Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the HSBC homeless banking scheme is dangerous?

93 replies

OneRuleForThem · 13/12/2021 16:40

I have just seen an advert for this. obviously I don’t think it’s a bad idea for homeless people. But do you also think that for everyone else overall this is a poorly thought out idea and will most likely attract nefarious types, who will take advantage of not needing to provide an address to store cash (for example - something like drug dealing)??

OP posts:
Flowers500 · 13/12/2021 18:41

Homeless people can’t access banks so they can’t access benefits, money from work they do, support from family. They can’t transfer money to get somewhere to stay. They sticks them in a cycle of poverty that’s virtually impossible to escape, largely because banks are too lazy to put in place the more long lengthy processes needed to confirm their identities. In this case they’re literally only allowing homeless people referred to charities to access these. It is perfectly possible to do the necessary identity checks and ensure they have somewhere where correspondence can be sent, it just requires more work from the bank. Places like Pockit have been doing this, it’s one of the major things homeless charities have asked banks to look into.

If you have a problem with that then you should seriously take a look in the mirror.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/12/2021 18:40

....and those are just the risks coming from outside forces.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/12/2021 18:37

I thought the risks would not come from genuine homeless people, but criminal types who would take advantage of being able to not have an address

As banks go, these kinds of amounts are extremely low on the risk scale to them.

Personally, if a multi-billion international bank and or HMRC run a minuscule financial risk in order that homeless people who have virtually nothing can be helped to improve their dire circumstances a little bit, I'm with the homeless every time.

They run all kind of risks every minute they're out on the street anyway. Not just the risk of losing 0.000000000000001% of their money, but the risk of theft (yes, some people really are that low), assault, rape, murder.

Flowers500 · 13/12/2021 18:36

What the actual fuck. I work in public policy BTW, if you’re going to comment on articles you should at least actually read them. I’m all for having an opinion, but how about making it an informed one???

NeedsCharging · 13/12/2021 18:36

I just feel like people are nitpicking now. It’s quite clear what I mean?? Iknoweveryone has a birth certificate, but I didn’t expect it to be as easy for a homeless person to produce ID as proof of who they are compared to a non homeless person

Not nitpicking at all just trying to understand your ignorance regarding homeless people.

Those accessing the HSBC scheme will do so through a trusted partner/prescriber who will already be supporting the person to access their ID.
I ordered a new BC for my 19 yo son this year on line it was less than £20 and all I needed to know were the details of his birth. Its not impossible to access your ID.

CheesyFootballsAreEvil · 13/12/2021 18:35

There are so many regulations about banking they will have thought of their anti crime procedures when designing the product. There might be enhanced flagging or something so say they see large amounts of money going in it might freeze the account? Who knows. I'm confident they have thought it through though.

Sinner10 · 13/12/2021 18:35

@TheSpottedZebra

Applicants have to be referred by one of a select few partners - eg homelessness charities. All communications are funnelled through that charity's local address.

So probably not that appealing to the local dealer!

Exactly this, not as easy as just walking in.
ComtesseDeSpair · 13/12/2021 18:34

They’ve been piloting it for over two years, so I’m sure they’ve foreseen and ironed out many of the potential issues. Though I’m also a little confused as about a decade ago I worked on the Barclays pilot of the same basic bank account for people with no fixed address product, so I’m unsure why what HSBC is doing is being held up as so novel.

OneRuleForThem · 13/12/2021 18:32

@NeedsCharging
So you assume they are homeless from birth then?

I just feel like people are nitpicking now. It’s quite clear what I mean?? I know everyone has a birth certificate, but I didn’t expect it to be as easy for a homeless person to produce ID as proof of who they are compared to a non homeless person. That was in response to someone that said banks would run ID checks to confirm someone was homeless and I asked how was a homeless person meant to do that if they don’t have ID?

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 13/12/2021 18:30

HSBC is my bank and they are genuinely shit. I assume they are doing this to garner positive publicity while they continue to close branches and provide ever worse customer service.

I suppose when they close their last physical branch they will in a sense be homeless, so possibly there is some congruence to this.

MintJulia · 13/12/2021 18:29

YABU. Huge amounts of work has gone in to the security checks and requirements behind the account.

NeedsCharging · 13/12/2021 18:28

I just didn’t think that someone that was homeless would have a form of ID

So you assume they are homeless from birth then?

OneRuleForThem · 13/12/2021 18:28

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry
Why have you put doesn’t have in quotations? Are you suggesting homeless people are pretending not to have an address?

No, I am saying (and have repeatedly said) I am talking about people signing up to this scheme saying they have no fixed address, not people who don’t actually have a fixed address. I put it in quote marks to differentiate from people who AREN’T pretending.

Also do you think homeless people don’t have birth certificates or passports?

I know they “have/had” them but no, I didn’t think most homeless people have their birth certificates or passports to hand, if asked for them for proof.

OP posts:
user14943608381 · 13/12/2021 18:26

So @OneRuleForThem there are 2 parts to Id check, one is a form of ID ( usually passport or driving license but others are accepted too) and the other address verification (utility bill or whatever).

There are other forms of enhanced due diligence too whereby the person is basically throughly googled, crime records, the banks also share information on known fraudsters and criminals so they’re notified if so and so applies for a bank account or loan etc even if it’s with another bank.

Banks in their nature are incredibly risk adverse, so the risks to this are minimal.

ChangeChingyChange · 13/12/2021 18:25

@Bobsyer

It’s possible but HSBC will have had this thought and done lots of risk assessment. There will be lots of checks and balances in place that the general public will never know about.
This. HSBC have been dealt with hugely before for money laundering issues, they won't let this be another downfall for them!
OneRuleForThem · 13/12/2021 18:25

@Clymene

OP, what do you think the risks are for banks in allowing homeless people to open bank accounts?
I thought the risks would not come from genuine homeless people, but criminal types who would take advantage of being able to not have an address
OP posts:
MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 13/12/2021 18:24

How could banks do in person ID checks on a person that “doesn’t have” a home address?

Why have you put doesn’t have in quotations? Are you suggesting homeless people are pretending not to have an address?

Also do you think homeless people don’t have birth certificates or passports?

OneRuleForThem · 13/12/2021 18:23

@NeedsCharging
What is your problem with homeless people and this desire you seem to have for them to remain homeless?

I did not say anything remotely close to that AT ALL.
I just didn’t think that someone that was homeless would have a form of ID

OP posts:
Clymene · 13/12/2021 18:22

OP, what do you think the risks are for banks in allowing homeless people to open bank accounts?

NeedsCharging · 13/12/2021 18:21

How could banks do in person ID checks on a person that “doesn’t have” a home address

So you think homeless people have lived in the streets since birth?
Do you think all homeless people never worked or lived in a house or have an NI number?
The homeless people who are eligible to claim benefits will be identified in various ways which is why they need a bank account to have their benefits paid in to.
What is your problem with homeless people and this desire you seem to have for them to remain homeless?

Funnylittlefloozie · 13/12/2021 18:21

So can you explain a bit more about why you think its a bad idea that homeless people are helped to reintegrate into society?

Don't bother worrying about the drug dealers. Do you really think the dealers sit around on suitcases stuffed with tenners because they can't access banks now? And don't worry about calling me naive either - I work with criminals every day, including organised crime figures and fraudsters. I just want to know why you think providing basic banking facilities to the homeless is a bad idea.

Clymene · 13/12/2021 18:20

You're right. Homeless people should never be able to access housing. Hmm

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/12/2021 18:18

How do you propose homeless people should be helped to integrate back into society?

Nobody is born 'a homeless person' - they're somebody's son or daughter whose life has gone very badly, for one reason or another.

Do you think they should just be left there in the shop doorway, to lead a life as difficult as possible, until they die and are out of the way of the nice 'normal' people? Rather than risk the possibility that a few tenners a week going their way might be the proceeds of fraud or crime?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 13/12/2021 18:14

Which bit do you think is unfair - that homeless people should be treated like humans or that banks can cause huge damage to society?

OneRuleForThem · 13/12/2021 18:12

@Namechangetimes100

No, it’s a fantastic idea! Props to hsbc, really could change lives and help people break out of poverty.

Those customers applying for the accounts will go through enhanced due diligence checks and the activity will be monitored. They’ll most likely be referred to branch for in person id checks. Banks do monitor for criminal activity you know. The accounts will also have no lending facilities so they aren’t a credit risk to the bank.

How could banks do in person ID checks on a person that “doesn’t have” a home address?
OP posts: