Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to become a single mother by choice?

531 replies

Eversograteful · 14/12/2021 02:49

I have made up my mind that I 100% do not want to get married. Ever. Even after kids.

My reasons:

  • I’m well educated. So don’t need to rely on anyone else for income.
  • I have savings and I’m saving up enough to buy a house and get a mortgage which will be 100% mine (then passed on to my kids later).
  • I’m planning on living off my savings for maternity leave then returning to work after 6 months to one year.

My other, more emotional reasons for not wanting marriage:

  • it’s patriarchal, marriage was designed by men to control woman’s sexuality (my opinion)
  • I don’t like the idea of becoming a “Mrs” some else’s last name
  • I find the idea of marriage in general sexist especially the part about changing your name
  • I find weddings a mixture of boring (for everyone else), cringy (for me) and expensive and I’m not prepared to waste £20,000 on one day when I could be saving up for a house deposit with that
  • I don’t like the idea of your entire identity being deleted forever and getting deleted for a man’s identity

I just don’t like anything about marriage, couldn’t care less about being protected and I don’t care about having to work by myself and for myself to build up wealth for my children. Honestly, I’d be quite prepared to become a single mother by choice as I feel it’d almost be easier as

  • I could parent the way that I want
  • I could sleep how I want and feel rested and relaxed during baby stage without being distracted by my husband and dealing with relationship issues
  • I don’t want to deal with relationship problems, I want to parent + focus on my work and paying the bills
  • I get to make parenting decisions by myself
Single mothers have spoken about how much easier it is not to consult anyone else and just do things

I don’t have kids of my own (yet) but I’ve been yearning for my own family (children only) since I was sixteen - I even have the names picked out!. Strangely I’ve always been turned off by marriage since I was a child (even though my parents are married). It’s only recently I’ve decided it’s something I definitely do not want.

AIBU for dreaming about having children on my own?

OP posts:
U8976532 · 15/12/2021 22:28

Also intrigued as to how you would react to having a son if that happened? Considering your low opinion of men.

shewillhaveherway · 15/12/2021 22:25

No, @MabelsApron is asking a perfectly valid question. You want this for you - which is fine if it only affects you. But you are a bringing a child into this and they have their own set of needs , which should be considered also.

No one can stop you cutting off your child’s access to their other parent, to part of their medical history, their genetic code, their sense of belonging. But if you wish to be a good parent part of that involves, at the very least, considering, acknowledging and dealing with the implications of that.

There will obviously be different answers to those implications based on the particulars of an individuals circumstances. It’s not hard to imagine situations where no contact would be entirely appropriate but choosing to deny your child access to their father so you don’t have to discuss your parenting choices is not one of them. Again not because of you - but because of your child’s rights.

SW1amp · 15/12/2021 22:23

You want me to go find a therapist who will get me to agree with you? Correct?

So that at the end of therapy I become convinced that marriage is a good thing. I should want to do things for my husband because I should love compromise for no reason and that I should want to have children if a man is present from help me. If I come out of therapy expressing such views, then that means the therapy has worked. Correct?

This is the most barking mad summary or assumption of what therapy entails that I have ever read Confused

You quite clearly don’t have the first clue what therapy is, but you very clearly need some

It’s not you against the world, OP
You are allowed to hold views, including ones that you don’t need to be married, without dripping with hate and bitterness
You can hold views but understand and appreciate those views aren’t always healthy and don’t originate from a place of logic or rationale thought. You can acknowledge that bad things have happened to you and shaped your world view to an extent as to be harmful

But I suspect your narcissistic streak runs deep enough that you won’t ever actually do any of those things because you are so convinced you know best at all times

Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 22:22

@SW1amp

The more you post, the more you are coming across as an angry, narcissistic know it all

If your intention was to articulate a rounded and reasoned case for why you could side step the worst aspects of a 2-parent set up by going it alone while still giving a child a stable and fulfilling upbringing, you are failing more with each post

What gets clearer from each post is that you will not contemplate any sort of self examination, let alone constructive criticism, and it’s like watching a slow motion car crash

Clearly some damage has been done to you in the past.

For the love of god, don’t pass it on to another generation because you think it’s easier to pay a sperm donor than examine your life and views

I could say the exact same about you. You’re unwilling to accept any other viewpoint but your own to the point where you’re now using therapy as a stick to beat me with in the hopes that I agree with you. Maybe you’re damaged. I know I’m not. I love the fact that you’re also calling me names, yet I’m the one that’s angry. Funny that.
OP posts:
scottishnames · 15/12/2021 22:20

Of course not. I never said any of those things that you are accusing me of.

RE Christian marriage, I was talking about the historical situation that has - as a matter of fact - existed in the British Isles for the past 1000 years and more, until non-religious marriages were made legal in the mid 19th cent. Before them, since before AD 1000, if people wanted to be legally married, the very, very large majority had to be married according to Christian conventions.. That was the only kind of marriage that the civil law - which regulated property and inheritance- recognised.

It's nothing to do with my opinions or beliefs; that's historical fact.

Medieval Catholic ceremonies varied from place to place. They incorporated a vast number of different local pre-Christian SOCIETAL customs. That was the way in which the early Catholic church grew and won influence, by working with existing structures. This won confidence - and new believers. But the 'core' of the marriage ceremony was always the same - and still is today (and in Cof E also): the bride and groom make binding promises to each other.

In my previous post I was using the Church of England phraseology - which dates from the 16th cent - as factual evidence of the situation that existed in a large part of the UK. The C of E marriage service- as this Catholic Encyclopaedia makes clear, is very similar to the pre Reformation Catholic marriage ceremony in England: "we find ourselves confronted by the curious anomaly that in the British Isles the Catholic marriage service resembles the Anglican [C of E] service more nearly than it does the form provided in the "Rituale Romanum".
source: www.newadvent.org/cathen/09703b.htm

Even today, in both C of E and Catholic wedding ceremonies are extraordinarily similar. This is the Catholic version:
To the groom:
"N., are you resolved to take N. to be your wife:
to love her, comfort her, honour and protect her,
and forsaking all others, to be faithful to her
as long as you both shall live?"
Full text of Catholic marriage service here: www.liturgyoffice.org.uk/Resources/Marriage/OCM-Marriage-Texts.pdf

Compare the C of E vows here:
To the groom:
"N, will you take N to be your wife?
Will you love her, comfort her, honour and protect her,
and, forsaking all others,
be faithful to her as long as you both shall live?"

In both churches, the bride is then asked exactly the same question.

Full text of C of E marriage service here: www.churchofengland.org/prayer-and-worship/worship-texts-and-resources/book-common-prayer/form-solemnization-matrimony

Yes, there are different prayers at the beginning and end, but the core - the promises made by bride and groom - are almost word for word exactly the same.

Re Paul. He was writing at a time when early Christians believed that Jesus was going to return and the world would end, so of course he urged his followers to focus their minds on spiritual things, rather than on worldly matters. But he did not tell people to avoid marriage altogether. In fact, he gives a lot of advice about it. Here is just one example:
As well as asking women to respect their husbands, Paul also asked husbands to love wives equally with themselves: "husbands should love their wives as their own bodies. He who loves his wife loves himself. For no man ever hates his own flesh, but nourishes and cherishes it, as Christ does the church"

I don't think Paul ever said that the point of marriage was pleasing your spouse. This is what his text says, and it's surprisingly MUTUAL:

“The husband should give to his wife her conjugal rights, and likewise the wife to her husband. For the wife does not have authority over her own body, but the husband does. Likewise the husband does not have authority over his own body, but the wife does. Do not deprive one another, except perhaps by agreement for a limited time, that you may devote yourselves to prayer; but then come together again, so that Satan may not tempt you because of your lack of self-control.” (1 Corinthians 7:3–5 )"

That has absolutely nothing to do with the OPs 'control of female sexuality'.

U8976532 · 15/12/2021 22:20

@Eversograteful because atomic bombs are created to give everyone a big hug Hmm

It's fascinating that the religious element is what's drawn you in after ignoring hundreds of replies. I wish you'd answer some of the personal questions, I'm intrigued by your age and background!

Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 22:20

@Darkpheonix

The fact that Jesus himself was born out of wedlock says a lot

No it doesn't. Jesus was conceived by a virgin and god. Actual god. The conception isn't repeated in the Bible. It's a unique set of circumstances.

I donr care about what the bible says tbh. You obviously do, which is odd given your stance.

For me, the issue isn't that you dont want to get married or planning a single parent life.

The issue is you seem total naive about the realities of having a career and being a single parent (I did it, so know its doable but immensely hard and means alot of compromising with other adults). You also don't seem to able to ever envisage a relationship that healthy and mutually beneficial.

That's the concern.

Though your picking and choosing which bits of the bible and religion you fancy seems fairly par for the course, when it comes to organised religion. But ots not relevant to most of us.

Which parts of the bible and religion am I picking and choosing?
OP posts:
Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 22:18

[quote U8976532]@SW1amp and Christianity [/quote]
Explain to me which part of Christianity I don’t understand.

I only brought that up because someone started speaking about the Church of England and what it believes about marriage

OP posts:
SW1amp · 15/12/2021 22:18

The more you post, the more you are coming across as an angry, narcissistic know it all

If your intention was to articulate a rounded and reasoned case for why you could side step the worst aspects of a 2-parent set up by going it alone while still giving a child a stable and fulfilling upbringing, you are failing more with each post

What gets clearer from each post is that you will not contemplate any sort of self examination, let alone constructive criticism, and it’s like watching a slow motion car crash

Clearly some damage has been done to you in the past.

For the love of god, don’t pass it on to another generation because you think it’s easier to pay a sperm donor than examine your life and views

Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 22:16

[quote U8976532]@Eversograteful I notice you left out me pointing out atomic bombs? So atomic bombs are all good because people designed and created them so ultimately God did?[/quote]
If you’re referring to the point about God creating technology then yes I’m sure most Christians would say God created atomic bombs too. If people are using those things to murder other people then - the bible is already clear on what it believes about murder.

OP posts:
Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 22:14

@SW1amp

So you can add ‘therapy’ to the list of ‘things you fundamentally don’t understand’

Along with children, parenting, healthy relationships and career progression

You want me to go find a therapist who will get me to agree with you? Correct?

So that at the end of therapy I become convinced that marriage is a good thing. I should want to do things for my husband because I should love compromise for no reason and that I should want to have children if a man is present from help me. If I come out of therapy expressing such views, then that means the therapy has worked. Correct?

Also, I should come out of therapy believing I experienced something traumatic because otherwise I’d want to find a husband and spend my life compromising with him for eternity because that’s what normal people do? Am I right that this is what you believe the goal is for me?

OP posts:
U8976532 · 15/12/2021 22:12

@Eversograteful I notice you left out me pointing out atomic bombs? So atomic bombs are all good because people designed and created them so ultimately God did?

Hope478 · 15/12/2021 22:11

People are saying you need therapy, because you have said that all husbands are rapists Hmm

No one cares that you don't want a relationship, just concerned about your strange view that all marriages include rape.

Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 22:10

@U8976532

It doesn’t really matter what other Christians think, fact of the matter remains that Jesus was born “artificially”, outside of marriage, to an unmarried woman, without a father on this earth. I’m sure Christians would agree that if God created everything, he also created the technology to artificially impregnate a woman.

So by that logic Christians are comfortable with atomic bombs, child abuse, rape, murder...all created by God? What even is a sin then?

And surely he was conceived spiritually not artificially...to save man from sin or whatever, not because Mary couldn't deal with getting poked by Joseph.

Child abuse, rape and murder are technologies?

You asked me what the bible says about children born without a father.
I answered and told you the entire Christian religion was founded on a baby born without a father - to an unmarried woman so that tells you what the bible thinks of it.

You responded by telling me some Christians only want children to be born inside marriage (even though this is not stated anywhere in the New Testament of the bible that Christians follow)

I responded God made technology available to impregnate women artificially. You respond by telling me child abuse, rape and murder were also created by God so Christians must approve of it Confused- even though those particular things are directly spoken against in the New Testament of the bible. So obviously they are not approved of.

The bible clearly thinks nothing special about a child being conceived within marriage as the most important figure in Christianity wasn’t.

OP posts:
Darkpheonix · 15/12/2021 22:07

The fact that Jesus himself was born out of wedlock says a lot

No it doesn't. Jesus was conceived by a virgin and god. Actual god. The conception isn't repeated in the Bible. It's a unique set of circumstances.

I donr care about what the bible says tbh. You obviously do, which is odd given your stance.

For me, the issue isn't that you dont want to get married or planning a single parent life.

The issue is you seem total naive about the realities of having a career and being a single parent (I did it, so know its doable but immensely hard and means alot of compromising with other adults). You also don't seem to able to ever envisage a relationship that healthy and mutually beneficial.

That's the concern.

Though your picking and choosing which bits of the bible and religion you fancy seems fairly par for the course, when it comes to organised religion. But ots not relevant to most of us.

U8976532 · 15/12/2021 22:06

@SW1amp and Christianity

Twizbe · 15/12/2021 22:06

🍿

DrSbaitso · 15/12/2021 22:03

I actually dislike therapy being used as a stick to beat someone whose views you don’t agree with

Good thing that's not even remotely what she did, then.

SW1amp · 15/12/2021 22:02

So you can add ‘therapy’ to the list of ‘things you fundamentally don’t understand’

Along with children, parenting, healthy relationships and career progression

Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 22:02

@MabelsApron

OP, what would the child be getting out of this?

Serious question. Not just “getting to be born” (they wouldn’t know any different if they weren’t) or “I think I’d be good at it”. You’d be bringing a child into a world where it was missing one parent. Anyone should, I think, be making the decision to reproduce based primarily on the best interests of the child. You’re already starting the child off at a disadvantage so the bar to justify this is higher.

I’ve seen 16 pages of discussion of why you want to do it but nothing on why you think this would be in the child’s best interests.

You’re asking a controversial question because it’s kind of veering into the “who deserves to have children” type of conversation which is inappropriate and (for good reasons) highly controversial. I’m pretty sure I don’t need to elaborate on why this type of conversation is dangerous
OP posts:
U8976532 · 15/12/2021 21:59

It doesn’t really matter what other Christians think, fact of the matter remains that Jesus was born “artificially”, outside of marriage, to an unmarried woman, without a father on this earth. I’m sure Christians would agree that if God created everything, he also created the technology to artificially impregnate a woman.

So by that logic Christians are comfortable with atomic bombs, child abuse, rape, murder...all created by God? What even is a sin then?

And surely he was conceived spiritually not artificially...to save man from sin or whatever, not because Mary couldn't deal with getting poked by Joseph.

Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 21:57

@SW1amp

Yes I need therapy because I don’t want to be in a relationship.

I love how women are required to be in a relationship or else they should sign up for therapy to get a therapist to force them into one.

You need therapy because you are unable to frame a relationship as anything other than borderline abusive, sexually coercive, and a burden on your life and will refuse to see any other point of view

And NO ONE forms those sorts of fervent views without something fairly awful having happened at some point, either directly or indirectly

You also have completely belligerent views about the notion of any sort of compromise for another adult but are willing to be totally subservient to your future hypothetical children - again, not normal or healthy, and almost certainly something you’ve arrived at after negative experiences, whether you’re aware of them or not

This isn’t just about whether or not you have any sort of romantic relationships in your future, but you absolutely will not be a good parent while you hold such fixed views about the value of other people, and while you hold such a high opinion of yourself and your ability to parent

And despite all your wonderful education, your career won’t amount to much if you go through your work life with such a superiority complex

Ironically, people who completely scoff at the idea of needing therapy are often the ones most in need of it and never have I seen that more true than with your posts

I actually dislike therapy being used as a stick to beat someone whose views you don’t agree with
OP posts:
Eversograteful · 15/12/2021 21:51

@Darkpheonix

Mary and Joseph were not married and Joseph was not the real father of Jesus and he is never referred to as such

Yes i know, I had a fully Catholic education.🙄

But he was still present with her. She wasn't alone. So it's no compatible to you. And it's not something the church advocates as their version of the right way.

You can't argue the bibles says 'don't get married' but then ignore their stance on children out of wedlock. Especially, based on the virgin birth of the messiah.

Joseph may possibly have been present with her but Jesus never really acknowledges him. The only father he talks about is “Father in Heaven”.

It doesn’t matter what the Old Testament thinks about children born out of wedlock. The New Testament which Christians actually follow says nothing about it. It wouldn’t make sense because then it’d be condemning Jesus himself. The fact that Jesus himself was born out of wedlock says a lot

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 15/12/2021 21:49

@SW1amp

Yes I need therapy because I don’t want to be in a relationship.

I love how women are required to be in a relationship or else they should sign up for therapy to get a therapist to force them into one.

You need therapy because you are unable to frame a relationship as anything other than borderline abusive, sexually coercive, and a burden on your life and will refuse to see any other point of view

And NO ONE forms those sorts of fervent views without something fairly awful having happened at some point, either directly or indirectly

You also have completely belligerent views about the notion of any sort of compromise for another adult but are willing to be totally subservient to your future hypothetical children - again, not normal or healthy, and almost certainly something you’ve arrived at after negative experiences, whether you’re aware of them or not

This isn’t just about whether or not you have any sort of romantic relationships in your future, but you absolutely will not be a good parent while you hold such fixed views about the value of other people, and while you hold such a high opinion of yourself and your ability to parent

And despite all your wonderful education, your career won’t amount to much if you go through your work life with such a superiority complex

Ironically, people who completely scoff at the idea of needing therapy are often the ones most in need of it and never have I seen that more true than with your posts

This post is so good it needs to appear twice.
SW1amp · 15/12/2021 21:46

Yes I need therapy because I don’t want to be in a relationship.

I love how women are required to be in a relationship or else they should sign up for therapy to get a therapist to force them into one.

You need therapy because you are unable to frame a relationship as anything other than borderline abusive, sexually coercive, and a burden on your life and will refuse to see any other point of view

And NO ONE forms those sorts of fervent views without something fairly awful having happened at some point, either directly or indirectly

You also have completely belligerent views about the notion of any sort of compromise for another adult but are willing to be totally subservient to your future hypothetical children - again, not normal or healthy, and almost certainly something you’ve arrived at after negative experiences, whether you’re aware of them or not

This isn’t just about whether or not you have any sort of romantic relationships in your future, but you absolutely will not be a good parent while you hold such fixed views about the value of other people, and while you hold such a high opinion of yourself and your ability to parent

And despite all your wonderful education, your career won’t amount to much if you go through your work life with such a superiority complex

Ironically, people who completely scoff at the idea of needing therapy are often the ones most in need of it and never have I seen that more true than with your posts