Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I pay our lovely cleaner?

137 replies

Alwaysfullofquestions · 13/12/2021 09:46

We’re hiring a woman to clean once a week because work is getting busier and busier and i also have a chronic illness which causes fatigue so I struggle to keep on top of it.

My only question is how do I pay her? She wants to be paid in cash but I want to make sure I’m doing it correctly, should I be paying by BACs? Or does it not matter? Anyone I’ve hired before for things like gardening or rubbish removal has been online banking.

Just want to make sure I’m doing it right and sorry if this seems like a stupid question!

OP posts:
caketiger · 13/12/2021 12:54

Our cleaner came highly recommended and we trust her implicitly. We leave her money In a tin that's solely for her. So she doesn't have to come and ask us for her money at the end of the clean which makes everyone feel awkward. Done it this way for ten years with no issues

Offmyfence · 13/12/2021 12:47

@logsonlogsoff

‘ Yeah it's really hard work! Why not get a months out in one go, ease that massive burden.’ *@Offmyfence*

Pain in the arse,
I said. Not massive burden. PITA.

Yeah, but you could assist it by getting in once a month, it's quite easy to think outside the box!
Offmyfence · 13/12/2021 12:46

[quote Amberflames]**@Amberflames jog on - I am not responsible for knowingly helping someone to evade tax because I may cash to my cleaner

Sorry that’s not what I meant. I meant that if you pay someone in cash because you know that individual wants cash to avoid paying tax then yes you are enabling tax evasion. There is a difference.[/quote]
Well of course, that is a massive difference, but nothing OP says is pointing to that, yet still be get the cries of tax evasion!

Amberflames · 13/12/2021 12:45

@Amberflames jog on - I am not responsible for knowingly helping someone to evade tax because I may cash to my cleaner

Sorry that’s not what I meant. I meant that if you pay someone in cash because you know that individual wants cash to avoid paying tax then yes you are enabling tax evasion. There is a difference.

Roselilly36 · 13/12/2021 12:31

I used to pay my cleaner in cash, she definitely was not a tax dodger, she declared her income correctly and could claim government help for the self employed during COVID. It’s wrong to assume that everyone is trying to dodge tax.

logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 12:27

‘ Yeah it's really hard work! Why not get a months out in one go, ease that massive burden.’ @Offmyfence

Pain in the arse,
I said. Not massive burden. PITA.

DynamiteFilledRadish · 13/12/2021 12:24

This thread is a delight, isn't it.

Cleaners are tax dodgers. She's probably claiming benefits so report her. She's so poverty stricken she needs the cash for food. "Insist she does a, b & c OP". People really do think cleaners are staff, don't they.

HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 13/12/2021 12:21

@ChangeChingyChange

It's up to you, if she wants cash its because she's tax dodging. If you feel uncomfortable with this then insist on Bank transfer only. She could say no then you've lost her as a cleaner. I'd have the conversation with her before she starts. Would it really bother you that much to not just pay her in cash?
What a ridiculous thing to say! Plenty of people prefer cash, nothing to do with tax dodging.

My cleaner is paid cash, as is his hairdresser wife. It helps keep better records of who has paid and which of them is paid for which service as they have a joint account.

Maireas · 13/12/2021 12:16

It's easy. Just get the cash out and put it in an envelope.
Cash obviously suits her for reasons pp have suggested.

Dogscanteatonions · 13/12/2021 12:15

Jesus why do people assume it's tax dodging? Some people here are awful. I've done cleaning in the past and it was a really place to clean and I couldn't start till 11pm at night and got home in the early hours. The only thing that kept me going was the notes placed on my hand - it actually made it feel worthwhile. The physical reward made it tolerable.

RaisedByPangolins · 13/12/2021 12:10

All those who think cash = tax dodge are confusing people like cleaners and gardeners charging £10-15 an hour with builders charging £1000s and wanting paid in cash.

RaisedByPangolins · 13/12/2021 12:08

I take a mix of cash and bacs payments for my self employed work.

FWIW I keep track of the cash income and include it in my self assessment because I have to show that I earn at least NMW as an hourly rate to be eligible for UC.

As a full time cleaner she could well be in receipt of IN WORK benefits and to be able to show a decent income will be important to her, so ‘tax dodging’ is not actually a positive in this situation - when you’re in receipt of ‘tax credits’ you need to show a decent income or will be sanctioned as your work is deemed to be ‘not viable’.

Triffid1 · 13/12/2021 12:04

Amazon don't "dodge" tax, they do not pay much corporation tax, because they do not make much profit, businesses pay corporation tax on profit not turnover.

That's funny. Jeff Bezos is one of, if not THE richest man in the world. Of course Amazon makes lots of profit.

Having said that, I'd agree it's not tax dodging so much as legitimate tax loopholes that are irritatingly available to massive corporates like Amazon and that the tax authorities should absolutely be closing those loopholes.

@Amberflames jog on - I am not responsible for knowingly helping someone to evade tax because I may cash to my cleaner. As a pp pointed out, that would mean every time I pay cash at a market or for any other service there's a problem.

A builder who knocks of 20% for VAT IS my problem because in that case, I am basically attempting to get out of paying the VAT and HE is enabling me in my tax dodging.

Change123today · 13/12/2021 12:01

We pay our cleaner by bank transfer- but I know she only accepts this way with clients she trusts- new clients are cash until she she feels she can trust etc this is due to on more than one occasion people not paying her! Whether she is tax dodging who knows (I can’t see her earning over the threshold anyway) she has insurance which makes me feel that she all above board.

mumwon · 13/12/2021 12:00

as many pp have said being paid cash does not mean they are tax avoiders - for many it means that they are guaranteed they have been paid & they can use the money straight away. It also could be she wants to keep her money quiet from her husband/partner (which as a mn we should understand) or she feels more in control of her money if tis in cash (aka I can only spend the cash I have & not get in debt or her partner -for instance - is overdrawn at bank)

SirensofTitan · 13/12/2021 11:58

@THisbackwithavengeance

This thread highlights the double standards on MN that I've seen a few times.

The general consensus on here is that benefit fraud doesn't exist and if it does, it's fully justified in some kind of Robin Hood mentality and people would only do so out of desperation to feed their 23 kids rather than being greedy, workshy cunts.

And yet conversely there is this general consensus that anyone depriving the Exchequor of a measly few quid from a €30 job, should be prosecuted for tax dodging.

There was a thread a while back where a poster had her arse handed to her because she proposed paying her sister or someone £200 per month to watch her kids for a few hours. That was apparently illegal and she should pay a proper nanny and full tax and NI and to do anything less made her personally responsible for the NHS being short funded.

Absolutely barking.

Think about it. You clean someone else's shit for 3 hours, say £30. That £30 does not include petrol to get to the house or the time spent in traffic to and from which is unpaid. If you then had to give up say £7 of that to the taxman, it wouldn't be viable. No-one would do it, it's just not worth it. Most domestic cleaners IME don't do it fulltime, it's just pin money.

And yet the same posters all happily spending at Amazon, the biggest fucking tax dodgers ever.

You seem very angry but your post doesn't stand up to any scrutiny.

Your hypothetical cleaner earning £30 per job then deducting petrol would only be paying £7 tax if she was a higher rate tax payer which doesn't make sense unless she has another income, does she clean for not much more than minimum wage for love?

Whatever you think of amazon they don't dodge tax or do you think that all the countries they operate in and take advantage of tax laws from haven't noticed that one of the world's biggest companies is breaking their laws?

Maybe do them a favour and let them know you've spotted what armies of hugely paid lawyers can't.

Offmyfence · 13/12/2021 11:56

[quote Itsalmostanaccessory]@Amberflames

You must have missed my post. So I'll ask again.

You've said the OP would actually be committing a crime if she paid in cash. Can you show me the law and sentencing guidelines please?

She isnt involved in any scheme here. She is just paying for a service in cash, which is totally legal. You've said it isnt and she would be responsible for aiding tax evasion. So... link?[/quote]
Gosh, I pay my cleaner cash and have done for around five years, do you think I will get a custodial sentence?

Itsalmostanaccessory · 13/12/2021 11:52

@Amberflames

You must have missed my post. So I'll ask again.

You've said the OP would actually be committing a crime if she paid in cash. Can you show me the law and sentencing guidelines please?

She isnt involved in any scheme here. She is just paying for a service in cash, which is totally legal. You've said it isnt and she would be responsible for aiding tax evasion. So... link?

MatildaIThink · 13/12/2021 11:52

@THisbackwithavengeance

This thread highlights the double standards on MN that I've seen a few times.

The general consensus on here is that benefit fraud doesn't exist and if it does, it's fully justified in some kind of Robin Hood mentality and people would only do so out of desperation to feed their 23 kids rather than being greedy, workshy cunts.

And yet conversely there is this general consensus that anyone depriving the Exchequor of a measly few quid from a €30 job, should be prosecuted for tax dodging.

There was a thread a while back where a poster had her arse handed to her because she proposed paying her sister or someone £200 per month to watch her kids for a few hours. That was apparently illegal and she should pay a proper nanny and full tax and NI and to do anything less made her personally responsible for the NHS being short funded.

Absolutely barking.

Think about it. You clean someone else's shit for 3 hours, say £30. That £30 does not include petrol to get to the house or the time spent in traffic to and from which is unpaid. If you then had to give up say £7 of that to the taxman, it wouldn't be viable. No-one would do it, it's just not worth it. Most domestic cleaners IME don't do it fulltime, it's just pin money.

And yet the same posters all happily spending at Amazon, the biggest fucking tax dodgers ever.

Those who illegally undercut legitimate workers by not paying tax are driving down wages, if a job is something people want doing then it will settle in at a sustainable level, that is how supply and demand work. Around here you probably won't find a cleaner for less than £15 ph and many are £20+. I don't have a cleaner, but pay for one for my mum as it helps her out, the cleaner charges £20 per hour and she does two cleans per day, either two or three hours each five days a week and usually one on a Saturday morning. She works very hard, she is great, she is fully above board with taxes, just as everyone should be.

Amazon don't "dodge" tax, they do not pay much corporation tax, because they do not make much profit, businesses pay corporation tax on profit not turnover.

Tax evasion is wrong regardless of who does it, no one should be allowed to get away with it.

Triyo · 13/12/2021 11:47

When I was a cleaner I made sure I got paid in cash, because fuckers don't pay on time otherwise. Oh I forgot, oh can you wait until I get paid, oh this oh that.
No, pay me before I leave.

Amberflames · 13/12/2021 11:43

[quote SleepingStandingUp]@Amberflames
Tou are knowingly enabling tax evasion.
All if you go to the market and they say cash only, do you say sorry I can't do that, I won't enable tax evasion? And do you always pay the extra to cover the charges of using card?[/quote]
I pay my cleaner by bank transfer which is free for both of us (plus the taxes to an agency). And my window cleaner has put his prices up which I would assume covers his transaction costs.

THisbackwithavengeance · 13/12/2021 11:41

This thread highlights the double standards on MN that I've seen a few times.

The general consensus on here is that benefit fraud doesn't exist and if it does, it's fully justified in some kind of Robin Hood mentality and people would only do so out of desperation to feed their 23 kids rather than being greedy, workshy cunts.

And yet conversely there is this general consensus that anyone depriving the Exchequor of a measly few quid from a €30 job, should be prosecuted for tax dodging.

There was a thread a while back where a poster had her arse handed to her because she proposed paying her sister or someone £200 per month to watch her kids for a few hours. That was apparently illegal and she should pay a proper nanny and full tax and NI and to do anything less made her personally responsible for the NHS being short funded.

Absolutely barking.

Think about it. You clean someone else's shit for 3 hours, say £30. That £30 does not include petrol to get to the house or the time spent in traffic to and from which is unpaid. If you then had to give up say £7 of that to the taxman, it wouldn't be viable. No-one would do it, it's just not worth it. Most domestic cleaners IME don't do it fulltime, it's just pin money.

And yet the same posters all happily spending at Amazon, the biggest fucking tax dodgers ever.

Offmyfence · 13/12/2021 11:40

@logsonlogsoff

‘ Sick of reading posts of how people "have no time" to organise cash payments. Get over yourself.’

While I agree that her cleaner should be paid in cash as she wants, it is a flipping pain in the arse remembering to get cash each week because it is quite literally the only thing we regularly need cash for anymore. Everything else is either transfer, PayPal or Contactless now. None of us ever
have cash in this house, even the kids pocket money goes on a card.

Yeah it's really hard work! Why not get a months out in one go, ease that massive burden.
SleepingStandingUp · 13/12/2021 11:38

@Amberflames
Tou are knowingly enabling tax evasion.
All if you go to the market and they say cash only, do you say sorry I can't do that, I won't enable tax evasion? And do you always pay the extra to cover the charges of using card?

PaperMonster · 13/12/2021 11:37

Ffs, tax dodging? I clean. I mostly get paid in cash because it’s more convenient for my clients. I won’t earn enough to pay tax but I’m registered with Hmrc and insured. Just give her the bloomin cash and be done.