Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the vast majority of people would think that allowing rapists to self ID as women is completely batshit?

104 replies

Galvantula · 13/12/2021 11:33

The people all over Twitter jumping to defend the rights of men to force everyone to refer to then as a woman, after raping them with their actual penis... Just wtf?

But no, JK Rowling is a bigot for highlighting this nonsense.

She shared this article about the Scottish Police who want to #bekind to the poor rapists and also fuck up all the statistics. The tiny % of sexual offences carried out by women doesn't take much to skew.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/6d5deff8-5acc-11ec-a18c-c6d6c5855d8c?shareToken=950f24c7503003e07e782cf76b53d56f

twitter.com/jk_rowling/status/1470092815506063365?t=4nIz6ltkdNO0Jp6PDGmKiw&s=19

OP posts:
Elsiebear90 · 13/12/2021 17:01

The thing that gets me the most is their arguments aren’t even logical, for example, if you say that anyone can be a woman, all they have to do is “believe” they are one, there is no genetic, hormonal, physical, behavioural etc requirement, then you’re changing the definition of the word woman from “adult human female” to something undefinable, a meaningless belief. If the term woman can mean anything then it is meaningless.

There are so many of their views and arguments that defy logic, but this is the main one that really made me start questioning whether people (including myself) are just blindly accepting this ideology without even thinking about what they’re defending or arguing for.

lifeturnsonadime · 13/12/2021 16:51

Anyone who thinks that it is OK to mis sex an adult human male who uses his penis as a weapon to rape another person (mostly women) is a rape apologist.

The number of men on twitter who are bending over backwards to vilify JKR for pointing out the obvious is absolutely disgusting.

It is clear that the only kind of 'women' who matter to these misogynistic men are the adult human male kind.

Putting the feelings of the rapist above those of the victims is unforgivable. A person is not raped by a gender identity. It is a thing that only an adult human male can do (with very limited exceptions in this country). What special feelings make an adult human male rapist who has weaponised his penis not a man?????

I am so angry about this.

Fidgetty · 13/12/2021 16:42

YANBU. In real life no adult I know would agree with this. It's only people who spend an inordinate amount of time on social media who get sucked in to trans ideology. However that unfortunately means the younger generation are particularly susceptible. It's the perfect storm of over use of the internet mixed with limited life experience/critical thinking skills. We can only hope they grow out of it!

The adults going along with it - politicians/policy makers - are usually woefully uninformed and simply think this is the latest social justice bandwagon they can jump on. If you asked them in private if they truly think a rapist with a penis is an actual woman they'd surely never agree?! It's actual insanity that it has come to this and has made me become incredibly cynical about the intelligence of the human race. It appears I had vastly overestimated it.

DdraigGoch · 13/12/2021 16:23

@daimbarsatemydogsbone

YANBU I suspect most ordinary people haven’t been following this too closely.

I do worry though - we had a long car trip at the weekend and DD (13) reeled off a long list of reasons to hate JKR - this anti-debate approach seems to have a lot of traction with younger people.

It's just like the Chinese cultural revolution.
HereticFanjo · 13/12/2021 16:22

YANBU and we all know it. Only a mischief maker could argue against this. It is indefensible.

Shedmistress · 13/12/2021 16:19

But, can you imagine if Wayne Couzens suddenly identified as female? Do you think Twitter would be demanding that he was allowed into a female prison?

There was a thread on here a few years back about Ian Huntley, as a news report had stated that he was now identifying as a woman. And a fair few MNers were up in arms that people were calling him 'he' and not 'she'.

Ian Huntely. The man who raped and murdered school girls. The man whose crimes kicked off CRB/DBS checks.

Misgendering was what they were upset against.

Luckily it wasn't true. However Karen White...

PleasantBirthday · 13/12/2021 16:07

@bibbidybobbidyboo

I wonder if part of the reason things have gotten this far is because none of the people who have done this have gripped the public consciousness. But, can you imagine if Wayne Couzens suddenly identified as female? Do you think Twitter would be demanding that he was allowed into a female prison?
Honestly? Yes. I do believe that people are so invested in this and have abandoned reason and their own perception of right and wrong to the degree that they would support that entirely.
nothingcomestonothing · 13/12/2021 15:50

Who are the 3% who invariably vote YABU to these threads? Come on, have the courage of your convictions if that's what you think and say why!

bibbidybobbidyboo · 13/12/2021 15:30

I wonder if part of the reason things have gotten this far is because none of the people who have done this have gripped the public consciousness. But, can you imagine if Wayne Couzens suddenly identified as female? Do you think Twitter would be demanding that he was allowed into a female prison?

VickyEadieofThigh · 13/12/2021 15:23

Come on, those who voted 'YABU' - tell us WHY.

Galvantula · 13/12/2021 15:18

@purpleboy

When will those in power wake up and see what they are doing?
Sturgeon knows fine but is all for it and says women's concerns aren't valid. Some fuckin feminist.
OP posts:
purpleboy · 13/12/2021 15:00

When will those in power wake up and see what they are doing?

sst1234 · 13/12/2021 14:13

Most people are too scared to speak out, for fear of being hounded by the aggressive trans lobby. This is misogyny if the highest order and it’s being state sanctioned.

DrSbaitso · 13/12/2021 14:02

@Thirtytimesround

The hate against JK Rowling is only understandable if you think about why untalented non-famous men, who want to be women, would hate the first self-made female billionaire writer, the first person to lose billionaire status through charitable giving, the menopausal domestic violence victim who refuses to let men define what it is to be female, and who has held fast to her beliefs despite daily rape/death threats when it would have been sooooo easy to just grovel to the bullies like almost every other public figure has done...

I am so, so proud that there are women like JK Rowling in the world, and I hope that when teens parrot the misogynist propaganda against her, the parents of those teens bother to parent their kids properly and push back on this hate.

This is an excellent post.

I'd add that attempting to terrorise women with rape and death threats has been around forever and is certainly nothing new on the Internet. The only thing that's new is that this time, they're claiming they're women.

FireworkParrot · 13/12/2021 13:49

@Thirtytimesround

The hate against JK Rowling is only understandable if you think about why untalented non-famous men, who want to be women, would hate the first self-made female billionaire writer, the first person to lose billionaire status through charitable giving, the menopausal domestic violence victim who refuses to let men define what it is to be female, and who has held fast to her beliefs despite daily rape/death threats when it would have been sooooo easy to just grovel to the bullies like almost every other public figure has done...

I am so, so proud that there are women like JK Rowling in the world, and I hope that when teens parrot the misogynist propaganda against her, the parents of those teens bother to parent their kids properly and push back on this hate.

I could not agree more.
Thirtytimesround · 13/12/2021 13:32

The hate against JK Rowling is only understandable if you think about why untalented non-famous men, who want to be women, would hate the first self-made female billionaire writer, the first person to lose billionaire status through charitable giving, the menopausal domestic violence victim who refuses to let men define what it is to be female, and who has held fast to her beliefs despite daily rape/death threats when it would have been sooooo easy to just grovel to the bullies like almost every other public figure has done...

I am so, so proud that there are women like JK Rowling in the world, and I hope that when teens parrot the misogynist propaganda against her, the parents of those teens bother to parent their kids properly and push back on this hate.

logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 13:32

@DisappearingGirl same-same. It drives me
Mad that any discussion around gender/sex/trans etc seems
To descend into accusations of bigotry.

logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 13:30

It’s BS - at the very least they should be categorised as trans MTF to make a distinction. Women are not raping other women.

Nevertime · 13/12/2021 13:29

I work with people who have a great deal of influence over vulnerable young people.

Without exception the "right" response involves inclusion, equality, the right to choose etc. These are educated, intelligent people and to present any other argument makes you a bigot.

RustyBear · 13/12/2021 13:28

From the Times article, quote from Police Scotland:

"Police Scotland requires no evidence or certification as proof of biological sex or gender identity other than a person’s self-declaration, unless it is pertinent to any investigation with which they are linked .”

Surely their biological sex IS pertinent to the investigation of a rape!

ErrolTheDragon · 13/12/2021 13:23

I hope this thread gets to stay in AIBU. I don't actually mind having a separate board for this discussion, but this is a current news issue that people should be made aware of.

Yes, absolutely. And also there's only voting on AIBU, which is relevant to the question raised by the OP.

DisappearingGirl · 13/12/2021 13:18

YANBU, it's madness.

I very much support the rights of trans and gender-non-conforming people to get on with their lives without being harrassed. I love the idea of people being free to express themselves however they like. I would happily refer to an individual trans person by their preferred name and pronoun.

However, I am very much against the following:

  • letting any male who says "I'm a woman" into women's prisons and sports
  • drugs and surgery for teens who are exploring their identity
  • not being allowed to have a word for biologically female people

I hope this thread gets to stay in AIBU. I don't actually mind having a separate board for this discussion, but this is a current news issue that people should be made aware of.

ErrolTheDragon · 13/12/2021 13:16

YANBU.

I had a look at the comments on the Times articles - readership generally pretty sensible adults I'd guess. They overwhelmingly agree.

On Twitter - JKRs tweet has over 50k likes now.

The police quote from the Times article
Detective Superintendent Fil Capaldi said: “The sex/gender identification of individuals who come into contact with the police will be based on how they present or how they self-declare, which is consistent with the values of the organisation. Police Scotland requires no evidence or certification as proof of biological sex or gender identity other than a person’s self-declaration, unless it is pertinent to any investigation with which they are linked.”

Great. The 'values of the organisation' evidently include rank misogyny and lack of concern for the victims of crime. As to proof of biological sex.... uh, the context is rape , which in all parts of the U.K. entails penetration by a penis. How the hell does he think it's not 'pertinent'?Hmm

Beowulfa · 13/12/2021 13:15

Rape specifically requires a penis under English & Welsh law. How is referring to the male accused as "she/her" not perjury?

Gottasinggottadance · 13/12/2021 13:14

Yanbu. I can't believe people on twitter standing up for rapists over women's rights. It does really show what an echo chamber Twitter is though - vast majority of people in real life would think this is bonkers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread