Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How do I pay our lovely cleaner?

137 replies

Alwaysfullofquestions · 13/12/2021 09:46

We’re hiring a woman to clean once a week because work is getting busier and busier and i also have a chronic illness which causes fatigue so I struggle to keep on top of it.

My only question is how do I pay her? She wants to be paid in cash but I want to make sure I’m doing it correctly, should I be paying by BACs? Or does it not matter? Anyone I’ve hired before for things like gardening or rubbish removal has been online banking.

Just want to make sure I’m doing it right and sorry if this seems like a stupid question!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HaaaaaveyoumetTed · 13/12/2021 21:59

@RaisedByPangolins

All those who think cash = tax dodge are confusing people like cleaners and gardeners charging £10-15 an hour with builders charging £1000s and wanting paid in cash.
Even then, it's not necessarily tax dodging!

We've paid our builder a mix of cash and BACS. It's all been accounted for and the tax declared appropriately. The cash was used to pay labourers and for skips etc all with proper paperwork - I know because most weeks I've seen it as the lads often collect their wages off me.

ohfook · 13/12/2021 19:55

@notanothertakeaway

I've always tended to assume people who insist on being paid in cash are not paying tax. I suspect that's often the case

However, there was a recent thread here where loads of people explained that cleaners, gardeners etc often prefer cash because it's (1) guaranteed money, (2) simple, (3) easier than issuing invoices & having to check bank statements to see if they've been paid

We pay our cleaner by standing order and she's fine with that. It does mean that we pay her whether she comes or not e.g. if she is on holiday or ill. But she knows the money is guaranteed and has never requested cash

I can imagine it's quite a hassle for cleaners to issue invoices and then check bank statements to see if they've been paid. And they won't want to carry out work in advance, trusting that invoices will be paid

But I can't see any legitimate reason for objecting to payment by standing order

When I was really struggling a few years ago I used to do tutoring. At the time I preferred cash because I needed the money and if it was paid into my account it would get swallowed up by fees or whatever.
Chloemol · 13/12/2021 18:00

@ChangeChingyChange

It's up to you, if she wants cash its because she's tax dodging. If you feel uncomfortable with this then insist on Bank transfer only. She could say no then you've lost her as a cleaner. I'd have the conversation with her before she starts. Would it really bother you that much to not just pay her in cash?
You CANNOT make such assumptions. What a nasty comment

Some people still don’t have bank accounts believe it or not

Lunariagal · 13/12/2021 17:45

Oh and before anyone mentions, every penny declared to hmrc.

Lunariagal · 13/12/2021 17:45

Oh and before anyone mentions, every penny declared to hmrc.

Lunariagal · 13/12/2021 17:42

I'm a self employed gardener and I prefer to be paid in cash as I don't want to be giving headspace to chasing people who have forgotten.

I have a new customer and he forgot a couple if weeks ago. Its easily done, and I dont want to have to log on to online banking daily to check.

With cash I collate and bank monthly, its just simpler.

winnieanddaisy · 13/12/2021 16:55

My DD pays the milkman, the window cleaner , the hairdresser and Uncle Tom cobbley and all by bank transfer. I think so many people don't have cash these days that I would ask her if you can just pay her that way . Good luck .

Fidgetty · 13/12/2021 16:20

Just pay her cash. Whether she's paying tax on it or not (probably not) is irrelevant to you. Honestly it's mental to me that people who can afford others to do their domestic work for them would begrudge a cleaner a couple of pounds. They must be so detached from the realities of life on a low income. Pay the woman cash!

Triffid1 · 13/12/2021 15:39

@MatildaIThink yes, I take your point re share price etc, but that doesn't change the fact that they do make a profit. The point I was making is that everyone always seems to think Amazon is dodging tax, and doing something borderline illegal and/or immoral. But in reality, they benefit from a tax system that allows allows huge corporates to find lots of loopholes - such as offshore registration. As a small business owner with none of these convenient loopholes, I find it extremely frustrating but don't blame Amazon - I blame the tax authorities.

MatildaIThink · 13/12/2021 15:26

@Triffid1

Amazon don't "dodge" tax, they do not pay much corporation tax, because they do not make much profit, businesses pay corporation tax on profit not turnover.

That's funny. Jeff Bezos is one of, if not THE richest man in the world. Of course Amazon makes lots of profit.

Having said that, I'd agree it's not tax dodging so much as legitimate tax loopholes that are irritatingly available to massive corporates like Amazon and that the tax authorities should absolutely be closing those loopholes.

@Amberflames jog on - I am not responsible for knowingly helping someone to evade tax because I may cash to my cleaner. As a pp pointed out, that would mean every time I pay cash at a market or for any other service there's a problem.

A builder who knocks of 20% for VAT IS my problem because in that case, I am basically attempting to get out of paying the VAT and HE is enabling me in my tax dodging.

Amazon makes very little profit because it reinvests nearly everything back into business growth, from AWS, to chip fabs, to it's own box company etc. Jeff Bezos is the world's second richest man (Musk is the first) because Amazon is worth so much money, his wealth is a combination of the value of the shares he owns combined with the money he has from selling share he previously owned. Amazon has never paid a dividend and his salary is often just a nominal dollar a year.

Amazon are doing what is actually the idea scenario for business, growing and adding value for shareholders by growth in value, rather than just handing out profit through dividend, which almost always leads to short termism in the business.

LakieLady · 13/12/2021 15:22

A lot of cleaners probably don't earn enough after expenses to use up their personal allowance anyway, so their tax liability would be zero.

And I agree about Amazon. They make megamillions in the UK and pay next to nothing in tax. That's why I boycott them.

logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 14:16

If your cleaner is lovely then just do whatever she’d prefer, don’t see why you wouldn’t TBH.

Warblerinwinter · 13/12/2021 13:47

Variable not visible

Warblerinwinter · 13/12/2021 13:47

I take a visible approach to cash payments
For a cleaner or odd job person earning low wage/hour I tend to go with cash if they ask and won’t take a BACS …I assume that some of these people mightn’t even have a bank account in normal way due to previous debt or other reasons. And if your not very IT literate or don’t have easy access to internet or a computer which low wage people might not have, then that is a good reason for them to only deal in cash
However, if it’s a plumber or trade charging £100 per hour for a call out and has a company with web site, obviously busy, then no I don’t. They’re definitely earning about personal allowances and they’re running a company so can deal with baking and internet. I refuse to pay cash for that- they’re the ones most likely to be avoiding tax. Had a few get a bit angst with me for refusing in past. My response was that if you told me you only dealt in cash up front I wouldn’t have hired you. And no I will not go and get cash. Either cheque or bank transfer. They always go for bank transfer. They’re trying it on basically.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 13/12/2021 13:24

@DynamiteFilledRadish

Excuse me? No one said she is poverty stricken.

When I said one reason for cash is that people who are overdrawn will end up having the bank transfer swallowed up and wont be able to use it. Cash means they have a choice of how to split it up and use it for what is most pressing.

That is an actual, legitimate reason for cash payments. And nothing at all to do with her being a cleaner. I know lots of "professional" people who live in their overdraft. I know a lot of people now who are still trying to get out of the debt lockdown put them into.

It isnt an insult or an indictment of someone to say that cash payments allow for people to access the money without worrying about overdrafts and bank fees taking it all up in one go.

Another reason for cash payments is to ensure people cant forgot and you dont need to send reminders whilst you wait for them to send the blooyd payment.

The OP wanted to know why cash payments might be wanted. Those are just 2 reasons. It is not an insult to the cleaner to say that.

witsendeverytime · 13/12/2021 13:20

I've always paid cleaners cash. Whether they declare it or not is up to them.

bratzybaby · 13/12/2021 13:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

LondonWolf · 13/12/2021 13:18

As a previously self employed domestic worker - not cleaner but similar, I loved cash as I could use to top up gas and electric meters and send teens to do without messing about with cards, give me kids pocket money in cash, cash birthday/Christmas presents for my multiple nieces and nephews etc. I really do judge people who get sniffy about paying domestic workers in cash. Get over yourselves.

Lincslady53 · 13/12/2021 13:10

I would get a small notebook, list the dates and payments, and ask the cleaner to sign for the receipt of the money when you give it to her. It will avoid any misunderstandings if she claims you haven't paid her when you have, or vica versa.

BlusteryLake · 13/12/2021 13:06

I pay mine by standing order, mainly because it is an awkward amount to have to get cash for every week (ie not just a simple visit to the cash machine). It is so much easier than having to remember to get cash all the time.

Offmyfence · 13/12/2021 13:01

@Mojoj

Sick of reading posts of how people "have no time" to organise cash payments. Get over yourself. No-one is that busy. Pay your cleaner in cash or find another cleaner.
Exactly!
logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 12:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2021 12:56

Tax etc is her responsibility so don’t worry about that

It’s not necessarily dodgy to pay in cash - might just be more convenient for her

christinalol22 · 13/12/2021 12:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

logsonlogsoff · 13/12/2021 12:54

@Offmyfence ‘ think outside the box!’

The 90s called, they’d like their bullshit business cliches back please.