Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Psychologist told me autism is a superpower

131 replies

Midnightpharma · 14/12/2021 08:27

I went to see a psychologist as part of a support package offered by my employer to help with my disability and perhaps learn a few strategies to deal with the anxiety I suffer from as a result of being autistic. I was talking about how my disability affects me, and the psychologist, at the end of my story, told me that "autism isn't a disability, it's a superpower!"

She proceeded to show me a kids video about how autistic people are a little different, but awesome and spent most of the rest of the session trying to make me think positively about my "superpower". I struggle on a daily basis and have had to take 6 months of sick leave in the last two years, keep feeling desperately uncomfortable at work and barely manage to stay in employment. To do so I need constant help in my home life. I can't work from an office full-time and have semi-regular shutdowns/meltdowns. I still have 10 hours of sessions left.

WIBU to try and cancel the others? I don't know what to do. They're not mandatory, but I don't want to look like I don't appreciate my employer's offer of support. At the same time this session was painful and invalidating and I'm not sure how to do another 10 hours of this. The person is a qualified psychologist who specialises is neurodiverse conditions. If being on the spectrum was a superpower why would you need to see a psychologist?!

OP posts:
Sirzy · 17/12/2021 10:01

Just because someone doesn’t outwardly seem disabled by their autism doesn’t mean they aren’t.

StellaGibson118 · 17/12/2021 09:53

@EIIa

I don’t use the works disable wrt my son because he isn’t. If anything he’s extremely able.

There is a world of difference between my best friend in a wheelchair and my son who needs melatonin to sleep and is anxious at times. I don’t abuse the concept of disability.

Piggybacking onto the idea of disability would be ridiculous and self indulgent in my situation and I don’t have to label him disabled. It’s insulting to those who actually are. There are many people who are truly disabled by their autism. My son isn’t, thankfully. A few years ago when he couldn’t speak, eat or poo - yes, he was definitely disabled by his autism. Not now.

Sorry but you need educating on this topic. Your views are ableist.
5keletor · 17/12/2021 09:25

I don't consider my autism to be a disability (e.g. When asked on forms, etc. if I have a disability), but it probably is. I also hate the "superpower" claptrap. There is such an image of autism being this wonderful thing making people "say it like it is", put their mind to anything, and so on. For me, that manifests as being too blunt and worrying about having upset people for ages afterwards, and the absolute delight that is hyperfocus.
I have "high functioning" autism (I believe the term isn't used anymore, however it was my diagnosis), but it seems to make people think of Bill Gates and Elon Musk and other super successful people with autism, when that is nowhere near reality for most of us, nor is it likely to ever be the case.
I am also surprised at the therapist using the patronising "superpower" line as they should know how varied the spectrum is - what about the autistic people who suffer through showering/brushing their hair/teeth every day because it's sensory hell, or skip it altogether at times because it's become unbearable? Do they not understand how distressing a shutdown or meltdown can be? If I was told I could make a wish and my autism would disappear, I wouldn't think twice about it.

Midnightpharma · 17/12/2021 09:21

@EIIa

I don’t use the works disable wrt my son because he isn’t. If anything he’s extremely able.

There is a world of difference between my best friend in a wheelchair and my son who needs melatonin to sleep and is anxious at times. I don’t abuse the concept of disability.

Piggybacking onto the idea of disability would be ridiculous and self indulgent in my situation and I don’t have to label him disabled. It’s insulting to those who actually are. There are many people who are truly disabled by their autism. My son isn’t, thankfully. A few years ago when he couldn’t speak, eat or poo - yes, he was definitely disabled by his autism. Not now.

You can be able and still have a disability? Whether or not I have a disability is not related to whether someone else is more disabled. Anxiety can also be a disability. I'm not saying that it is the case for your son, but having a disability is not a race to the bottom. I'm not sure I understand the point of your comment.
OP posts:
BlackeyedSusan · 17/12/2021 09:02

Must have missed the queue for the superpower part when it was handed out. Definitely disabling. You need significant impairment to be diagnosed.

EIIa · 17/12/2021 08:55

I don’t use the works disable wrt my son because he isn’t. If anything he’s extremely able.

There is a world of difference between my best friend in a wheelchair and my son who needs melatonin to sleep and is anxious at times. I don’t abuse the concept of disability.

Piggybacking onto the idea of disability would be ridiculous and self indulgent in my situation and I don’t have to label him disabled. It’s insulting to those who actually are. There are many people who are truly disabled by their autism. My son isn’t, thankfully. A few years ago when he couldn’t speak, eat or poo - yes, he was definitely disabled by his autism. Not now.

behindanothername · 17/12/2021 07:55

The word disabled isn't a negative one. It means you are navigating a world not designed for you. Whether in a wheelchair, blind, part of the Deaf community or neurominority, the world isn't designed for us and therefore we are disabled by it. Disability as a word also has a community with it, you find support and other people through it. It is frustrating hearing people say "I am not" "my child is not"

Using words like differently abled, super power, and so many other society friendly words takes away from the challenges people face daily.

With physical disability the physical world isn't designed with you in mind much of the time, the same goes for being autistic, dyslexic or the myriad of other neurodiversity conditions. Lights are too bright, music is too loud, you are expected to act/be a certain way, read documents in a meeting in x minutes and the list goes on. All of these things are disabling as they don't allow you the equitable and inclusive experience of the world.

RBKB · 17/12/2021 07:36

I can see why you found the phrasing patronising, and as if she was invalidating your difficulties.

I think neurotypical people can see the benefits and qualities of autistic thinking. Clarity, and a lack of desire to manipulate others, focus, etc. So yes, autism could be seen as a very quality way to be...however...the neurotypical world is causing you huge stress and pain, as it does for so many. And that is not ok. But possibly give the therapist one more chance, as she is not necessarily minimising your pain, and will now focus on it with you?

user478843898 · 17/12/2021 07:11

@Midnightpharma can you change your therapist for the next sessions?

Circlesandtriangles · 17/12/2021 06:42

I had counselling a few years ago for infertility. I was so stressed out. Trying for 2 years and nothing, every month going by without conceiving was taking over everything for me. In the first session, my counsellor suggested taking a break from ttc for a few months: I was enraged. Really railed against it. Was so mad at her. Felt so insensitive and belittling. I told her about how I felt and we discussed it in a few sessions. She acknowledged my thoughts on it, but mentioned it again at least once in each session.

I warmed up to it.
I tried it and actually it helped a lot. I was really surprised.

I am not saying it's in anyway the same, just a story about how sometimes things that seem like the opposite to the help we wanted can help. I think you should try another session and start off with your feedback on how the last session made you feel & see what happens. If that doesn't help, a change of person to deal with who uses a different style of counselling might be a good move. Good luck!

Frankii · 17/12/2021 06:25

If you think about it, almost all the superhero and fantasy films have gone down the track of grim backstories or miserable personal lives full of responsibility for the superheroes, being ostracised from normal life, alienated from the world.

Their abilities are often portrayed as a burden as much as a gift, until the superhero finds other people like them who they can have a mini community of sorts with, away from real life.

I know it's all just fiction and just like the glib sentiment being mentioned on this thread, it's meant to tap into that insecurity in every person to reassure them that "you're special not different, there are others like you, and you have value and worth to the world".

But really, having superpowers isn't all it's cracked up to be when you step back and look at it. It's not something I would choose. I'd like to be more normal thanks.

Theyellowflamingo · 16/12/2021 22:06

I’ve had this about my son. It’s not a superpower and as I told the last person who happily chirped this nonsense to me “It’s not like he can f fly!”.

Some of his traits have benefits (his ability to remember absolutely everything in minute detail for example) and he has many things at which he excels but there are many other traits that make his life harder. His autism is certainly no tragedy but childish and twee minimising of his struggles doesn’t help him, nor does it make it clear to neurotypical people that he needs some help and adjustments making to a predominately NT oriented world to enable him to function as a happy and fulfilled person. Afterall, who needs to provide an ehcp or pay for an assistant or get rid of the dyson hand drier or provide a pictorial timetable for a superhero….

WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly · 16/12/2021 21:41

I am autistic. Until this year I did see it as a disability. Now I see it as a cognitive difference, a different operating system.

I don’t see it as a super power though. I see it as neither better nor worse than being neurotypical and unfortunately the world isn’t geared to the minority so it absolutely can be harder to function in the world.

TopCatsTopHat · 16/12/2021 21:40

Only read the op, but had to chime in and agree that this superpower bollox is such claptrap. Toxic positivity if you ask me!
My dd is in the process of being assessed, she's great but it gives her an uphill battle to fight in certain areas and the fact is that compared to a nt person some things are harder for her. The end.
When I mentioned it to a friend I have they aid this superpower shite, and while I appreciate the sentiment that she wanted to cheer on her good qualities, the fact is that it is not the truth of her reality. She IS great, but her autistic qualities do not give her anything extraordinary in a positive sense, that part of her just gives her difficulties which she through great strength manages to overcome.
Sorry you had that op, very invalidating and uninformed.

Gilead · 16/12/2021 21:34

Parts= pratts!

Gilead · 16/12/2021 21:33

I’m a (retired) autism specialist and for fucks sake I’d be reporting for malpractice. This is appalling. It takes no account of your individual circumstances, how you prefer to operate, and is clearly dismissive. There are one or two parts who have suggested that some of us suffer with anxiety because we are made anxious by the label but not by the fact that we’re autistic. They’re wankers.
Seriously, report to their professional body, they don’t understand autism and shouldn’t be allowed to work with autistic people.
Rant over for now.

Heatherjayne1972 · 16/12/2021 21:30

My nephew is autistic and it definitely isn’t a superpower
Unless compulsive spitting eating grass and being unable to communicate ( amongst many other issues) is somehow a ‘super power’.
If a’professional’ said this to my sister she wouldn’t be responsible for her actions

Or is this ‘professional’ assuming that all autistic people are like Rainman

Rno3gfr · 16/12/2021 21:29

I’ve always wondered how autistic people would feel about the whole “superpower” narrative that has become popular. I think it’s great as some autistic people have amazing abilities, however it kind of minimises some of the struggles that autistic people face as a result of their condition.

I were to seek help from a psychologist as I was suffering, I wouldn’t want to be reminded of how great the condition is. I can see why you’ve been out off. Maybe try another session and see how it goes? If you feel it’s not helping then cancel them.

StellaGibson118 · 16/12/2021 21:19

This thread is like entries for "tell me youre nt without telling me youre nt". Deary me

DerbyshireMama · 16/12/2021 21:16

@user1478172746

"Most of us don't get to use our abilities" - yes, but if you know them, you can conciously change the situation (with help or on your own). You can seek ways to use them and congratulate yourself with every successful step, not comparing your journey with NT. Some will leave NTpicals in the dust with their success, but for some fulfilling life will be amazing and something to be proud of. "Autism is tragedy" is not a better narrative, only worse in my opinion. If you don't love even part of your autistic self, that means the problem is low self-esteem. And that one is on society, starting from childhood.
If you were replying to me then you completely misunderstood my comment. I don't think "autism is tragedy" at all and I wouldn't swap for a neurotypical brain if you paid me, but anyone who has walked this path knows it's hard. Your comment manages to be patronising and infantilising while also implying that if we just tried a bit harder it would all sort itself out.
LetsHearIt · 14/12/2021 20:23

I'm really sorry to hear of your experience @Midnightpharma
I am also autistic and have had some really ridiculous things said to me by mental health professionals.
It could be worth seeing her again.
Maybe write down what it is you're feeling and how you felt about last session.
You may read this to her in your next session if you feel you want to. Or email it to her?

It would be really interesting to see how the remaining sessions unfold after she's done her whole 'autism is a superpower' and showing you these videos.
Now that's out of the way, I wonder how she'll approach it.
However, if you find the same thing happening in the second session, I'd see if you can change psychologists.

Cheeseplantboots · 14/12/2021 14:59

@TurnUpTurnip

I see lots of people say this about their autistic children and I don’t agree, it definitely isn’t for my daughter anyway. I wouldn’t expect to hear that from a professional
Same here. My son is amazing but life is a huge struggle for him every single day. He’ll never live independently, needs 2:1 support 24/7. Can’t communicate etc. There absolutely nothing good about autism in our house. Its definitely not a super power! I’d be furious if a professional said this to me. Shows they have absolutely no understsofvsurusm if the fact that it’s a spectrum and that some people are profoundly affected.
saraclara · 14/12/2021 13:40

I HATE this whole superpower claptrap.

I'm not autistic, but I've taught severely autistic children for my entire career, and my adult DD is mildly autistic.

I'd like that psychologist to have come into my classroom of non-verbal and highly anxious children and THEN tell me it's a superpower.

This psychologist is going to continue to be wrong for you, OP, because they clearly have no clear oncept of autism, or empathy for your situation. It's perfectly fine to say so and ask for someone else. That's normal in any kind of counselling, and psychologists and counsellors understand that. You have to be a good fit for it to work. This person won't be offended or hurt.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 14/12/2021 13:26

For people who are high functioning enough ASD is not always considered a disability. It is a processing disorder or difference. Something to be managed through anxiety control / working hours / strategies to improve friendships and communication.

I rarely swear but this occasion calls for it. That is the most fucking stupid bullshit I have ever read. I have autism and it is a disability. It doesn't matter how good the person is at developing compensatory strategies - it is a disability. And we don't need to be told to "manage" the condition. That is so fucking patronising I cannot tell you.

Whoever thinks that is a sensible or sensitive thing to say should fuck off.

OffCycling · 14/12/2021 13:19

You have my sympathy OP. Living with autism can be so overwhelming and hard to cope with. Hope you find a solution that suits you.