Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what happened in the F1 yesterday?

242 replies

WonderingWoman30 · 13/12/2021 11:58

I am trying to get my head around what happened with Lewis v Max in the F1 yesterday! I have read articles and was watching it… but I don’t understand the controversy… can anyone explain in (very) simple terms?! Xmas Blush

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 13/12/2021 13:40

[quote ClowningAround21]@BHX3000 I would never claim Max is undeserving, he is a great driver, who, over the course of a season, went into the final race level pegging, i thought he would win on track, through pace alone, his qualifying lap was awesome, it totally threw Mercedes.

Moving forward, i would either/or, ban pit stops under the SC, make the SC such that time gaps have to be maintained, as per the Virtual SC.[/quote]
But the SC and pit stops are part of the overall strategy. It would be very boring if it was just a simple race. It's the planning of pit stops, choice of tyres, percentage risk of safety car at different stages of the race, and on different tracks, etc that makes it an interesting sport.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 13:40

@Stellaris22

At least Hamilton campaigns for human rights, funding campaigns to increase diversity in F1 and actively spoke out to stop a sponsorship deal with a company affiliated with Greenfell.

The bit that shocked me the most under SC was Verstappen continually edging out in front of Hamilton, that was just shocking driving and he should have been told to stop. No end to the dangerous driving he does.

Funny, I thought Hamilton was intentionally going so slowly as to goad Max into going past him Grin
LookItsMeAgain · 13/12/2021 13:39

Also, to clarify, when they red flag a race, the drivers return to the pits and can change their tyres during this time without penalty. Lando Norris (McLaren driver) has claimed that this practice is also unfair to other drivers on the grid who may have changed tyres a lap or two before the red flag which puts them out of position on the track.

user1497207191 · 13/12/2021 13:38

@PlanetNormal

Yet those three white drivers from middle class backgrounds don’t get criticised in the right-wing tabloids for where they choose to live, but a mixed-race driver from a working class background does. Has it ever occurred to you to wonder why that is?

There was plenty of criticism for the while middle class Nigel Mansell when he became a tax exile in the Isle of Man when he was at the height of his F1 career!

There's been plenty of criticism for white middle class singer Shania Twain who "moved" from Canada to Switzerland, apparently for "creative reasons"!

Plenty of criticism for various other UK pop stars who've arranged their world tours to pay no UK tax on the tour revenue - lots of those were white middle class.

It's not a race issue at all - unless you've already decided that based on your own bias.

Laiste · 13/12/2021 13:37

BiscuitBean and MindyStClaire thank you for explaining :)

Wow i know even less about F1 than i thought, lol. Fascinating!

ClowningAround21 · 13/12/2021 13:37

@BHX3000 I would never claim Max is undeserving, he is a great driver, who, over the course of a season, went into the final race level pegging, i thought he would win on track, through pace alone, his qualifying lap was awesome, it totally threw Mercedes.

Moving forward, i would either/or, ban pit stops under the SC, make the SC such that time gaps have to be maintained, as per the Virtual SC.

LookItsMeAgain · 13/12/2021 13:37

@Laiste

So - and i know there will be a good reason - why don't they all just slow down and stop when there is a big incident on the track. They must all stop within a certain number of seconds and then start again when the track is clear?

Everyone stays in order and the race just carries on.

They do. It's when they "Red Flag" the race. They didn't want to do that with so few laps left in the race.
Stellaris22 · 13/12/2021 13:36

At least Hamilton campaigns for human rights, funding campaigns to increase diversity in F1 and actively spoke out to stop a sponsorship deal with a company affiliated with Greenfell.

The bit that shocked me the most under SC was Verstappen continually edging out in front of Hamilton, that was just shocking driving and he should have been told to stop. No end to the dangerous driving he does.

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 13/12/2021 13:36

Agree that, as a lifelong fan, I have never ever complained about the use of a safety car - the very, very last thing I want to see is someone hurt or killed on the track.

The use of the safety car yesterday was totally sensible. Latifi's car was all over the track.

The way it was called is was unprecended and an absolute shit show. I've never seen the SC called back in when only half the lapped cars have unlapped and without the full lap warning that it's going to do so (and after everyone had just been told the lapped cars would stay in position). It has made a mockery of what was going to be a legendary season, regardless of who won. Now it will be remembered for this farce, not the great racing. Masi has made a total eff up and has been getting worse and worse in later races this year.

Also agree that to slag him Lewis for living in Monaco but fail to do the same to Max (who also lives in Monaco) is stupid.

BiscuitBean · 13/12/2021 13:36

Spot on @BHX3000 two very deserving drivers this season.

It’s a shame for both of them that this has happened when (for a change) it’s got nothing to do with either of them. This wasn’t two drivers exchanging harsh moves on the track. This is two drivers who’ve worked their arse off, through a stacked calendar, only to have their driving be the sub plot to a load of bullshit politics and controversy. It’s not fair for either of them.

LemonSwan · 13/12/2021 13:35

The whole season had been insane for unprecedented situations / nearly impossible decisions. I think it was a rather poetic and fitting ending.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 13:31

@ClowningAround21 I 100% agree, it was a disgrace how it all unfolded. I really do hope we don’t see something like that again.

I just don’t think we should take away from either driver’s achievements this season. Max deserved it. He’s had the most wins, the most poles, the most podiums and has been brilliant. Lewis has also been brilliant, and he would have deserved it equally as much.

I think we’re having a healthy discussion on this thread actually, whereas everywhere else on social media you can see so many people directing their frustrations at Max, when he himself didn’t do anything wrong or corrupt yesterday. How everybody else acted, both Merc and RB, and the FIA, was a complete joke, which makes it all a shame, but no need to claim he’s an undeserving champion and should feel bad about winning this way.

user1497207191 · 13/12/2021 13:30

@MrsFin

I'm pretty pleased Hamilton didn't win though - based on the fact that he pays no/very little tax in the UK. He lives in Monaco, though he owns residences elsewhere in the world. He specifically told Parkinson in an interview years ago that he had decided not to live in the UK to avoid taxation.
There are very few slebs/sports personalities/pop stars/film stars who don't "live" abroad to avoid paying UK tax. It's nothing new.

Nigel Mansell famously "moved" to Isle of Man to avoid UK tax.

HMRC had to do "sweetheart" deals with several "exiled" UK athletes for them to agree to come to the UK for the 2010 Olympics (they'd have to pay UK tax if there hadn't been sweetheart deals and claimed they simply wouldn't bother attending!).

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 13:30

@Laiste

So - and i know there will be a good reason - why don't they all just slow down and stop when there is a big incident on the track. They must all stop within a certain number of seconds and then start again when the track is clear?

Everyone stays in order and the race just carries on.

A good question.

Formula one cars aren't road cars, they can't be started by the drivers. It needs a team of mechanics. Similarly, the tyres need to be up to temperature or it could be dangerous. The safety car aims to achieve what you've described.

MaryStuart · 13/12/2021 13:30

This is interesting.

To wonder what happened in the F1 yesterday?
BiscuitBean · 13/12/2021 13:30

@Laiste

So - and i know there will be a good reason - why don't they all just slow down and stop when there is a big incident on the track. They must all stop within a certain number of seconds and then start again when the track is clear?

Everyone stays in order and the race just carries on.

They would probably all crash immediately I would have thought. Without keeping tyres warm, and engines cool, the cars would just be undrivable.
ClowningAround21 · 13/12/2021 13:29

@BHX3000 When has Valtteri been used to sling shot Lewis and then pull over?
Anyway, it made no difference to the result or indeed qualifying, Max couldn't convert it.

readsalotgirl63 · 13/12/2021 13:26

I also understand that Hamilton didn't have a set of softs left to change to - that is also down to strategy over the whole weekend. It's not Verstappens fault he took a risk in pitting and changing tyres to be able to take advantage of the opportunity should it arise.

These things happen in F. I'm old enough to remember Nigel Mansel's tyre blowing out in the last lap when he was "sure to win ". Think it was 1986

Laiste · 13/12/2021 13:26

So - and i know there will be a good reason - why don't they all just slow down and stop when there is a big incident on the track. They must all stop within a certain number of seconds and then start again when the track is clear?

Everyone stays in order and the race just carries on.

ClowningAround21 · 13/12/2021 13:26

@BHX3000 Nothing like yesterdays farce has ever happened before in F1, in the past, the race would have finished behind the safety car, as per the rules.
Of course SC's have effected race results in the past, just as rain or mechanicals do but re writing rules, in race, to favour one driver over another is, tbh, corrupt.

I also believe Hamilton should have been made to give back the place in the opening lap, Max made that corner first and Lewis should have backed out.

I've followed it since the days of Hunt.

PlanetNormal · 13/12/2021 13:25

@MrsFin

I'm pretty pleased Hamilton didn't win though - based on the fact that he pays no/very little tax in the UK. He lives in Monaco, though he owns residences elsewhere in the world. He specifically told Parkinson in an interview years ago that he had decided not to live in the UK to avoid taxation.
Jenson Button, Britain’s other recent F1 World Champion, and Hamilton’s former team-mate, also lived in Monaco when he was racing in F1. George Russell & Lando Norris, Britain’s young F1 stars who will both drive for top teams next season are in the process of moving to Monaco. All for the same reason, obviously.

Yet those three white drivers from middle class backgrounds don’t get criticised in the right-wing tabloids for where they choose to live, but a mixed-race driver from a working class background does. Has it ever occurred to you to wonder why that is?

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 13:23

[quote BHX3000]@ClowningAround21 I ask again, do you really think engineering a slipstream is something or new or unusual?

Both Mercedes and RB have done that at half the qualifying sessions this year. Some tracks you don’t stand a chance without a slipstream. Everyone does it, especially between teammates and even more so when it’s vital for the championship.

Let’s not take away from Max’s pole, or anybody else’s quali results, because of a slipstream. Half the poles are achieved thanks to a slipstream, and 90% of those are off your own teammate.[/quote]
Absolutely, and no one should lose sight of the fact that Max is a deserving world champion, even the circumstances are controversial. It was one of the all time classic seasons, either driver would have deserved it.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 13:22

Yes Max's position behind Lewis and huge advantage over third gave him the chance to roll the dice.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 13:21

@ClowningAround21 I ask again, do you really think engineering a slipstream is something or new or unusual?

Both Mercedes and RB have done that at half the qualifying sessions this year. Some tracks you don’t stand a chance without a slipstream. Everyone does it, especially between teammates and even more so when it’s vital for the championship.

Let’s not take away from Max’s pole, or anybody else’s quali results, because of a slipstream. Half the poles are achieved thanks to a slipstream, and 90% of those are off your own teammate.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 13:17

I get you feel Max should be rewarded for putting on new tyres but equally, why should Lewis see his 12 sec racing advantage wiped out?

I don’t ‘feel’ he should be rewarded, it’s the natural consequence of F1 racing. Same for Lewis losing his advantage. Come on, it’s not like this is the first time this exact scenario happens? Races and championships have been lost and won due to SC. If someone thinks it’s unfair or unusual, they’ve not watched F1 for long.

If yesterday had happened without the Masi involvement and subsequent shenanigans, Hamilton’s loss would have been utterly heartbreaking. But not unfair, or disputed, or Max’s win less deserving. Just very unlucky and sad.

He had time to pit, they rightly chose not to, because en Max would have stayed out. It’s the same thing that happened in Hungary. When you’re the lead car you can’t react to what your opponent is doing, you need to risk it.