Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£300 on Xmas presents?

234 replies

TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 08:00

My partner and I have 4 children. 2 each from previous relationships. Parenting is split 50/50. All teenagers.
So in our house we have a rule of £300 on each child for Xmas. Which I think is ok.
However, my step children's dad (my partners ex h) always has and always will absolutely spoil his children. They get a lot, and I do mean a lot, all throughout the year, nevermind Xmas and birthdays. Latest iPhone, ipads, 4 or 5 pairs of £150 trainers, lots of very nice clothes, both of the latest xbox and playstation, the list could go on.

My 2 have older games consoles, older phones, not apple products, more reasonably priced clothes.

I've suggested to my partner that we level things up a bit. And only a bit. But she says that we have to treat them all equally. I do agree with this. But it's really hard seeing the ever increasing gap between what the children have, and wear. My 2 children don't moan about it, or ask for much, or anything really. That doesn't mean that they don't notice the difference though. It's all very uneven. Which makes me feel bad. I know the emphasis there is on how I feel.

We all want our children to have nice things right? And provide for them based on what we can afford without spoiling them.

My partner is adamant that if I spend more on my 2 to level things up a bit, then she will have to spend more on her 2, which she doesn't want to do as 300 is plenty.

What do I do?

I've tried talking to my partner about it, and we both have different opinions.

I definitely need to have another conversation about it with her, but it will be difficult, and will end up with her getting angry so I'm avoiding it for the moment.

OP posts:
TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 10:09

@Whatafustercluck

Wow, £300 is already a huge amount! We're financially comfortable but spend less than that between two dc. They get so much anyway, from grandparents, aunts and uncles. I wouldn't be levelling up anywhere. You cannot continue to play keeping up with the Joneses. Some people can afford more, that's life. I remember always being the poor relation with my step daughters, me and dh couldn't afford very much at the time and our presents always paled into insignificance. But the result has been that DSD2 understands the value of money more, as well as the value of spending time with family above all else. She's now a wonderful, socially and financially aware 21yo who we're very proud of and she respects us hugely and talks fondly about memories rather than material things.

Whatever happened to the real spirit of Christmas?!

Lol the real spirit of Christmas! I absolutely agree with this, but try saying that to a teenager!!

And yes £300 is a lot. But it doesn't get you far if you're trying to buy something like a bike, or a pc, or laptop, or phone. You don't get much for £300.

OP posts:
Nevermakeit · 13/12/2021 10:02

I wouldn't spend more at Xmas, £300 is a LOT, and it will just create tension.
But I would spend more during the year eg on better clothes, if you are concerned, so that Xmas really is just the superfluous stuff.
Your children are teenagers so they understand the situation, and you can explain it to them. Xmas is always unfair, as some children have loads of family (eg uncles and aunts) lavishing them with presents, and others have small families so just a couple of presents.
I had very small family (just parents and grandparents), so always had few presents, now I look at my DC who have so many (lots of childless uncles), and some years esp when they were smaller I actually didn't get them any presents at all (I was always asked to advise what they might want, so I could direct), as they just had so many anyway, and I would just buy them things through the year.
(I do think the question of who is the higher earner, you or you current partner is interesting).
And you need to consider the other presents they will get from your side of the family (and your ex????).

But fundamentally the real question here is not 'do they have as much as the other two', but 'do they have enough' - and I would think that with £300, they do!!

ErinAoife · 13/12/2021 10:02

I agree with your partner you should treat all the children equally. I am sure your kids understand that it is the grand parents of your partner that spoilt her kids and not you or her.

Babynames2 · 13/12/2021 09:57

Do you and your partner have shared finances? If not then I would keep birthdays/Christmas equal but spend extra on your own throughout the year, the same as their own dad does.

Bluesheep8 · 13/12/2021 09:55

This is just another part of the shitty stick some kids in blended families are beaten with and one of the many reasons I would never subject DD to a step parent.

Even a step parent without kids?

Whatafustercluck · 13/12/2021 09:53

Wow, £300 is already a huge amount! We're financially comfortable but spend less than that between two dc. They get so much anyway, from grandparents, aunts and uncles. I wouldn't be levelling up anywhere. You cannot continue to play keeping up with the Joneses. Some people can afford more, that's life. I remember always being the poor relation with my step daughters, me and dh couldn't afford very much at the time and our presents always paled into insignificance. But the result has been that DSD2 understands the value of money more, as well as the value of spending time with family above all else. She's now a wonderful, socially and financially aware 21yo who we're very proud of and she respects us hugely and talks fondly about memories rather than material things.

Whatever happened to the real spirit of Christmas?!

Igneo · 13/12/2021 09:52

It's all very uneven. Which makes me feel bad. I know the emphasis there is on how I feel.
It’s really easy to get sucked into a deep level of guilt as a parent when families break up. Overcompensating is common, and measuring financial input is easier than really thinking about the other inputs.

I have made a point of buying stuff my kids need, it’s not always fair. I certainly don’t spend an equal amount at xmas, just make sure they have a decent pile each.

I remember getting my littlest on a really cute pair of trousers in the sale. My colleague was shocked i had bought just one pair of trousers, she thought that this was really unfair of me, and that if I couldn’t buy for them both, I shouldn’t buy for one. I went home and explained to my then 5 yr old that they didn’t have them in her size, and her sister needed a pair of trousers. She learned she’d get stuff when she needed it/ when her size came up in sale rack. No upset at all.

Sounds like your kids are already on the right path with accepting such ‘unfairnesses’ especially if they are not asking for much at xmas.

If you feel guilt, perhaps remind yourself at these moments of occasions when you have taught your kids to deal with life’s unfairnesses instead of indulging them, and know that this is a more important aspect of parenting than providing the latest iphone.

TooMuchPaper · 13/12/2021 09:52

@dottiedodah
Did you read the op? Where it says parenting is shared 50/50? So the father is not trying to buy them because he only sees them EOW

LittleMysSister · 13/12/2021 09:46

It's a tough one to manage BUT I'm sure your children won't think too much of it if you keep reminding them that it's the other kids' dad who is buying them all of these things, in the same way they might get gifts from your ex's side of the family while your DP's kids don't.

I don't think there is anything wrong with you spending a bit more on your children during the year if that works for you, but I think giving more expensive/double the amount to half the children in your household if they are all sitting there opening them together would be a bit unfair.

PS. £300 is already a generous amount per child! Your children are certainly not missing out, even if they are getting a bit less than their step-siblings.

JustLikea · 13/12/2021 09:46

It's just stuff they get it they're not stupid so don't worry about it

If they're upset they'll tell you but they won't be because they love you

I'd be fine with the fact that at least he's buying things I don't have to.

Georgy12 · 13/12/2021 09:38

@MollysDolly

It's all good and well my partner saying it has to be equal when it's not her children that receive less.

But they only receive more because of the non resident parent. This isn't your partner buying them brand new iPhones.

But then you say you can do exactly that for your children. I guess it's because the lavish things for her children don't come out of your household income, where as the lavish things for your children would. She has no say in what her ex does. But I do think she is quite right in saying that the household pot of (just making up figures) £2000, should not be £600 on her children, and £1400 on yours, just so you can keep up with her exH.

Where's their mother in all this?

When you're a blended family it's not all the same pot though is it? Yes for practical everyday living you'd each contribute but when you have your own kids your money is for them and shouldn't be joined to a 'family pot', why should OP fund his step kids at the expense of his own when they have their own parents! Not fair to OPs kids. Where does it stop? Inheritance for example shouldn't be split 50/50 but based on what each person contributed. Out of interest OP, who's the higher earner, you or your wife because if it's you, and everything is to be split 50/50, your kids are being cheated.
NameChangeCity123 · 13/12/2021 09:34

I can understand wanting them to be more equal but they're teenagers and I'm sure they will understand that you have different financial set ups in different situations anyway

UsernameInTheTown · 13/12/2021 09:32

This is just another part of the shitty stick some kids in blended families are beaten with and one of the many reasons I would never subject DD to a step parent.

Babyvenusplant · 13/12/2021 09:18

One good thing is that your two will value things more because they're not constantly getting the latest of everything without having to do anything for it

Tal45 · 13/12/2021 09:17

To be honest I'd be more concerned that her kids would grow up with the assumption that money grows on trees and that all these very expensive things are easy to come by as they are given out so freely. I'd worry they might grow up with a very entitled view and have a big shock when they start working. Your kids are likely to have far more realistic expectations about what they 'should' be able to afford.

Popcornriver · 13/12/2021 09:15

I just wanted to add that's it's not always the 'fairest' thing to spend absolutely equal amounts on children. I don't! They're both different ages and need/want different things.

RevolvingPivot · 13/12/2021 09:14

@MollysDolly

It's all good and well my partner saying it has to be equal when it's not her children that receive less.

But they only receive more because of the non resident parent. This isn't your partner buying them brand new iPhones.

But then you say you can do exactly that for your children. I guess it's because the lavish things for her children don't come out of your household income, where as the lavish things for your children would. She has no say in what her ex does. But I do think she is quite right in saying that the household pot of (just making up figures) £2000, should not be £600 on her children, and £1400 on yours, just so you can keep up with her exH.

Where's their mother in all this?

I assumed both were female. Bad assumption if not sorry.
Popcornriver · 13/12/2021 09:13

I see the point your partner is making but it's not her children that live with others who have much more is it. And while it might be fair to keep things equal in your household, it's not really equal is it?

I'd also be annoyed at a partner deciding what I could and couldn't spend on my own children. Sorry. And if she spends more because you have, that's not your fault. The current set up isn't fair.

MollysDolly · 13/12/2021 09:12

It's all good and well my partner saying it has to be equal when it's not her children that receive less.

But they only receive more because of the non resident parent. This isn't your partner buying them brand new iPhones.

But then you say you can do exactly that for your children. I guess it's because the lavish things for her children don't come out of your household income, where as the lavish things for your children would. She has no say in what her ex does. But I do think she is quite right in saying that the household pot of (just making up figures) £2000, should not be £600 on her children, and £1400 on yours, just so you can keep up with her exH.

Where's their mother in all this?

Georgy12 · 13/12/2021 09:11

I mean of course your wife is happy with the arrangement, it's her kids who benefit 🙄🙄

girlmom21 · 13/12/2021 09:10

OP my SSis always had more than us because her dad could afford it but that wasn't my SM's or DF's faults.

We never resented them for it, if that helps.

Georgy12 · 13/12/2021 09:09

I understand everyone on here saying the kids should all get the same from you but tbh I'd be upset if it were my kids. Their dad is spending what he wants on HIS kids and people seem to think that's fine. I'm of the opinion of you want to spend more money on YOUR kids, and you can afford it, no-one has the right to say you can't, that includes your wife. I'm sure she's lovely but I wouldn't let anyone dictate what my kids get from me xx

Mumdiva99 · 13/12/2021 09:09

@tuesdaySmoozday but it's not equal is it. If one needs new school shoes do you buy 3 other pairs to make it fair? If one needs a new jumper do you buy 3 more? If one is invited to a birthday party and you buy a gift for the birthday child you don't immediately spend the same on the other 3 kids etc etc Next time one has a school trip point out to her that's not fair.....

I would find it hard to reconcile that attitude with the reality of life. Does your wife have issues from her childhood around this? (My mum is funny about equality because she was bought up believing her sister - who was her parents by birth - got more than she did).

Thatsplentyjack · 13/12/2021 09:08

is pretty much indirectly punishing them because they have another parent who can afford to spend on them.

Punishing them how? They have this stuff already. The OP is not taking anything away from their step children, just wants to give their own children more so they don't feel too different. I think that's completely fair and if the step children and their mother can't see that and accept it then they are spoiled and controlling imo.

Thatsplentyjack · 13/12/2021 09:06

At first I was going to say YABU because I thought you wanted your partner to spend less on her dcs, but I don't see the problem with you spending a bit more on your dcs. Do your children see their other parent? Do they spend money on them for Christmas.

Honestly thought I would be telling my partner to fuck off if I'm honest. If I could afford to give my children more, then j would be regardless of what my partner said. I wonder if she would feel the same if it was the other way around, I think not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread