Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that many women have had a ‘lucky escape’?

93 replies

Sweetlikejollof · 12/12/2021 23:04

I’ve been thinking about this recently - have you ever broken up with someone and thought ‘that was a lucky escape’?

Years ago, I dated this guy for about a month/six weeks. Extremely wealthy, recently divorced, older (late twenties v mid thirties). He was very full on, doing what I now recognise as love bombing, but at the time was very flattering. Dozens of roses sent to my office after our first date, etc.

He was incredibly controlling, to the extent he tried to order for me at restaurants a few times (I demurred), once tried to tell me what to wear on a date (I demurred), and complained when I changed my hairstyle ‘without discussing it’.

He loved to ‘debate’ me, and would come up with the most ludicrous hypothetical arguments to bait me, then congratulate me for ‘standing up for myself’ and being ‘possibly even smarter than him’.

He wanted me to meet his five year old daughter almost immediately (I refused, point blank), and referred to his ex wife in extremely uncomplimentary terms. I once saw a picture and we were extremely similar in appearance- I was just a decade younger.

He made weird jokes about how he could track me/read my messages if he wanted (he worked in tech), but wouldn’t because he trusted me.

There’s much much more, but you get the picture! He was gorgeous and I was very flattered by him, and being swept off to dinner at a Michelin starred restaurant or tea at the Ritz is pretty fun. I felt like I was in a film.

However, even with all that, I cannot believe that I dated someone so awful for more than a month. I finally came to my senses and dumped him - and I have never felt such relief. It’s insane, but as soon as I sent the ‘we’re done, it’s not me, it’s you’ text (yes, I dumped him over text and have zero regrets), I felt like a weight had been lifted. It was only a few weeks, but he was this weird oppressive presence and - knowing what I now know about abusive behaviour - I’m extremely certain that my life would have turned out horribly if I’d stayed with him. I have no doubt that he’s honed his tactics and is currently making someone else utterly miserable.

Have any of you had similar lucky escapes?

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 13/12/2021 07:35

This thread is prime Daily Fail/tabloid material and I suspect that's why earlier posters have chosen not to share all the details.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 13/12/2021 07:15

I broke up with a long term partner before we got married and had kids for what at the time were the wrong reasons (I basically met someone else) in hindsight starting a family with him would have been a disaster. He had mental health issues, was not picking up his share of the running of the house, was terrible with money, and was just a bit of a man child really. Now I do have a child I realise how hard it would have been with him, compared to my new partner who is incredibly supportive.

It does make me think back though, 2 months into our relationship he dumped me for no good reason, I gave him another chance and admittedly he didn't cause any such drama again. But I don't think I would do that again now I'm older and wiser.

HoseMeDownWithHolyWater · 13/12/2021 06:57

My first boyfriend from 16-19. He was controlling and physically abusive. He tried to talk me into having a baby with him when he sensed he was losing me.

We're in our 30s now and he's got two children with his partner. I often see her (we both still live in close proximity) and wonder if he treats her how he treated me. I sincerely hope not.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 13/12/2021 05:51

Yes I was head over heels for a guy I met at uni. I didnt even see the red flags before I reflected on it with my MN knowledge. We never actually started dating and with hindsight im v v glad.

LaurenKelsey · 13/12/2021 05:06

After my marriage ended I tried online dating. God, what a bunch of absolute losers I had messaging me. I started seeing one good-looking man for three or four months and we had a lot of fun, but there were things that really bothered me. He was cheap, perfectly happy if I paid for meals, tickets, anything. He was also very hands-off and seemed to have phobic issues with germs and physical contact. He was less educated and uninformed about the world around him, was intelligent enough but couldn’t be bothered to learn anything. I gave up on him and decided I was done with men. I’ve since lived a very lovely single life and thoroughly enjoyed it! 😬

TiddlesTheTiger · 13/12/2021 04:30

My DD started dating a guy.
One evening, they told me that he had been wrongly accused of assaulting his sister and would be in court for it some time in the future.
My DD fully believed he was innocent, especially as she'd had dinner with him & his mum - and the mum had said the sister was making a fuss about nothing.
They split up - I'm not sure of the details there.
Then a few months later there was a report in the local paper.
The guy was found guilty of sexually assaulting a woman and got 2 years in jail.

Moonkatz · 13/12/2021 03:46

When I was younger I dating a few guys before I met my DP. I’m not sure any of them were viable. Some were pretty awful; mean, controlling etc. Others were not horrible but rubbish boyfriends who didn’t value me in any way or were dead beat. One ending up a drug addict, one went to prison for a while. One was a stoner, probably dealing with emotional issues, completely emotionally unavailable. He’s has turned his life around, has a phd now but is still commitment phobic. Ladies do not waste time on guys like that, if they are avoident, unavailable then no matter how else they are they aren’t for you.

One guy was sexy, funny and a bad boy, I was besotted with him for a while but it was a pure sexual attraction and I didn’t actually like him that much when the list subsided. He was rough and unkind, depressed and paranoid from years of drug abuse. But I wanted his baby for a hot minute.

One was abusive, I dated him for six months before getting out. Years later I met another ex of his in another country who had been with him for 7 years and he’d put her though hell. In the end she’d fled abroad to escape him. Yikes! She is well and flourishing now!

Another couple were nice guys but not right for me and after an initial attraction there was no real connection between us. One was a friend I should never have got involved with he liked me and I started dating him on a whim and I ended up really hurting him, which I regret.

It was a rough ride with those guys and I did have some dodged bullets but I do feel that my experience with men helped me recognise a good thing when I found it in DP. I’m also glad I got out when I did!

Graphista · 13/12/2021 02:54

@Ariann a friend of mine had a similar experience though not quite as bad. The man in question married her bigamously and when she attempted to divorce him is when she discovered this. Also discovered she didn't even know his real name! He was apparently a very well known con artist with a side hustle in forging documentation! Zero indication of any of this while they were together we were all gobsmacked!

Graphista · 13/12/2021 02:48

Bullet dodged moments ?

Absolutely!

There was the rugby player who I suspected was a closeted gay from a v religious family who claimed he didn't believe in sex before marriage as a result but I noticed he never got aroused when we were together not ever. There were some other clues too...8 months after breakup comes out as gay (and sadly ostracised by his family) he's now married to a lovely chap that a friend of mine was once engaged to!

The wealthy playboy who loved that lifestyle just a little too much - disappeared into coke addiction a few years after we'd split

The love bombing older man who proposed after three weeks! Then sulked for a week when I said it was too soon when he stopped sulking I dumped him. He married the next lass he met and she was pregnant within 2 months of them getting together. Marriage lasted 18 months and I heard she left cos he was controlling and very intense

The seemingly quiet, polite chap who when we went to the cinema for our 2nd date refused to watch anything with a black lead actor! (I actually walked away from that one then and there!)

Oh yes and the piece de resistance the again seemingly nice normal chap who I really liked and then he appeared on tv...on crimewatch! I literally threw up on that one! For a violent burglary too! (And yes I did phone the police when I recognised him they already had plenty of witnesses though, he wasn't the brightest either! He'd looked right at the cctv with no disguise of any kind on! So everyone he'd ever met was phoning in!)

I think most women (and a fair number of men) have a story or 2!

My brother caught one lass he was dating just a few weeks into their relationship poking holes in his condoms

Another tried to pass off her home as owned by her and tried to get him to lend her money due to "cash flow" problems and when she sold the house she'd pay him back - she was renting

Another had a TERRIFYING temper...

If I ever have daughters, I’m going to do my very best to make sure I raise them to be non-compliant and have zero tolerance for this sort of garbage.

My dd is 20 and I genuinely worry I've made her TOO picky! She's debating her current beau because he has a different sense of humour to her! Not offensive in anyway he just likes rather juvenile slapsticky stuff whereas she prefers more observational sarcastic style which he doesn't really get. By her account in every other way he's lovely so I've reminded her she isn't perfect either! Grin

HollowTalk · 13/12/2021 02:18

@TonyThreePies having sex with you with a deliberately broken condom in order to get you pregnant is rape.What a horrible horrible man.

Ilady · 13/12/2021 01:56

I am thinking of the lucky escape that one of my friends had.
She knew this man for a long time and they ended up getting together one night. He knew that she wanted to have a relationship with him and he kept her on standby between his other girlfriends.
My friend asked him to meet her one day and he cancelled at the last minute and gave a poor excuse.
She then found out that he had a new girlfriend via someone they both knew.
Within a few months of this his new girlfriend was pregnant and he was delighted with this.
Its a few years ago since this happened. My friend found out a few things about this man and all was not as it appeared in his life. He refused to listen to advice he was given and is now dealing with the fallout of this.
The best thing was he contacted my friend about 18 months ago and within a short period of time he wanted to get into a fwb situation. My friend declined his kind offer as he is still living with the mother of his child. She not willing to take him and a young child on.
She told me that's what happens when you rush into having a baby with a woman you barely know and the day to day reality kicks in.

Nowayoutonlydown · 13/12/2021 01:53

I met a man when I was 18, he was 32, fell for him, hook line and sinker, life was like a little romantic film for today first couple of months, then he became a bit weirdly possessive, left me covered in love bites If he wouldn't see me for a few days, told me one day it was him marking me as his possession. At that point I started to realise that everyone had a point, it wasn't really funny. I'd have in excess of 10 love bites all over my neck. Then he cut my hair as we were watching TV. Just took a massive chunk out of it. All the while, he was telling me how a love like ours was special, he would never leave me, we were trying to have a baby....all far too quickly!

Then he just disappeared. This was about 7 months into our relationship.

I found out later that he got someone else pregnant and he couldn't tell me so he just left.

Lucky escape! I'd have never had any sort of life with him.

Ariann · 13/12/2021 01:37

I had come out of a relationship and was enjoying being young and single, living with friends in a beautiful, safe, clean city and going out after work every night.

I met a young man in a pub. He was a "settled gypsy" from a big family housed all over the city. He was very funny and good company and asked me to go out with him the next night. I went and there was something about him - like he could see right through me. He seemed to know things about me that only I knew. We went out for the next six months, after work, all the time. He had an awful lot of money. He didn't talk about his work and I didn't talk about mine One night though, he said "You don't need to do that job - I'll look after you". I just laughed.

He went everywhere by taxi - he would not walk 50 metres. I think he had a taxi to himself. I didn't understand why - he just said "It's for convenience".

One night he was due to call and take me for dinner. He never came. I never saw him again. I tried to call him - phone was always off. I went to his house and no-one would ever answer the door to me.

I was very, very upset by it all, because actually I was very attached to him - I loved him.

He had disappeared off the planet. I didn't see him in our usual places or pubs. No-one knew where he had gone.

One year later, and I read in the local paper that he was very high up in the drug trade and had been in court for two counts of attempted murder. He was found not guilty of both. Another murder occurred, that of his "best friend" and he was charged with that and found not guilty again. Then he vanished.

I found out later from a nightclub owner that he had been living with his long term partner (from another gypsy family) for 8 years - so - all the time he had been seeing me.

I think of him often still, twenty years later.
I had a lucky escape as I got away from the situation unscathed (almost).

JeffThePilot · 13/12/2021 01:26

One guy I met on a night out, good looking, seemed witty and interesting. Swapped numbers, agreed to meet up. Texted back and forth a bit but I got put off by how intense he was getting over text, so I cooled it and declined his invite to meet for dinner.

He went bonkers, sending me streams of ranting texts, even sending them from a friends phone after I blocked him.

I asked around and found out he was actually married. Threatened to tell his wife. The texts stopped and I never heard from him again.

Lucky escape for me. Not so much for his wife.

Frozenlikeablockofmarble · 13/12/2021 01:25

My first serious boyfriend at uni had - in retrospect - a controlling streak, but it never washed with me. It got very serious but we were both too young. As an example, we went out for afternoon tea and he moaned at me because I drank coffee. Not the done thing (I’ve never liked tea). I insisted on my choice of drink, and said he was the one spoiling it by making a fuss.

We went out for dinner with his best friend, also a fellow student. He moaned at his friend for having tea after dinner, as it was also ‘not the done thing’. I stuck up for his friend - honestly how the pair of us put up with him I do not know, as it seemed to me to be the opposite of good manners to adversely comment on what others were having, as the point of manners is to make others feel at ease. After a few incidents like this I broke up with him . . .

As it happened, I was very friendly with his parents, who were lovely people, and that friendship persisted until their deaths. They came to my wedding with now DH and told my parents - slightly tactlessly we felt, but we did all, DH included, have a good laugh about it - “I should have been their DIL.” And I think I had a lucky escape. I would have been forever standing my ground with him, so wearing.

Come to think of it, on my first date with DH I was struck by how he just didn’t make any comment about my food choices, which I was primed for (as I have a form of ARFID which people absolutely feel compelled to comment on). It was so refreshing I felt at home with him from the start.

It’s the first time I’ve actively thought about the difference between the two of them, so yes, in retrospect, very glad I didn’t pursue it further as it would only have got worse, and about more serious things. I wonder if he grew out of all that snobby controlling rubbish - I hope so, for his wife’s sake.

nettie434 · 13/12/2021 01:22

Just to make it totally clear, I meant the ending, not your experience with the horrible controlling chap!

nettie434 · 13/12/2021 01:19

Oh TokenGinger, that is 💖💖💖. As Sweetlikejollof says, it would make a great film!

Lordoftheflyingpan · 13/12/2021 01:18

@TokenGinger … did we date the same guy? My experience is so similar. Very well-educated, professional job, good looking, well liked… and terrifyingly manipulative.

Mine was very controlled most of the time but would have outbursts. He started lashing out in frustration. Throwing things. Breaking things. Not hitting me, never me, but my environment.

He broke up with me because he was “worried one day he’s going to hit me and if he did that he would get in so much trouble because everyone always takes the woman’s side it’s so biased towards women”.

AcrossthePond55 · 13/12/2021 01:12

I've had more than a few 'no second/third dates', as I'm sure most of us have. And a short marriage when I was young and stupid that was also a lucky escape.

My main lucky escape was in the early 80s. I was dating a guy I knew was a coke dealer (LA club scene, wealthy clientele) but he kept me away from the 'business end'. I started getting 'skittish' when he started to leave a couple of (big, hulking) 'pals' at his house with me 'to keep you company' when he left to 'transact business' (ie see his suppliers). Then these 'pals' started hanging around the clubs we went to when we were there. My 'skittishness' developed into a sense of real danger so I broke off the relationship.

He skipped town abruptly a few months later on the run from some 'wise guys' he'd burned in a drug deal. And those 'pals'? They were 'protection' but things got too hot for him to stick around.

Lord, the 80s were something!!!

Sweetlikejollof · 13/12/2021 00:53

@TonyThreePies How utterly terrifying. What a loon!

@TokenGinger Well, that had a rather fabulous ending! If that were a film, I’d watch it! Grin

@HesBoughtAFuckingHat Then I suppose you and I have different metrics regarding what constitutes a lucky escape.

OP posts:
HesBoughtAFuckingHat · 13/12/2021 00:46

I’m not sure if I would consider that to be a lucky escape. It was just a brief relationship with someone who you quickly realised was a dickhead. I’m sure almost everyone - male and female have experienced this.

NameChanger54321 · 13/12/2021 00:44

God, yes. When I look back now, I think, what was wrong with me? How did I allow myself to be treated so terribly?

He was awful. He was very, very intelligent in terms of being book smart, but his emotional intelligence was way off. He was most put out that I didn't go to university and earned a higher salary than him and had bought my own house quite young, despite the fact he had a PhD and said her had a much higher earning potential than me, and had to make sure he was better than me at everything else.

He'd watch the tv with subtitles on and whenever he saw a long word, he pause the TV and asked me what it meant. If I didn't know, he'd make me Google it, then a week later he'd ask me again what it meant and if I'd forgotten, he'd tell me he just wasn't sure I was smart enough to mother his children.

He had a female friend who he somehow managed to make me believe it was okay for him to sleep at her house once a week because he liked to go there for a smoke and didn't want to go home - of course now with more self respect I can see he was cheating on me.

He was very controlling and a cock lodger, too. He'd want me to travel to his place (HMO) most nights to stay, despite me having my own place where we could be alone and he'd always ask me to pick up food alone. Financially, I was crippled. I was just earning enough to pay a mortgage alone, bills etc, fuel for work. Then having to pay to feed him most nights was just so hard. I understood feeding him when he was at mine, but the fact he'd want me to buy food for his place too was just utter cheek.

He expected everything for free. He had a gym membership that allowed him access to two gyms and he'd always cheat the system by changing his second gym to a different one so he could go elsewhere. Once, he changed it to my gym but the change didn't compute in time. We arrived at the gym at 6am and he was so, so rude to the PT who let him in. He then needed a code to get into the toilets and again, was so rude. "For fuck sake man, you know I'd need a code so why let me get all of the way to the changing rooms to have to come back to get you to let me in?" I apologised profusely to the PT. I was so embarrassed.

We went on holiday and he said to me, I'm just not sure I only want to have sex with you for the rest of my life. I love you so much and want to stay with you but I think I want sex with other people, so I want you to know that I will begin to have sex outside of the relationship. That was the start of the end for me. I just had to pluck up the courage to end it. Luckily, he did it for me. When we got home from holiday, we were at his place and we're mid-episode of a series. He said to me can you go and make dinner now? I said not yet, I'm enjoying this, let's watch this episode. And he got up, went downstairs, cooked himself some food and came back upstairs and sat eating it next to me. I said have you really just made yourself food and not me? He said what the fuck is wrong with you? You're illogical. You just said you didn't want food yet, you wanted to watch tv, so why would I make you food if you didn't want food? I'd brought us both two chocolate bars each. He finished the food and ate his two chocolate bars. Then said he wanted more, he said can you pass me a chocolate bar from over there (at this point I didn't realise he had eaten his two). I said, I can't see yours, would you like one of mine instead? And he flipped. "One of mine? What the fuck is wrong with you? Why are you so possessive of a chocolate bar? Why are you trying to make out that I am greedy and have to make a point of letting me know it's your chocolate bar I'm eating?" Then he threw it at me, full force and told me to get the fuck out and it was over.

I count myself lucky because I clearly didn't have the self respect to end it myself, so it was a blessing that he ended it.

I'm very happy to say that six years later, I'm very happily settled with a little boy and my lovely partner who just so happens to be that lovely PT I had to apologise to profusely.

LetterBug · 13/12/2021 00:42

Great thread!!

Yousexybugger · 13/12/2021 00:33

Had a date planned this week that didn't happen, I turned up but he was delayed at work and it eventually got later than I wanted to wait so I decided to go home. I let him know this politely by text. He hadn't left work by that point so hadn't gone out of his way.

I got a whiny, petulant, blame shifting voice note about how I was obviously very frustrated and not communicating this with him. None of it was his fault (it was his fault he was late, not intentional and no hard feelings from me, but nobody else involved), and he was the one that should be upset. I got such seriously odd vibes!! He also tried to claim I had got the time wrong (I hadn't).

There were a couple of other things about him that had raised flags but I have honestly never felt such a strong urge to block someone in my life! He could've been the world's nicest man having a bad day but that felt like a real lucky escape to me.

Sweetlikejollof · 13/12/2021 00:30

@HelloBunny Oh, I had one of those! 😂 I was bored out of my mind, but he was a sweetheart. I’m not quite sure if I’d count mine as a lucky escape, as opposed to just a relationship that didn’t pan out. I’m fairly certain I’d have made him thoroughly miserable and he didn’t deserve that!

OP posts: