Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£300 on Xmas presents?

234 replies

TuesdaySmoozday · 13/12/2021 08:00

My partner and I have 4 children. 2 each from previous relationships. Parenting is split 50/50. All teenagers.
So in our house we have a rule of £300 on each child for Xmas. Which I think is ok.
However, my step children's dad (my partners ex h) always has and always will absolutely spoil his children. They get a lot, and I do mean a lot, all throughout the year, nevermind Xmas and birthdays. Latest iPhone, ipads, 4 or 5 pairs of £150 trainers, lots of very nice clothes, both of the latest xbox and playstation, the list could go on.

My 2 have older games consoles, older phones, not apple products, more reasonably priced clothes.

I've suggested to my partner that we level things up a bit. And only a bit. But she says that we have to treat them all equally. I do agree with this. But it's really hard seeing the ever increasing gap between what the children have, and wear. My 2 children don't moan about it, or ask for much, or anything really. That doesn't mean that they don't notice the difference though. It's all very uneven. Which makes me feel bad. I know the emphasis there is on how I feel.

We all want our children to have nice things right? And provide for them based on what we can afford without spoiling them.

My partner is adamant that if I spend more on my 2 to level things up a bit, then she will have to spend more on her 2, which she doesn't want to do as 300 is plenty.

What do I do?

I've tried talking to my partner about it, and we both have different opinions.

I definitely need to have another conversation about it with her, but it will be difficult, and will end up with her getting angry so I'm avoiding it for the moment.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hawkins001 · 26/01/2022 23:15

@TuesdaySmoozday

My partner and I have 4 children. 2 each from previous relationships. Parenting is split 50/50. All teenagers. So in our house we have a rule of £300 on each child for Xmas. Which I think is ok. However, my step children's dad (my partners ex h) always has and always will absolutely spoil his children. They get a lot, and I do mean a lot, all throughout the year, nevermind Xmas and birthdays. Latest iPhone, ipads, 4 or 5 pairs of £150 trainers, lots of very nice clothes, both of the latest xbox and playstation, the list could go on.

My 2 have older games consoles, older phones, not apple products, more reasonably priced clothes.

I've suggested to my partner that we level things up a bit. And only a bit. But she says that we have to treat them all equally. I do agree with this. But it's really hard seeing the ever increasing gap between what the children have, and wear. My 2 children don't moan about it, or ask for much, or anything really. That doesn't mean that they don't notice the difference though. It's all very uneven. Which makes me feel bad. I know the emphasis there is on how I feel.

We all want our children to have nice things right? And provide for them based on what we can afford without spoiling them.

My partner is adamant that if I spend more on my 2 to level things up a bit, then she will have to spend more on her 2, which she doesn't want to do as 300 is plenty.

What do I do?

I've tried talking to my partner about it, and we both have different opinions.

I definitely need to have another conversation about it with her, but it will be difficult, and will end up with her getting angry so I'm avoiding it for the moment.

Any updates on the current situation ?
MollysDolly · 15/12/2021 12:26

@Lockdownbear

Possibly more too it, but define 'wealthy' ?My head wealthy means millionaire who doesn't need to think about money at all.

Not some one who makes the choice between increasing their savings fund or spending a bit extra at Christmas to buy a PS5.

Yes, I agree.

But is it a PS5 once a year that OP is portraying? It's not "a bit extra at Christmas" according to OP. Her DC are armed with the latest everything, every time they return from their father. Who is apparently not wealthy. But somehow has the ability to endlessly spoil them throughout the year in his 50% residence with them, so much that OPs children are "poor relatives"

Their own mother doesn't provide anything of consequence according to OP, and he doesn't want to talk about her contribution, whilst fixating on what OPs ex does. OPs partner sets a Christmas budget of £300 per child within their household. OPs problem is outside of their household, someone else keeps buying her children endless luxury items. Yet somehow he can't spend his own separate money throughout the year?

The exH doesn't limit his purchasing to Christmas. So why is it, by, say June, when the partners DC are lining up their 6 pairs of trainers, that OP can not buy another pair for either of his? If it's not a birthday, or a Christmas, (where budgets are set so the parents in the household treat the children in the household the same) why is it that he can't buy shoes for his children in June?

luverlybubberly · 15/12/2021 12:13

@MollysDolly My ex buys our kids lots of expensive stuff (despite probably having credit card debt) because that's how he shows his dad guilt. Our kids have the latest iPhones, ds is getting a PS5 and the kids say that he regularly offers to buy them stuff that they don't need.

He's posted this dilemma before and always gets the same replies each time. Despite him saying that he's not prioritising his relationship over his kids, he clearly is by staying with this woman who doesn't sound like a good person at all.

Lockdownbear · 15/12/2021 12:02

Possibly more too it, but define 'wealthy' ?My head wealthy means millionaire who doesn't need to think about money at all.

Not some one who makes the choice between increasing their savings fund or spending a bit extra at Christmas to buy a PS5.

MollysDolly · 15/12/2021 11:54

Have you noticed OP avoids any question that shows he's taking the piss once you have the full context.

He just wants sympathy and validation. Whilst hiding the whole picture. He and his children are the poor victims that way. It's rather manipulative.

So, on the basis, for example, you read it as: they both have plenty of excess cash....

What makes you think this? Because OP says his children only have one decent pair of trainers each and her children have 6. So what's his story, he only buys his children one pair a year, because with allllllll his excess cash, he can't buy another pair and neither can their mother who again, he's pretending doesn't exist can provide for her own children.

These "6 pairs" the other children have. Well they must all be from the exH. Because if he's claiming his children are these "poor relatives" because he can only spend the same as his partner, then she can't be getting her children anything. With all her excess cash. Never buys anything. They both have their own separate cash, loads of it, but for no reason at all, it can't go on the children. Starting to see OPs story not add up?

Oh, then there's the exH, buying both his children 6 pairs of trainers, both his children the latest console, both his children the latest iPhone, every gadget going, every time they go to his, they return with all these expensive and luxurious items. But as soon as you point out, he's just trying to keep up with her exH, OP starts, "no, he's not wealthy". Well, which is it. He's nice and rich when you want to list endless purchases of luxury items to make your children look hard done by. But as soon as it's pointed out you're in competition with him? Oh no, he's got no money.

I suspect there's far more to this than the story OP tells.

HunterGatherer · 15/12/2021 11:21

"She gets angry"..... and what does that look like OP?
"I'm trying to avoid world war 3" Hmm Do you feel safe?
She sounds quite nasty to me, she's prioritising her own DC and doesn't care that yours have less. No way could I let my DC be treated like this. Teenagers are sensitive souls, they will notice their tatty trainers esp if their siblings have the latest gear. I don't know why you are with this arse of a woman, presumably she has other great qualities.

Lockdownbear · 15/12/2021 10:58

@MollysDolly
They contribute equally to the house but have separate finances.

The extra would be coming out the Ops pocket nothing to do with the partner.
I'm reading it as neither of them are skint and their is plenty excess cash.

Just because people have excess cash it doesn't mean they are happy for their kids to have more than one decent pair of trainers. Kids are in school shoes half the time and they have growing feet why on earth do they need more than one decent pair of trainers, that will be out grown before they are out worn?

I'm assuming the Ops children's mum isn't in the position to spend big money on their kids. Why should she influence his spending either?

£300 budget sounds generous until you consider the cost of teens clothing, although some would argue trainers and clothing shouldn't be a gift.
Other stuff like consoles and bikes are expensive and probably not manage able on a £300 limit.

The Ops partners Ex is spending BiG money on this kids, his choice to do that. Which in turn means they are the Jones. The Ops partner appears to have decided to avoid getting into a battle of trying to out spend her ex hence her £300 limit. Their kids know if they want big ticket items 'then ask Dad'.

Why should the Op also stick to that £300 limit because it suits his partner for them as a couple not to appear to spend more on his kids than hers?

The kids don't even open their gifts together!

MollysDolly · 15/12/2021 09:26

It's none of her business what you spend on your children, you're their Dad for goodness sake.

Well it is if they live together and she has to pay far more of the living expenses, so he can buy his children more presents. If the household rent/bills are (say) £2000, and both partners pay £1000, and have £300 left over for presents, that's fair. What's not, is "well, I'm spending my £1000 on my children, matching what your exH buys...so I'll spend my money on my children, and so you'll need to cover my rent and bills" That's very much her business.

Why should you restrict your spending because she doesn't want to match it?

It all depends where the increased spending is coming from. OP says he doesn't earn more than his partner. So it's not like he's got all this excess kicking about. If they both had loads of excess, then there wouldn't be a £300 budget and this "my children only have one pair of decent trainers" situation that OP says there is.

Her children get enough from their own Dad.

And this is a conversation OP needs to have, with his own children's mother.

SpilltheTea · 15/12/2021 09:05

She's being ridiculous. It's none of her business what you spend on your children, you're their Dad for goodness sake. Why should you restrict your spending because she doesn't want to match it? Her children get enough from their own Dad.

MollysDolly · 15/12/2021 08:49

And when you say, you gave your parents extra money to spend on your DC, and she was cross because her DC weren't treated the same....

Presumably her parents do treat all 4 of the children the same, hence her annoyance that you created a situation where it wasn't the case with your parents.

And again, when people say "stop competing with her exH because he is wealthy" you are quick to say, "no he's not". You seem to have an answer for everything, to suit your narrative.

And you also say you and your partner earn the same amount. So this £300 budget isn't because you've got so much more to spend, and she can't match it. She knows what is required to run the household, because she's paying her half. And knowing the cost of that responsibility, she knows that £300 per child (£600 in total) is what is affordable to both of you, with your joint living costs.

So when you want to use more for your DC presents, where's that coming from? The money you've jointly saved up over the year? Well it can't be because you say you have separate finances. The money that should be going on joint bills?

Is the problem because she has to make up the shortfall because there isn't enough for general living costs in your house if you choose to spend more on your DC.

You also keep glossing over there own mother's responsibility. As if they only have (to use your example) one pair of decent trainers because that's all you spend. So their mother gets them nothing?

Mellowyellow222 · 15/12/2021 08:26

This lady sounds very controlling.

You should be making decisions for your children. I do find it odd that some lady who isn’t related to your children is controlling how much they get for Christmas from their dad.

While £300 is generous - you should be free to spend more of you want.

Some years they may want or need big ticket items. If you can afford more why’s sore she get to say no? Her children are getting g these items elsewhere - why should yours be denied

GrazingSheep · 14/12/2021 23:05

Yet again 2 adults shack up together without giving a flying fuck about the impact on the children who have zero say in decisions that impact hugely on their lives.

GrazingSheep · 14/12/2021 23:04

Why do your children have to suffer because of the choices you have made in your relationships?

luverlybubberly · 14/12/2021 19:07

My teen is getting a PS5 this Christmas from his Dad which wouldn't be possible if his partner constrained him to a £300 limit. He doesn't spend this much every celebration but this is how much they cost and ex wants to surprise ds

MrsBobDylan · 14/12/2021 18:18

I think you need to parent your kids and your partner can do hers.

If she wants things to be so bloody equal, why doesn't she stop her ex from spending such a fucked up amount on their kids?

I think there are bigger issues her than the Xmas budget.

Yearonebesties · 14/12/2021 17:53

I absolutely would not let my partner tell me how much of my own money I could spend on my own children.

1forAll74 · 14/12/2021 16:44

I think a lot of children get too much , too soon, these days,especially when you are talking about expensive gadgets etc. You then get to the point,where other birthdays and Christmases come around again, so you have to up the ante with costs again, and then think of what they want next time again.. kind of never ending.

FuckingFabulous · 14/12/2021 14:37

So over the last seven YEARS you've not been able to get your kids what you want, because your partner says no?? Or is it the last year and a half of their lives that she's tried to change things for them so that her kids dad treats them as special and you treat them as if they're your kids, but your kids get no special treatment? She sees it as fine that her kids get special treatment from their dad who has them half the time but can't abide you treating your kids that you have half the time?

You have a jealous partner there.

Get your kids whatever the fuck you like! It's not down to her at all.

sofakingcool · 14/12/2021 14:13

I'm with a lot of the other posters here, your partner is being very unreasonable

MrsWhites · 14/12/2021 14:03

Your partner is very unreasonable, she wants to limit what you spend on your children whilst her children enjoy the spoils of having a wealthy father and therefore have expensive things.

If it were her children who didn’t have the latest things etc would she feel the same?

MollysDolly · 14/12/2021 13:54

Is the budget agreed at £300 each child because that's what she can afford, or could she afford more?

If you've got so much more excess to spend on your own children, where is that money currently going?

If your excess money is for necessary household expediture, then your partner has a point. If your excess is just sitting in your bank, going on nothing, or piling up your savings then she doesn't as much.

Nowayoutonlydown · 14/12/2021 09:33

@TuesdaySmoozday

Ok. I think the majority opinion here is that I'm not being unreasonable.

And I should grow or strap on a pair of balls and have the conversation. As well as maybe get stuff throughout the year so it's not as big a deal at Xmas.

I've always tried not to spoil my children and don't really buy them much throughout the year. Maybe that's part of the problem.

Not looking forward to the conversation!

I hope your conversation went OK, I imagine it will have been a tough one. Your partner does read as quite controlling. I'm struggling to understand how she can see that one set of children are receiving all of this stuff, when the others aren't, and that's just OK in her mind. I couldn't personally do that myself...equality isn't just for Christmas (though it does seem to become painfully obvious at that time often!)

I can appreciate that she doesn't want a discrepancy at Christmas (always was one during our Christmases growing up.and it always hurt to realise I was receiving less than my siblings)

But it was also quite painful throughout the year, and was more of continuous reminder that I didn't matter as much, and also a source of embarrassment.
How do the kids feel themselves? Are yours envious? Do hers ever make comments that they have wheras the others don't?

I think she needs to think about what it would feel like if her own kids were the ones who were left behind... at that point wouldn't she want her children to receive additional stuff?

OkThenJustChill · 13/12/2021 23:19

Maybe instead of spoiling them OP, you should instead put some money aside for them for unj/house deposit. Your partner doesn't need to know how much you've contributed. It could even be a joint amount from you and your DC's mum. I would even privately explain to your DC that this is your intention. They might remember their step siblings being spoilt wnen they're older but they'll thank you in the long run.

Lockdownbear · 13/12/2021 23:18

Your DC are old enough, from what you say, to understand that their circumstances are not the same as your partner's DC.

How are the circumstances different?
4 teens, in a blended family.
2 get £300 from Mum and shedloads from dad.
2 get probably not too much from Mum and £300 from Dad.

This Dad can afford to and wants to give more to his kids. But is being stopped by the step mum who's probably quite happy her kids have the latest consoles etc

FrothyDragon · 13/12/2021 21:35

I know you don't want your DC to feel that they're missing out. And with the love you're showing them, how could they be?

It's difficult to see how much your DP's ex is putting into his children and knowing there's a disparity. But that's not your gap to fill. He isn't setting the bar higher for you; he's doing what he feels is right for his DC, and he's within his rights to. That's not something you need to "catch up" to.

Your DC are old enough, from what you say, to understand that their circumstances are not the same as your partner's DC. Go easy on yourself. If you want to spend more on your DC, do it because you want to, not because you need to fill some gap that's created by your partner's ex.