Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£300 on Xmas presents?

234 replies

TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 08:00

My partner and I have 4 children. 2 each from previous relationships. Parenting is split 50/50. All teenagers.
So in our house we have a rule of £300 on each child for Xmas. Which I think is ok.
However, my step children's dad (my partners ex h) always has and always will absolutely spoil his children. They get a lot, and I do mean a lot, all throughout the year, nevermind Xmas and birthdays. Latest iPhone, ipads, 4 or 5 pairs of £150 trainers, lots of very nice clothes, both of the latest xbox and playstation, the list could go on.

My 2 have older games consoles, older phones, not apple products, more reasonably priced clothes.

I've suggested to my partner that we level things up a bit. And only a bit. But she says that we have to treat them all equally. I do agree with this. But it's really hard seeing the ever increasing gap between what the children have, and wear. My 2 children don't moan about it, or ask for much, or anything really. That doesn't mean that they don't notice the difference though. It's all very uneven. Which makes me feel bad. I know the emphasis there is on how I feel.

We all want our children to have nice things right? And provide for them based on what we can afford without spoiling them.

My partner is adamant that if I spend more on my 2 to level things up a bit, then she will have to spend more on her 2, which she doesn't want to do as 300 is plenty.

What do I do?

I've tried talking to my partner about it, and we both have different opinions.

I definitely need to have another conversation about it with her, but it will be difficult, and will end up with her getting angry so I'm avoiding it for the moment.

OP posts:
luverlybubberly · 13/12/2021 12:44

I did manage to allow me to spend 160 on a Samsung tablet for a birthday present instead of the £100 limit she normally sets

You have posted before. Can you not see that she is being outrageously controlling ? You are prioritising your dick over your kids. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Goldbar · 13/12/2021 12:43

What would happen if you just bought what you wanted to buy for your kids and, if challenged, shrugged your shoulders and said that they're your kids and it is your money that you are spending on things that they need so you don't really think it is anyone else's business? That's what I'd be tempted to do in your situation.

LittleMysSister · 13/12/2021 12:41

@TuesdaySmoozday

Her opinion is that it would not feel nice or fair to her children if my children receive more
I can see what she's saying in terms of Christmas, which is the only time they'd actually be sitting together to open gifts, so you wouldn't want some kids opening vastly superior gifts in front of the others.

But I don't think she should be limiting what you spend through the rest of the year, as long as it's not impacting you & the household financially.

If you can afford it without leaving yourself skint and you want to spend it, then you should be able to without her getting on your case.

5keletor · 13/12/2021 12:41

Sorry, but your partner sounds horrible and controlling. I wouldn't be having a discussion about it, if you want to spend more on your kids to even it out, do so. You don't need her permission. It's worrying that you don't like discussing it with her because she gets angry, to be honest, it sounds like you'd maybe be better off without her controlling you.

luverlybubberly · 13/12/2021 12:40

Have you posted about this before ?

I would not be with someone who tried to prevent me from buying stuff for my kids with my money.

I would not have them living with step siblings who got loads more stuff when I could afford to match it.

Goldbar · 13/12/2021 12:40

@TuesdaySmoozday

Her opinion is that it would not feel nice or fair to her children if my children receive more
Tell her that the status quo doesn't feel nice or fair to your children so she needs to tell her ex that he needs to stop giving expensive gifts to his own children. See how far you get with that. Then everything can be completely equal between all the children.

This is ridiculous. You're making your relationship sound like a prison sentence. And it's not only you who is being controlled, but your kids through you.

lockdownalli · 13/12/2021 12:39

As they are teenagers, they are plenty old enough to understand that their step siblings other parent is more wealthy and therefore they get more/better things. Just the same as a mate at school might.

I think you are infantilising them tbh OP.

misskatamari · 13/12/2021 12:36

and the thing is (refering to your last post), your kids wouldn't be receiving more would they. Even just adding a bit extra to their christmas funds, the step kids are STILL getting more overall.

NoodlesPoodles · 13/12/2021 12:35

@TuesdaySmoozday

Her opinion is that it would not feel nice or fair to her children if my children receive more
But it's ok for your dc to receive less?!? I'm sorry but she sounds horrible...and controlling.
misskatamari · 13/12/2021 12:34

I'm with you on this OP. It's not like you want to spoil yours in the same way the dad spoils your step kids (with constant spending), you just want to give your children some of the same things that their step siblings have. I imagine in their shoes it does smart a bit, seeing their step siblings get given so much and them not. Even the nicest, most generous etc person, would struggle not to have that sting.

I always remember the phrase "fair doesn't have to mean equal" and think it applies perfectly here. The current set up isn't fair on your children. By gifting a bit more at christmas to them, you increase the fairness of the situation.

I hope your partner comes round and starts to see this. I would really struggle with seeing my kids be treated this way. Yes £300 is a fair whack of money, and kids need to learn they can't always have whatever they want etc etc. But the unfairness of this situation doesn't sit right with me, and I would be addressing it for sure.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 13/12/2021 12:34

Do her parents spend equal amounts on her children and yours?

The more you tell us about her, the more I think she is being emotionally and financially controlling.

Nevermakeit · 13/12/2021 12:33

Just realised one of my earlier messages not clear. Can you get her to set her EX a limit? Like she does to you and your parents? Sounds like he is the main one she is NOT setting a limit on, and therein lies part of the problem? That way the onus is on her.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 13/12/2021 12:32

@username1293948

Sorry but their father can buy whatever he damn well pleases for his own children…
Of course he can. and so can the OP for her own - problem is she is being controlled by her partner who says she cannot buy what she wants for her own children.
TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 12:32

Her opinion is that it would not feel nice or fair to her children if my children receive more

OP posts:
AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 13/12/2021 12:30

@TuesdaySmoozday

We both earn approx the same, split all bills, and have separate bank accounts. There is no joint pot for Xmas.
OK, then I change my opinion. She can't dictate what you spend your own money on, outside of the bills etc.
TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 12:30

@Wheelz46

Seems like it's her way or the highway.

How I would look at it is, 'if she wasn't in the picture, what would I buy?' If that turns out to be more than the £300 spent on her kids, then that's for her to deal with and increase her spending if she so desires.

Nobody would be telling me what I could or could not spend on my own kids out of my own pocket! I think you should put your foot down OP tell her this is what you are spending on yours and its upto her if she wants to even it out!

I'd be told..

You're not supporting me
We're meant to work as a team
Why are you making such a big deal out of it
Why is everything so hard with you
We're meant to be a family

OP posts:
Nevermakeit · 13/12/2021 12:29

If it's any consolation at all, I spent my childhood being the 'poor kid' (very relative - we were very comfortable but I was in a school where some were ambassador's children and the likes, with lifts in their homes etc), with very principled parents.... I wasn't unhappy at all but very aware and the result of it was I developped huge ambitions to be successful in life and make a lot of money myself, to be able to be 'one of those people' and buy all those things myself!
Was def a big motivator to do well at school, go to a top university and get a high paid job (first job was in consulting) at the start of my career (which then went downhill when I had the DC but that's another story!:).

Goldbar · 13/12/2021 12:27

She is being controlling.

You have largely separate finances apart from splitting the bills. So no joint family pot.

Why are you letting her tell you how you should spend your money? Do you tell her how she should spend her money?

Spend what you want on your own kids and she can match it for her children (out of her own money) if she thinks it is really necessary given what their dad already buys them.

If she insists on controlling your finances and your relationship with your children in this way, I would seriously re-think the relationship.

TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 12:27

@Thatsplentyjack

I assumed you had shared finances, separate finances? Absolutely tell her to fuck off. Spend what you like on your own kids.
Separate. Yeah don't think saying that to her will get me far!!
OP posts:
Wheelz46 · 13/12/2021 12:26

Seems like it's her way or the highway.

How I would look at it is, 'if she wasn't in the picture, what would I buy?' If that turns out to be more than the £300 spent on her kids, then that's for her to deal with and increase her spending if she so desires.

Nobody would be telling me what I could or could not spend on my own kids out of my own pocket! I think you should put your foot down OP tell her this is what you are spending on yours and its upto her if she wants to even it out!

AnotherOneWithNoGoodName · 13/12/2021 12:26

What happens in her ex's home (and what happens in your exes home) is out of your control.
So you and your partner have to decide what happens in your home, with your (presumably) joint finances, when it comes to Christmas etc. Personally I wouldn't base this on what the ex partners are going to do.

HollowTalk · 13/12/2021 12:26

Honestly, you need to find your backbone. Why are you putting up with this? Your poor children. This partner is dominating you and your children. Her own children are spoiled rotten and you're being told what you can spend on your children.

If I were your children I'd think you didn't have my back.

TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 12:26

@IgneousRock

How would she even know exactly how much you've spent? Do you have to show her the receipts or something?!
No but she would know, it's mostly obvious approximately how much stuff costs
OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 13/12/2021 12:25

I assumed you had shared finances, separate finances? Absolutely tell her to fuck off. Spend what you like on your own kids.

Nevermakeit · 13/12/2021 12:24

@username1293948

Sorry but their father can buy whatever he damn well pleases for his own children…
Sounds like she is very good at setting and enforcing limits.... If she sets a limit on what your parents spend, surely she should agree to what her ex spends. That way EVERYONE has a limit, and if there is a gap, it doesn't come from Xmas....?