Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what happened in the F1 yesterday?

242 replies

WonderingWoman30 · 13/12/2021 11:58

I am trying to get my head around what happened with Lewis v Max in the F1 yesterday! I have read articles and was watching it… but I don’t understand the controversy… can anyone explain in (very) simple terms?! Xmas Blush

OP posts:
WonderingWoman30 · 13/12/2021 12:42

Thanks all! I think I get it now Xmas Grin

OP posts:
BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 12:42

@ClowningAround21

  1. Max was plenty fast enough yesterday, his car wasn’t.

  2. They didn’t change their minds because Red Bull complained. The FIA-team radios we see on TV are delayed. These conversations happen before we get to hear them, so they’re not aligned with the race control directives, which we do get live.

  3. If they had red-flagged the race, that would have been incredibly stupid given their previous decisions this season. Ask drivers what they thought about the late red-flag in Baku, when it was actually needed because of safety. They were saying ‘it’s a f*ing joke’ on the radio. Ask drivers what they thought about them not red-flagging Q3 in Spa, which almost cost several drivers their lives. They couldn’t red flag for a simple crash, which was next to a recovery vehicle and an escape route.

  4. I agree, Masi needs to go. Clearer rules need to be written. Competent stewards need to be employed so this farce doesn’t go on for years.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 12:42

@senua

The closing of the gap was correct. I don't think 'correct' is the word here; 'conventional' maybe. Why should the Safety Car being out mean that time-differentials are lost due to bunching? How is that fair? I think PlanetNormal's analogy is spot on.
Because you need to bunch the field to safely deal with an incident. Safety cars are the norm for all forms of track motorsport that I'm aware of. The alternative is a red flag and standing start for every incident which is even more artificial.

Those going on about football etc aren't considering the safety aspect.

BiscuitBean · 13/12/2021 12:41

@MindyStClaire Definitely! Having slower cars mixed in when there’s bad weather seems a recipe for disaster! Mind you, I’m sure it was Martin Brundle that said it so make of that what you will Hmm

Maybe83 · 13/12/2021 12:40

Mercedes say the race director failed to implement the regulations regarding safety car use under one regulation. Race control rejected on the basis they implemented two superseding regulations.

Mercedes also claimed that Max breached over taking rules while safety car was out. Race control rejected as they didn't find the move of Max s car to constitute overtaking.

Lewis was clearly concerned with Mercedes tire strategy and Mercedes ran with it. It didn't work out for them.

I didnt see Toto Wofle to unhappy with Race controls inconsistency when they didn't instruct Lewis to give back track position like they did Max last week earlier in the race. Overall if there has been inconsistency throughout the season it worked the majority of the time to Mercedes favour. The hypocrisy of Totto Wolfe is quite something.

The teams behaviour yesterday was disgraceful. They won the Constructors due to the driving of both of their drivers. Valtteri Bottas last race with Mercedes and no acknowledgement from them. If the roles were reversed they 100% would have thrown everything at it and probably taken the same tyre strategy as Redbull.

I'm absolutely delighted to see their dominance over and I think its making them look absolutely pathetic.

I can't wait for next year.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 12:40

What I would really love (and this is one for the fans rather than the casual observers) is to know what Charlie Whiting's radio sounded like.

Did the teams speak to him the way they speak to Masi? Did he dither to the same extent? I just can't imagine it somehow, but I'm wondering how much my opinion of him is swayed by seeing behind the curtain as it were, maybe this is how it's always been.

senua · 13/12/2021 12:39

The closing of the gap was correct.
I don't think 'correct' is the word here; 'conventional' maybe. Why should the Safety Car being out mean that time-differentials are lost due to bunching? How is that fair?
I think PlanetNormal's analogy is spot on.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 12:38

I don't think I've ever seen it be used (although I can't follow as closely these days as have small children, and my memory is shite these days because of said small children).

Of course, it used to be the norm that lapped cars remained where they were, but they have been unlapping for years now.

I think it would be safer to remove them in bad weather than leave them there in the spray!

ClowningAround21 · 13/12/2021 12:37

I half didn't want to watch as I'm a Max fan and throughout the season the rules have been bent in Mercedes favour so many times. I had been predicting that after so much Merc dominance they wanted what looked like a battle right to the last race but that Lewis would be allowed to have a record breaking championship before he's pitted against George Russell. So in actual fact it was a huge surprise to me that they allowed Max to win by allowing this interpretation of the rules this time...

Max wasn't fast enough during the race, despite starting on poll.

The rules are the rules and they state that all cars must un lap the safety car (before the race can start again) not just the 5 between Max and Lewis, there wasn't time to do this, so the rules were not interpreted, they were broken and this allowed a contrived result, especially given they first said no cars would be allowed to un-lap themselves and then, when Redbull complained, they changed their minds.

I'm a F1 fan not a Lewis or Max one, F1 has been bought into mockery, why the fuck didnt Masi red flag it and re start with 5 laps to go.

I hope the legal challenge is upheld and they get a new race director, someone who knows the rules & doesn't allow challenges to his authority in race.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 12:37

@PlanetNormal

The football Champions League Final was in the 89th minute (of 90) when the stadium lights suddenly went out. Team A was leading Team B 5-0 at the time. The referee stopped the game while the lights were fixed.

There was till 1 minute of the game still to be played, but when the referee re-started the game he ignored the rules, re-set the score to 0-0, sent off Team A’s goalkeeper and all its defenders and said ‘next goal wins’. Team B scored and ‘won’ the match.

It wasn’t the referee who re-set the score to 0-0. That was the natural consequence of the safety car, in yesterday’s race. It happens ALL the time, and those saying it doesn’t, have no idea about F1. The mistake was the way they ‘turned on the lights’ again…

Lewis Hamilton himself has benefitted from
SC/red flags situations this season, multiple times. When the score was re-set and he was able to catch up those in front, or change tyres, or repair his damaged car… that’s just F1, it happens.

The safety car in procedure wasn’t followed properly yesterday, which doesn’t take away from the initial need for, and consequences of, a safety car.

BiscuitBean · 13/12/2021 12:36

@MindyStClaire There is an option for them to be left in situ which I can't remember being used before, but it's there.

I think they said something yesterday about that being predominantly used in bad weather? I’m not sure I’ve ever seen that tbh.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 12:35

@PlanetNormal

The football Champions League Final was in the 89th minute (of 90) when the stadium lights suddenly went out. Team A was leading Team B 5-0 at the time. The referee stopped the game while the lights were fixed.

There was till 1 minute of the game still to be played, but when the referee re-started the game he ignored the rules, re-set the score to 0-0, sent off Team A’s goalkeeper and all its defenders and said ‘next goal wins’. Team B scored and ‘won’ the match.

No.

The safety car coming out is normal and important. The closing of the gap was correct.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 13/12/2021 12:32

@MrsFin

I'm pretty pleased Hamilton didn't win though - based on the fact that he pays no/very little tax in the UK. He lives in Monaco, though he owns residences elsewhere in the world. He specifically told Parkinson in an interview years ago that he had decided not to live in the UK to avoid taxation.
He was one of the top 5000 UK taxpayers in 2019. Maybe look in to it a bit more before making silly comments.

And who would choose to leave here over living in Monaco if they could afford it Grin

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 12:32

AND in addition to this, the race director specifically stated that the lapped cars wouldn't be allowed to unlap themselves before randomly changing his mind after it was too late for mercedes to change strategy.

Mercedes wouldn’t have been able to change strategy regardless of Masi’s decision on the unlapped cars. That’s not how it works.

Even if he’d changed his mind laps earlier, Mercedes couldn’t bring Lewis in for new tyres, because he would have lost track position. That’s the same scenario as every time there is a SC/VSC, the strategy wasn’t affected by Masi’s decision.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 12:31

For people who watched for the first time yesterday:

Safety car: comes out when there's an accident, slows down the cars and bunches the field up so an accident can be cleared safely (obviously can't have marshals on track with cars racing). No overtaking allowed. Usually, lapped cars are allowed overtake and build a gap in front of the pack so that when the racing resumes, cars are together in race order.

People (on Twitter etc) complaining about Hamilton losing his advantage to Verstappen are flat out wrong - losing an advantage to a safety car is a normal part of racing, and it's an important part of strategy to have a plan for what to do. It was more or less a no brainer for Hamilton to stay out and keep track position, and a definite no brainer for Verstappen to stop for fresh tyres once Hamilton didn't.
That much was all fine.

As others have said, the problem is in the lapped cars. Usually, they're all allowed to overtake. There is an option for them to be left in situ which I can't remember being used before, but it's there. There is an accepted wish that races shouldn't finish under safety car where possible.

The argument is over whether or not Masi was allowed to only let SOME lapped cars through rather than ALL. There wouldn't have been time to let them all through and restart the race. Personally, I think if what he did is allowed under the rules (rather than just convention), I think it was the best call to allow the race to finish as a race. If it's not allowed under the rules, then obviously it wasn't ok - but what on earth a court of appeal could do I don't know. That will be the discussion now.

However, I do think the dithering wasn't great, and that Masi hasn't been inspiring as a race director. It's time for someone new.

It is an incredibly fitting ending to this season that it ends in controversy and close racing. Anyone saying this sort of controversy is anything new in F1 isn't familiar with the sport.

I do think the result will stand, but that procedure will change in future.

ZoBo123 · 13/12/2021 12:31

@PlanetNormal

The football Champions League Final was in the 89th minute (of 90) when the stadium lights suddenly went out. Team A was leading Team B 5-0 at the time. The referee stopped the game while the lights were fixed.

There was till 1 minute of the game still to be played, but when the referee re-started the game he ignored the rules, re-set the score to 0-0, sent off Team A’s goalkeeper and all its defenders and said ‘next goal wins’. Team B scored and ‘won’ the match.

This. But also allowed the losing team to change half their players so they were fresher whilst the other team were tiring.
senua · 13/12/2021 12:31

@MrsFin

I'm pretty pleased Hamilton didn't win though - based on the fact that he pays no/very little tax in the UK. He lives in Monaco, though he owns residences elsewhere in the world. He specifically told Parkinson in an interview years ago that he had decided not to live in the UK to avoid taxation.
And where does Max Verstappen live?
BiscuitBean · 13/12/2021 12:30

@MrsFin Sorry but that’s blow for blow what happened…the situation is clear as mud to be honest. Mercedes took a barrister into their meeting with the stewards yesterday! A barrister, for a car race. The mind boggles.

They took already confusing rules and twisted them beyond recognition. Money talks I guess!

TokyoSushi · 13/12/2021 12:30

Bloody shambles. The amount of time I've dedicated to this since March (and will again next year as I totally love it!) and they go and do this at the end!!

PlanetNormal · 13/12/2021 12:29

The football Champions League Final was in the 89th minute (of 90) when the stadium lights suddenly went out. Team A was leading Team B 5-0 at the time. The referee stopped the game while the lights were fixed.

There was till 1 minute of the game still to be played, but when the referee re-started the game he ignored the rules, re-set the score to 0-0, sent off Team A’s goalkeeper and all its defenders and said ‘next goal wins’. Team B scored and ‘won’ the match.

Lillygolightly · 13/12/2021 12:29

Yes it was wrong, entirely!!

I appreciate the fact that they wanted to race/world championship to finish under racing conditions BUT….

Lewis had dominated the entire race up until that point, he had nursed tyres, pitted carefully and built a gap between him and Verstappen.

Tell me what racing element (other than a twist of fate and blind luck to max) gave Max the advantage? What did Max do to win the race? Would he have won the race without the Safety Car and lapped cars being moved from his path to Lewis? Of course not, so no he didn’t really win in my opinion (and that’s not to say that he couldn’t have won or shouldn’t have won, championship really could have gone either way as both talented excellent drivers) and it’s such a shame that after such a competitive and exciting season that this is the way the championship was won!

If I were Max I would have hated to win it this way! You spend all season racing, being competitive who wants it to end under a cloud of doubt and controversy. You don’t want any doubt that you are anything less that completely and utterly deserving of the championship title.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 12:29

Had the safety car not come on, Verstappen would have been too far behind to be able to win.

The safety car had to come out as there had been a crash and there was a car parked up in the middle of the road. It would have been unsafe not to bring the SC out.

The problem was the way the brought it back in. That was done in an unbelievably silly way. Decisions taken in the spur of the moment whilst both Toto and Christian (team principals) kept shouting at the race director, who then decided to override the rulebook and give us a final showdown lap which ultimately gave Max the win, as he was able to overtake Lewis.

Now the question is whether the regulations were not applied because of simple ignorance, incompetence, the pressure to put on a show by F1’s new American owners, or bias towards one competitor.

The latter one seems unlikely given how the FIA have favoured Mercedes all season, but you never know.

It’s a deeply political sport where money and power and influence decide who rules, most of the time.

MrsFin · 13/12/2021 12:27

I'm pretty pleased Hamilton didn't win though - based on the fact that he pays no/very little tax in the UK. He lives in Monaco, though he owns residences elsewhere in the world. He specifically told Parkinson in an interview years ago that he had decided not to live in the UK to avoid taxation.

Bucanarab · 13/12/2021 12:27

What @BiscuitBean said. In addition to this, Mercedes had based their strategy of not bringing Lewis in for a tyre change on the rules meaning that the race would end under the safety car but it didn’t so he had the old tyres on and Max had new soft (I think) tyres on so he was able to go quicker.

AND in addition to this, the race director specifically stated that the lapped cars wouldn't be allowed to unlap themselves before randomly changing his mind after it was too late for mercedes to change strategy.

JustFrustrated · 13/12/2021 12:25

Removing all bias....it was bullshit.

Masi has turned it into a farce, and should be sacked. How can teams safely race/create strategy if the devised rules aren't adhered to? The rules aren't some whim, they're there to keep drivers safe.

What concerned me the most was how close the safety car came to being in an accident. As an observer it looked messy, and nothing around the safety car should ever look messy.