Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not go out of my way to help an ex-work colleague whose actions led me to leave?

161 replies

RoseJam · 13/12/2021 13:54

Five years ago, I had a great job with a great company. I did well, got promoted and put on a flagship project. I was partnered up with a work colleague (different role to me) - who I found challenging as they didn't want to be on the project and was very resistant to change. The work colleague moaned and complained to higher management which led to my managers considering putting me on a performance plan. At the time work colleague realised the impacts of what he had done and told me he was sorry and felt bad as he didn't realise all his moaning could have potentially led to my dismissal. (Previous to this, I had been a top performer in the company and have always got on well with my work colleagues.) I ended up giving my notice shortly after and have gone on to much better things. I still keep in touch with my ex-work colleagues from that company and we have regular social meetups.

Last month the ex-work colleague was made redundant. He has had 18 months pay. He asked me for help getting a job, so I was happy to give general advice and recommend a few agencies and companies in our industry I knew who had vacancies. However, he has now asked me to contact the agents and the company I am currently working at and recommend him and put in a good word for him for doing the role that I currently do.

On one hand, I think it would be nice to help but he did a very different job to me and I don't know how transferable it would be to mine.

On the other hand, I cannot forget that his actions led to a very tough patch in my career. I would not have left otherwise. Although in hindsight, leaving turned out to be great careerwise for me.

AIBU - Yes - give him a recommendation regardless.
YANBU - No - you've done enough already.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mary46 · 14/12/2021 12:13

No op and knowing your luck you be working with him again! Just let it be. He sounds bit sneaky!

Disfordarkchocolate · 14/12/2021 11:47

Your experience is that they are disruptive when asked to do work they don't want to do.

No way would I recommend anyone like this.

bembridge11 · 14/12/2021 11:12

You have done more than most. And well done for moving on to better things!
They need to act like an adult and sort themselves out!
You arent their mum!

mommybear1 · 14/12/2021 08:08

I know you have made up your mind OP and I think it's the right choice. Similar thing happened to me, I was ultimately forced out and went to another business made a success etc and let bygone go etc around 4 years later a motley bunch who had a hand in my exit contacted me to move to my new firm. Foolishly I thought it would be the right thing to do to bring them over we had been close - bygones be bygones etc - what a mistake. After a few months they tried their old tricks and were unsuccessful but it made for a horrible working atmosphere then one of them got the ear of a much much higher up and I was pushed out of my main account and lost my client. I went to another client who was lovely and still managed to progress well but every day was hell. I got pregnant and left on maternity leave. The old client got in touch and I now work as hoc for them - the bunch have been in touch at various points for advice/new job opportunities- unsurprisingly it's been a hard no from me Grin.

Capricopia · 14/12/2021 08:07

Think about what you’re contemplating here - you know he’s not a good worker, so you would be putting your reputation on the line to lie and pretend he was. That could hugely backfire on you.

This isn’t about holding a grudge; it’s about your honesty and professional reputation. Don’t risk that for someone you have no obligation to.

Beachgirl33 · 14/12/2021 07:58

No way

RantyAunty · 14/12/2021 07:01

He's truly a first class CF.

I'm curious to what he was doing that caused you to be put on a PIP?
Was he going to your boss and higher ups and complaining about how you were running things?

I take it during the past 5 years he didn't get promoted to your position?

Whingasaurus · 14/12/2021 06:28

No, and I'd be honest and say why. Not one of my male friends would even consider doing this they'd laugh, say no and not give it another thought.

RedRum27 · 14/12/2021 06:12

Don’t be taken for a mug by this person, no way would I even be speaking to someone who made me leave my job. Why are you even giving them the time of day?

snackodactyl · 14/12/2021 05:33

OP you really should check out AskAManager who gets letters similar to your situation. If he even made it as a candidate she recommends not hesitating to let your company know that you wouldn’t be happy with him working there due to past events. They’ve known and trusted you for longer. There’s also good tips on how to put some boundaries in when you get requests like this, as you say you get them a lot?

In an ideal world, shutting this request down would give him some food for thought on how to treat people better. In his case I can’t imagine it will though.

kazzakiwi12 · 13/12/2021 23:06

@CharityDingle done! Thanks for that!

NovemberNovemberDarkNights · 13/12/2021 18:41

@RoseJam

Wow - thanks for all the messages!

I am a softie at heart and if ever I can help people I do. But there are times when it has backfired. I don't want to get burned again. I waivered about this as it's been 5 years since it happened, and it ended up leading to some great opportunities for me.

To those asking about personal recommendations and would I have recommended him otherwise - the answer is NO. I really don't ever recommend anyone in my business as I am a consultant now, and our industry is quite small, so a lot depends on word of mouth. I have an excellent reputation right now. Anyone I actually think is worth recommending is always employed anyway, are always inundated with offers, and will be known anyway in the industry.

Read your own post, then ask yourself WHY you even thought about it.
powershowerforanhour · 13/12/2021 18:28

"waivered about this as it's been 5 years since it happened, and it ended up leading to some great opportunities for me."

So basically he gave you a shove, you fell out the window...and happened to land on a bed of rose petals with a pot of gold buried in it. That neither of you knew was there, instead of concrete.

God loves a trier but hates a chancer so it's a hard no. Don't inflict him on your colleagues or yourself. If you're worried about the poor darling getting a job- well, there are plenty of more deserving cases out there and I wouldn't be inclined to help him push past them to get to that job.

ilssagain · 13/12/2021 18:27

They didn't want to be on the project and was very resistant to change. The work colleague moaned and complained to higher management

Why on earth would you recommend someone like that??
It's your reputation at stake if you recommend him and he behaves the same way in his new role.
Also if he were to be successful at applying for a job in your company you might have to work with him again and he could cause the same amount of trouble.

And it's not your problem he's been made redundant and is looking for a job. It's not your problem if he doesn't find one. He will have to take whatever work he can get if he wants to keep money coming in but that's his problem.
Maybe he was made redundant because he was a pain in the arse in his most recent job too.

No, no and no.
You've pointed him in the direction of some vacancies but that needs to be the end of it.

Just say that as you haven't worked with him for 5 years you are not in a position to recommend him as you do not know what his current standard of work/abilities are and wish him luck.

TractorAndHeadphones · 13/12/2021 18:16

Why do you want to help this person inflict damage on some other poor sod?
Part of being good at your job includes being collaborative and he was not.
Honestly you’re a mug you should have just said you don’t know anyone hiring.

Gonnagetgoing · 13/12/2021 17:46

No and no again and no comment. Ten to one he’ll mess up again and may even pull trick he pulled with you with someone else. Let him struggle but be civil.

Gonnagetgoing · 13/12/2021 17:45

Don’t do this and don’t feel guilty. Mostly it’s men I find who have the brass neck to pull this trick. Women sometimes do too though.

He can’t be doing that well if he needs your recommendation/help and so on for a job and in some twisted narcissistic way he may even feel you owe him (despite him causing you to resign) or have a twisted knowledge of how great he is —yet still needs your help—. I also couldn’t rest easy if he messed up again so I’d be civil but wouldn’t help much nor recommend, let him do his own legwork and no doubt he’ll be fine.

TonTonMacoute · 13/12/2021 17:27

YADNBU

Don't even give him a second thought!

Beeinalily · 13/12/2021 17:23

CF to even ask!

RoseJam · 13/12/2021 17:23

@AthelstaneTheUnready - thank you!! You are absolutely right and it is very helpful to think of him this way as spam communications.

I know he has been asking others to help him out too - so I won't stand out if I ignore him. In fact, he messaged me via Linked In a few days ago asking me to call him - but I haven't called him back and neither do I intend to.

Also, I have decided if I am asked about him, I will respond with 'No comment' - my managers will know what that means! As much as I would like to slate him for what he did, I have to remain professional as possible. Interestingly, I did have a conversation with another trusted and respected professional in my industry about him - and he was on the same page as me - so I feel a bit better.

OP posts:
CharityDingle · 13/12/2021 17:14

@kazzakiwi12

If you click on the yanbu, that will change your vote.

Rainartist · 13/12/2021 17:13

No way! Why should you do his legwork?!
I wouldn't be actively seeking out endorsing him to management unless he put you as his referee.

AthelstaneTheUnready · 13/12/2021 17:13

@RoseJam, you seem like a sweetheart who responds to anyone tugging at the heartstrings or asking for help.

Perhaps you're feeling the pressure of the request, thinking his future may be affected by your response?

But you haven't worked with him for 5 years. I can GUARANTEE you that this man is not looking solely to you to help him find a way to pay his bills/keep a roof over his head/etc.

He'll have messaged EVERY likely and unlikely he's met in a general attempt to spread the word he wants a new job. He is NOT relying on you, and you alone, to assist him. There will be many others receiving similar fishing messages.

You won't stand out if you politely decline, you may not even register. Think of it as spam communications to see who bites, and don't give it another thought.

Pinksloth · 13/12/2021 17:13

@PrincessNutella

It would be unethical to put a good word in for him. You should only recommend someone you think would be good for a job. Don't cheapen your reputation.
This!

How could you recommend a work-shy, manipulative moaner to anyone?

Not very fair to the agency or your colleagues.

Pinksloth · 13/12/2021 17:12

@PrincessNutella

It would be unethical to put a good word in for him. You should only recommend someone you think would be good for a job. Don't cheapen your reputation.
This!

How could you recommend a work-shy, manipulative moaner to anyone?

Not very fair to the agency or your colleagues.