Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joke taken the wrong way

213 replies

cakes90 · 13/12/2021 23:05

I went to a meetup group tonight and was having a laugh with a few people I just met. There was a running joke about some of the fake profiles on meetup. I said to one guy as a joke I thought he may have been a fake profile before he came to the event - this is a joke and I never thought that at all. He got really cagey and said there was nothing wrong with his profile. I apologised as I didn't mean anything. I didn't realise he would be offended. There is no way I would want to upset or offend someone.

The atmosphere was tense then, as it was near the end of the night he said he isn't stopping out as he is tired, he looked at me and said 'nothing to do with the company'. Now, before this incident he said he was tired anyway. A long time friend said as soon as I said the joke she could see how someone would take it the wrong way and you have to be careful with people you don't know and have just met. I was a member of the group for 3 years and have left it. I have not had anyone fall out like this in the years I have been going to meetup.

Looking back over this night it seemed like these people were quite socially awkward. I wish I had not gone now and waited for the next event when my long time friends would have gone as they are not like this and would have laughed. Was it bad I tried to joke?

OP posts:
TheFairPrincess · 14/12/2021 07:36

Yeah the problem is like a lot of people my understanding of a "fake profile" is a catfish profile - so in my books meeting something in real life for the first time and saying you thought they might have been fake is a compliment - implying that they appeared too good to exist IRL.

He seems to be insecure in himself to the point where any comment relating to himself, well it seems like he assumes it to automatically be a slight on him.

I think that people should be able to see that as it's a pretty well know cultural reference. Obviously the way you say it can make all the difference but it sounds like it was just an awkward situation all round and it's a shame.

I wouldn't leave a group of long time friends though! Especially when it's so easy to explain why your comment was meant to be flattering/funny and you just missed the mark for this overly sensitive man baby guy. :)

Sally872 · 14/12/2021 07:31

The guy is new so didn't get you were joking. Maybe when he said "nothing to do with the company" he was trying to join in with your joke style, or maybe reassure you there was no offence taken.

Massive over reaction to leave the group. You made a tiny error. He may or may not be a bit huffy about it. Try not to worry about it and definitely don't leave a group you enjoy over this tiny negative interaction.

knittingaddict · 14/12/2021 07:29

@thinkingaboutLangCleg

I wouldn’t have taken offence at your lighthearted remark, OP. But I have learnt to be very cautious about joking with strangers. Some people are very prickly. You don’t know how people are going to react.

Don’t beat yourself up about this, though. I wouldn’t leave the group over this. Write it off to experience, and enjoy the next meeting with your friends.

Because it's always the other person's fault that they don't understand your "banter". How ridiculously sensitive of them. Hmm

I don't think I'm too sensitive, but I would be a bit confused if a complete stranger singled me out for their running joke. At best it's thoughtless, at worst it's a bit cruel.

The joke wasn't funny, but it was also at the expense of someone else, which is a worse offence. However I don't think op needs to worry about how to interact with this man next time, as I highly doubt it will come back to the group.

girlmom21 · 14/12/2021 07:29

@NoBetterthanSheShouldBe

He made a point of saying that he wasn’t leaving because of the company, and looking at you. My social skills aren’t the best, but I’d take that as him reassuring you that he WASN’T offended?

I can see how your comment would have put him on the back foot, though.

It depends how he said it - it might have been sarcastic. I read it that way.
TokyoTen · 14/12/2021 07:28

Perhaps he has some fake profiles so got paranoid. Seems an oner reaction on your part though.

Notajogger · 14/12/2021 07:28

Afterwards he was asking my friend what a fake profile looked like, he seemed really paranoid

If course he seemed paranoid!
You accuse the others if being socially awkward but as other posters have said, it's you who is the socially awkward one here.

Anomelettefortheroad · 14/12/2021 07:27

It sounds like the sort of thing i would say tbh i don't do well making small talk with people i don't know. Don't stop going to the meet ups just because of him, if it was me id be a bit embarrassed that id said the wrong thing but id go next time my friends were going and style it out. I would actually make an effort to say hello to him next time and see what response you get.

NoBetterthanSheShouldBe · 14/12/2021 07:26

He made a point of saying that he wasn’t leaving because of the company, and looking at you. My social skills aren’t the best, but I’d take that as him reassuring you that he WASN’T offended?

I can see how your comment would have put him on the back foot, though.

Lokdok · 14/12/2021 07:14

I think maybe you're the socially awkward one. It's not the done thing, especially if this is a professional meetup group, and you shouldn't have singled one person out. Maybe they did have some minor falsehood on their profile and you made them feel uncomfortable for that reason, but you'll never know. It's totally unreasonable to leave the group though, why would you do that?

girlmom21 · 14/12/2021 07:14

This seems really strange to me.
If you were going to say to someone you thought their profile was fake surely you'd tell them why - because they're really good looking/had no picture/it was really generic/it was really 'out there'. If you just say their profile looks fake it's not surprising he's confused.

Is it a running joke for the group or for the evening?

If it's a running joke for the group it sounds like more of an initiation to see if the newbies react in the right way. Very strange.

It's also weird to accuse him of being sensitive when you're quitting a group you have been in for 3 years because of it.

This one was a complete lack of judgment on your part

HappyMeal564 · 14/12/2021 07:09

Looking back over this night it seemed like these people were quite socially awkward

To be honest you are sounding more socially awkward than them.

FOJN · 14/12/2021 07:05

I’d be thinking he does have other fake profiles online to get so weird about it all. Sounds like you’ve had a lucky escape. Forget about him.

That's what I'd have though too. The pointed comment about leaving, "nothing to do with the company" feels off too. You made a joke, he didn't get it, you apologised, don't think anymore about it. Go back to the group but give him a swerve.

FlamingoQueen · 14/12/2021 06:57

Blush I would have probably said the same thing! I think it’s because I expect people to have a sense of humour!
I’d carry on going to your meet-ups and just remember not to joke with this person again.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 14/12/2021 06:41

It was only a joke. That'll be why he has to go on the internet for friends, because he is a humourless sod in real life and has no mates.

BigYellowHat · 14/12/2021 06:32

The trouble is, you never know what someone else’s sense of humour is like. Personally, I would have laughed but he didn’t. From what you’ve written it sounds as though you didn’t do anything wrong.

SparrowNest · 14/12/2021 06:27

If someone told me they thought my profile was a catfish I’d take it as a compliment because the implication is you looked too hot/amazing to be true. Maybe different in the context of the fake profiles on this group? I don’t think I’d take it as an insult, though. I suppose if the guy is not hugely conventionally attractive etc it might seem like you’re mocking.

TisTheSeasonToBeVegan · 14/12/2021 05:54

He sounds like hard work and not your type of person (he wouldn’t be mine either), so no real loss.
Even if he didn’t find it funny, it wasn’t offensive, and he was being ridiculous to react in a way that made there be a weird atmosphere in the group.

I’d be thinking he does have other fake profiles online to get so weird about it all. Sounds like you’ve had a lucky escape. Forget about him.

HarlanPepper · 14/12/2021 05:44

I think you're getting a ludicrously hard time here from the majority of posters. Surely most people can understand making an unthinking remark on an impulse or getting carried away by a group joke. Yes, you shouldn't have singled one person out, I can see how he felt humiliated (I would have been too), but you apologised. It was a mistake. People make those.

Hopefully he'll be OK by now and he'll go back to the group too - but you shouldn't leave over this. You obviously get a lot out of the group.

MimiDaisy11 · 14/12/2021 05:01

It’s interesting that people have a polar opposite meaning to saying your profile looks fake. I’m in the camp of taking it as a compliment as most fake profiles are too good to be true with model pics. What’s the point of making a fake profile of a loser? So I’d think you were saying I was good looking.

However for some as demonstrated here it means weird (?) or some other offensive thing.

You said it’s a running joke in the group but since the guy was new maybe he didn’t know. If you apologised and explained it then I don’t know what more you can do. Some people are sensitive but it’s also hard to fully judge it without having been there.

I think it’s a bit drastic to not go back. I’d just go back when your friends will be there.

Beautiful3 · 14/12/2021 04:47

It was a silly thing to say. Just say sorry and carry on going. Silly to leave something you love to do, because of it.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/12/2021 04:46

He's not really fallen out with you.. he just doesn't understand the joke.

Saying 'haha, worried you might be one of those fake profiles' means 'thought you may have been too good to be true...' with the implication 'now you are here, I can see you are indeed every bit as good/fun/whatever as your profile suggested'... ie a good thing.

Unless there is some huge element you've left out beyond it being a running joke he was unaware of, and him thinking you've called him some sort of internet troll... i think its just one of those 'you've apologised, move on' jobs!

Silvershroud · 14/12/2021 04:34

TBH, it is quite funny, like the way a stand-up deals with a heckler. You could also try "did someone tell you it was fancy dress?" or "so your carers are having a night off tonight, then?" At least it would show if he had a sense of humour!

Lightstoobright · 14/12/2021 04:30

To state the obvious, if he was not white / has a foreign name then you were probably being -not just rude- but subtly racist and it's no wonder he was upset. I'm assuming you did actually believe that his profile was fake, even for a second, otherwise you wouldn't have said it.

cookiemonster2468 · 14/12/2021 04:30

I have not had anyone fall out like this in the years I have been going to meetup

I mean he didn't really "fall out" with you did he? He politely excused himself and said it was nothing to do with the company. The way you interpret that is up to you but it's hardly a big bust up.

cookiemonster2468 · 14/12/2021 04:28

Well it wasn't a great thing to say to someone who obviously goes to meetup groups with people they've met online and obviously values that part of their life. I can see how suggesting it was a fake profile could have been offensive and don't really get the joke.

However I don't think it's really enough to stop you going to a group you've been in for 3 years? That seems disproportionate for a little bit of social embarrassment. Just shrug it off and move on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread