Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what happened in the F1 yesterday?

242 replies

WonderingWoman30 · 13/12/2021 11:58

I am trying to get my head around what happened with Lewis v Max in the F1 yesterday! I have read articles and was watching it… but I don’t understand the controversy… can anyone explain in (very) simple terms?! Xmas Blush

OP posts:
DirectionToPerfection · 13/12/2021 14:32

@MindyStClaire

For people who watched for the first time yesterday:

Safety car: comes out when there's an accident, slows down the cars and bunches the field up so an accident can be cleared safely (obviously can't have marshals on track with cars racing). No overtaking allowed. Usually, lapped cars are allowed overtake and build a gap in front of the pack so that when the racing resumes, cars are together in race order.

People (on Twitter etc) complaining about Hamilton losing his advantage to Verstappen are flat out wrong - losing an advantage to a safety car is a normal part of racing, and it's an important part of strategy to have a plan for what to do. It was more or less a no brainer for Hamilton to stay out and keep track position, and a definite no brainer for Verstappen to stop for fresh tyres once Hamilton didn't.
That much was all fine.

As others have said, the problem is in the lapped cars. Usually, they're all allowed to overtake. There is an option for them to be left in situ which I can't remember being used before, but it's there. There is an accepted wish that races shouldn't finish under safety car where possible.

The argument is over whether or not Masi was allowed to only let SOME lapped cars through rather than ALL. There wouldn't have been time to let them all through and restart the race. Personally, I think if what he did is allowed under the rules (rather than just convention), I think it was the best call to allow the race to finish as a race. If it's not allowed under the rules, then obviously it wasn't ok - but what on earth a court of appeal could do I don't know. That will be the discussion now.

However, I do think the dithering wasn't great, and that Masi hasn't been inspiring as a race director. It's time for someone new.

It is an incredibly fitting ending to this season that it ends in controversy and close racing. Anyone saying this sort of controversy is anything new in F1 isn't familiar with the sport.

I do think the result will stand, but that procedure will change in future.

Agree with all of this.

The comparison to a 5-0 lead in a football match being wiped out is absurd, and shows a total lack of understanding of F1 as a sport.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 14:30

Remember Belgium where Verstappen led the cars round the track for 2 laps behind a safety car before the race was stopped, gaining him an extra win and half points?

That wasn't to favour Max or RB. It was because of the massive financial implications of not running the race. Anyone on pole would have been given the same chance. It's nearly happened before but the weather has cleared in time to have a race. It was inevitable it would happen some time.

drpet49 · 13/12/2021 14:29

AND in addition to this, the race director specifically stated that the lapped cars wouldn't be allowed to unlap themselves before randomly changing his mind after it was too late for mercedes to change strategy.

^The race director changed his mind after Christian Horner of Red Bull kicked off

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 14:28

I’m very excited about Lewis vs George next year. I too wonder what the dynamic will be.

Will we get a Seb vs Charles in 2019? Because that was amazing to see. Second race and they tell Charles to keep position, yet he goes and overtakes the no. 1 driver, because he’s faster and wants to be in front. It was brilliant!

A bit like Lewis sending it into the first corner at his first ever race in Melbourne 2007. Those are the kind of moves that tell you they mean business and they don’t care how decorated the older guy is, they’re not there to play second fiddle to anyone. Moves of future champions.

I can’t wait to see how Mercedes approach it next year and whether George will equal or best Lewis. It’s a win-win for him; if he doesn’t beat Lewis it won’t be a huge deal and he will learn so much anyway, but if he beats him it’ll be fantastic to see how well he’ll have proven himself against one the best ever.

I can’t wait for 2022 Grin

JuneDr · 13/12/2021 14:28

One argument that keeps popping up on SM about how unfair it is that Lewis had a 12 second advantage before the safety car then he didn't ... Well yes, that happens all the time when a SC is deployed, it always benefits the driver behind that's not new nor unfair.

AFS1 · 13/12/2021 14:27

@HalfWomanHalfMincePie

They all play silly buggers on the track (well, almost all).

Lewis drove Max off at Silverstone.
Max drove him off yesterday and was 'salty' (great term!) about having to give the place back last week.
Michael S drive Barrichello into a wall and Damon H off the track (and loads of other stuff Grin.
Alonso had to have known about crashgate.
Vettel clearly went back on team race agreements with Webber (Multi-21).
Tyrell fired lead shots out of the car to lighten it up - ha!
Jenson drove a car with a secret second fuel tank - double ha!
Senna deliberately took Prost out in Japan 1990

I don't think any are all good, or all bad. Human nature simply is more complication than that.

Hamilton didn’t drive Verstappen off the track at Silverstone. He had the advantage at the bend. Verstappen did his usual thing of trying to bully the other driver into giving way. Hamilton stood his ground. Verstappen was the victim of his own dangerous driving style and ended up in the wall.

This season’s championship has been skewed in favour of Red Bull. Remember Belgium where Verstappen led the cars round the track for 2 laps behind a safety car before the race was stopped, gaining him an extra win and half points?

If they were so keen for the final race to end in style, they should have red flagged the accident and then had a straight sprint shoot out over 5 laps in fresh tyres.

Naillig222 · 13/12/2021 14:26

@MindyStClaire

I don't think I've ever seen any suggestion it wasn't a mistake (Russell's tyres). It's the sort of mistake that does happen and Mercedes haven't been bullet proof in that regard at all.
They haven't, but they're usually fairly on the ball. I know it's very conspiracy theory of me, but I think it was to save face for Hamilton. Have to say I lost a bit of interest in the sport after that. Pinch of salt nowadays. Still watching though 🙈
JuneDr · 13/12/2021 14:26

There's definitely a question mark over how the rules were applied. But I am glad overall that Max won. I think he has done brilliantly this season and deserved it. Afterall, the decision by the FIA wasn't his doing, he made the most of the situation he was in as would any other driver. If it had been Lewis he'd have done exactly the same and as a whole I think Max (well he has by the statistics) has done better this season.

DogInATent · 13/12/2021 14:24

Dh is old enough to remember Senna driving into Prost & no one was on the phone to their lawyers.
I'm old enough to remember Mansell pushing his car over the finish line, and cars routinely having to run through the marbles on the slow-down lap to make sure the car made minimum weight for regulations.

F1 has always had rules. There have always been gains and losses as a result of them.

PS. Russell drove Lewis's car when Lewis was unable to drive because Russell will be driving for Mercedes next season and he was never going to be a contender this season. It's not unusual and many other well-known drivers have driven for the 'wrong' team mid-season.

It will be interesting to see how Lewis treats George next season. Will he nurture a younger driver?

JuneDr · 13/12/2021 14:22

@BiscuitBean

Also to add, I think Mercedes second objection was the fact that Verstappen was level (arguably ahead) with Hamilton before the SC came in.
He wasn't when the SC came in and the race restarted though, hence why it was rejected. That was a desperate attempt at an appeal.
MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 14:22

Apparently Mercedes have withdrawn their appeal, which I think is for the best.

Let F1 celebrate its new champion, and relish a new era.

Pohtaytoes · 13/12/2021 14:21

Well, there is a lot of shite in this thread. F1 is being run now as a viewer attention grabbing drama due to who owns it now sadly.
In a way it's good that Netflix Drive to Survive has garnered F1 new fans, but many of them sadly appear to be rather ignorant of F1 rules and regulations. The toxicity of F1 fans has ramped up hugely in the past three years. Exhibits of this are in this thread.

There is no way in hell that race should have ended like that and it most definitely needs to be investigated by an outside party like CAS.

As a fairly neutral party being a McLaren fan, I'm shocked by what has happened this season. It would never ever have happened under Charlie Whiting the previous race director. FIA has always had it's issues, e.g in the Schumacher and Ferrari power years, but it was never this bad.

I support Mercedes taking them to court, it won't affect Max's championship, however it will keep the focus on the terrible decisions made by Masi and his stewards and hopefully next year we can get fairer and more consistent stewardship.

Max's title is forever going to be tainted by this, and for once the mess was not his doing, but Michael Masi and his stewards. Max himself didn't put a foot wrong in the race, but it should have been Lewis' victory without a doubt.

This is going to be even more poorly regarded as a world championship win than Schumacher's was in 1994.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 14:20

If you were further down the field and had a lapped car in front of you, that wasn’t allowed to pass, couldn’t you argue it was unfair because you didn’t therefore get the chance to have a go at the car in front of you in terms of track position?

Drivers have spoken about it already. No positions changed in either the drivers’ or the constructors’ championship yesterday, so I guess they don’t believe it’s worth the extra work now that the season is finally over. They probably just want to go home.

The only swap in the WDC was Carlos getting P5 and Charles P7, and I don’t think them being in the right order at the restart would have made a big difference. Maybe Charles could’ve gotten Lando if he gained two positions, but that’s very unlikely. In any case, Ferrari let it go because it didn’t matter at the end of the day.

The drivers have said it was all very strange and confusing. They will probably demand some explanations. Let’s not forget some of them sit on different boards and committees that decide how the regulations and safety rules should be applied. They represent their colleagues’ views so they will most certainly ask for clarification.

FlorenceWintle · 13/12/2021 14:20

while Red Bull threw all caution to the wind and used everything they had.

Because they were going to lose so it’s easy to make the decision to do that. No point being cautious when you’re staring defeat in the face! And it worked for them.

You might be a Max fan and I agree he is a worthy winner but can you honestly say there’s not a bit of a question mark over how the rules were applied?

incywincyspiders · 13/12/2021 14:19

People comparing F1 with football.. it isn't comparable. Most laps led does not mean that you will win. That is the beauty with F1 - anything can change at any given point of a race. That is where strategy (and luck a lot of the time) comes in.

People are also kind of missing the point. Lewis absolutely deserved to win the race yesterday. But he didn't deserve to win the championship this year. The FIA have heavily favoured Mercedes the entire season, Max has lost at least three wins through no fault of his own (or the car). Max got some of the luck that Lewis has benefited from multiple times this season...

CupcakesK · 13/12/2021 14:19

Both drivers totally deserved the title, before the race I said I'd be happy with either and the person who drove the best race deserved to win. To end like it did is beyond ridiculous and I don't think I'll be watching next year..

The whole situation with teams on the radio to MM over the last few races has been absolutely farcical - it's like players surrounding the ref in football, no respect and doesn't do anyone's reputation any good. However, when MM and the FIA are seeming to make the rules up as they go along, I can't really blame RB and Mercedes for acting the way they have.

Both TW and CH have acted badly in the second half of the championship, but the way CH has sounded in the media and on the radio is desperate - like someone who was looking at losing their job if MV didn't win (or RB didn't win the constructors title).

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 14:19

I just hope Russell ends up being more of a Rosberg type teammate, rather than Bottas.

I think he'll be more of an Alonso! Fully expecting sparks to fly, should be a fun one.

Naillig222 · 13/12/2021 14:19

The football analogy is ridiculous because it completely misses out on what the actual problem was yesterday (the unlapping rules).
Losing advantage due to safety car and pitting are normal.

SpaceshiptoMars · 13/12/2021 14:18

I think the FIA are simply giving LH a huge hint that it is time to move over and give the youngsters a chance. If one driver consistently wins, year after year, people stop watching.

However, they may have created a monster for themselves. They'll need to rein Max in before he actually kills someone. The video of his car sitting on top of Lewis' head was alarming.

The papers were interesting. Almost universally, the front page pictures were large one of LH, small one of MV. Usually the other way round, winner v. loser.

logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 14:18

Some bloke drove a
Fast car faster than another bloke.

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 13/12/2021 14:18

They all play silly buggers on the track (well, almost all).

Lewis drove Max off at Silverstone.
Max drove him off yesterday and was 'salty' (great term!) about having to give the place back last week.
Michael S drive Barrichello into a wall and Damon H off the track (and loads of other stuff Grin.
Alonso had to have known about crashgate.
Vettel clearly went back on team race agreements with Webber (Multi-21).
Tyrell fired lead shots out of the car to lighten it up - ha!
Jenson drove a car with a secret second fuel tank - double ha!
Senna deliberately took Prost out in Japan 1990

I don't think any are all good, or all bad. Human nature simply is more complication than that.

MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 14:18

I don't think I've ever seen any suggestion it wasn't a mistake (Russell's tyres). It's the sort of mistake that does happen and Mercedes haven't been bullet proof in that regard at all.

BorgQueen · 13/12/2021 14:17

If Mercedes had brought Lewis in for new tyres during either incident, Max might not have been able to pass him on the final lap. It’s the Mercedes team’s poor judgement that cost Lewis the race as much as anything. They gambled, they lost.

PizzaCrust · 13/12/2021 14:17

@Naillig222

Neither of those things. I completely understand about the cars and Russell's ability.

I don't believe that Mercedes accidently put on the wrong tyres. And then pitted him when he flew up ahead again.

Oh this fucking infuriated me. There's not a chance in hell they accidentally put on the wrong tyres, as you say.

I just hope Russell ends up being more of a Rosberg type teammate, rather than Bottas. Bottas is an amazing driver but I wish he'd been allowed to race without having to think about the golden boy every time. And, yes, I know Checo helped Max in the last race but there's a big difference between helping a teammate in an equal points finale as opposed to constantly having to back off so your teammate can swan to victory.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 14:15

As the F1 community, commentators etc, have been saying all year long, Mercedes have been unchallenged since 2014. They’ve done some mistakes every year, but it did not affect them in any way due to the huge advantage they had. They could afford screw ups because they were going to win anyway.

You only have to look at all the mistakes Mercedes have made this season, to understand why George’s tyre mixup at the end of 2020 will most likely have been genuine. They’ve made mistakes, just like every other team, some of them huge. It was unfortunate that one of them happened in Sakhir but I don’t agree that it was done on purpose, because they’ve displayed that same behaviour time and time again this year.