12/2021 16:43

@WhatToDo1988WhatToDo1988 Exactly, you've clearly been honest with your DP and he's accepted your decision. It's quite different to have it sprung on you.

Cameleongirl · 14/12/2021 16:41

@GarlandsinGreece I think it's different if you're a very high earner and being so generous doesn't really impact your spouse and children's standard of living. That's not the case in the OP's situation, though, they'll have to really tighten their belts.

WhatToDo1988 · 14/12/2021 16:39

My parents are from a country where there is no pension or healthcare. My grandmother would be dead if my parents didn't pay for her heart medication, food,etc. I am not exaggerating. When my parents are older and cannot make an income anymore, I will be supporting them 100% with everything they need, at my own sacrifice. They are wonderful parents who gave me everything. This is the arrangement and my English partner understands it. If my partner ever tried to stop me supporting my parents, I would leave said DP. No doubt about it.

However my parents are my responsibility. You need to decide whether you are happy with this or not and leave if not. You cannot continue to let resentment build up or pay for your in laws at your own detriment, this is no way to live. It sounds like he was not honest with you or he didn't realize how much money they would need. Life is too short to live with an arrangement that does not work for you.

GarlandsinGreece · 14/12/2021 16:39

My husband bought his mother a house, one sister and her family lives rent-free in another property we own, and another sister has her rent paid. People think we are insane, but it’s a complicated tale, husband is a very high earner, and I think it’s nice to help out family.

SpinnersWindow · 14/12/2021 16:28

Where do you live? Where does she live? How old is she, does she work, has she ever worked, have you met her? Questions, questions ...

Fretfulmum · 14/12/2021 16:27

It depends if you can afford it. FIL expects DH to pay for lots of things but FIL spends his money carefree and on things which are luxury items so that’s where our resentment kicks in. If he genuinely tried to save and couldn’t cover the basic necessities we would be more willing to help.

MrsKDB · 14/12/2021 16:22

this is difficult for me to understand, my mum worked until she was 73 and would HATE handouts from us! but in our culture wealth is more usually passed down the generations, helping younger / working couples get a better start; I can see that in others this is reversed.

Cameleongirl · 14/12/2021 15:21

@Olinguita

No siblings, MIL from a country with no pension, has no assets, DH was not entirely honest about the situation at the time of marriage. I will do everything I can to help because she can't meet her basic needs alone. But we will have to do some serious belt-tightening and it places a lot of pressure on where we can afford to live, means I have to work more and in a type of job I wouldn't necessarily have chosen in order to be able to provide rather than say, being part time to spend time with kid...
Not quite as drastic, but one of my SIL's had a similar experience with her DH, who announced after they were married that they'd have to help out his parents financially - they were still working, but needed some extra help. She was pretty annoyed as you can imagine!

I don't know exactly how they worked it out, but I think they've kept their finances separate (except for joint purchases and bills). I know he's bought his parents a car and paid for various items.

If your DH wants to support his mother, he should definitely do so out of his own salary - of course it will still impact you. Does he have any siblings? That was an issue with my BIL, he's one of three, but the only one who really helped their parents....

lunar1 · 14/12/2021 15:14

Yes, DH is Indian. He supported them before we met and will continue to support them. I'm more than happy with the situation and he's had always been honest. We can afford what we send and it's certainly given us some piece of mind over the last two years when we have been unable to visit.

jimmyjammy001 · 14/12/2021 15:09

Sounds like your DH has duped you as he knew telling you the truth would probably end the relationship, I would definitely be questioning the relationship if he has done this to you, this is money that you could be spending on you and your family's future, instead he has roped you into his family troubles

whynotwhatknot · 14/12/2021 15:04

its the lieing that would get me not the actual fact of helping them out

why should you work more though why cant he

Lasair · 14/12/2021 15:01

I would find that a tough pill to swallow

CheddarGorgeous · 14/12/2021 14:59

@Porcupineintherough

Out of interest *@CheddarGorgeous, what would you say if the OP* was living round the corner from her elderly parents and was helping them with her time - cooking, cleaning, errands etc. Would you say she then had to compensate her husband for the time she could have been devoting to her main family unit?

It's not the resource, it's the dishonesty. If OP was already spending hours a week supporting elderly parents and didn't tell her partner before they got married he's be equally entitled to be unhappy.

sjxoxo · 14/12/2021 14:52

No & I wouldn’t because I know she’s fallen out with numerous people over money. I’d be very angry if my DH had kept his intention to financially support his parents through old age a secret prior to getting married; unless he’s Bill Gates it means big sacrifice for your family & kids and even your own retirement. Xo

Skeumorph · 14/12/2021 14:46

Your DH's dishonesty is the problem and I would probably be thinking very hard about the future.

You say you can't give details which does limit how people can help. But in terms of an arrangement - like hell would I work in a job I didn't want to, or give up time with my young child. Me, and my child, would be more of a priority than MIL. Tough.

The trouble is of course that because he lied until you were married, you are forced to fund because if he sends money he earns directly, you are forced to plug the gap.

Stop plugging the gap if it does not suit you and let him solve the problem. Drop the rope.

It's amazing how these kind of people, who are keen to drag others in to pay for their choices or debts, change their tune once their golden geese say no more.

Refuse to pick up that slack and I am pretty sure he'd rather not lose his own home than pay for MIL.

Where is she, can she work, are there other family members?

Porcupineintherough · 14/12/2021 14:42

Out of interest @CheddarGorgeous, what would you say if the OP was living round the corner from her elderly parents and was helping them with her time - cooking, cleaning, errands etc. Would you say she then had to compensate her husband for the time she could have been devoting to her main family unit?

Tohaveandtohold · 14/12/2021 14:40

The issue here is the dishonesty.
I support my mum, she lives in a third world country, she never worked till my dad died so she only did menial jobs since then that’s not enough to live on. Luckily, she has my dad’s house (so no mortgage or rent). Myself and my 3 brothers send her an amount we can afford monthly and the exchange rate is very good so it’s not a lot of money that can affect my family life in a way and we save another small amount of money monthly just in case she needs expensive medical care, etc in future, that way, it won’t be a burden then.

Dh knew this before we were married because I’d been supporting her ever since, infact things are better now that my brothers can also help since they’ve got better jobs l, etc.
The main issue you have is the dishonesty. That will surely lead to resentment. Also, there’s nothing worse than being the only pillar of support.

itspartytime · 14/12/2021 14:28

Yes we support PIL . (Wouldn't everyone if it were needed ? )
Bought their house from them, over market value, and let the stay living in it. This way we know they are safe. Yes it's been hard but worth it even though at times I'd have preferred an annual family holiday abroad. But hey Ho. That's life. Hope my kids look after me if I need it.

Disfordarkchocolate · 14/12/2021 14:28

If you don't have children @Olinguita I would leave. That sort of deception would ruin the trust and respect I had for my husband. What else has he hidden?

CheddarGorgeous · 14/12/2021 14:24

DH was not entirely honest about the situation at the time of marriage.

I would find this very hard to forgive. I'd also be very clear that the majority of sacrifices should be made by him.

toddybell · 14/12/2021 14:21

My husband comes from a culture where the male children fund their parents lives once they're earning, so they're essentially their parents retirement plans. My husband opted out of this since his parents are wealthy. He's now been ostracised by them and disinherited from their will.

Asi1 · 14/12/2021 14:20

Yes, my husband's family who are allegedly well off but my husband still sends 200 pound a month. Stopped recently as l am finishing my maternity leave and my 39 weeks are up.

I have contributing through my maternity to household expenses and before that took responsibility for all tge bills, rent for 2yrs while my husband paid off a debt his parents took out on his behalf. And during this time he was still sending them money but l asked for nothing.

I hate myself for being so fucking understanding. 😔

HideousKinky · 14/12/2021 14:18

Yes - DH who is Chinese supported his mother, a responsibility he shared with 6 other siblings.

He made it clear to me at the time we got married in 1988 that he would be giving her money every month for the rest of her life (she died in 2010). I loved my MIL very much, as did he, and there were never any difficulties over this, but he said one of the reasons he raised it with me before we were married was because he didn't want it to cause problems between us (I think he had observed marriages in his culture where there had been quarrels over supporting elderly parents)

Santahatesbraisedcabbage · 14/12/2021 14:14

Well your dh needs to step up. And you need to back away.

Contactmap · 14/12/2021 14:13

Not trying to be nasty but she sort of expects it as her 'payoff'(for want of a better word for raising 4 kids as a single parent when money was very tight.
Same with my mother. She gets by on a small pension, but holidays, meals out, a cleaner and other luxuries are paid for by the four of us. She had her hard times and now it is time for us to treat her well and pay back. We don't resent it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread