Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying per head for Xmas dinner at sil house

285 replies

Michellexxx · 13/12/2021 18:21

We’re going for a ‘second Xmas’ at sisters house. They have requested that we each pay per head for the meal.. we have hosted about 3 Tim’s before and they have brought a course/bottle/maybe offered 20 quid one year. But if we don’t eat the cheese/drink the wine they brought, they took it home.
It’s been calculated that the family coming will basically pay for the food part and they’re gonna pay for extras..

It’s a relatively far drive and we’ve never charged like this- even when they stayed at ours and had all their meals here!

I have already suggested it’s a bit much for some family who are travelling. The hosts earn reasonably well, so I don’t understand this! We’re having to pay £45 to travel 2 hours and obv most people won’t be able to drink because they’re driving!

Am I over thinking this?

OP posts:
lightisnotwhite · 13/12/2021 21:21

Can you not suggest you’ll host as “ you feel bad they can’t afford to host properly”. Or just say you’ll bring your own food as you’ll love to see everyone but as you have a long drive and can’t drink it’s not worth spending the same as dinner out.

Be as cheeky as they are.

ZenNudist · 13/12/2021 21:21

Just say £45 per head is too much. I will pay the without alcohol price and you will tell me how you are calculating ot. Plus I didn't charge you to eat at my house x y and z times. She's your sister surely you can say what's what to her.

Kite22 · 13/12/2021 21:16

I think you have to call it out, in the family WhatsApp group.

Say "Don't be ridiculous. You came to us last time, and, as hosts we paid for everything (except the cheese that you took home) so on the year we come to you, then surely it is your turn to treat everyone ?"

Is possible, get the other people going to say the same or back you up if it is a family group, or to send the same text if it is by text.

If they say something about not being able to afford it, then you can say that "you will put in a bill for when you hosted them, and then they will cancel each other out"

I understand you want to see people and spend Christmas together, but it isn't going to be very enjoyable if you are all sitting there resenting it.

BabaykaYaga · 13/12/2021 21:15

Did you post about this a while ago?

Chloemol · 13/12/2021 21:11

If they don’t pay when they come to you, and take food back, they shouldn't expect you to pay if you go to theirs.

I wouldn’t go to any family that would expect me to pay, I would happily take a dessert, wine, whatever but no money

I wouldn’t be going and would tell them it’s to help them keep costs down
I also wouldn’t be inviting them to mine anymore

SirensofTitan · 13/12/2021 21:09

@HeronLanyon

I’ve never heard of family charging family. Totally get if you can’t afford it then either invite fewer or everyone just. Food/drink organised before with host. But to charge family cash ?! Hmmm
I haven't in real life but I've read about it loads on here, it comes up every year so must be quite common

I do have a bit of sympathy for hosts, if someone is happy to do all the shopping, prep, cooking, washing up and general running around but can't afford to splash out for a meal several people I don't think in principle asking for a contribution is always rude.

qpmz · 13/12/2021 21:04

Your sister charging money to eat at her house? That is not normal. If you can't afford it, don't host.

Imdreamingofapeacefulxmas · 13/12/2021 21:02

If people have the room others don't have but... Are cash short I can imagine a discussion, hate to charge but we are a little short this year, happy to host if people can chip in? Bring food or wine or cash.

We were thinking of... X y.. Z.. Happy to do something else.

Or if it was immediate family and they were struggling I would hope they would simply say and then we all chip in to help them out!

However... People who are OK and start "monitoring" things... Watching... Sip wine wondering if the can leave with their bottle in tact, watching who eats their cheese etc drains all the joy out for me.
I can't relax around people like that it really affects me it's just so incredibly tight.

XingMing · 13/12/2021 20:47

It won't happen in our family. You'd have to prise the oven gloves from BiL's hands; we'll be allocated supporting roles, and will bring nice wine.

;;

RosesAndHellebores · 13/12/2021 20:42

If you can't afford to host, you don't host. It's mean.

Sceptre86 · 13/12/2021 20:41

I find this such an alien concept and wouldn't go. You simply don't invite more people than you can afford to feed. Surely as guests you would bring something eg. wine, flowers a dessert and pitch in with the cleaning anyway? I guess it depends on how much you enjoy their company and if it's worth it for peace.

Disfordarkchocolate · 13/12/2021 20:35

@JadeSeahorse

It would be a “No thanks” from me.

If I’m spending £45 on food alone then I much prefer to choose my own and enjoy it in the comfort of my own home.

YADN overthinking this!

Me too
Puffinhead · 13/12/2021 20:34

@HollowTalk

Ask them why the rules are changing now that they are hosting.
Exactly this.
woodhill · 13/12/2021 20:30

@Michellexxx

They have done this before but didn’t ask for quite as much. It was a number of years ago. But the Turkey wasn’t cooked properly so everyone left after having a slice of beef and some veg..they apparently lived off Turkey curry etc for weeks 🙄 I just find it quite rude too!
What do other family members think, it's such a cheek.

I wouldn't get them any gifts either, they don't deserve it

HopefulHetty · 13/12/2021 20:30

I'd be tempted to go, eat in a restaurant even McDonald's, then drop in with my box of baking to offer round. And have a lovely meet up.

Sparklybanana · 13/12/2021 20:26

Nope. Unless they are clearly much less well off and wanted to return the mental load of hosting. If they can afford it then just laugh and say the contribution is doing for the last few years and it'll be nice to have the night off!

Makewomenfemaleagain · 13/12/2021 20:25

Awfully rude and cringeworthy.

heymammy · 13/12/2021 20:25

Very bad form tbh to charge family for a meal unless it's the way it's always done - which it clearly isn't in your case!

Just don't xfer the money Wink are they ballsy enough to call you out? I'd have a measured response ready.

maconandmacorons · 13/12/2021 20:21

I've read a few of these threads over the years and I always assumed they were made up but I met a friend through the children this year and her MIL does this.

You're a guest. If you invite people to your house/event, you cater for them. Your in laws are rude and awful and I'd just flat out refuse. It's so cringey and tight it makes my ears hurt. If they can't afford to host, they shouldn't invite people.

HeronLanyon · 13/12/2021 20:19

I’ve never heard of family charging family. Totally get if you can’t afford it then either invite fewer or everyone just. Food/drink organised before with host. But to charge family cash ?!
Hmmm

Ourlady · 13/12/2021 20:18

If you're happy to be taken advantage of (again!) then just go.
You were always going to pay and go so I don't understand why you ask for opinions when you already know they are being tight gets?
Personally I would ask why you have to pay to go to her Xmas dinner but they don't offer to pay when they come to yours.

Nancydrawn · 13/12/2021 20:17

It's horrifically rude.

Unless there's an outside reason (someone's been ill or made redundant or is quite young/old), then it's never, ever acceptable to ask for payment for hosting. In fact, in those cases I would hope that the family would offer to cover the bills without being asked, so there still wouldn't be a reason to ask for actual payment.

Now, if she wanted to make it pot luck and assign everyone to bring a dish, that would be fine--convivial, even. But actual cash? No.

WellLarDeDar · 13/12/2021 20:17

I would never ever ask anyone to pay for dinner at mine. When I've hosted my family for Xmas they've automatically contributed without being asked, it's a group effort like one person brings the turkey someone else brings a ham sort of thing. Though DHs family... Not to much, but I'd never ask.

Beautiful3 · 13/12/2021 20:15

£45 each!!! I'd rather go to a restaurant! I wouldn't go. Just say, no thanks! Always think it's rude when you've hosted for free, and they ask for payment!

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 13/12/2021 20:13

I have come to the conclusion, after reading many threads of this type on MN, that the host/ess is free to say exactly what their expectations are eg, no children at a wedding, dogs forbidden etc and that guests are free to decline invitations.