Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£300 on Xmas presents?

234 replies

TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 08:00

My partner and I have 4 children. 2 each from previous relationships. Parenting is split 50/50. All teenagers.
So in our house we have a rule of £300 on each child for Xmas. Which I think is ok.
However, my step children's dad (my partners ex h) always has and always will absolutely spoil his children. They get a lot, and I do mean a lot, all throughout the year, nevermind Xmas and birthdays. Latest iPhone, ipads, 4 or 5 pairs of £150 trainers, lots of very nice clothes, both of the latest xbox and playstation, the list could go on.

My 2 have older games consoles, older phones, not apple products, more reasonably priced clothes.

I've suggested to my partner that we level things up a bit. And only a bit. But she says that we have to treat them all equally. I do agree with this. But it's really hard seeing the ever increasing gap between what the children have, and wear. My 2 children don't moan about it, or ask for much, or anything really. That doesn't mean that they don't notice the difference though. It's all very uneven. Which makes me feel bad. I know the emphasis there is on how I feel.

We all want our children to have nice things right? And provide for them based on what we can afford without spoiling them.

My partner is adamant that if I spend more on my 2 to level things up a bit, then she will have to spend more on her 2, which she doesn't want to do as 300 is plenty.

What do I do?

I've tried talking to my partner about it, and we both have different opinions.

I definitely need to have another conversation about it with her, but it will be difficult, and will end up with her getting angry so I'm avoiding it for the moment.

OP posts:
TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 15:43

@girlmom21

But it's OK for the OP's partner to tell the OP to spend less on his own children than he would like to?

But the OP can have that out with his partner or say that this is how things will be moving forwards.

As it is, the OP just wants a dick-measuring competition.

Couldn't be more wrong about that. Not in competition with anyone at all. Have you read any of my posts?
OP posts:
girlmom21 · 13/12/2021 15:33

Why don't you just tell your partner you'll buy your kids what you want? Don't do it to compete with her ex though...

girlmom21 · 13/12/2021 15:32

But it's OK for the OP's partner to tell the OP to spend less on his own children than he would like to?

But the OP can have that out with his partner or say that this is how things will be moving forwards.

As it is, the OP just wants a dick-measuring competition.

Lockdownbear · 13/12/2021 15:10

@Salayes

Other solution - get better gifts for your kids and give them to your ex to give to them. Same goes for birthday items and other luxury goods throughout the year. That way you’re not actually giving joint gifts with her that are not equal, you’re enabling your ex to give the same as her ex. I wonder what she’d think of that solution. I’d put it to her and see what she says.
Wtf should his partner get a say in that? If Op wants to gift via his ex it's nobody else's business.
IgneousRock · 13/12/2021 15:04

@Hemingwayscatz

So your issue is the fact your partner’s ex spends a lot on his children whereas your ex (and you) don’t have as much to spend on your DC or choose not to? You can’t control how much your step-children’s Dad spends on them, that’s his choice and you can’t tell their Mum to spend less on her children because it makes you look or feel bad.
But it's OK for the OP's partner to tell the OP to spend less on his own children than he would like to?
PeeAche · 13/12/2021 15:02

Hey OP, some advice from the other side of the tracks:

My DH and I have 2 children that live with us 30% of the time, both his from a previous marriage. We are expecting a new baby next year (hopefully - providing this one stays sticky!)

The kids are 10 and 7. At their other home with mum, her boyfriend has another child who is 7.

My DH's ex and her boyfriend aren't working so money is fairly tight for them. (It know this isn't the same for you, but the experience is still comparable I think)

We are in a much better position financially and we cater to the children's needs quite... erm... enthusiastically.

(We spoil them! 🤦🏻‍♀️)

That said, we don't spend anywhere near £300 at Christmas... but maybe it'll be different when they're teens! 😱

At their home with mum, they receive less than their mum's boyfriend's son because of this discrepancy. Fewer treats and days out throughout the year and sufficiently less at Christmas.

Their dad is just trying to even things out, which is nice for his son. Sadly, it doesn't go unnoticed by my SC, who just think their mum and her boyfriend "love" the other boy more.

Obviously this is compounded by them all being of a similar age, and being quite young.

We are party to conversations that they don't dare have with their mum, through fear of upsetting her. So we really do get to see the other side of things. We have decided that no matter what happens with our little one, they'll all be treated the same because it does seem to have quite a profound impact.

(By the way, of course my DH pays his full child support, before anyone jumps me!!)

Westerman · 13/12/2021 14:40

Have I got this right? Your partner felt aggrieved that your parents spent more on your children (their own grandkids) than they spent on her kids? Does she not recognise her own hypocrisy??

Deisogn · 13/12/2021 14:08

If you have separate money I'd choose to upgrade their phones just not at Christmas. If the other two have the latest phones there will be no need for her to spend more although that's her choice. I wouldn't let mine be the poor relations if I could afford it. I'd be buying them new trainers throughout the year. To avoid the fight I just wouldn't do it at Christmas. Then it's her fight to pick with you. So long as you're paying your half of the bills she has no say in what you spend your money on really.

turnaroundtime · 13/12/2021 14:04

@TuesdaySmoozday

Her opinion is that it would not feel nice or fair to her children if my children receive more
But it's ok if hers receive more. Even if it comes from your parents it's not ok. So basically it's ok if hers receive things from anywhere but yours can not. Ffs grow a set and prioritise your dc. You will lose their respect and leave them with a lifetime of therapy otherwise
turnaroundtime · 13/12/2021 14:01

@TuesdaySmoozday

I did give my parents some extra money last xmas to buy something a bit extra for my children (which made me feel very guilty and like I was doing something bad)

That caused a problem as she was upset that my parents bought my children more than her children

I think you have a relationship problem. It seems like it's her way or the highway. You are allowing your dc to be the ones to suffer. You have done real issues here. To be frank, she sounds awful. Happy to see her 2 thrive and happy to see your 2 look on sadly. This is not ok. It's not fair. She says you need fi be fair? This is not fair. You need to strap on some balls and have a bug conversation and if your partner belie your 2 going around as the poor relations is ok, I would question the whole relationship.
Allsorts1 · 13/12/2021 13:56

I think you’re right to want to level them up a bit but I don’t see why this should be done on Xmas day? Can’t you just give them gifts throughout the year so that they have similar consoles etc to their step siblings? Rather than an awkward day opening different amounts of gifts. If you have extra budget for them then spend it, but do it on their birthday or whenever makes sense, so it’s less obvious.

Mellowyellow222 · 13/12/2021 13:55

@TuesdaySmoozday

I did give my parents some extra money last xmas to buy something a bit extra for my children (which made me feel very guilty and like I was doing something bad)

That caused a problem as she was upset that my parents bought my children more than her children

I think you have issues with your partner.

I can absolutely understand your desire to even things up between the kids. I would feel the same.

Like others have commented, you can buy them extras through the year. It’s also none of your partners business what your parents buy your kids.

It must be tough for your kids seeing their step siblings get so much more. While yes it’s life, if you want to even it up go ahead! I would.

You sound like a great parent and a great step parent.

ChateauMargaux · 13/12/2021 13:54

How do the children feel? They are your children and if they are teens, there are only a few more years to build the relationship on which your future lives are adults will be based. It also feeds into how they feel about themselves.

My children understand that they do not get as much as some of their friends but we do our best to ensure that they get what they need as well as some of what they want. If one of them wants to play an expensive sport, then some of that sports kit needs to be considered as part and parcel of the overall present picture. if they need new trainers but would prefer a branded pair rather than the pair on offer at the sports shop.. then they have to also factor that in. As it happens, we have one child who doesn't value expensive things but loves going places, so that becomes her spending pot.

The person who is undermining your partner here in terms of what the children receive, is her ex... if you and your partner do not believe that teenagers should have 4 or 5 pairs of trainers a year plus the latest iPhone.. then that is not being reflected by their step dad.

It is a really tricky situation and I do not know the answer. Would you otherwise buy them iPhones and expensive trainers? If not.. well then I think the answer is no.. and you should explain why... perhaps put some money in their savings account

HairyToity · 13/12/2021 13:50

I once heard a friend complain about having a smaller/cheaper pile than her half-siblings, the justification from her mum was that she'd get a massive pile at her dad's later. She was a teenager at the time, and was really hurt by it.

AndSoFinally · 13/12/2021 13:46

Why haven't you acknowledged the idea of just buying things throughout the year to even things up?

I can absolutely see why you can't give vastly more for Christmas/birthdays to one set of DC, they're bound to compare and feel hard done by.

There's no reason you can't just buy things throughout the year though? SDC can hardly complain yours have got a new £150 pair of trainers if they're standing there with the same pair on their own feet?!

You're making this far more complicated than it needs to be. Are you looking to start an argument with your DP? Is this about more than just Christmas spending?

Aimee1987 · 13/12/2021 13:45

I see where your coming from but I dont think Christmas is the time to do it.
I would say spend the 300 on each child and when they need a phone next year just get them whatever phone you want ( so they have similiar level as their stepsiblings).
Similarly the new laptop for school work, new ( designer if you like) clothes when they need them. Even a new games console but mabey for birthday.
I would ask though how much of the extra stuff they get from the other parent is in your house? Because I would aim for similiar stuff within the house. So match the phones and clothes if you have the money and inclination but Christmas isnt the time to even up.

Salayes · 13/12/2021 13:45

Other solution - get better gifts for your kids and give them to your ex to give to them. Same goes for birthday items and other luxury goods throughout the year. That way you’re not actually giving joint gifts with her that are not equal, you’re enabling your ex to give the same as her ex. I wonder what she’d think of that solution. I’d put it to her and see what she says.

Salayes · 13/12/2021 13:43

I initially thought you were being unreasonable but i’ve changed my mind now. I don’t see why she should set spending limits for your kids on their birthdays and Xmas.

Overall, her kids get more yet she is insisting that’s ok, but when you try and address this it’s not ok because she’s not looking at the overall situation of what the kids get from four parents but just you two in isolation.

In practice it means that actually your children are not being treated fairly, she is ensuring they are second class by insisting on these ‘equal’ spend limits which aren’t actually equal at all when all four parents are taken into account.

She does sound controlling and like she is projecting. One rule for her kids and one rule for yours she says if you try and change anything, when the reality is it IS one rule for each set of kids - with hers coming out on top in terms of bigger ticket items and better quality things. If she truly wants things to be equal how about she sets a spend limit with her ex that is on a par with your ex for what gets spent on her kids? Bet that would go down like a cold cup of sick. Hmm

MollysDolly · 13/12/2021 13:39

So, when you say a great example, is that her DC have 6 pairs of trainers each. Yours have one nice, and one scruffy pair.

Why is this? Does she not spend on her DC at all (because she doesn't have the money), and all the nice things they have come from the exH?

Hadalifeonce · 13/12/2021 13:29

Do your partner's children open their gifts from their father in your home?
If so I would suggest they get them when they are with him, so the difference isn't so obvious.

WhatsMyNameGonnaBeNow · 13/12/2021 13:28

OP didn’t you have a similar thread quite recently? Something along the lines of your partner’s child having an iPad but she wanted you to only spend up to £100 on a tablet for your child’s birthday? Apologies if I’ve confused you with another poster but if it’s you then I think your partner is quite happy for your children to be in second place all the time!

If I’m understanding correctly, you don’t have any DC together, is that correct? And all the dc are 50/50 in each parents home? If that’s the case (and I think some posters are assuming it’s only your partners DC who are part of a “blended family”) then you are just as entitled to choose what your children get as any other father.

I could understand your partner’s concern if your spending on dc meant she had to pick up the financial slack elsewhere but that doesn’t seem to be the case. Rather she’s perfectly happy for her dc to have things that, if you follow her “rules” 🙄, your dc can never have.

I wouldn’t go along with this and expect it will breed resentment among the dc, possibly towards you too for putting your new partner before your dc.

girlmom21 · 13/12/2021 13:27

How are your children treated by their other parent at Christmas?

Ponoka7 · 13/12/2021 13:24

I don't understand why in the 18months you haven't leveled things up. How Christmas is managed is a conversation that should have been sorted out two years ago. I don't think that it is controlling of her. You want to suddenly make a change that wouldn't go down well with your stepchildren. They should be treated the same over Christmas. So have you consistently spent less on them over the last seven years than she has on hers? How has this happened? Level up on Birthdays.

Fluffymule · 13/12/2021 13:22

@TuesdaySmoozday

Her opinion is that it would not feel nice or fair to her children if my children receive more
But sure this works the other way around too? Your opinion is that it does not feel nice or fair to your children that her children receive more?

Your finances are separate. So perhaps you/she could look at it that her children receive £x from their parents (however it is split) and from now on your children receive £X from their parents (however it is split).

That seems pretty fair. In total the children receive similar levels of presents from their birthparents, just the split of who pays across the three households differs slightly.

Most kids have a good sense of fairness. I'm sure they would see this as a win for all too.

Goldbar · 13/12/2021 13:20

@Hemingwayscatz

So your issue is the fact your partner’s ex spends a lot on his children whereas your ex (and you) don’t have as much to spend on your DC or choose not to? You can’t control how much your step-children’s Dad spends on them, that’s his choice and you can’t tell their Mum to spend less on her children because it makes you look or feel bad.
That's not the issue. The issue is that the OP isn't allowed to spend their own money on their children, not that the OP doesn't actually have money to spend.