Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what happened in the F1 yesterday?

242 replies

WonderingWoman30 · 13/12/2021 11:58

I am trying to get my head around what happened with Lewis v Max in the F1 yesterday! I have read articles and was watching it… but I don’t understand the controversy… can anyone explain in (very) simple terms?! Xmas Blush

OP posts:
BiscuitBean · 13/12/2021 13:16

@goldfluffyclouds That said - the decision to either use virtual or real safety car in many cases has shown not to be about safety but to give a 'more interesting' race.

100% this, there’s been a number of times this season we’ve had exactly the same conversations because it’s just not made sense! Mind you, there’s just been a lot this year that’s not made sense. I can’t see how any of it has been good for the sport.

The biggest irony is how big a deal they made of not wanting it to be decided in the stewards room, and that the championship should be decided on the track. And they’ve done this! Confused

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 13:16

[quote LookItsMeAgain]@Lillygolightly - I don't even think that Max would have been on pole for Sunday's race had he not received a slip stream from Perez in qualification!
He also got a slip stream from him during the race so Perez has clearly signed himself to be the #2 driver in RBR. They hadn't won the Constructors championship - Mercedes had that in the bag as long as Lewis finished the race. So it was all down to the Driver's Championship.[/quote]
Too lazy to go back and check, but wasn't Verstappen faster than Hamilton on the lap without a slipstream too?

ClowningAround21 · 13/12/2021 13:16

[quote BHX3000]@LookItsMeAgain Max gained a 0.1-0.2 advantage from that slipstream. His gains vs Lewis were made in S3, where a slipstream is useless, and he didn’t even have one there. He was 0.5 up on Lewis during his first run. The gap would’ve have stayed the same, had Max completed his second run (which he didn’t, as there was no need).

People not thinking XYZ, when the data and telemetry states otherwise, doesn’t give way to very accurate takes on the matter.[/quote]
Using an opposing teams car to slipstream to gain an adv in qualifying is one thing, engineering it is quite another.
But agree, Max would still have ended up on pole, though it did him little good as he couldn't convert that into race pace on the day.

Otter77 · 13/12/2021 13:15

Also they only let the cars between Lewis and Max unlap themselves, if they’d done all the cars (as per the regulations) then Max might have had Carlos Sainz nipping at his heels trying to get past him which would have been a different proposition again.

okaythen123 · 13/12/2021 13:14

@senua

The closing of the gap was correct. I don't think 'correct' is the word here; 'conventional' maybe. Why should the Safety Car being out mean that time-differentials are lost due to bunching? How is that fair? I think PlanetNormal's analogy is spot on.
You're wrong.

The use of a safety car means no overtaking but the gaps are closed. This always happens in any race.

The Virtual safety car however used in lesser circumstances as the Latifi crash means drivers have to reduce their speed by 40% no overtaking and therefore the gaps remain.

Regardless they always will bunch up on a safety car. That's the way the cookie crumbles in f1 . It will either benefit a driver or it won't.

Both Merc and Redbull both were always going to complain about everything. Should Lewis have slowed down to allow max to regain his position after the first lap incident? Probably!

Should toto Wolff (merc boss) have complained to the race director about Perez's defending at lap 20 as "dangerous" absolutely not! It was racing.

The whole thing is a total shame for what's been a fantastic season.

Agree with pp who said they should have red flag the race and restarted after the crash was cleared!

ClowningAround21 · 13/12/2021 13:13

How they dealt with the SC coming back in was not on. Red flagging and therefore wiping out RB’s advantage from gambling on the strategy, would’ve been even worse

No not at all, because the strategy RB used on a SC pit stop wasn't available to Lewis, he was too close to the pit lane entrance to come in and give his team time to change tyres, Max had an additional 12 seconds.
Also, had Lewis pitted, Max may not of, handing him track position and if the race had finished behind the SC, Max would have then won, with everyone say what an idiot he was for stopping! max had lost the race at this point, he had nothing lose.

I get you feel Max should be rewarded for putting on new tyres but equally, why should Lewis see his 12 sec racing advantage wiped out?

If you don't want the 5 lap finish, then the race would have finished behind the SC, not ideal either :(

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 13:12

@LookItsMeAgain Max gained a 0.1-0.2 advantage from that slipstream. His gains vs Lewis were made in S3, where a slipstream is useless, and he didn’t even have one there. He was 0.5 up on Lewis during his first run. The gap would’ve have stayed the same, had Max completed his second run (which he didn’t, as there was no need).

People not thinking XYZ, when the data and telemetry states otherwise, doesn’t give way to very accurate takes on the matter.

Intheopinionofourexpert · 13/12/2021 13:09

For me the biggest issue was that Red Bull, for the second time in consecutive races pushed Masi to change his mind, which he then did. Even Britney (if you watched Drive to Survive) who isn't exactly a fan of Lewis Hamilton, said what a ridiculous scenario that is.

Intheopinionofourexpert · 13/12/2021 13:06

@MrsFin

I'm pretty pleased Hamilton didn't win though - based on the fact that he pays no/very little tax in the UK. He lives in Monaco, though he owns residences elsewhere in the world. He specifically told Parkinson in an interview years ago that he had decided not to live in the UK to avoid taxation.
And you think all the other drivers, including Verstappen, live where?
LookItsMeAgain · 13/12/2021 13:06

@Lillygolightly - I don't even think that Max would have been on pole for Sunday's race had he not received a slip stream from Perez in qualification!
He also got a slip stream from him during the race so Perez has clearly signed himself to be the #2 driver in RBR. They hadn't won the Constructors championship - Mercedes had that in the bag as long as Lewis finished the race. So it was all down to the Driver's Championship.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 13/12/2021 13:04

@Essexmum321

As a PP said Lewis Hamilton is one of the highest 5000 tax payers in the UK, he earns money and pays taxes in 19 countries and has pledged to donate £20 million to charity to support underrepresented groups in the UK
This. I'm fed up with the hate towards Lewis and I'm not even a particular fan of his as I support McLaren.

I'm even less of a fan of Max for allowing his father to follow him around and bask in reflected glory after everything he's done.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 13:04

There is no ideal solution but at least a re start, with 5 laps to go, with all cars on their best rubber, allows for some competition, one lap with one car on brand new softs and the other on worn out hard tyres is not a competition.

It has happened so many times before, and it would have been a fair competition had they not screwed up the procedure which allowed it. Latifi crashed one lap early, and we’re not even discussing this today. It happens, it’s F1.

How they dealt with the SC coming back in was not on. Red flagging and therefore wiping out RB’s advantage from gambling on the strategy, would’ve been even worse.

maxelly · 13/12/2021 13:03

Exactly Mindy and BHX, the fact that a safety car might have to come out and erode any lead/time differential at any time in the race is just part of parcel of racing and race planning, no-one can legitimately call it unfair. In fact I think Lewis was on the radio to Bono at various points in the race worrying about his tyres and the possibility of a safety car or VSC because he foresaw this very scenario playing out (but there was just never a good moment to bring him in without losing too much track position). The bit that's (potentially) unfair is that Merc had to make their very quick decision re pitting thinking they understood what the rules about the safety car would be and turned out they didn't, to their cost...

LookItsMeAgain · 13/12/2021 13:02

@Crazyhouse123

So....if you take out any bias towards Hamilton on balance was this wrong as per race rules and regulations? I am more of a motogp fan but followed the news on this yesterday and can't really get my head around it Grin
YES.

I honestly feel for all of the staff in all of the other teams as they had to be part of this shit show too.

Why would they follow any of the rules that the FIA have written if the most basic one regarding the safety car wasn't followed by the very people who wrote the rules!

ClowningAround21 · 13/12/2021 13:01

@BHX3000

The time line is clear, they decided to not un-lap the cars (handing Lewis the race) then changed their minds BUT only 5, had they done all the lapped cars, as per the rules, the race would have finished under the safety car.

A contrived finish to the race.

There is no ideal solution but at least a re start, with 5 laps to go, with all cars on their best rubber, allows for some competition, one lap with one car on brand new softs and the other on worn out hard tyres is not a competition.

LookItsMeAgain · 13/12/2021 12:59

@MrsFin - you wrote:
I think that what happened was that Hamilton was some way ahead of Verstappen, but then when the safety car came on Verstappen was able to catch up, and then went on to get ahead of Hamilton on the last lap and won the race. Had the safety car not come on, Verstappen would have been too far behind to be able to win.
This is not correct.

There was an accident with a Williams car (it crashed into the barriers) and the Safety Car had to come out to keep all of the remaining drivers to a set speed limit while the marshals could recover the damaged car. This took a number of laps and was very near the end of the race.

When the Safety Car came out, Lewis Hamilton had passed 5 cars (i.e. there were 5 cars on a lap behind Lewis that were between him and Max Verstappen. Max still had to overtake these cars and was on the same lap as Lewis).

Then it came down to the rulebook. As @BiscuitBean wrote, it was either a decision to let all of the cars overtake the safety car and then bring in the safety car or leave all of those 5 cars between Max and Lewis and have Max overtake them (as Lewis had to do prior to the Safety Car) and try to then overtake Lewis to win.

Michael Massi (Race Director) decided to let only the 5 cars between Max and Lewis go ahead of the safety car (thereby unlapping themselves and putting them at the 'back' of the queue and on the same lap as the leaders but NOT the ones that were behind Max and were a lap or two down) bringing Max much much closer to Lewis and on fresher tyres and more likely to be able to overtake Lewis without having the hassle of having to overtake the other 5 cars.

This is NOT about what Lewis earns or Max earns or even about Netflix Drive to Survive.

This is about the most basic rules in the sport and how they get applied when there is the Driver's Championship at stake.

This is like saying to someone cycling the Tour de France that they can have a top of the range bike with new tyres to compete against their nearest rival but when the final stages are being decided and they are level on time (or points as it was in the case of F1), that you are suddenly handed a tricycle with tyres that aren't new, a number of your competitors that were between you and your main rival can go in front of you and yet your main rival can be right behind you, keep cycling their top of the range bike and they go on to win.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 12:58

Yes I'm not sure I ever recall thinking a SC was unnecessary, and the rules around when it should be used are very strict (rightly) since Bianchi.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 12:56

Me and husband often find ourselves discussing the choice after referring to the track maps/positions as sometimes it looks more like politics than safety... Especially the timing of when the safety car virtual or otherwise ends...

I think it’s great when fans understand the sport and are able to fully get all the procedures involved in a race.

But I don’t think anyone believes the FIA plays games with the timing or deployment of VSC/SC. That’s a safety issue, people are constantly dying or being injured and they do not take it lightly. Discussing whether a SC is needed or not is not our job, because we don’t have all the data they do, to support such decisions.

Fans opposed the halo and the HANS device. They’ve saved so many lives already. We don’t have the information they do when it comes to vital safety decisions.

The issue yesterday was the SC in procedure, not the deployment or timing of it, you can’t manipulate those.

maxelly · 13/12/2021 12:52

You've sort of got it MrsFin, Lewis had a virtually unassailable lead most of the way (Red Bull admitted as much with about 15 laps to go saying words to the effect of they needed a miracle). Max was in second place and making ground on Lewis at this point but needed to lap a number of cars before reaching him which in itself would take some time. Lewis's only concern was he had old hard tyres on that should, with cautious driving make it to the end without puncturing but wouldn't let him push hard for faster times. Then the miracle Red Bull needed happened, a backmarker (Latifi) crashed causing a safety car to come out with about 5 laps to go giving Max the ability to close the gap to Lewis to effectively nothing - this was totally not the fault of the stewards BTW and no-one is criticising the bringing out of the safety car which was totally necessary).

The controversy came where both teams then had to make a snap decision about a second pit stop to change tyres during the safety car, Mercedes were assuming that normal previous 'rules' would be followed, i.e. that once the track was clear in about 3-4 laps, either the normal 'unlapping process' would be followed which takes a couple of laps to do and therefore the race would end behind the safety car with an automatic Lewis win (but the stewards wouldn't want this as is an anticlimactic end to the race and would result in protests from Red Bull) OR that no unlapping would happen due to lack of time and therefore it would basically be impossible for Max to have time to get past the cars he needed to lap and catch Lewis in time. The latter is what the stewards initially broadcast would happen and therefore Mercedes left Lewis on his old tyres and in the lead with Max stuck behind a bunch of cars, whereas Red Bull having nothing to lose at this point brought Max in for new tyres. Then suddenly the stewards appeared to invent a new process where only the cars between Lewis and Max moved out the way allowing the climactic final lap where Max with the tyre advantage was able to take the race. That's why people are unhappy as although potentially strictly in line with the rules which state the race director can ultimately decide everything to do with the safety car, in their pursuit of wanting an exciting final lap it does seem to have favoured Max who was slower all the way (not necessarily through bad driving, the Merc was probably just the faster car)... but on the other hand Mercedes had to make their decision re the pit stop very quickly virtually as soon as the crash happened due to where Lewis was on the track, by the time all the shenanigans with the lapping/unlapping happened they'd basically made their bed and had to lie in it as they'd have had to bring Lewis in after Max and lost track position anyway by that point (but it would have been a more fair and exciting final showdown if they'd both had fresh tires compared to Max just zooming off, Lewis WUZ ROBBED!)

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 12:52

The VSC doesn’t allow for the track to be cleared efficiently when needed. The SC had to be deployed last night because a recovery vehicle was also on track.

Last time that happened, without a SC, Jules Bianchi lost control of his car and drove straight into a tractor crane. He died a few months later after never waking up from a come due to the injuries sustained in the accident.

These are racing drivers. If you don’t tell them to slow down, they won’t slow down. This is why VSC and SC’s are needed, because the race organisers are responsible for their safety and you can’t have cars going around at 200mph and cranes rescuing crashed cars, on the same piece of track, simultaneously.

goldfluffyclouds · 13/12/2021 12:52

[quote BiscuitBean]**@senua* I don't think 'correct' is the word here; 'conventional' maybe. Why should the Safety Car being out mean that time-differentials are lost due to bunching? How is that fair?*

That’s a good point. The virtual safety car rules seems more fair where all drivers decrease speed by 40% so it doesn’t bunch them up so much.[/quote]
Sometimes the bunching up is absolutely needed to give enough space on track for recovery, sweeping up to make the track clear.
That said - the decision to either use virtual or real safety car in many cases has shown not to be about safety but to give a 'more interesting' race. Me and husband often find ourselves discussing the choice after referring to the track maps/positions as sometimes it looks more like politics than safety... Especially the timing of when the safety car virtual or otherwise ends...

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 12:47

[quote BiscuitBean]**@senua* I don't think 'correct' is the word here; 'conventional' maybe. Why should the Safety Car being out mean that time-differentials are lost due to bunching? How is that fair?*

That’s a good point. The virtual safety car rules seems more fair where all drivers decrease speed by 40% so it doesn’t bunch them up so much.[/quote]
I'm not convinced by the VSC. It seems to have hugely varying and unpredictable effects on the gaps depending on where drivers are on the track when it goes green again.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 12:46

@senua

The closing of the gap was correct. I don't think 'correct' is the word here; 'conventional' maybe. Why should the Safety Car being out mean that time-differentials are lost due to bunching? How is that fair? I think PlanetNormal's analogy is spot on.
Safety cars are needed for, well, safety. You need to compress the field so they all drive closely together and there is one minute each lap where the track is clear and people can clean it up, repair the damage, or move a car off the road.

For less severe incidents, there is now something called the Virtual Safety Car. Drivers slow down by 40% but the gaps remain the same, there is no need to compress the field.

There was a VSC earlier on in the race, where the incident was less serious. The SC at the end - and it’s natural consequences - isn’t something that can be argued. It would’ve been much worse for someone to crash into Latifi’s car and end up hospitalised because they wanted to respect the gaps created.

Essexmum321 · 13/12/2021 12:44

As a PP said Lewis Hamilton is one of the highest 5000 tax payers in the UK, he earns money and pays taxes in 19 countries and has pledged to donate £20 million to charity to support underrepresented groups in the UK

BiscuitBean · 13/12/2021 12:44

@senua I don't think 'correct' is the word here; 'conventional' maybe. Why should the Safety Car being out mean that time-differentials are lost due to bunching? How is that fair?

That’s a good point. The virtual safety car rules seems more fair where all drivers decrease speed by 40% so it doesn’t bunch them up so much.