Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not go out of my way to help an ex-work colleague whose actions led me to leave?

161 replies

RoseJam · 13/12/2021 13:54

Five years ago, I had a great job with a great company. I did well, got promoted and put on a flagship project. I was partnered up with a work colleague (different role to me) - who I found challenging as they didn't want to be on the project and was very resistant to change. The work colleague moaned and complained to higher management which led to my managers considering putting me on a performance plan. At the time work colleague realised the impacts of what he had done and told me he was sorry and felt bad as he didn't realise all his moaning could have potentially led to my dismissal. (Previous to this, I had been a top performer in the company and have always got on well with my work colleagues.) I ended up giving my notice shortly after and have gone on to much better things. I still keep in touch with my ex-work colleagues from that company and we have regular social meetups.

Last month the ex-work colleague was made redundant. He has had 18 months pay. He asked me for help getting a job, so I was happy to give general advice and recommend a few agencies and companies in our industry I knew who had vacancies. However, he has now asked me to contact the agents and the company I am currently working at and recommend him and put in a good word for him for doing the role that I currently do.

On one hand, I think it would be nice to help but he did a very different job to me and I don't know how transferable it would be to mine.

On the other hand, I cannot forget that his actions led to a very tough patch in my career. I would not have left otherwise. Although in hindsight, leaving turned out to be great careerwise for me.

AIBU - Yes - give him a recommendation regardless.
YANBU - No - you've done enough already.

OP posts:
friendlycat · 13/12/2021 15:24

I genuinely don't understand how you think you could recommend somebody who in your opening post you state was resistant to change,
didn't want to work on a project that he was assigned to, moaned and complained.

None of those attributes in my mind are those of somebody that I would highly recommend and I would not want my reputation tainted by recommending somebody possessing those qualities.

It's nothing to do with karma (though I can see it comes into play) it's about how professional this person is and he has already shown himself not to be so in your own experience of working with him. Therefore, it is wholly inappropriate of your to recommend him to anyone.

BobbinThreadbare123 · 13/12/2021 15:21

Oh hell no. I wouldn't have replied in the first place. OP, you are very magnanimous but I would suggest cutting that off for this chap right now.

RantyAunty · 13/12/2021 15:20

Ghost this guy.
He's a bad worker and sabotaged your promotion.
You're known by the company you keep.

museumum · 13/12/2021 15:08

I am very much a 'forgive and forget' or 'benefit of the doubt' person but when you recommend somebody it is YOUR reputation that is on the line. I don't know how you could possibly recommend him in all good conscience.

Lunde · 13/12/2021 15:08

Do not recommend him

You risk his future potentially poor performance being linked to you and the agencies might start questioning your judgement in recommending him

You have done more than enough already given the way he treated you

WildMaryBerriesWithBrandyCream · 13/12/2021 15:07

Favours to him... are they also favours to the company you now work for?

If you help him get work at your place, you become (at least a little) responsible for him and his performance too. Are you sure you think he is good for your new workplace and the people there? You don't sound to be.

snackodactyl · 13/12/2021 15:07

tapeandglue makes an excellent point. It’s not going to look good for you professionally if your work hire him based on your recommendation and he repeats history there. That or sitting there belittling any progress you’ve made because you weren’t like that where you both previously worked.

Okbye · 13/12/2021 15:04

He's a grown man!! Tell him to sort out his own life!

Urrrgh I HATE people like this! 🤬

TakeMe2Insanity · 13/12/2021 15:04

No!

LaBellina · 13/12/2021 15:02

@ShakesFist

definitely not!

i was speaking to someone about forgiveness the other day. It's a very Christian concept isn't it - turn the other cheek, let the person without sin cast the first stone. It often comes packaged with guilt.

ultimately sometimes in life, people do not deserve forgiveness and that is OK. Not forgiving someone does not make you a bad person! You carry on with your life, let him carry on with his. He is the ultimate in cheeky fuckery tbh.

Exactly! And even if she has forgiven him, she doesn’t owe him any favors. I agree with pp that it might even come back to bite her in the arse because he will show his true colors soon enough and they will wonder why on earth the op has recommended him. Then that’s the second time he damaged her reputation. I would keep a far distance from this person.
DPotter · 13/12/2021 15:02

I agree you have gone above and beyond to help an ex colleague who basically shafted you.

Definitely do not recommend - any future poor behaviour on his part will reflect badly on you. In fact if you're asked by anyone in your company about his performance I would say I cannot recommend him.

Fluffymule · 13/12/2021 15:00

@CharityDingle

Sorry Mike, I can't do that. Have you forgotten that I actually ended up leaving X company because of the trouble you caused for me on the TwatElectrics project? I'm happy that it's water under the bridge now, but I wouldn't be prepared to work with you again, no.

100% this, minus the sorry at the beginning.

Yes, no Sorry needed.

No need to be 'nice'. Consider how 'nice' he was to you when your job was on the line because of his behaviour.

You've done more than most people would have done in the circumstances already.

ShakesFist · 13/12/2021 14:58

definitely not!

i was speaking to someone about forgiveness the other day. It's a very Christian concept isn't it - turn the other cheek, let the person without sin cast the first stone. It often comes packaged with guilt.

ultimately sometimes in life, people do not deserve forgiveness and that is OK. Not forgiving someone does not make you a bad person! You carry on with your life, let him carry on with his. He is the ultimate in cheeky fuckery tbh.

Annonymiss123 · 13/12/2021 14:57

@titchy

I'd be tempted to say 'Dave, if I was to comment on your work to Acme plc it would be to say you're a very difficult person to work with who will destroy the mental health of your colleagues. I think perhaps you'd therefore prefer if I didn't comment?' Followed by a smile.
^^ This!

He has a neck like a jockey’s bollocks!

cstaff · 13/12/2021 14:57

In my firm if someone applies for a job and they know that you have worked in the same firm previously as the applicant, HR or one of the managers will approach you directly and ask "what was so and so like in your last job".

I was caught off guard one day and didn't realise that this was to do with a job applicant and they asked me what this girl who I had worked with before was like and without thinking I said something along the lines of "I'm glad I don't work with that b*tch anymore - couldn't be dealing with her BS". HR just looked at me and said well I guess we wont be giving her the job she applied for. I just turned bright red but funnily enough they never employed her.

WaltzingTilda · 13/12/2021 14:55

Don't recommend him and don't help him. Only tell him what he can find out from Google.

WaltzingTilda · 13/12/2021 14:54

No good deed goes unpunished. Tell him to apply and if your employers think he is suitable then they'll recruit him. A bad penny is trying to turn up again, dont help it!

tapeandglue · 13/12/2021 14:54

He's a snake.

Recommend him and you'll be the one who gets blamed when everyone realises his true colours. I only recommend people who I know can do the job, and who I know would fit into the team.

I'm currently leaving a job in similar circumstances to you, and hell would freeze over before I help the snake who has prompted me to run.

LaBellina · 13/12/2021 14:50

Wow OP you’re so kind!
I would have gladly rubbed in his face that I didn’t forget how he ‘unintentionally’ screwed me over and wouldn’t have helped him at all. In fact, I might have told people my story and how unreliable, lazy and a non teamplayer he is….

Fernando072020 · 13/12/2021 14:50

I'm sorry but I don't even understand why you've done what you've already done. He nearly got you fired... And you're now helping him? That sounds mental.

snackodactyl · 13/12/2021 14:48

Ooh, fuck that OP. I get that it would be awkward due to socialising out of work but never forgive, never forget. I had a colleague who operated horrifically and extended an olive branch when they heard I would be moving to greener pastures. I maintained a wall of silence because I knew a similar request to yours would soon follow. That and because I wanted to leave all the crap behind.

Sally872 · 13/12/2021 14:47

In fact if I was comfortable with managers etc I would go as far as to warn employers this muppet is seeking employment in case he does find a role in your current company via agencies.

CharityDingle · 13/12/2021 14:47

Sorry Mike, I can't do that. Have you forgotten that I actually ended up leaving X company because of the trouble you caused for me on the TwatElectrics project? I'm happy that it's water under the bridge now, but I wouldn't be prepared to work with you again, no.

100% this, minus the sorry at the beginning.

Gargellen · 13/12/2021 14:46

@RoseJam

We are only still in contact as I regularly meet in a large group of ex-work colleagues, and he is one of them. We are friendly but I can never forgive or forget what he did. At the time, I was so upset by what happened that I took a huge gamble by leaving without a job to go to - but luckily was not out of work for that long.
But you have already forgiven and forgotten what he did to you by helping him as much as you have. If anything you have validated him by helping him. Seriously, I would never have even answered his emails or whatever it was from him asking you to help him out. He is a rotten toerag and what he is experiencing now is karma.
DraigFach · 13/12/2021 14:46

I'd be quite honest, that you're not willing to make a personal recommendation based on your last professional interactions - but if he really wants you to you're happy to share that experience with any recruiters if approached.

That should make it clear that he's being a cheeky, lazy arse and to stop chancing his arm!

Swipe left for the next trending thread