Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying per head for Xmas dinner at sil house

285 replies

Michellexxx · 13/12/2021 18:21

We’re going for a ‘second Xmas’ at sisters house. They have requested that we each pay per head for the meal.. we have hosted about 3 Tim’s before and they have brought a course/bottle/maybe offered 20 quid one year. But if we don’t eat the cheese/drink the wine they brought, they took it home.
It’s been calculated that the family coming will basically pay for the food part and they’re gonna pay for extras..

It’s a relatively far drive and we’ve never charged like this- even when they stayed at ours and had all their meals here!

I have already suggested it’s a bit much for some family who are travelling. The hosts earn reasonably well, so I don’t understand this! We’re having to pay £45 to travel 2 hours and obv most people won’t be able to drink because they’re driving!

Am I over thinking this?

OP posts:
Pigsears · 14/12/2021 18:28

If this was the first year of this, it means you could continue along the same lines with your sister next year when you host.

If you choose not to do with other siblings, then that's fine, you absorb that cost but charge out to sister based on number of people in her family.

unless everyone is on board, it makes things awkward. But if a big group, and its for the whole extended family, and one family has to do it, and there is not a lot of cash, then may have to start sometime...

TatianaBis · 14/12/2021 18:28

Fuck that.

Schooldilemma2345 · 14/12/2021 18:21

That’s disgusting behaviour IMO! If you host you accept that you bear the brunt of the expense. If people offer to bring a contribution (and they really should if they’re close enough to spend Xmas with you). Then you say, “oh great, yes, please could bring a pudding/cheese/similar”. They should always bring wine- it’s totally up to you whether you open it there and then or save it for another occasion (as long as the booze is flowing!). Also, if you don’t end up eating what you’ve contributed, you certainly don’t take it home! That’s sooo rude!! If you need your dish back there and then you transfer it into something else!

FFS what is wrong with people!!

TinselTottyTart · 14/12/2021 18:19

I personally wouldn't go, however you could be a bigger person and take cake, wine etc and let them squirm. Money?, hell mo.

WimpoleHat · 14/12/2021 18:17

These things can be tricky. If you’re well off, it’s easy to recoil in horror at the idea of anything other than “host pays and guest brings a bottle of wine”. But if you’re not so well off and there’s an expectation that people will get together at Christmas for large meals, then it can be tricky. My friend was always the host for 20 as she had the house “in the middle” of all the relatives and had just enough space for everyone to stay. But this meant an astronomical grocery bill for her, not to mention an eye watering amount of laundry and washing up. So they did it on a “everyone gives her £30 and she just orders all the food” basis.

What’s different here, though, is that the hosts seem to have changed the rules when it’s their turn. That does seem a bit off!

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 14/12/2021 18:14

The only people I've ever split the cost of a 'christmas dinner' with were my housemates at uni. I would say to them if they are struggling financially you are happy to host.
We usually take something eg my brother a few years ago said to my parents that he'd found a new local butcher and ordered the turkey and beef (just distracted them etc when talk of paying for it came up), or we'll say we've got a case of wine we'll bring, and I'll quite often make something for pudding and just say it's a recipe I want to try out or it's a favourite people have enjoyed before. Last time we hosted PIL brought a huge hamper and told us in advance not to get certain things as they had a hamper 'going spare' , everyone always brings a bottle. There are polite ways to mitigate the expense and effort from the host. Just charging per head seems a bit off.

Maggiejardine · 14/12/2021 18:10

It sounds more like a restaurant to me. If I could not afford to host a meal I wouldn’t invite anyone.
Ask your SIL if she has a machine so you can tap your card

thenovice · 14/12/2021 18:06

I think I would make my excuses, using Covid as the reason to avoid discomfort.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 14/12/2021 18:02

There was a very similar discussion about this recently - it made the Mirror!

www.mirror.co.uk/news/weird-news/my-laws-charging-christmas-dinner-25514579?swet=

pinkpantherpink · 14/12/2021 18:01

Oh dear. So they have form for this and don't bat an eyelid at potentiak food poisoning. Big swerve from me I reckon. No thank you!

ohmyohmy123 · 14/12/2021 17:50

I would say you will go but after the meal just to see everyone. Then eat at home at 12, arrive at theirs for 2.30ish after they've eaten. Take some desert you can share and have some and your own drinks.

keeptheaspidistra · 14/12/2021 17:44

This seems to be relatively common thing to do but to me billing family and loved ones just seems to sap the fun out of things at Christmas. I'd rather arrange to go out to a restaurant and pay my share that way

Dentistlakes · 14/12/2021 14:30

I don’t understand people who charge family for Christmas lunch when they are hosting. I would be happy to provide a course and we usually offer to provide the ingredients or a course (e.g cheese) and we always bring bubbly and wine, but I find asking for money a but strange. Even more so in your case op when you have hosted at no cost to them in previous years.

SmolCat · 14/12/2021 14:24

How much exactly are they asking @Michellexxx? Is it £45 a head?

neverornow · 14/12/2021 11:16

We introduced this about 10 years ago. Each couple contribute £50 towards food, drink and treats for the kids (we all have DC's). The hosts usually always ended up coughing up a bit more on extras but thankfully hosting duties are rotated every. And designated drivers were fed first.
Suggest you do the same - speak to family on the day and see if you all can do this going forward.

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 14/12/2021 11:08

@WhatTimeIsItMrGinola

Enable them to do what exactly, split the bill?

Enable them to be rude enough to ask for money for invites THEY have given out.

Enable them to be CFs in asking for money for what other people have kindly given THEM for free in previous years.

Enable them to think that it is normal to charge people and if people dont want to pay, then they dont have to obviously, but then they dont come to a family gathering.

Previous meals werent free though.

OP said the other family either bring food or have paid £20 before. Which is seemingly what they're asking OP for (once taking away the £45 travel costs).

It seems lots of posters havent actually read the full posts before jumping to the conclusion that SIL is a CF - all while letting brother get away with it of course.

WhoopsWhatsMyNameAgain · 14/12/2021 11:04

@GloriaSicTransitMundi

I would 'accidentally' reply all, and say 'Gosh sis, worried about you - are you having money problems? Only we've hosted you so many times and we never asked for money, but I remember you brought cheese last time then took it home with you. Are you ok hun?'

Then everyone on the invite list can have a think about how they respond, I bet you're not the only one thinking CF-ery.

Would you actually send that?! Thats a really rude message and definitely not one I'd send to family.

The OP is paying £45 for travel. That's her perogative. Presumably the other family pay to travel when she hosts.

They are also charging £20 for food and drink for 2 adults and 2 young children. That's pretty cheap.

It's not ideal to charge but neither is it ideal for one family to foot the full bill. It can get stupidly expensive for multiple people, especially when this is a second Xmas dinner and they've had to pay for another recently too.

If OP really doesn't want to, fair enough. She can message her SIL or brother (because it's his household too, why do women have to take the blame) "hi, were quite tight on cash atm due to Xmas, would you mind if we bring a course instead of a payment? We won't be drinking much due to driving so hope this is ok?".

BoredZelda · 14/12/2021 10:57

Depends. We used to go back to my parents, as did my DB and DS. We'd chip in £50 a couple as it wasn't fair for my retired parents to bear all the costs especially as we're all in decent jobs. We also share out chores like washing up and veg prep etc.

Same here. Mum and dad are doing a get together for us all at theirs after Christmas. I’m buying in the food so they don’t have to spend anything or lift a finger.

If someone asked us to chip in, I’d be happy to do it, but if you’re not then just decline.

LilyTheMink · 14/12/2021 10:56

". we have hosted about 3 Tim’s before and they have brought a course/bottle/maybe offered 20 quid one year."

Was it We Three Tim's?

We've hosted them before, they are great fun.

HopefulHetty · 14/12/2021 10:55

And she'll be providing food for her own children.

HopefulHetty · 14/12/2021 10:54

Op says in total, including petrol, it will cost about £65.

readwhatiactuallysay · 14/12/2021 10:52

Oohhh a passive agressive christmas day sounds just fabulous!!

readwhatiactuallysay · 14/12/2021 10:51

Has anyone realised the £45 is OPs travel cost not whats being asked for?

StormyTeacups · 14/12/2021 09:24

If I did go, I would have to be really passive aggressive and say "oh, is this what we're doing now? I missed out all those times we hosted! I've already bought XY to contribute as normal"

liveforsummer · 14/12/2021 09:17

@notacooldad

These threads baffle me. This year everyone is against it , some year's people think it's not a bad idea and say how expensive it is, how fuel prices are rising and it's a good idea to share the cost and you have the treat of a decent meal that you havent had to make or wash up, why should one couple should have all the costs etc A few years ago I was appalled that idea of paying someone in the family for Christmas dinner but MN persuaded me it wasnt a bad idea. Now everyone hates the idea!!! 🤷‍♀️ 🤣
Often it just depends on the response of the first couple of posters 😆