Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what happened in the F1 yesterday?

242 replies

WonderingWoman30 · 13/12/2021 11:58

I am trying to get my head around what happened with Lewis v Max in the F1 yesterday! I have read articles and was watching it… but I don’t understand the controversy… can anyone explain in (very) simple terms?! Xmas Blush

OP posts:
senua · 13/12/2021 17:58

the rules are the for Safety first and Fairness second.
You are still doing mental gymnastics to justify the status quo.
They will know the relative positions of the cars when SC is announced eg P2 is 10 seconds slower than P1; P3 is another 4 seconds; etc. Have SC as at present (so presumably satisfies your safety concerns), have bunching at the re-start but ... when you get to the end of the race add on the 10 seconds, 4 seconds, etc. It takes out most of the unfairness.

Fluffycloudland77 · 13/12/2021 17:57

I find Crofty biased and sometimes just downright bonkers ‘Will Bottas win today after getting P2 yesterday? IS THIS HIS YEAR FOR THE CHAMPIONSHIP!!!!!”

Well Crofty, let’s go with no as;

He’s not allowed to win.
He goes backwards at the start & backs the midfield up causing accidents
He has no spatial awareness and panics in traffic.

Despite all this “oooh he could WIN today” Theoretically Mazepin could win but you need to stay grounded in reality when your commentating and not go off into your own little alternative reality where Bottas is a serious contender & not LH patsy. Dh and I wonder if there’s two Bottas and we just need to pay the extra fee to see the one challenging LH for the championship. He only pulls his finger out when his contracts up for re-signing.

Brundles much better. Rosberg is a legend 😂 and calls a spade a spade. DH licks LH arse so much 🙄 CH shut him down recently.

goldfluffyclouds · 13/12/2021 17:52

Sunday's are too hectic in our house so we quite happily just record C4 and watch about 10pm...
Hate Steve Jones but can live with it (or fast forward) as it's free!!!
But I do have to be careful to avoid social media or my father in law!!!

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 17:51

@senua what do we do then, change the whole way in which F1 works? The rules that have governed the sport for 71 years? Do we also get rid of the technical regulations by which teams design their cars? So they’re all the same and nobody has an advantage from driving the best car? What do we do, introduce spec cars, to simplify things? And get rid of the feeder series which is where spec cars belong?

F1 has never been a real level-playing field. As a driver, no matter how good you are, you need to be in the right team at the right time in order to win. That’s down to luck.

F1 is an engineering competition first (hence the world formula, a driving competition second, and a political show third. Even though politics are overtaking everything else lately. Getting rid of anything that can give someone an advantage would destroy the sport’s essence.

DogInATent · 13/12/2021 17:50

@senua - the rules are the for Safety first and Fairness second.

If you want to know why, have a look at how it used to be.

senua · 13/12/2021 17:41

I've copied this off another thread:
"Another trap is thinking that if you need to perform mental gymnastics in order to make a theory work, those mental gymnastics are a sign of your intelligence. You are therefore consider yourself more intelligent than the people who think you are wrong, because those people are not clever enough to understand your mental gymnastics."

That's my take on the Safety Car. I think that the current set-up is unfair. I'm not talking yesterday's race specifically (where it cost LH his 11 second lead), but generally. The aficionado are saying I'm wrong because I don't understand the complexities of F1 blah blah. I'm saying they are wrong - rules in sport are there to make a level playing field, not to create an extra piece-of-bad-luck to overcome.

DogInATent · 13/12/2021 17:40

Honestly, you don't need much German to understand F1 commentary!

ORF and Servus alternate which of them shows each race. So you set your VPN to Austria and then bring up the Live TV website of whichever has the turn that week. I used to watch on RTL, using a second dish and decoder that we had set-up for German TV in the UK anyway. But Sky have got that market too now.

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 17:36

I actually think Crofty and Martin Brundle are quite okay when it comes to bias, especially in recent years. The Sky feed is now used for all international broadcasting in English, including F1TV, so they need to keep it more neutral. There used be a lot more British bias, it’s less nowadays.

They do still have an obsession with George and he can do no wrong in their eyes. Ferrari are either the evil (when they’re good), or non-existent (when they aren’t). It’s been the latter this year, especially Sainz - the man must be invisible to them. Hill, Button, Rosberg and company are another topic altogether, but I always enjoy hearing their views.

Bias is understandable and to be expected in any sport, also F1 is inherently British. But you can find bias in other countries as well, it’s only natural. Spain’s Antonio Lobato is obsessed with Sainz, and took his final standings as proof that he’s beaten Leclerc this year Grin

Angelcupcake · 13/12/2021 17:23

That's a shame, I don't understand much German...could just try it anyway, but I quite enjoy listening to the commentary, it makes it more exciting!

Angelcupcake · 13/12/2021 17:19

I just googled servus and ORF... do you understand German? It's probably quite interesting hearing the commentary from another country. They must have a different take on events... I'm sure our commentators must be biased!

BHX3000 · 13/12/2021 17:18

@DogInATent I watch with a VPN too, the Swiss channels usually. I’m fluent in all 3 - French, German and Italian - so I swap between RTS, SRF and RSI depending on my mood that week. With the occasional online stream 🙈 of either Sky in English (Sky Italy for Monza!), or DAZN in my native language.

I also have F1TV Access so can rewatch the ‘race in 30’ with Crofty and Brundle after it finishes. I really like comparing the different views and takes each broadcaster has. Although I wish F1TV Pro was an option in countries such as the UK or Germany, because I’d happily pay for that and be able to watch it live, fully legally. I’ve tried using my family’s DAZN account with a VPN but it also doesn’t work. You’d think it was Netflix! Grin

@Angelcupcake Servus and ORF are public TV channels in Austria, they broadcast the races for free. If you speak good German they’re a good option for watching with a VPN.

RunningFromInsanity · 13/12/2021 17:07

@Chesneyhawkes1

I don't mind the tax exile thing but the vegan dog is taking it too far.

I was pleased to see Max win.

Again, veganism for dogs is not terrible if researched properly. For dogs like bulldogs who are plagued with skin issues and allergies cutting out meat etc can often sort out their problems. I imagine his dog has a top notch diet.
Angelcupcake · 13/12/2021 17:06

We watch it on sky, and record it if I'm working/we're out with the DC. DP pays but it's expensive, keeps thinking about cancelling because it feels indulgent, C4 highlights just aren't the same.
I wasn't aware of these other platforms for watching it... Are servus and ORF based abroad?

Chesneyhawkes1 · 13/12/2021 16:59

I don't mind the tax exile thing but the vegan dog is taking it too far.

I was pleased to see Max win.

DogInATent · 13/12/2021 16:53

Hopefully, over the closed season, the interested parties (manufacturers, GPDA, Liberty Media, track owners) can get together and learn a few lessons from this season so that there's clearer guidance to Race Directors as to what the objectives are. Allow Race Directors to exercise a degree of flexibility to respond within overall objectives - safety, fairness, and racing.

I don't think there's anything wrong with employing former drivers as Race Directors. Most drivers have raced for more than one team. It doesn't take much awareness of the history of Formula 1 to realise that driver and spectator safety has to come first. Making a good spectacle for television is down the list.

Anyway.. off the main topic, how's everyone been watching the F1 this season? It was quite a change for me to watch it with English commentary this weekend. I've been using a VPN to watch it online on either Servus or ORF most of the season since RTL lost it to Sky.

Swirlywoo · 13/12/2021 16:39

Their tax situation is completely irrelevant to the last lap of yesterday's race.

RemorselessNorsemen · 13/12/2021 16:39

@RunningFromInsanity

Max also lives in Monaco, along with several other drivers, including British Alex Albon and soon Lando Norris. All for tax reasons.

And it’s hardly like Lewis is popping back to use the NHS services Wink

Alex Albon has a house in Milton Keynes that he bought when he signed. He lives there a fair bit of the year because it's handy for the factory. You can often spot him out for a jog around Furzton Lake in the off season. The apartment in Monaco he rents from David Coulthard.
JuneDr · 13/12/2021 16:37

And you can't grumble too much, pay me millions and I'd be living there too!

RunningFromInsanity · 13/12/2021 16:36

Max also lives in Monaco, along with several other drivers, including British Alex Albon and soon Lando Norris. All for tax reasons.

And it’s hardly like Lewis is popping back to use the NHS services Wink

RemorselessNorsemen · 13/12/2021 16:33

Meanwhile, I continue to grumble about the fact I should have been going to a team Christmas party on Friday night and it's been bloody cancelled. Sodding Covid.

RemorselessNorsemen · 13/12/2021 16:32

@ChloeCrocodile

To allow some to unlap but not others is the farce.

Absolutely this. I really like that strategy (including tyres and potential for SC) is a huge part of F1 and it really adds to my enjoyment of the sport. I'm also glad that Hamilton and Mercedes are no longer winning everything without much of a battle. I watch a lot of different sports so I'm completely accustomed to the idea that some decisions are subjective and some are plain wrong. But in this instance the officials knowingly disregarded the rules because they were more concerned about the spectacle than fairness. That is just wrong in any sport.

I think this probably goes back to a decision made earlier in the season, collectively by all teams, that wherever possible a race should be finished under 'green flag conditions'. This was discussed throughout all entrants to the races and agreed by all.

I think Masi knew that finishing it under a safety car would have caused controversy so opted for what he thought was probably the path of least resistance, get the back markers that were directly in the way out and let the two race to the line. This was compounded by the fact that time was ticking due to difficulties in moving Latifi's car and there were not enough laps of the race to do what he wanted.

It will be talked about forever I imagine, viewing figures for Drive To Survive will be through the roof this year and the sport will have the huge resurgence it's been looking for.

LakieLady · 13/12/2021 16:31

@MrsFin

I'm pretty pleased Hamilton didn't win though - based on the fact that he pays no/very little tax in the UK. He lives in Monaco, though he owns residences elsewhere in the world. He specifically told Parkinson in an interview years ago that he had decided not to live in the UK to avoid taxation.
Yep, same here. I have no truck with tax exiles like him, Tina & Philip Green, Richard Branson etc.

And I went right off MotoGP's Cal Crutchlow when he moved to the Isle of Man, presumably for tax reasons.

HalfWomanHalfMincePie · 13/12/2021 16:28

@Angelcupcake

That's a bit mean wisper... I'm enjoying the discussion! Nobody at work/home is interested in talking about f1 with me! 😊
Me too! Grin
Angelcupcake · 13/12/2021 16:28

That's a bit mean wisper... I'm enjoying the discussion! Nobody at work/home is interested in talking about f1 with me! 😊

Wisper1 · 13/12/2021 16:24

Nothing happened, the whingerthon / yawnathon continues. There's been no real racing since the 90's. When someone trys, in this case Max, the other team(s) goes blubbing to the teacher.