Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Joke taken the wrong way

213 replies

cakes90 · 13/12/2021 23:05

I went to a meetup group tonight and was having a laugh with a few people I just met. There was a running joke about some of the fake profiles on meetup. I said to one guy as a joke I thought he may have been a fake profile before he came to the event - this is a joke and I never thought that at all. He got really cagey and said there was nothing wrong with his profile. I apologised as I didn't mean anything. I didn't realise he would be offended. There is no way I would want to upset or offend someone.

The atmosphere was tense then, as it was near the end of the night he said he isn't stopping out as he is tired, he looked at me and said 'nothing to do with the company'. Now, before this incident he said he was tired anyway. A long time friend said as soon as I said the joke she could see how someone would take it the wrong way and you have to be careful with people you don't know and have just met. I was a member of the group for 3 years and have left it. I have not had anyone fall out like this in the years I have been going to meetup.

Looking back over this night it seemed like these people were quite socially awkward. I wish I had not gone now and waited for the next event when my long time friends would have gone as they are not like this and would have laughed. Was it bad I tried to joke?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
weddingdilemmma · 15/12/2021 14:07

@StEval

Ouch! Op you have crossed a boundary here. He is a stranger to you and you made a " joke" But it sounds more like you were picking on him and expecting everyone to roar with laughter. Not very nice. You know it wasnt very nice , hence the flounce and strop. You messed up, apologise and learn from it, move on.
^ Exactly this! You're saying he's over reacting and paranoid but you're the one obsessing over it and posting on MN instead of apologising and moving on.

If you look at all the responses I don't think you'll find anyone that 'gets' the joke,
This would suggest that what you said wasn't actually funny but you can't seem to accept this:

I would understand if they were something about his profile that you felt you knew him well enough to tease him about. But 1) there was nothing about his profile that made you say it (apparently), and 2) you don't know him well enough to tease him

Personally, I wouldn't be offended if someone said that to me. However, I would be a baffled and either ask them what they meant or shrug it off and change the subject. That's because I'm quite thick skinned, confident and don't tend to dwell on what strangers think of me. However, to a less confident individual who is brand new to a group and may already be nervous,
I completely understand his reaction. He's probably been trying to work out what's wrong with his profile and why you'd think he was fake.^

5keletor · 14/12/2021 23:09

As others have said, if sounds like the main issue is that the "joke" just wasn't funny, so was taken as an accusation due to the complete lack of humour. It is an odd thing to say, I guess.
It does sound like you've brought quite a bit of drama to the group, I'd forget about it and not bring it up again if you do go back, otherwise people are just going to feel uncomfortable again.

LordPeppercorn · 14/12/2021 23:00

@cakes90

I have already apologised once and he accepted it. I am not apologising again, I don’t have to beg for forgiveness.
To be fair, you're the one who sounds paranoid. You say he's accepted the apology. Who's asking you to beg then? You're wondering why he had to leave, what him looking at you meant and you left the group because of it all. You've now come to mumsnet to make a thread about it.

Yet, him asking what the comment you said to him meant is paranoid?

I think you're projecting. You both lost each other in communication (and possibly sound a bit alike). That's all.

LordPeppercorn · 14/12/2021 22:55

@AwaAnBileYerHeid

It was only a joke. That'll be why he has to go on the internet for friends, because he is a humourless sod in real life and has no mates.
Wow, what is this - school? Such an immature thing to say.Confused

OP (and many others on mumsnet) also 'goes on the internet for friends'. What do you have to say about them?

LizzieW1969 · 14/12/2021 22:53

@shreddednips

You're both overreacting IMO. I'm not sure I understand the joke, but I also don't think it was grossly insulting or anything. I wouldn't have been bothered, although perhaps baffled, but he was, so an apology was in order. Assuming you did apologise, it seems a bit OTT for him to not let it go.

You're also overreacting by leaving the group. If you wanted, you could send a message to him apologising again and explaining that it was intended as a joke and not meaning to suggest that there was something actually wrong with his profile, but that you realise it sounded mean and want to say sorry. It seems a shame to miss out on something you enjoy because of a misjudged joke.

I do think it's worth taking what your friend (and PPs) are saying about not making personal jokes with people you don't know well. It's nothing to do with 'walking on eggshells'- he doesn't know you, so he doesn't know whether you were making a harmless joke or being catty.

This is spot on. Jokes like this should be restricted to people you know. Even then, it can be misunderstood; my DM never realises when my DH is pulling her leg.
Kite22 · 14/12/2021 22:05

I also agree with @ComtesseDeSpair

and very much this:

So you upset someone but it’s their fault for being “paranoid” and you won’t go back to the group because of “too much aggro”?

A more mature response would be to reflect on the fact that your flippancy has upset someone and think about how you could be kinder in future.

shreddednips · 14/12/2021 18:31

You're both overreacting IMO. I'm not sure I understand the joke, but I also don't think it was grossly insulting or anything. I wouldn't have been bothered, although perhaps baffled, but he was, so an apology was in order. Assuming you did apologise, it seems a bit OTT for him to not let it go.

You're also overreacting by leaving the group. If you wanted, you could send a message to him apologising again and explaining that it was intended as a joke and not meaning to suggest that there was something actually wrong with his profile, but that you realise it sounded mean and want to say sorry. It seems a shame to miss out on something you enjoy because of a misjudged joke.

I do think it's worth taking what your friend (and PPs) are saying about not making personal jokes with people you don't know well. It's nothing to do with 'walking on eggshells'- he doesn't know you, so he doesn't know whether you were making a harmless joke or being catty.

Corbally · 14/12/2021 18:25

@mam0918, you’ve completely misunderstood the purpose of Meetup.

Twopenny · 14/12/2021 18:16

@mam0918 but the meet ups are for loney or socially awkward people who dont already have friend groups... you sound like a privileged abelist bully in that sentence because excluding someone is cruel but excluding someone from something designed specifically for them is ridiculous.

Er, what? Meetup.com isn't specifically for lonely or socially awkward people?

I'm on it because I'm into art, and local art classes and events are organised through it. There's also a really active LGBT group that organises events for the community via Meetup.

mam0918 · 14/12/2021 14:35

@TractorAndHeadphones

OP - ONE person couldn’t take a joke and now you don’t want to go back? That’s an overreaction. It wasn’t the best joke but neither was it offensive unless someone was very sensitive. To let it ruin the whole atmosphere is horribly socially awkward. Go back and enjoy your long term friends. I can be sensitive too but if someone apologises the intention is clear. If he’s too paranoid and socially awkward he should stay home and not go to any meet-ups. Nobody can say that they’ve NEVER said the wrong thing. So why not treat others like you’d want to be treated if you said the wrong thing?
If he’s too paranoid and socially awkward he should stay home and not go to any meet-ups.

but the meet ups are for loney or socially awkward people who dont already have friend groups... you sound like a privileged abelist bully in that sentence because excluding someone is cruel but excluding someone from something designed specifically for them is ridiculous.

OP was the one that was socially awkward (the only other option is she is deliberately just straight-up mean) and cause the issue not him.

Enough4me · 14/12/2021 13:33

OP I hope you are ignoring the OTT messages and busy having fun.

Some on here would like to torture you by the sounds of it for saying a joke that fell flat 🤣

cushioncovers · 14/12/2021 13:03

I think you were nervous and tried to deflect that by making a joke at someone else's expense. It backfired.

I've done this before at a dinner party. It didn't go down well I'm still embarrassed by it years later.

Don't worry too much about it op but just try not to do it again.

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 14/12/2021 12:56

You sound like hard work, op. The group’s probably breathing a collective sigh of relief.

StEval · 14/12/2021 12:43

Ouch!
Op you have crossed a boundary here.
He is a stranger to you and you made a " joke"
But it sounds more like you were picking on him and expecting everyone to roar with laughter.
Not very nice.
You know it wasnt very nice , hence the flounce and strop.
You messed up, apologise and learn from it, move on.

notanothertakeaway · 14/12/2021 12:39

If I go back I will avoid him as I can't be walking on eggshells all the time with people in fear of saying something wrong

OP, you don't seem very remorseful

Are you by any chance someone who makes comments like "I'm a marmite person. People love me or hate me?" If so, please know that it's not a good look

notanothertakeaway · 14/12/2021 12:34

@ComtesseDeSpair

Look at it from his perspective: it’s his first time at a meeting trying to make new friends, and a complete stranger has just told him, out of nowhere, that there’s something about the way he looks in his photo or what he’s written about himself in his profile which comes across as fake / weird / suspicious.

It’s not exactly flattering, is it? Especially if he’s already feeling a bit self conscious because it’s his first time at a meeting. And it isn’t funny. And if you’ve only just met him, he doesn’t know it’s a “running joke.”

It’s a bit precious to delete yourself from the group over it, though. Can’t you just avoid him and focus on the others you do know?

I agree with @ComtesseDeSpair

OP, I actually don't really understand how you intended your comment to be funny. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt that you meant his profile seemed too good to be true ie attractive, high achiever, interesting hobbies, whatever

But, with hindsight, can't you see how this could be taken the other way? Many people would interpret your comment as saying there was something strange about his profile

Put yourself in his shoes. Imagine you posted your photo on this thread, and people joked that they thought it wasn't real. How would you feel?

Marvellousmadness · 14/12/2021 12:26

....
Nothing happened
You made a joke
He was being way too precious about it
And your "friends" are... well.. not your friends..

You apologised. Now keep your head up. And keep walking. And surround yourself with people whom aren't so easily offended and pedantic about things

Saoirsesersha · 14/12/2021 12:20

I’d take it as a compliment
I don’t see what the issue is to be honest

Flowers500 · 14/12/2021 12:15

To be really honest here, it sounds like everyone involved is not 10/10 for social skills. And that’s fine, you’re in a group for people who want to meet other people, it’s what should be expected.

People make misjudged jokes all the time, there was nothing terrible said and at most it should have just fallen flat. However the way you have reacted is so over the top it suggests your reading of the situation was poor. Likewise his reaction suggests he wasn’t able to read that it was intended as a lighthearted and friendly comment. So misunderstandings all round.

The fact you seemingly want to sulk, tantrum your way out of the group or ignore him suggests your accusation of them being socially awkward is something that could be pointed your way too. These groups sound like a good opportunity to work on social skills so maybe think of it that way, a chance to learn to get along with him?

I’m guessing people in this scenario aren’t all NT?

NewPapaGuinea · 14/12/2021 12:10

There’s always an element of truth to a joke. Why did you think/suggest his profile was fake?

AnnieJ1985 · 14/12/2021 11:34

I picture it as something like
*general chat among the group, fake profiles come up, lighthearted conversation about not being sure if a profile is real etc

  • the man in question isn't part of the conversation, or not paying attention or whatever
  • OP turns to him and makes what they think is lighthearted comment along the lines of "oh I wasn't sure your profile would turn out to be a real person hahaha"
  • Other man didn't get the joke (which wasn't IMO hilariously funny or offensive, just a throw away comment) and it got awkward trying to explain it to him (not his fault, or OPs really, just one of those things)
  • Evening was coming to an end anyway, but it ended a bit "off"

I don't see why people are saying its too late to apologise/backtrack after making the comment. What do you expect OP to do, they can't turn back time?

Sometimes jokes aren't funny, they fall flat, you mis-read a situation or the person on receiving end doesn't get what you mean - you can end up making it worse by trying to explain something that wasn't a big deal to start with. If the man is upset by it, it wasn't the OPs intention, while I think we should be considerate of others feelings and apologise if we upset someone.

CuntAmongstThePigeons · 14/12/2021 11:24

Covid has obviously just made many people very isolated and insecure and unable to interact normally. I think its really sad.

I've made snippier/meaner/more personal jokes to people I've met in the queue at the post office or the bus stop and they've laughed and we've had a good time together.

You would expect someone turning up to a specific event to meet others and make friends would be more light hearted, open to joking, he just sounds like really hard work.

Also agree that you perhaps touched a nerve and something about his profile, is faked/exaggerated. Otherwise what an over reaction.

Fireatseaparks · 14/12/2021 11:16

Joke*

Fireatseaparks · 14/12/2021 11:15

@cakes90 - can you explain the Joe a bit more?

As it stands, without any context, it doesn't seem either funny or unfunny - you said you thought his profile was fake, because sometimes meetup groups get fake members.

What's the rest, what do the fake members normally join for? Was there anything about his profile that made you think it was fake? If so, what? If not, what's the joke?

Help us out.

Enough4me · 14/12/2021 11:14

I'd definitely use it as a joke if I was with a group of people on a social event talking about dating profiles. I would joke about my own profile, profiles in general, the whole weird first messages thing and would not single a person out unless I knew they shared my sense of humour.

I think the OP didn't know her audience and selected one person, but has reflected on this so time to move on. We learn through our mistakes.