Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying per head for Xmas dinner at sil house

285 replies

Michellexxx · 13/12/2021 18:21

We’re going for a ‘second Xmas’ at sisters house. They have requested that we each pay per head for the meal.. we have hosted about 3 Tim’s before and they have brought a course/bottle/maybe offered 20 quid one year. But if we don’t eat the cheese/drink the wine they brought, they took it home.
It’s been calculated that the family coming will basically pay for the food part and they’re gonna pay for extras..

It’s a relatively far drive and we’ve never charged like this- even when they stayed at ours and had all their meals here!

I have already suggested it’s a bit much for some family who are travelling. The hosts earn reasonably well, so I don’t understand this! We’re having to pay £45 to travel 2 hours and obv most people won’t be able to drink because they’re driving!

Am I over thinking this?

OP posts:
WhatTimeIsItMrGinola · 14/12/2021 09:11

Enable them to do what exactly, split the bill?

Enable them to be rude enough to ask for money for invites THEY have given out.

Enable them to be CFs in asking for money for what other people have kindly given THEM for free in previous years.

Enable them to think that it is normal to charge people and if people dont want to pay, then they dont have to obviously, but then they dont come to a family gathering.

LookItsMeAgain · 14/12/2021 08:49

You need to counter that request with one of your own where you would say "Well SiL, for the times we've hosted you, including petrol and drink etc. we will come in at the same costs you're looking to charge us so why don't we say we've covered the costs already because we've hosted you, yes?"
Or if you've hosted them more often than they've hosted you, send them a bill for outstanding festivities that they have enjoyed at your expense.

GloriaSicTransitMundi · 14/12/2021 08:49

I would 'accidentally' reply all, and say 'Gosh sis, worried about you - are you having money problems? Only we've hosted you so many times and we never asked for money, but I remember you brought cheese last time then took it home with you. Are you ok hun?'

Then everyone on the invite list can have a think about how they respond, I bet you're not the only one thinking CF-ery.

C8H10N4O2 · 14/12/2021 08:33

The traveling two hours works both ways - they would be driving with one not drinking if they came to you.

I agree contributing is different from charging. The most convenient address for the family Christmas may not be the family who can afford all the costs every year. So families bring contributions to the party or by putting money in a pot but then sharing in deciding what to buy for the family party. I don't see how that is worse than families avoiding a get together because no one person can afford the big event for a twenty odd people. I've never totaled up the cost per head explicitly but have generally spent more than she is charging by the time you tot up all the extras.

As for taking stuff home - again depends on the context. I explicitly tell people no need to bring anything family do anyway at Christmas as they want to contribute despite it not been necessary. We end up with way more in the house than we can use. I'm definitely guilty of sending younger and older members of the family home with food parcels. Perhaps that is SiLs experience and why she takes surplus home.

If you think she is over charging for the food and trying to make money out of the occasion then either call her out over it and ask her if she really needs to charge members of the family who may struggle to afford it or suck it up. Those are the options.

Fatgalslim · 14/12/2021 08:15

@purpledagger

I don't think asking for a contribution is a bad idea, because hosting can be expensive and stressful. But this should be something like help out by bringing a starter/pudding/side dish.

But requesting £45 - surely they must be making a profit, I mean, how can Xmas dinner at someone's house cost that much??? Unless they are fabulous cook and using Unicorn tears, what does £45 get you?

This, what exactly are you getting for the money as you say only the hosts will be drinking?
timeisnotaline · 14/12/2021 08:08

Why would you put up with it, it isn’t the first time and it will just happen again after all, so why don’t you bite the bullet and just call them out on it?? ‘Looking forward to seeing people. Bit surprised at the payment request, we will have to put it on the tab for all the Christmas dinners hosted at ours. But of course we can bring a pudding or nibbles, anything in particular?’

SSOYS · 14/12/2021 08:06

I can understand the amount- I’m sure ours is costing about that much and that’s before you think of the booze. But of course it’s very odd to ask you to pay. I’d understand it better if they were short of money but then why do such an extravagant meal?

lottiegarbanzo · 14/12/2021 08:02

Contributing can make sense if the same family always hosts.

Contributing is not quite the same as charging.

She's your sister, talk to her.

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 14/12/2021 08:00

Can you go to see family but decline eating?? That is awful behaviour that deserves calling out. Go for a walk while they are all eating?

Lockheart · 14/12/2021 07:58

@WhatTimeIsItMrGinola

You'll go, you'll pay and you will enable them
Enable them to do what exactly, split the bill?
purpledagger · 14/12/2021 07:56

I don't think asking for a contribution is a bad idea, because hosting can be expensive and stressful. But this should be something like help out by bringing a starter/pudding/side dish.

But requesting £45 - surely they must be making a profit, I mean, how can Xmas dinner at someone's house cost that much??? Unless they are fabulous cook and using Unicorn tears, what does £45 get you?

readwhatiactuallysay · 14/12/2021 07:53

I understand why you want to go, its not about the meal, but about seeing the family.

£45 for a family to travel wouldn't bother me at all, we spend alot more than this visiting over the holiday and dont give it a second thought and to be honest if i had a relative who was struggling financially i would be more than happy to help them out to facilitate them having a turn at hosting......BUT they have gone about this all wrong i think with a charging by the head bloomin approach and charging for drink etc

I personally would have a private chat about why they are charging, should they maybe do a buffer style day instead to reduce the cost for them.
But i dont think you are being unreasonable in your situation.

littlebilliie · 14/12/2021 07:43

Stay at home and spend your money on a lovely Christmas Day

notacooldad · 14/12/2021 07:11

These threads baffle me.
This year everyone is against it , some year's people think it's not a bad idea and say how expensive it is, how fuel prices are rising and it's a good idea to share the cost and you have the treat of a decent meal that you havent had to make or wash up, why should one couple should have all the costs etc
A few years ago I was appalled that idea of paying someone in the family for Christmas dinner but MN persuaded me it wasnt a bad idea. Now everyone hates the idea!!! 🤷‍♀️ 🤣

Ellen888 · 14/12/2021 07:07

@2catsandhappy

Ask her to email the menu. All the courses, sides and drinks. Tell her you will be giving a review.
GrinGrinGrin

I'd also tell environmental health her hygiene listing was out of date and the premises needed inspecting and then dob them in to the tax office as well.

But then I'm not nice....

DrManhattan · 14/12/2021 06:20

But you are still going? Fair play to them for getting away with it. Less CF and more doormat.

WhatTimeIsItMrGinola · 14/12/2021 00:25

You'll go, you'll pay and you will enable them

NatriumChloride · 14/12/2021 00:08

Wtf did I just read?? Charging family for a meal at your house? Absolutely batshit. No way.

Dasher789 · 14/12/2021 00:04

Iv never been charged but I'd be more than happy to chip in for our families Xmas lunch. The same person hosts every year. Its a lot of food and a lot of work. I'd much rather chip in for someone else to do it that host myself. My family travel from across the country so no one really brings anything themselves.

WhereYouLeftIt · 13/12/2021 23:17

She's your sister. Surely you can tell her she's being very rude and remind her of all the times you've hosted her without this grasping greediness? And that she can whistle for charging you a penny, it's just not happening?

repottingthescabious · 13/12/2021 22:58

@Michellexxx

They have done this before but didn’t ask for quite as much. It was a number of years ago. But the Turkey wasn’t cooked properly so everyone left after having a slice of beef and some veg..they apparently lived off Turkey curry etc for weeks 🙄 I just find it quite rude too!
stop.

that way madness lies.

just have your own family Cristmas at home and do not host again for this lot!

lottiegarbanzo · 13/12/2021 22:51

Speak to her.

2catsandhappy · 13/12/2021 22:28

Ask her to email the menu. All the courses, sides and drinks.
Tell her you will be giving a review.

Classica · 13/12/2021 22:23

There's no way I'd go. And no way I'm manage to be completely polite either. Pointed comments would be made.

The only scenario I could see it being acceptable to charge a guest for their Christmas dinner (or second Christmas dinner) would be if everyone was extremely hard up and spreading the cost ensured all had a nice time without an individual taking a financial hit they couldn't afford.

Justmuddlingalong · 13/12/2021 22:22

I would not take cash and bring my debit card out after the meal. Seems a normal way to make a transaction in covid times. 🤷‍♀️