Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what happened in the F1 yesterday?

242 replies

WonderingWoman30 · 13/12/2021 11:58

I am trying to get my head around what happened with Lewis v Max in the F1 yesterday! I have read articles and was watching it… but I don’t understand the controversy… can anyone explain in (very) simple terms?! Xmas Blush

OP posts:
Ansjovis · 13/12/2021 15:05

After the Belgian GP, where there was an extensive debate as to whether the race had actually started or not, I wasn't surprised at what happened yesterday. The race director then set a precedent that he could and would make up rules on the spot and that has continued.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 15:03

@eggsandwich

If I was Max I would be pretty gutted to of won my first Grand Prix like that.

Max was always going to be a future champion but yesterday’s race just turned into a needless farce.

Yesterday was Max’s 20th Grand Prix win.

If you mean championship, I don’t see why he should be gutted about it. They started working towards that championship back in March, what happened yesterday doesn’t take away from either competitor’s work throughout the season. Max had more wins (even excluding Abu Dhabi), more podiums, more poles and led more laps than Lewis, and he had 2 more retirements on top. That’s 50 potential points he lost out on, 75 if we count Hungary. He’s been superior this year, both him and RB’s approach to each race.

The race was a farce, the championship wasn’t.

DogInATent · 13/12/2021 15:00

For those saying that LH/Mercedes should have put on fresh tyres under the safety car.
By the time of the last SC session it was too late. It was the previous SC.

Mercedes have been repeatedly calling tyre strategy badly. Even Lewis was questioning the team's decision when he realised Max had changed to a fresh set of Soft tyres. It was a gamble for Red Bull, but they knew it was a circuit with a high likelihood of a further SC incident as tyres aged.

All season Red Bull have been getting the under-cut on Mercedes on routine pit stops, and making better calls on reactive pit stops under safety car conditions. The end result has been that Max has been in a better position after routine stops and he's usually had better tyres than Lewis in the closing stages of the race. Too often Lewis has been given the instruction to nurse tyres and mind the curbs to avoid punctures.

I don't think safety car procedures have changed very much in a long time. It was always practice to clear the lapped cars out of the way, and the pack has always bunched up behind the safety car. They clear the lapped cars because it's safer and creates better racing. What might have changed is the number of safety car incidents in a season. They do seem to bring it out (and the virtual safety car) far more often. Part of this is down to circuit design, and part of it is the cars - they're far more fragile and there's a lot more bits to fall off with the complex wings and aerodynamics.

Swirlywoo · 13/12/2021 14:59

Masi made up a rule at the end of the race Lewis was winning, to engineer a more exciting finish, is basically what happened.

Horner would have been equally livid.

Both Max and Lewis are fantastic drivers and did not deserve this shitshow ending. Also how they pay tax is irrelevant.

mydogisthebest · 13/12/2021 14:59

Not sure that Susie Wolff needs sympathy. I would far rather be married to Toto than the whinging windbag that is Horner. Toto is also far better looking.

maxelly · 13/12/2021 14:54

@Lazypuppy

Mercedes screwed up on strategy and didn't pit hamilton for fresh tyres and now Toto wolff is throwing his toys out the pram. If hamilton had been pitted like he asked twice he would have beat vertsappen on that final lap.

Mercedes have had so much luck with safety cars going theit way this year.

Also they still won constructors, and Bottas has now just been ignored by mercedes even though that was his final race. Awful from toto and mercedes regardless of result

I mean in hindsight, perhaps yes, but where/when are you saying they should have pitted? Before the safety car/after Max's stop? He would have come out behind Max and in traffic, no guarantee of getting through even with the SC in play which of course at that point they didn't know was coming. After the SC - then Max would in all likelihood have stayed out having seen Lewis pit so Lewis would have been the one stuck behind the other cars, even assuming the same thing would have happened with the lapping/unlapping decision, it would have been Lewis on new mediums or used softs (I think someone upthread said he had no new softs left, they were used in quali) vs Max on slightly used mediums, again no guarantee of the win there. This is controversial speculation obviously but my view is in either scenario Max would have driven extremely aggressively to stop Lewis getting by him, if they both crashed Max took the championship anyway on tiebreak so you can see why Merc took what they thought was a safety-first approach by staying out and maintaining the biggest possible gap....
eggsandwich · 13/12/2021 14:53

If I was Max I would be pretty gutted to of won my first Grand Prix like that.

Max was always going to be a future champion but yesterday’s race just turned into a needless farce.

JuneDr · 13/12/2021 14:52

If hamilton had been pitted like he asked twice he would have beat vertsappen on that final lap

Yes Lewis wasn't happy with that decision way before the lapped cars issue happened.

He even said at one point 'is he right behind me' and they told him 'yes if the lapped cars are made to move'. He knew he'd lose on the older tires if that happened.

Lazypuppy · 13/12/2021 14:48

Mercedes screwed up on strategy and didn't pit hamilton for fresh tyres and now Toto wolff is throwing his toys out the pram. If hamilton had been pitted like he asked twice he would have beat vertsappen on that final lap.

Mercedes have had so much luck with safety cars going theit way this year.

Also they still won constructors, and Bottas has now just been ignored by mercedes even though that was his final race. Awful from toto and mercedes regardless of result

TangfasticsAreFantastic · 13/12/2021 14:47

@BHX3000

My greatest sympathies, however, go to Susie Wolff... I think I'd have been sleeping in the spare room last night if I was her!

From all the videos and photos on social media, I’m assuming she got a good night’s sleep with the bed to herself. Toto was partying until the small hours and he did not look sober enough to find his way back to the hotel, even the one on the track Grin

Ha ha! I didn't see that! In which case, I won't want to be her today. Hungover and angry Toto does not sound fun!
JuneDr · 13/12/2021 14:47

@RunningFromInsanity

Lewis deserved to win the race but Max deserved to win the Championship.
Yes this.
MindyStClaire · 13/12/2021 14:45

@cuparfull

Imagine you were in a running race and the race was paused ...(as behind the safety car) then the 6 people behind the leader of the race were allowed past the 1 placed person....because they were actually a lap behind the first and 7th placed.

Then allow the 7th placed person to catch up closer to the 1st placed person....and then restart the race for a single lap.

The race director effectively gave the 7th placed person an advantage by clearing the obstructing cars and allowing a narrowing of the distance between the 1st and 7th on the track.
The 7th on the track had faster, newer tyres and won.

Totally unfair in any book but given F1 are self regulating, the turkeys aren't going to vote for Christmas are they. Total sham!!!

By 7th, you mean 2nd.
BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 14:45

My greatest sympathies, however, go to Susie Wolff... I think I'd have been sleeping in the spare room last night if I was her!

From all the videos and photos on social media, I’m assuming she got a good night’s sleep with the bed to herself. Toto was partying until the small hours and he did not look sober enough to find his way back to the hotel, even the one on the track Grin

CupcakesK · 13/12/2021 14:45

For those saying that LH/Mercedes should have put on fresh tyres under the safety car...

The point is that the FIA are making the rules up as they go along - in this case they could have then decided to end the race under the safety car and then LH would have lost out in this scenario too. The FIA are basically saying it is their decision to make which surely no longer makes it a competitive sport.

That's why the whole situation is farcical. I hope it does go through the courts, not that LH should win but so the FIA are forced to do something about their ridiculous behaviour.

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 13/12/2021 14:43

@BHX3000

May I also say, how great it is that Mumsnet is discussing F1 in such detail? Even if for the wrong reasons 🙈

This is so much less toxic than Reddit or Twitter, if I don’t remember to set up a discussion thread when the new season starts, someone else please do it!

Yes to this!
cuparfull · 13/12/2021 14:42

Imagine you were in a running race and the race was paused ...(as behind the safety car) then the 6 people behind the leader of the race were allowed past the 1 placed person....because they were actually a lap behind the first and 7th placed.

Then allow the 7th placed person to catch up closer to the 1st placed person....and then restart the race for a single lap.

The race director effectively gave the 7th placed person an advantage by clearing the obstructing cars and allowing a narrowing of the distance between the 1st and 7th on the track.
The 7th on the track had faster, newer tyres and won.

Totally unfair in any book but given F1 are self regulating, the turkeys aren't going to vote for Christmas are they. Total sham!!!

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 14:42

May I also say, how great it is that Mumsnet is discussing F1 in such detail? Even if for the wrong reasons 🙈

This is so much less toxic than Reddit or Twitter, if I don’t remember to set up a discussion thread when the new season starts, someone else please do it!

OhdearOhdearOhdearIndeed · 13/12/2021 14:41

@senua

In very simple terms: Formula 1 decided that it is no longer a sport; it is a manufactured TV entertainment with predetermined outcomes, akin to WWE.
Grin

I think it was a bad decision. If it was any other race the normal rules would have stood. They wanted an entertaining final lap, but you can't just change the rules of the sport just for entertainment purposes. Where does it stop?

TangfasticsAreFantastic · 13/12/2021 14:41

Whoa - didn't think that was so long! Blush

TangfasticsAreFantastic · 13/12/2021 14:41

There was a lot to disagree with yesterday and now Michael Masi has put the FIA in a really awkward position.

You can't take away the win from Max because Red Bull played it perfectly, using every opportunity that was presented to them, just as any racing driver or team would do. They were very fortunate to have had a "free" pitstop available when the SC came out, and they'd have been stupid not to take it.

It's also not their fault that Masi decided to play by his own rules (as others have alluded to - there seems to be a much higher need to produce "entertainment" since the new American owners came in).

Mercedes, rightfully, have an axe to grind. The rules give two options plus a get out of jail "race director has authority" rule that's never been an issue before. Unfortunately even if they did know what Masi was going to do, they'd have been screwed. If they'd pitted, Max would have stayed out and Lewis would have lost track position, so it was a bit of a lose-lose scenario in that respect.

I can't see the FIA changing the result, but I think some rules will end up changing and heads will roll. What form of compensation there will be for Mercedes is unclear. It's the kind of thing that could lead to teams boycotting F1 in the future, which is clearly not good for the sport.

Either Masi needs to go (though the commentary team were saying that who else would want the job!), or at the very least they need to ban in race communications between the race director and the teams.

Masi has no say on penalties, etc. That's all down to the stewards team. He is purely in charge of controlling the race itself. He seemed to not handle the stress of yesterday very well at all.

Mercedes aren't innocent in everything that happened yesterday. Lewis should have given the place back, or clearly reduced the advantage he got by going off track. Then Lewis was complaining that Perez was driving dangerously. Bollocks he was - he was racing, and bloody good racing it was too - I had no concerns whatsoever that they were going to take each other off. From that point of view Perez is a much "cleaner" driver than Max.

I had no preference on who was to win - I'm an F1 fan, not a fan of any driver in particular. It's fair to say that F1 lost yesterday though.

And as for comments re George's tweets. I too was very disappointed in his comments. It's sad to see him becoming a Mercedes puppet before he's even got his boots in the door. I hope to god Merc allow him to race next year.

My greatest sympathies, however, go to Susie Wolff... I think I'd have been sleeping in the spare room last night if I was her!

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 14:38

@MindyStClaire

Remember Belgium where Verstappen led the cars round the track for 2 laps behind a safety car before the race was stopped, gaining him an extra win and half points?

That wasn't to favour Max or RB. It was because of the massive financial implications of not running the race. Anyone on pole would have been given the same chance. It's nearly happened before but the weather has cleared in time to have a race. It was inevitable it would happen some time.

Exactly. I also don’t see people complaining about George’s ‘podium’. If anything I’ve seen suggestions he could’ve won the race or something like that, had they run it. People will see what they want to see.

A few times in F1 history, qualifying has mattered more than the race. That’s why good qualifying results earned those drivers points in Belgium. You could argue Monaco is the same, it awards qualifying results. That’s F1.

threebillboards · 13/12/2021 14:38

It was farcical

TinyPaws · 13/12/2021 14:38

Farcical. I don't think I'll bother watching next year. What's the point, if the FIA can decide at the last minute to depart from their own rules to all but crown their chosen champion?

RunningFromInsanity · 13/12/2021 14:35

Lewis deserved to win the race but Max deserved to win the Championship.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 14:34

Hamilton didn’t drive Verstappen off the track at Silverstone. He had the advantage at the bend.

If you look at the images, telemetry analysis and official investigation reports, you’d see this isn’t true. Lewis was at no point ahead of Max.

Lewis was penalised for that move, just like Max was penalised in Monza or Jeddah. The issue is how inconsistent the penalties have been this year. It used to be that pulling the move Lewis did (and sending your opponent to hospital) was a drive through or stop and go penalty. Not an insignificant 10 second penalty which did nothing to prevent him from winning the race.

They’ve both driven aggressively, and that’s why the battle was so exciting throughout. The race was clean yesterday from lap 2 onwards, and neither of them deserved the end they got. For once, it wasn’t their fault that the FIA screwed up.