Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not make DD rewrite her cards for her teachers?

115 replies

ChristmasCardDyslexia · 13/12/2021 17:42

DD is 7, year 3.

She is quite badly dyslexic and struggles with reading and writing.

She’s tried really hard to write her Christmas Cards this year (last year I wrote them and she signed then she wanted to do them all this year). The last two she did are for the Deputy Head/Senco and her class teacher.

Her writing is wobbly, bigger and smaller in some parts but she worked so hard on them and is really excited to give them out tomorrow.

ExH thinks I should make her re-write the teachers cards “neater” because it shows I don’t care or watch her writing (I did, I helped her spell names and words). I think they won’t care and will see how much effort she’s put in. When she finished she looked exhausted but was so proud of herself – we’ve been writing them in batches of 3-4 cards for over a week.

So AIBU? Or do I need to make her rewrite them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 16/12/2021 16:38

Ah how lovely! Well done to her, and to you for being such a brilliant support to her.🌷

ChristmasCardDyslexia · 16/12/2021 16:27

So she's come out of school with another certificate today "Most improved child of the term" she was crying with happiness, her teacher said she couldn;t not vote for her Smile

OP posts:
Double3xposure · 15/12/2021 18:39

Wonderful update OP.

And congratulation to Dd on her Ht award. 🏆

Rexthesnail · 15/12/2021 18:11

The teachers teach her! They know her handwriting. Please don't make her write them again, poor kid will feel rubbish about herself

hangrylady · 15/12/2021 17:53

Tell him to fuck off. Prick.

Greenandcabbagelooking · 15/12/2021 17:45

I'd much prefer a card written by a child, complete with spelling mistakes, and in their authentic handwriting, then a card written out perfectly by a parent who doesn't think their child's writing in good enough.

I've still got a card from my first year in education where the last bit of my name has been rendered as "Bum".

HeadPain · 15/12/2021 17:40

Your DD sounds wonderful

Gretaburley · 15/12/2021 16:39

@ChristmasCardDyslexia fantastic update OP.

ChristmasCardDyslexia · 15/12/2021 16:32

So in typical DD fashion she stands up when she hears her name and walks to the front to get her certificate, then there was one more song with all the kids sat on a bench at the front of the assembly, as the songs playing DD randomly starts dancing.

Could see the headteacher smiling and giggling at her, was told afterwards by the teacher it's typical of DD, she just does completely random but appropriate things.

OP posts:
Marmelace · 14/12/2021 17:29

So your ex has no problem with humiliating her then, what a disgusting prick. All three of my sons are dyslexic and I'd never have done that to any of them. I used to help mine by writing most of the card and getting them to sign their names, it encouraged them and made it a happy thing.

HeadPain · 14/12/2021 17:03

@ChristmasCardDyslexia

DD gave her card to the DHT as we walked in, DHT gushed at it told DD she'd done really well with it and it was going to go into her office and sit on top of her filing cabinet (she shares an office with the head) for the whole school to see when they go in.

DD was thrilled.

Dropped her at the classroom and as I was about to walk passed the HT she called me over and invited me to the Christmas Assembly tomorrow (all outside) as DDs been given a Headteachers Award for her efforts this term.

I can't believe it, she's never in 3.5 years had a Headteachers Award, she's going to be so happy. And I might cry a lot a little too

Brilliant! Actually brought a tear to my eye! Well done her. And you.

I'm sad that her dad is the way he is. Hope she isn't affected by him

HeadPain · 14/12/2021 16:55

You absolutely SHOULD NOT get her to rewrite them and I hope she hasn't heard this negativity about them. She has done very well and should be very proud of herself. That's a big job for her. Well done to her and Merry Christmas!

CarButtonCloth · 14/12/2021 15:14

Congratulations to your DD on getting Head teacher's award OP, that is really lovely.

AndARiverBeneathYourFeet · 14/12/2021 12:34

Oh, and I couldn't even write on the straight lines in exercise books when I was 9 - doesn't mean anything! My handwriting is still absolute crap, and it doesn't matter as everything at work/higher ed is typed anyway. Handwriting doesn't reflect the amount of care put in - some of us are just awful handwriters.

Your daughter should be really proud and her teachers will be too.

AndARiverBeneathYourFeet · 14/12/2021 12:32

Your ex is a TWAT. Well done to your girl for her hard work.

NotTheOriginalFeargalSharkey · 14/12/2021 11:47

No. She has tried and is pleased with her work.
My dd is a year ahead and still has awful writing. I have had a few conversations with school. Please drop the cursive. Let her write normal printed letters. At least we have a chance of reading print!

firstimemamma · 14/12/2021 11:21

I used to be a teacher and trust me being made to re-write the cards is the kind of thing that can really stick with a child for the rest of their life. Please ignore your awful ex and be proud your child had a go. No-one will care about the handwriting quality anyway.

Nevertime · 14/12/2021 11:11

Of course you don't re do them. Well done you and DD

I used to get DS to do a few and then do the rest with my left hand

ChargingBuck · 14/12/2021 11:10

he claims there's nothing wrong with her reading or writing and she can read and write fine with him, I and the DHT have asked for video evidence but it's never forthcoming

Grin Grin Grin Grin Grin

Yup. Competitive undermining arsehole.
So pleased to read your update about the Award OP.
That wouldn't have been on the radar if this had been left up to ExH. He'd like to pretend 1) there isn't a problem 2) if there is, only I know how to solve it.

I bet your headteacher thinks he's a pompous, bullshitting ass.

ChargingBuck · 14/12/2021 11:06

ExH thinks I should make her re-write the teachers cards “neater”

& how much writing practice does ExH do with his own child?
What services has he engaged with, to learn how to help DD?
Has he even bought a book, to teach him how to best help?
Had a consultation with the school, paid to see a private specialist?
AMAZING! - he's done bugger all except criticise from the sidelines, has he OP?

Who the fuck is he to tell you how to parent, & to undermine his own child by making her do her cards again?

Is he usually this negative, nitpicky, & unsupportive?

The teachers will be pleased & proud of DD's efforts. They won't be looking to find something 'wrong', & by extension have a not-very-subtle dig at your parenting ...

Stop telling ExH about stuff like this.
It sounds like you are handing him ammo & asking to get fired on. You don't need his approval, you don't need his permission, & I'm a little concerned that you needed to come here & ask if it's ok to ignore his twittery ...
But very pleased you did!

I hope this is the beginning of you feeling more confident in your own decisions. You've done a supportive, sensitive & creative job with DD & her cards. Take pride in that & enjoy it for what it is - & never ask your ExH for approval again.
And I hope his negativity isn't used against DD. It would be cruel & counter-productive to make her do her cards again. What an arse he is - he has a dyslexic child & appears not to have bothered to learn a single thing about how to encourage & support her with it.

Buy yourself an early Christmas present OP,
www.amazon.co.uk/Woman-Your-Own-Right-Assertiveness/dp/0704334208?tag=mumsnetforu03-21
& well done on not playing ExH's game. He is looking to undermine you, & doesn't care that his DD's feelings & confidence get dented in the process.
What made you feel that his opinion carried any weight at all - let alone more than yours? You are clearly caring & committed to DD - all that matters is that YOU (& she) know that. Flowers

ChristmasCardDyslexia · 14/12/2021 10:54

@ChampagneLassie she really is amazing, she tries so hard at school and really doesn’t always enjoy it due to her struggles. I’m so proud of how hard she tries with it though.

OP posts:
ChampagneLassie · 14/12/2021 10:47

@ChristmasCardDyslexia

DD gave her card to the DHT as we walked in, DHT gushed at it told DD she'd done really well with it and it was going to go into her office and sit on top of her filing cabinet (she shares an office with the head) for the whole school to see when they go in.

DD was thrilled.

Dropped her at the classroom and as I was about to walk passed the HT she called me over and invited me to the Christmas Assembly tomorrow (all outside) as DDs been given a Headteachers Award for her efforts this term.

I can't believe it, she's never in 3.5 years had a Headteachers Award, she's going to be so happy. And I might cry a lot a little too

This actually made me cry too! Even before reading the teachers' responses I was thinking any half-decent teacher will know how much effort this took and appreciate it. Shame on her father. He really needs to learn more about dyslexia. I'm dyslexic and I couldn't read or write till I was 10 (but undiagnosed until University!)... I was considered a bit dim through-out school. My dad thought University was a too ambitious. I've got a degree and 2 masters - one from Cambridge. I excelled at a highly numerate profession and been very successful when I play to my strengths. I've come to think of dyslexia as more of a superpower than a handicap. Dyslexic's think differently - and the world needs diversity and creative thinking. Encourage your ex to look at this www.madebydyslexia.org/ he needs to appreciate the amazing daughter he has
Orangebonbon · 14/12/2021 10:34

ChristmasCardDyslexia Agree with everyone else, your ex is an arse, but how does he know that your daughter has written out the cards and her writing is not the best.

littleowls83 · 14/12/2021 10:30

Eldest DS is dyspraxic and dyslexic and consequently hates writing and hasn't sent Christmas cards in years. I would only ask him to rewrite something if it is completely illegible. He physically can't write 'neatly' so thats not an option.

DS also self harmed before getting his dyspraxia diagnosis after being told for years at school he was lazy etc. If you know she has made a good effort, please don't make her write it again, that is a very bad path to go down.

Newrunner29 · 14/12/2021 09:54

Pleasr dont make her rewrite i am dyslexic and as a kid my dad did a few things that just made it worse like he writing my pen friend letters because i wasnt good enough and making me read a dictionary because they thought it would help, it just made me and still effects my confidence in writing.