Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Psychologist told me autism is a superpower

131 replies

Midnightpharma · 14/12/2021 08:27

I went to see a psychologist as part of a support package offered by my employer to help with my disability and perhaps learn a few strategies to deal with the anxiety I suffer from as a result of being autistic. I was talking about how my disability affects me, and the psychologist, at the end of my story, told me that "autism isn't a disability, it's a superpower!"

She proceeded to show me a kids video about how autistic people are a little different, but awesome and spent most of the rest of the session trying to make me think positively about my "superpower". I struggle on a daily basis and have had to take 6 months of sick leave in the last two years, keep feeling desperately uncomfortable at work and barely manage to stay in employment. To do so I need constant help in my home life. I can't work from an office full-time and have semi-regular shutdowns/meltdowns. I still have 10 hours of sessions left.

WIBU to try and cancel the others? I don't know what to do. They're not mandatory, but I don't want to look like I don't appreciate my employer's offer of support. At the same time this session was painful and invalidating and I'm not sure how to do another 10 hours of this. The person is a qualified psychologist who specialises is neurodiverse conditions. If being on the spectrum was a superpower why would you need to see a psychologist?!

OP posts:
santasmuma · 14/12/2021 11:05

@BessieFinknottle

Your tone was a bit off to me, santasmuma, but I understand now that's not what you intended.

I don't know how to put what i mean without people reading some tone but I didn't mean to be off at all. It's a point most people might disagree with, but I see it as valid. I'm not here to act like I'm better or superior though.

BessieFinknottle · 14/12/2021 11:00

Your tone was a bit off to me, santasmuma, but I understand now that's not what you intended.

RedToothBrush · 14/12/2021 10:59

@RandomLondoner

I was wondering if the psychologist was male, but reading again I see not. This seemed like a classic case of a male vs female mindset, where the male thinks their job is to fix a problem, and the person being spoken to is enraged because they want sympathy, not solutions. (As a male, I think sympathy is not only pointless, because it fixes nothing, but positively harmful, because it rewards you for staying where you are. It entrenches misery, rather than combatting it.)

How would it help to be told that your life is shit because your brain is different? The pyschologist can't change the way you are wired. I assume the most they can do is help you find strategies to be happier and successful. Concentrating on potential positives in any situation seems to me a sensible approach that any person should be taking all the time.

There are people who are successful because of autism, even without being savants. I realise not everyone can be another Michael Burry, but on a more mundane level, years ago I heard of an investment bank that specifically recruits autistic people to do a certain type of job, because they are unusually suited to it. Even if one doesn't have the education or skills for that, I don't see why there couldn't be other jobs that were a good match for some others.

Sexist tripe.

Who says women 'don't want to be fixed'?

One of the striking things about autism is how it manifests differently in males and females. If thats the case perhaps its merely a question of the solutions offered are generally more relevant to males. Perhaps this also means that females need different solutions which reflect the differences in their problems. This does not equate to the patronising trope of 'wanting sympathy'.

It annoys me intensely how offer it is presented in life that a problem only has one possible solution. Its rarely true. But rarely are we offered a variety of possible options with an explanation of who they might suit. For example phonics don't work well for all kids. Its currently the learning method of choice but it doesn't work for all kids and there are other learning methods available which have been used in the past but have fallen out of favour.

Its a subject of research at the moment how there are a lot of different types of counselling out there for all manner of issues and conditions - with very little scrutiny and over sight about whether what is being offered to a particular person is actual appropriate for them. There are concerned that far too many people are being referred to sessions which are not only inappropriate to them but might actually exacerbate issues and do harm in the process. I know NICE are trying to look into some of this.

I don't think saying people arent engaging or somehow trying with a particular treatment is helpful in this context. It might genuinely actually be a problem and the gaslighting about it only makes that worse.

Where that leaves the OP is potentially pretty shit, because she may be in a situation where she ends up labelled as 'uncooperative' when it might be that its actually doing harm to continue.

This is where we need this reframed as it being a real valid issue that lots of people are being merely offered the wrong solution. Not 'sympathy'.

Tal45 · 14/12/2021 10:57

@santasmuma

We don’t frame Autism as a disability in this house. It’s not useful for my particular child who is essentially gifted. He has anxiety issues and sleeping issues and is shy - he knows his brain is wired differently. We label the symptoms and treat them separately. If anybody ever called my child disabled, I’d be quite shocked.

Your child is not shy. Your child has a social communication disorder, a disability which makes him appear shy. She is so dismissive. Denial won't make your childs disability any less. Label and treat isn't how autism works. Understand and adjust.

How you could possibly be shocked if someone called your autistic child disabled, they have a disability Hmm

I think she'd know better than you if her child is shy. There are plenty of people with autism who are not at all shy and are desperate to make friends with everyone. Shyness is not part of a diagnosis of autism and plenty of people are shy that don't have autism.

I don't consider my son disabled either although asperger's syndrome is considered a disability. I'm not in denial about it, I just see a very clever, often lazy but happy teenager whose is comfortable in his own skin and coping far, far better than many of the kids at his secondary school who aren't considered disabled. I wouldn't be shocked or offended by someone calling his disabled though, maybe surprised because he's just who he is to me.

I agree with 'understand and adjust' though and to me that is huge. Employers really need that to be their mantra and I really hope that's the case when it come to my son having interviews and finding a job. I think the OP's employers really need to take that on board as well and not think farming the OP out to the psychologist will be all they need to do to get her 'fixed'.

Carryonmarion · 14/12/2021 10:55

Sounds like your therapist practices "positive psychology" which is controversial. Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) is more practical, sounds like its more for you and has a better overall evidence base. I would ask if your psychologist could use CBT as you think it is better suited to your needs however the relationship with the therapist is also important so if this psychologist isn't the one for you please ask for another. It is normal for people to ask for alternative therapists. There does tend to be waiting lists for CBT so if you do decide to stick with this therapist please discuss taking alternative approaches, any psychologist worth their salt would work with you on this.

santasmuma · 14/12/2021 10:54

@BessieFinknottle

I mean, you may have a point santasmuma, but it's very much only a maybe. You could have phrased your message to reflect this, instead of taking the superior tone you did.

Sorry. It's just what I wrote. I'm not very articulate and I'm awful at explaining clearly but you knew what I meant and recognise I may have a pint. Any superiority you have placed yourself. I certainly don't feel or want to be that.

M0rT · 14/12/2021 10:53

If there are other options definitely look into changing. I have this support in my job and there are a number of psychologists/psychiatrists/coaches that we can pick from and they bill the company it's not a directly employed person.
A skills coach might be more useful for you, as you are not depressed more looking for strategies to implement to improve your daily life.
I don't have autism but a fair few physical health problems and had a life coach to help me work in the supports and habits I needed to build to improve my daily life. It was very useful.
Mine was more focused on physicality but I'd imagine there is huge demand for managing anxiety/over stimulation and identifying priorities etc.
The identifying priorities one I manage in work by directly asking managers what they need first and putting reminders in my calendar and blocking out meetings with myself to get things done.
I greatly sympathise, I find a lot of corporate speak and culture difficult to understand and as far as I know am NT.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 14/12/2021 10:53

@HadaVerde

That’s appalling.

Tbh it’s crap even if directed at a child.

The whole autism is a superpower narrative is utter shite.

I agree. I have autism and the last thing I see the condition as is "a superpower".
santasmuma · 14/12/2021 10:52

Is it possible Ella knows her child better than you do, santasmuma?

Of course they do. It's not uncommon for parents to minimise and dismiss their child's autism though. I'm allowed to comment. I may be right and I may be wrong, but 'shy' to describe an autistic person who's whole diagnosis depends on communication deficits seems rather dismissive to me.

steppemum · 14/12/2021 10:49

@RandomLondoner

I was wondering if the psychologist was male, but reading again I see not. This seemed like a classic case of a male vs female mindset, where the male thinks their job is to fix a problem, and the person being spoken to is enraged because they want sympathy, not solutions. (As a male, I think sympathy is not only pointless, because it fixes nothing, but positively harmful, because it rewards you for staying where you are. It entrenches misery, rather than combatting it.)

How would it help to be told that your life is shit because your brain is different? The pyschologist can't change the way you are wired. I assume the most they can do is help you find strategies to be happier and successful. Concentrating on potential positives in any situation seems to me a sensible approach that any person should be taking all the time.

There are people who are successful because of autism, even without being savants. I realise not everyone can be another Michael Burry, but on a more mundane level, years ago I heard of an investment bank that specifically recruits autistic people to do a certain type of job, because they are unusually suited to it. Even if one doesn't have the education or skills for that, I don't see why there couldn't be other jobs that were a good match for some others.

this is such a missunderstanding of anything to do with help and support.

I work in a pastoral role. 90% of the time people need space to be heard. If you are a psychologist or a counsellor, your job is very specifically NOT to tell people what to do. Your job is to primarily listen.
As a generalisation, yes, men find this hard to believe. They don't get it. But most people need to be heard. Once they are given space to talk about how things are for them, they are then able to begin to see where the crux of the issue lies and therefore how they could move forward. You telling them what to do doesn't help.
It has to come from within.

In OPs case, the psychologist bulldozed over anything the OP was trying to say. How is that helpful?
As a man, your desire to 'fix things' is not helpful, and you need to understand that

Chocolatewheatos · 14/12/2021 10:48

She's trying to counter the constant message that autisitics are less than, that they can't do things, autism is bad and all that. It affects autistics self esteem and actually makes them less able. But you were talking about your difficulties and she told you that you're wrong which is just as demeaning as being told you're wrong for being autistic. I wouldn't cancel but I'd email and explain why she didn't handle it well. Funnily enough I've just been driving and thinking about all the positives from my autism and how sometimes my brain working differently is actually different in a good way.

Email and explain and that you're really just interested in practical ways to work with your autisitic brain.

BessieFinknottle · 14/12/2021 10:47

I mean, you may have a point santasmuma, but it's very much only a maybe. You could have phrased your message to reflect this, instead of taking the superior tone you did.

BusBusBus · 14/12/2021 10:45

I'd really struggle with words like superpower and a kids videos to take anything the person said seriously.

BessieFinknottle · 14/12/2021 10:44

Your child is not shy. Your child has a social communication disorder, a disability which makes himappearshy.

Is it possible Ella knows her child better than you do, santasmuma?
Shyness and a social communication disorder could be considered separately. For example, my autistic DS can struggle with anxiety in social situations, but he's a very sociable person otherwise, not 'shy' at all.
I just don't like people assuming they know better like this, whether it's the OP's psychologist or someone on a thread. Listening to what people are telling you is important.

Tal45 · 14/12/2021 10:40

I think the problem with some psychologists is that they get caught up in their research and then seem to be able only to think along those lines. She probably wrote a paper/thesis on why autism is a super power and now it is her mantra and she's in a bit of a rabbit hole with it and thinks it solves all problems.

I wonder if you could take a proactive approach and write a list of things you struggle with and tell her that you are looking for strategies to help you manage those particular things.

3scape · 14/12/2021 10:35

It sounds patronising. That might be useful for children to help with their self esteem but you are an adult, fully able to articulate problems in your life and to know your personal strengths. It also sounds very 'general' and not about you as an individual who needs support. You need a better fit that this psychologist.

santasmuma · 14/12/2021 10:33

For people who are high functioning enough ASD is not always considered a disability. It is a processing disorder or difference. Something to be managed through anxiety control / working hours / strategies to improve friendships and communication.

Oh off you go with your labels Hmm

Ozanj · 14/12/2021 10:25

@santasmuma

We don’t frame Autism as a disability in this house. It’s not useful for my particular child who is essentially gifted. He has anxiety issues and sleeping issues and is shy - he knows his brain is wired differently. We label the symptoms and treat them separately. If anybody ever called my child disabled, I’d be quite shocked.

Your child is not shy. Your child has a social communication disorder, a disability which makes him appear shy. She is so dismissive. Denial won't make your childs disability any less. Label and treat isn't how autism works. Understand and adjust.

How you could possibly be shocked if someone called your autistic child disabled, they have a disability Hmm

For people who are high functioning enough ASD is not always considered a disability. It is a processing disorder or difference. Something to be managed through anxiety control / working hours / strategies to improve friendships and communication.
amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 14/12/2021 10:19

Oh OP Sad I feel enraged even thinking about this for you.

Is there a Union you can talk to about what the psychologist said? Are they a one man band so to speak or are they part of a company? Do complain if you can.

I will assume you are an adult and not a seven year old child, like the psychologist seems to think you are. I'm so sorry. Sending you a virtual un-mumsnetty hug.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 14/12/2021 10:19

We have had this recently, as my daughter was informed her dyslexia was also a 'superpower'. We had a good laugh about when bad spelling might save the world!!! It's actually not funny though to be invalidated by someone, especially a psychologist. They should be listening to you, listening to what you need, and responding to you- gently challenging your language perhaps after a while, not jumping in and denying your experience.

I wouldn't want to continue with a crap therapist, also the therapist should listen when you say 'that's not working for me'.

The ironic thing is you are going for help with your anxiety/social communication issues- and she's a rubbish communicator! NT sometimes don't even notice their deficits in these areas.

Can you ask for someone else?

SpaceshiptoMars · 14/12/2021 10:18

A self-audit is useful. Itemising every skill you have in one column, every limitation in another. Work out what you absolutely need, office-wise, body-wise to really fly. "Superpowers" may be over-egging it a bit, but if you have significant impairment and are holding down employment, it must be that your abilities are valuable to your employer.

santasmuma · 14/12/2021 10:15

shy is dismissive

santasmuma · 14/12/2021 10:13

We don’t frame Autism as a disability in this house. It’s not useful for my particular child who is essentially gifted. He has anxiety issues and sleeping issues and is shy - he knows his brain is wired differently. We label the symptoms and treat them separately. If anybody ever called my child disabled, I’d be quite shocked.

Your child is not shy. Your child has a social communication disorder, a disability which makes him appear shy. She is so dismissive. Denial won't make your childs disability any less. Label and treat isn't how autism works. Understand and adjust.

How you could possibly be shocked if someone called your autistic child disabled, they have a disability Hmm

Sirzy · 14/12/2021 10:06

Helping a person identify their strengths is one thing, but dismissing the struggles as happened to the OP certainly isn’t going to help!

Mariammah · 14/12/2021 10:01

Many of us never get the chance to benefit from our skills because we're held back and dismissed because of the things we can't do
This is very true. I’m super intelligent and highly qualified but can’t get past the interview stage for any job. Interviewers feed back that they were impressed with my qualifications but I made them feel awkward because I’m too withdrawn and I don’t smile or talk enough. The only jobs I’ve had are ones where employers are desperate and just want to hire any warm body. I wouldn’t be impressed if someone said autism is a superpower, because it’s ruined my life due to not being able to get a permanent job.