Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Criminalising 12 and 13 year old.

85 replies

ItsAllAboutTheLighting · 13/12/2021 14:08

A 12 abs 13 year old jumped my 10 year old son, beat him to the ground, punched him in the ribs, the head repeatedly, kicked him in the back.

He was hurt and traumatised.

I've called the police and they are investigating. Slowly.

When I spoke to police about it 3 weeks ago, he said there were a few options and whilst I could press charges and the kids end up with a criminal record, they discourage it due to not wanting to criminalise children.

There is another option where the kids join this kind of scheme which lasts a few weeks, not really sure what it entails but they also have to write and apology to my son.

Those children know I have reported it to the police.

I was in favour of the scheme, but now want to press charges.

The reasons are this

2 kids kicked the hell out of my 10 year old.

When they had finished a girl who was with them said to one of them "Chris, you need to stop beating people up"
So he does it a lot apparently Hmm

And lastly, this week when my son was out for the first time since, he bumped into one of them and he told my son "he wants to slap the bitch" the bitch being me.

To answer some questions which I know will be asked
We live next door to a green and park. This is where the incident happened.
My 10 year old went out again because I can't keep him hostage.
He's allowed in close proximity of our home and I know where he is all the time (find my iPhone).

WIBU to criminalise these children.

Right now I'm pissed off and possibly not thinking rationally so wanted some views that weren't emotionally charged.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 13/12/2021 16:08

@MrsGarethSouthgate

However, if the offenders don’t admit it, and there is sufficient evidence to show them being responsible then the only option is to charge them to court. Solicitors will usually try to advise their clients to admit their part at an early stage if possible, knowing that intervention work is available as an alternative to court.
Am I right in thinking that even once the police have charged them, the CPS could still decide not to prosecute, @MrsGarethSouthgate?
ItsAllAboutTheLighting · 13/12/2021 16:03

Thanks @MrsGarethSouthgate that was really helpful, as you can probably tell, I didn't know any of that!

With regards to their home lives, this is where my struggle was.
I work with families in my career who have chaotic home lives, where DV takes place, housing issues and more.
I absolutely understand that this might be an issue.

One thing that stood out to me though is that the older one of them is incredibly short for his age, he's very very gobby and walks in a kind of weird swagger.
I wonder if he's been bullied for his height and he's trying to make himself bigger/better somehow.

Either way, he's 13, my son is 10 and there were two of them. My empathy ends about there.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 13/12/2021 16:00

If the resolution meeting is part of a restorative justice scheme, these can be quite effective at reducing reoffending.

I'd want to know a bit more about it before deciding, I think.

Oblomov21 · 13/12/2021 15:55

Press charges. At least Your'll know you did all you could.

Blossom64265 · 13/12/2021 15:54

You need to take the strongest options available through the legal system. If the parents were taking this seriously, I might have a different opinion, but clearly they do not.

How do I know they don’t take it seriously, because the perpetrators are outside together after the incident. Any child involved in an assault should lose the privilege to be out unsupervised for a very long time. If it were my 13yo I would start walking him to the school door and picking him up like he was in reception.

Vates · 13/12/2021 15:54

Also what happens to the children that are bullied/beaten up by other kids that also have an abusive home life? Because that was me. I was severely bullied in school and my home life was so bad that I just stopped going home.

THIS! It is not just about them and their precious home life. They can wreck havoc and suffer no consequences for fucking years, I don't give a shit about personal ones or what they are/were going through. They need to know that their behaviour is wrong and suffer actual consequences. I found it disturbing that my bully even had children.

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 13/12/2021 15:49

Also what happens to the children that are bullied/beaten up by other kids that also have an abusive home life? Because that was me. I was severely bullied in school and my home life was so bad that I just stopped going home.

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/12/2021 15:49

I had a violent parent and grew up in an abusive environment. My dad punched me in the face, trashed my house, threw furniture at my head. I had to lock myself in my bathroom and tried to climb out the window at 7 years old because I thought he was going to kill me. I have never been violent or aggressive towards anyone. I still believe its a choice.

I'm so sorry this happened to you. It's dreadful. And one of the many things I think is that we need to support and celebrate the circuit breakers in families. Those people who stop the abuse falling down families generation after generation.

MrsGarethSouthgate · 13/12/2021 15:48

However, if the offenders don’t admit it, and there is sufficient evidence to show them being responsible then the only option is to charge them to court. Solicitors will usually try to advise their clients to admit their part at an early stage if possible, knowing that intervention work is available as an alternative to court.

MrsGarethSouthgate · 13/12/2021 15:45

Hi OP. I am a police officer, and evidence review officer, so make charging decisions.

In cases like these, yes there are a few options, but these are for the police to determine the most appropriate.

It sounds like you and your son have ruled out Community Resolution, which would be for the offender to admit guilt and apologise. That’s fine, that’s your son’s prerogative.

What happens next depends on whether the offenders admit it in interview. If they do, and providing that they are not recorded for similar already, they would be eligible for a caution. This is not your decision, and although you may be asked for your views ultimately police decide whether this is the appropriate outcome.

However, it may not reach this stage because the first step after they admit guilt would be to refer them to the Youth Offending Scheme. They will meet with them and check their suitability for intervention work, and if approved they will have to attend a series of appointments in which they work on specific topics like peer-pressure, substance-misuse etc. (depending on the nature of the offending). If they engage well, at the end of the scheme there may be no further action or they may indeed be issued with that caution.

If the offender doesn’t engage, or is not suitable due to previous, proven offending (not just hearsay) then they will be charged or summonsed to appear in court - again this is a police decision not CPS unless there were serious injuries.

Charges to court for juveniles are only for the more serious cases, or when all other previous intervention work has tried and failed already - it’s obviously preferable to try to turn the child around and get them off the offending pathway if at all possible.

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/12/2021 15:45

@DontKnowWhatToThink7

And that isn't to say that we should condone it, just understand that harsh punishments are really unlikely to work.

Genuine question, what should be done then? If there's never any kind of punishment then surely people will keep repeating their actions because they can get away with it.

If I had my way? Parenting classes for the parents with sanctions for them if they didn't do them, in-home assessments by qualified SWs with suggestions for change, early intervention in households with issues, massive investment in DV, addiction and MH services to stop parents failing in the first place. Or women having to stay with a violent man because of housing. A proper culture change around parenting. Jobs which actually pay decently so parents can parent rather than relying on children to parent themselves. Work on making the environment we live in interesting, beautiful and child-friendly so children aren't bored and angry. A more egalitarian society because a lot of social unrest comes from perceived unfairness. Mentoring for boys at risk.

And that's just a start. In this specific case, honestly it may be too late and the kid just has to go through it, making everyone around him unhappy for years until he's either entrenched or wants to change. Possibly having his own children and the cycle continues.

Vates · 13/12/2021 15:43

Yes. They attack people and are of the age of criminal responsibility. Why is anybody objecting to this?! They are just thinking about their next targets and how to evade being caught.

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 13/12/2021 15:43

I'm not sure that is true. I think they do it because they learnt that behaviour from somewhere. They either experience or see a lot of violence and either think that is normal or they lash out at others because they are being abused one way or another at home. And/or they have not been taught proper boundaries/behaviour. Children are a product of their upbringing. They don't come out being angry and violent.

I had a violent parent and grew up in an abusive environment. My dad punched me in the face, trashed my house, threw furniture at my head. I had to lock myself in my bathroom and tried to climb out the window at 7 years old because I thought he was going to kill me. I have never been violent or aggressive towards anyone. I still believe its a choice.

RavingAnnie · 13/12/2021 15:33

@DontKnowWhatToThink7

I feel like the majority of kids who do things like this, go around beating people up, acting aggressive etc do it because they know that they can get away with it.

YANBU

I'm not sure that is true. I think they do it because they learnt that behaviour from somewhere. They either experience or see a lot of violence and either think that is normal or they lash out at others because they are being abused one way or another at home. And/or they have not been taught proper boundaries/behaviour. Children are a product of their upbringing. They don't come out being angry and violent.
Evergreenblue · 13/12/2021 15:31

OP recently I have found its always the same with the police and I have now grown to distrust them intently they are useless.

After I had serious trouble with some one coming to my home and threaten me with violence, the police came 19hrs after I called petrified for my safety. I had it all on CCTV and the police were not even interested in taking the footage, the police officers who came ended up arguing with me not to press chages as they said they knew best. In the end I more or less told the police to leave as they were adamant they knew better and said it was better just to have a word with him and give him a warning.

I found out in the end they did pretty much zero kicking it into the long grass and when he came round and threated me again. He just laughed and said the police wont do any thing and he was right.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 13/12/2021 15:28

Id press charges in a heart beat.

RavingAnnie · 13/12/2021 15:28

I think I'd want to know more about what the course involves and also what's being done at home ie social services involvement? What is happening/has happened to these children to make them behave like this.

I would rather there was an attempt at rehabilitation at this age (rather than the court route as once they start on this path I think it's difficult to get them back. Court/prison is unlikely to make them change their ways tbh and may make them worse.

As PPs have said y to though not actually likely to be your decision in the U.K.

Dixiechickonhols · 13/12/2021 15:25

I’d chase police up and report the offender approaching your son and the threat made to slap you.
Make it clear you want it taking further not just an apology.
We had fencing damaged by 2 young teens and I was happy to go down apology route - it was a silly act that had got out of hand. They were spoken to with parent at police station (which made a big impact) wrote me a proper apology letter and paid £40 each to fix. Word got around other kids too so it didn’t happen again. That’s very different to a teen deliberately injuring a young child and then targeting him again.

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 13/12/2021 15:23

And that isn't to say that we should condone it, just understand that harsh punishments are really unlikely to work.

Genuine question, what should be done then? If there's never any kind of punishment then surely people will keep repeating their actions because they can get away with it.

MrsTerryPratchett · 13/12/2021 15:12

@DontKnowWhatToThink7

The issue for me is that violence doesn't come from nowhere. 'Nice' people who don't have violence in their lives think that harsh punishment is a shock. The likelihood is that this child lives with harsh all day every day.

It's still a choice. I grew up with a violent parent in a very unhappy home and I have never been aggressive or violent towards anyone.

There's a lot of research around this. Some children don't, some turn it inwards and some act out. There are genetic and societal reasons why, brain plasticity and other biological and psychological things we don't choose. And, of course, there is the fact that society allows and condones a higher amount of violence from boys than girls. It also depends what age children are, what else is in their lives as a mitigating factor, what other adults they have.

Of course some of it is a choice, but a lot isn't.

And that isn't to say that we should condone it, just understand that harsh punishments are really unlikely to work.

Easterndream · 13/12/2021 15:07

Firstly I'm really sorry to hear what happened to your son. It's really awful and I understand how cross and upset you would be. To be honest I don't know what would be the best thing to do but I have this feeling that to do stuff like that, at that age, to a smaller child means that you've had an up-bringing that reflects it and that a criminal record wouldn't mean anything to them or their families. I just don't think they'd care in the least. The course and letter of apology is not going to be enough but I feel it would "inconvenience " the children and families more than a record even though it probably wouldn't even scratch the surface in reality. At the very least to me it would be consistent with my views of trying to learn from mistakes and be better going forward, however unlikely that may be in this case.

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 13/12/2021 15:04

The issue for me is that violence doesn't come from nowhere. 'Nice' people who don't have violence in their lives think that harsh punishment is a shock. The likelihood is that this child lives with harsh all day every day.

It's still a choice. I grew up with a violent parent in a very unhappy home and I have never been aggressive or violent towards anyone.

RantyAunty · 13/12/2021 15:04

Then chose this for themselves. They're old enough to know right from wrong but they just don't care.

Where are their parents in all this?

You should file charges against them. Too bad the parents can't be charged as well.
Sue the parents if you can.

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 13/12/2021 15:02

I feel like the majority of kids who do things like this, go around beating people up, acting aggressive etc do it because they know that they can get away with it.

YANBU

LaBellina · 13/12/2021 14:59

That’s entirely your interpretation and I’m not responsible for how you take it….your post didn’t have a friendly tone either (I would say rather condescending) so perhaps if it bothers you, you could set up a good example. Won’t go into further discussion from now on to not derail the OP’s thread.