Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not go out of my way to help an ex-work colleague whose actions led me to leave?

161 replies

RoseJam · 13/12/2021 13:54

Five years ago, I had a great job with a great company. I did well, got promoted and put on a flagship project. I was partnered up with a work colleague (different role to me) - who I found challenging as they didn't want to be on the project and was very resistant to change. The work colleague moaned and complained to higher management which led to my managers considering putting me on a performance plan. At the time work colleague realised the impacts of what he had done and told me he was sorry and felt bad as he didn't realise all his moaning could have potentially led to my dismissal. (Previous to this, I had been a top performer in the company and have always got on well with my work colleagues.) I ended up giving my notice shortly after and have gone on to much better things. I still keep in touch with my ex-work colleagues from that company and we have regular social meetups.

Last month the ex-work colleague was made redundant. He has had 18 months pay. He asked me for help getting a job, so I was happy to give general advice and recommend a few agencies and companies in our industry I knew who had vacancies. However, he has now asked me to contact the agents and the company I am currently working at and recommend him and put in a good word for him for doing the role that I currently do.

On one hand, I think it would be nice to help but he did a very different job to me and I don't know how transferable it would be to mine.

On the other hand, I cannot forget that his actions led to a very tough patch in my career. I would not have left otherwise. Although in hindsight, leaving turned out to be great careerwise for me.

AIBU - Yes - give him a recommendation regardless.
YANBU - No - you've done enough already.

OP posts:
Sally872 · 13/12/2021 14:46
  1. you don't have enough knowledge that his skills transfer to your role. So perfectly reasonable not to.

  2. you know he can drive good people to leave so would actually be unfair on your employer to suggest he would be a good fit.

  3. if he does this again it may reflect poorly on you for recommending him.

He obviously isn't sorry otherwise he would know it is inappropriate to ask. I can't believe he has the audacity.

SoyMarina · 13/12/2021 14:45

I can't believe you are still in contact with him!

CharityDingle · 13/12/2021 14:45

At the time work colleague realised the impacts of what he had done and told me he was sorry and felt bad as he didn't realise all his moaning could have potentially led to my dismissal.

I would say he knew exactly what he was doing, and sorry wouldn't cut it with me. I would help him when hell freezes over, but not before then. I would never speak to him again, but I am an unforgiving type.

IntermittentParps · 13/12/2021 14:45

I think he can fuck off.

Etinoxaurus · 13/12/2021 14:44

@Tal45

I think I'd just ignore the request. If he was the reason you felt you had to quit your job I don't know why you'd even still be in contact with him tbh.
This! Why on Earth have you done so much already Confused?
Skeumorph · 13/12/2021 14:44

Wow, are you mad?!

Out of interest, do you honestly think you could recommend him, in good faith? If so, how?

If I were your boss, and you recommended an ex-colleague who had been the reason for you leaving your previous place of work, I'd seriously question your professional judgement.

To recommend someone, you owe it to your present employer to be in no doubt of them being a good colleague. It's not just your own repuation on the line - the fact is that if you recommend them, you're vouching for them, making it so that your employer is more likely to trust them.

I'd be pretty angry if my employee did this - recommend someone they absolutely knew had a history of causing issues.

That's before you even get to your own situation. If I were you at this point, I'd probably be having an off the record conversation with my boss giving them the heads up that this person was looking for a job, was likely to use my name as an 'in' - and that I felt I owed it to them to let them know the history and that I'd feeel very uncomfortable working with them again, and couldn't say that they were a good or trustworthy employee.

As for them. It's so outrageous that he would ask this (Always a HE isn't it!!) - that I'd probably be brutally honest.

'Sorry Mike, I can't do that. Have you forgotten that I actually ended up leaving X company because of the trouble you caused for me on the TwatElectrics project? I'm happy that it's water under the bridge now, but I wouldn't be prepared to work with you again, no.'

CatJumperTwat · 13/12/2021 14:43

who I found challenging as they didn't want to be on the project and was very resistant to change. The work colleague moaned and complained to higher management

How could you put in "a good word" or recommend this man in good conscience? You know he isn't a good worker/teammate. Forget everything else.

godmum56 · 13/12/2021 14:42
  1. no
2 hell no 3 fuck no

I mean why would you?

FoxgloveSummers · 13/12/2021 14:42

i think you have your answer Grin

TBH if he's this much of a shameless prick I might say I'd try to put in a good word for him and then never mention him. Or even do the opposite. It might seem nasty but it's about protecting yourself and others. You're clearly a bit of a sweetheart or you wouldn't be considering thing, how would you feel if he targeted another soft-hearted type?

Agree with PP he's after your job and wants to victimise you again.

DO NOT RECOMMEND HIM fgs.

What I would do is try to find out from ex-colleagues what got him the boot in the end.

fairydust11 · 13/12/2021 14:42

Fuck that. Do not help him. Why are you in contact with him if he was the reason you left your previous company?

SchadenfreudePersonified · 13/12/2021 14:40

@titchy

I'd be tempted to say 'Dave, if I was to comment on your work to Acme plc it would be to say you're a very difficult person to work with who will destroy the mental health of your colleagues. I think perhaps you'd therefore prefer if I didn't comment?' Followed by a smile.
Ooooh!

Nice one!

I would be so tempted to do this if I was in this position.

Nomorepies · 13/12/2021 14:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on the poster's request

frazzledasarock · 13/12/2021 14:40

So basically he’s so lazy he can’t be arsed to do his own job search and wants u to recommend him so your company approaches him directly?

Why are you even still speaking to someone who nearly ruined your career?

Ghost him.

I can imagine any man in your shoes doing a female colleague who’d been the cause of them leaving their job any favours or giving it a thought!

Why invite trouble into your workplace? You’re mad.

Pipsquiggle · 13/12/2021 14:40

He is a CF isn't he!!

So some great suggestions already.

My DH has a policy of never putting forward anyone with a personal recommendation as he doesn't want the fallout from their possible poor performance - people / employers remember this kind of stuff. He will help them, like you have already, but will not go any further.

PrincessNutella · 13/12/2021 14:40

It would be unethical to put a good word in for him. You should only recommend someone you think would be good for a job. Don't cheapen your reputation.

Tomatalillo · 13/12/2021 14:39

YANBU.

Never mind the past if you back him now then your it’s your reputation on the line. If he would be someone you would genuinely gladly pick to join your team then that’s one thing but you should only recommend him if you genuinely think he’s a good employee, not as a favour.

UniversalAunt · 13/12/2021 14:39

Between when you left & now is roughly five years?

Short of signposting him to general resources & making general supportive comments, you cannot introduce or vouch for him with others as you cannot know him that well.

That he has asked you after all this time & what has gone on between you, apology or not, says that he has not got enough people on his side already.

Once bitten, twice shy etc

Interrobanger · 13/12/2021 14:39

I only ever recommend people who I know are shit hot.

He does not sound shit hot.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 13/12/2021 14:37

@Dogshitduty

tbf you have already done a lot more than I would have
This ^

I would have told him to f*ck off when he first asked for a favour.

He's behaved badly towards you once, he'll do it again.

He isn't your responsibility - walk away. Apart from anything if he can't cope with his new role it will reflect badly on you if you have spoken in his favour.

BabyDreamsz · 13/12/2021 14:36

13:54RoseJam
He's a user - Don't help him
He knew what be was doing
Get this rubbish out of your life, don't even engage on any level with him
He'll do the same once he's in your company

BorsetshireBanality · 13/12/2021 14:34

Fuck no - he wants your job!

Tell him that the specific role he’s looking for is already filled!

HollowTalk · 13/12/2021 14:33

I would reply with, "Have you lost your memory?"

fakereview · 13/12/2021 14:30

I'm amazed that you have helped him in any way. He led to you losing your job (I know you left, but not entirely voluntarily).

I'd tell him to bog off.

Coconuttts · 13/12/2021 14:29

How did his complaining almost result in you being performance managed? He complained about you? It must have been some serious shit stirring for that to happen. Run a mile, he's horrible!

PizzaCrust · 13/12/2021 14:28

You've done far too much for him already. He actively tried to sabotage your career, remember.

I wouldn't be talking to him anymore, and honestly, if anyone asked my opinion of him, I'd be telling them the truth. Not that he was a good employee, rather he was a snake.

He made his bed, he can lie in it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread