Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not make DD rewrite her cards for her teachers?

115 replies

ChristmasCardDyslexia · 13/12/2021 17:42

DD is 7, year 3.

She is quite badly dyslexic and struggles with reading and writing.

She’s tried really hard to write her Christmas Cards this year (last year I wrote them and she signed then she wanted to do them all this year). The last two she did are for the Deputy Head/Senco and her class teacher.

Her writing is wobbly, bigger and smaller in some parts but she worked so hard on them and is really excited to give them out tomorrow.

ExH thinks I should make her re-write the teachers cards “neater” because it shows I don’t care or watch her writing (I did, I helped her spell names and words). I think they won’t care and will see how much effort she’s put in. When she finished she looked exhausted but was so proud of herself – we’ve been writing them in batches of 3-4 cards for over a week.

So AIBU? Or do I need to make her rewrite them?

OP posts:
honeylulu · 13/12/2021 19:21

Oh no definitely no rewriting. Your ex sounds like my father who used to make us start again with our thank you letters if there was a single spelling mistake or crossing out. He also used to dictate what we had to write; natural childlike sentences were wrong apparently. Sometimes I'd be in tears wishing I could give the present back rather than sit through this long torturous process. Aarrrgghh!

Commend her enthusiasm and hard work!

KatherineofGaunt · 13/12/2021 19:18

Never re-do. A child's normal handwriting and spelling tells a teacher that the child did it for themselves - that's worth its weight in gold on the teacher satisfaction and happiness chart!! I'm sure her teachers will treasure them.

Kanaloa · 13/12/2021 19:13

Absolutely you shouldn’t get her to rewrite them. I love getting cards from kids with their wobbly childish writing in it, even the spelling mistakes are lovely because they remind you that it’s the child’s own work/effort. As opposed to a parent writing it all/coaching the child. Her teachers will be made up with the effort and thoughtfulness she’s out in.

crystal1717 · 13/12/2021 19:12

Please dont make her rewrite them. Enthusiasm is worth its weight in gold.

MadeOfStarStuff · 13/12/2021 19:08

Your ex is a dick. Sadly you’re going to have to get used to standing up for your daughter to her other parent.

Don’t undermine your daughter’s hard work and effort by telling her it’s not good enough. Her teachers will appreciate how much effort she would’ve put into writing them.

Downton57 · 13/12/2021 19:06

I thought your wee girl must have written something rude in the cards! Of course she shouldn't rewrite them. Tell your ex to bog off. I still treasure the cards and messages written by the children in my class. The wonky spelling and handwriting just make them more adorable.

flashy44 · 13/12/2021 19:01

@ChristmasCardDyslexia

DD is 7, year 3.

She is quite badly dyslexic and struggles with reading and writing.

She’s tried really hard to write her Christmas Cards this year (last year I wrote them and she signed then she wanted to do them all this year). The last two she did are for the Deputy Head/Senco and her class teacher.

Her writing is wobbly, bigger and smaller in some parts but she worked so hard on them and is really excited to give them out tomorrow.

ExH thinks I should make her re-write the teachers cards “neater” because it shows I don’t care or watch her writing (I did, I helped her spell names and words). I think they won’t care and will see how much effort she’s put in. When she finished she looked exhausted but was so proud of herself – we’ve been writing them in batches of 3-4 cards for over a week.

So AIBU? Or do I need to make her rewrite them?

No please do not,it will knock her confidence massively ,praise her and tell her she did really well writing the cards.The teachers will not be scrutinising the writing of a 7 year old.My gcs xmas cards from his class all have simillar writing just like his,its all up down, big ,small letters.
Double3xposure · 13/12/2021 18:59

@ChristmasCardDyslexia

I showed her father in a "look how hard she's tried" kind of way expecting him to say "Oh thats great well done" but he just told me to get her to rewrite them.

Her teacher is fantastic always has something positive to say about DD and she also really likes the DHT/Senco who works with her a lot and always tells me how "funny and lovely" DD is.

But I was a bit worried they'd both think I didn't appreciate them enough to write the cards myself and get DD to sign them. She was so keen though "When do I get to write the cards for Mrs Jones and Mrs Smith mum?" sort of thing

So now you’ve learned not to show him things. Because he doesn’t have the same priorities as you.

Listen to the teachers here and send the cards just as they are. And tell your Dd what a great job she did and how proud you are.

CarButtonCloth · 13/12/2021 18:58

No she definitely shouldn't rewrite them. What a horrible message that would send that her absolute best efforts aren't good enough. Ex sounds awful.

BurningTheClocks · 13/12/2021 18:55

I’m a teacher, and I still have 7 year old David’s card that says

Fank you for teaching me spelling and uvr fings

He’s 38 now, but that card meant a lot to me.

ChristmasCardDyslexia · 13/12/2021 18:51

I showed her father in a "look how hard she's tried" kind of way expecting him to say "Oh thats great well done" but he just told me to get her to rewrite them.

Her teacher is fantastic always has something positive to say about DD and she also really likes the DHT/Senco who works with her a lot and always tells me how "funny and lovely" DD is.

But I was a bit worried they'd both think I didn't appreciate them enough to write the cards myself and get DD to sign them. She was so keen though "When do I get to write the cards for Mrs Jones and Mrs Smith mum?" sort of thing

OP posts:
Newduvet · 13/12/2021 18:46

She did her best and she is proud and that is all that matters.

Your ex is a gimp.

viques · 13/12/2021 18:42

@HattieBlue

My 6yr old has written her cards and the teachers names are phonetically (SP?) spelt. I have just said well done and sent them in. The teachers will much prefer that to someone standing over a kid making them write something in a "perfect" way. They know how hard writing is for your DD so these will be extra special!

At least he is proving why you should be glad he is an Ex!!

This reminds me of the pile of mysteriously addressed cards we used to have on the staffroom table that we would try to identify and get to the right class/ child. One really puzzled us all for days until a teacher pounced on it and claimed it as her own.

In wonky lowercase “mismif” aka Miss Smith.

Theunamedcat · 13/12/2021 18:41

My son can't really write so I bought him a stamper with his name on it and he stamped his cards with massive enthusiasm Grin

You do what's right for you

covilha · 13/12/2021 18:37

So your ex wants her to rewrite the cards but wants you to be the bad guy. Does he normally get you to impose the sanctions he thinks up? Would he do it for you? As a dyslexic I still recall my father ripping up my homework so I had to repeat it. And I was well aware I was having to waste my time to satisfy someone else’s ego. Don’t be that parent OP x

Double3xposure · 13/12/2021 18:37

Who’s showed the cards to the father and ask for his opinion ?

Prescottdanni123 · 13/12/2021 18:36

I'm a teacher. I would be very appreciative of the effort and thought that she has put in. I would not think that she hadn't tried or that you didn't care.

Chely · 13/12/2021 18:35

The teachers will appreciate her efforts.
Tell the ex to sod off

XmasElf10 · 13/12/2021 18:32

Aaarggghh don’t listen to him. She tried hard at a thankless task.

QueenofLouisiana · 13/12/2021 18:31

If she’s done her best, her teachers will recognise this and be thrilled. I’d rather have one handwritten by any one of my class than gave one written by their parents.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 13/12/2021 18:30

Absolutely tell him to do one and while he is there do some research on dyslexia.

unhappyteacher · 13/12/2021 18:29

@ChristmasCardDyslexia I really should change my name as I've left the school that was making me so unhappy Smile

I think it's lovely that despite your daughters challenges with writing, she wanted to persevere and do her cards herself, he should be proud of her for that alone. In my experience though, a lot of people don't see dyslexia as a "real" learning need and it's nothing a dictionary won't sort out Hmm

HyacynthBucket · 13/12/2021 18:27

Glad he's your X, OP. How unkind of him.

2catsandhappy · 13/12/2021 18:27

She is a star!
You sound like a lovely, caring and thoughtful mum.

Your ex is a knob.

BingBongToTheMoon · 13/12/2021 18:23

How does he know what they look like?
If she wrote them with him, it would’ve been his responsibility to correct her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread