Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Get boosted...but still nothing for under 12s?

110 replies

Cutie101 · 12/12/2021 20:14

As a primary school teacher, AIBU to ask why on earth we still aren't vaccinating young children? My own child's year group has closed as almost half the year group have tested positive over over last week including a teacher (not omicron).
I have children hugging me, fingers up nose and all over everything all day every day, but still I am basically working in a petri dish. This is a disaster waiting to happen. This is crazy.

OP posts:
TremoloGreen · 14/12/2021 13:58

Well, if you're happy to have repeated school closures, class closures, teachers off sick/self-isolating, and regular periods of self-isolation for you and your child, then go ahead, don't vaccinate.

I only hope that when the vaccination is available for the over-5s that they keep the schools open for the vaccinated kids.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 14/12/2021 13:55

@FortniteBoysMum you said Yes the elderly relative of these children need protecting. That is why these relatives have been offered the vaccine

Not all the vulnerable are old. And immunosuppressed people, half a million of them, do not necessarily have antibodies after repeated vaccination.

Pedalpushers · 14/12/2021 13:55

People don't seem to understand that societal vaccination is not, and never has been, about individual protection against disease. The entire concept of a vaccination programme is about reducing the pool of those available to be infected to eliminate the spread of a disease in the population, something we are currently not doing. The problem is that covid, under the true definition of vaccination, can't be vaccinated against, as people don't develop full or long term immunity. So we have this weird halfway house pushing the emphasis onto individual protection and a neverending cycle of boosters as these conditions provide pressure for the virus to mutate. We've built an enormous rod for our backs.

Chachasha · 14/12/2021 13:53

Completely agree. And there's evidence Omicron spreads fastest in this age group without any reassurance there are no longer term health implications. Meanwhile other countries have successfully vaccinated under 12s and shown it is not an issue. Very rare myocardial issues are almost always successfully addressed in a short time frame. Meanwhile it is unfortunately not the case that children don't become ill and die with Covid and there is evidence the virus has mutated to use children as a host more effectively.

It's scandalous.

SheikhMaraca · 14/12/2021 13:47

@TremoloGreen

Exactly. Don't think you understand how public health decisions are reached. School closures are not just political by any means.

If you want an example of how overall 'public benefit' decisions are used to make decisions in the UK's national vaccination programme, consider the Varicella vaccine which is approved for infant over 12 months but not adopted in UK for the general population (only those considered high risk for complication from chickenpox). Why? Because it's beneficial to keep chickenpox in the general population... for adults who have previously contracted chickenpox, being exposed to children with the condition gives an immunity boost that reduces the risk of shingles (which is much more likely to cause complications, peripheral nerve damage etc). Simply put, when it was costed, it's more expensive for people to have shingles than for children to have chickenpox, which is generally a mild disease (high-risk children excepted per policy).

Sorry if you don't like that, but that's exactly how it works... and isn't necessarily unreasonable IMHO. I think I already said that I feel my children are more likely to suffer harm from a patchy education/ limited social opportunities than from a COVID vaccination. At a population level you also have to think of harm to all childrens' education, social development, risk of abuse, risk of poverty because parents lose jobs/money due to lockdowns, being affected by parental mental health problems etc.

This is such a worrying post, and another example of the faulty reasoning behind our response to the pandemic.

Put simply, Two wrongs don’t make a right. Just because we have unreasonably made children suffer unnecessarily in scenario A, that cannot be used as justification to do a similar, equally unreasonable thing in scenario B.

(You’re factually right though, which is why my DC received the varicella vaccine privately)

montysma1 · 14/12/2021 13:46

Or if you have no understanding of how viruses spread maybe you should button it.
She signed up to be a teacher. She didnt sign up to endanger herself and ger family.

SheikhMaraca · 14/12/2021 13:41

@SaltedCaramelHC

you can when it's part of general health, including mental health.
Politics can never be a consideration in medicine, of any form…what a dreadful suggestion.
OMG12 · 14/12/2021 13:23

Inflammation not inflation!

FortniteBoysMum · 14/12/2021 13:22

Yes the elderly relative of these children need protecting. That is why these relatives have been offered the vaccine. My child should not be put at risk by having a vaccine that may not be safe for him to benefit someone else who can protect themselves. My son has a heart condition and the risk of myocarditis if he has the vaccine terrifies me. His older brother at 15 is vaccinated to reduce the risk to his sibling because the risk to him is far less likely to be serious. However My youngest will not be having the vaccine. These jabs are not risk free. My mother had her booster and went blind for 10 minutes. They thought she suffered a stroke. 3 weeks on she has had several rounds of blood tests mri scans the lot to determine why she is still in excruciating pain with a severe headache ever since. They suspect a possible bleed on the brain but it seems the doctor request one type of scan whilst the hospital carries out another. This means no result is conclusive. Hence why I will not risk my child's health for a vaccine. And no I am not anti vaccinations I had my booster Saturday. Its about the risks being assessed correctly. My child is unlikely to suffer seriously from covid so he will not be vaccinated but to reduce his risk of infection we have all received the jab.

OMG12 · 14/12/2021 13:22

I’d much much rather see these vaccines being given to third world countries where vulnerable people are still without any vaccine.

If it is sanctioned for under 12s I really think that any covid passport should not be linked to jabs for under 12s. I have been v Ill since my 2nd jab, I know lots of people who have, doctors just brush it off with “it’s not a noted side effect” well it never will be noted at this rate, even though blood tests have now proven the inflation I have been complaining of since my second jab, it’s still not being taken seriously.

My 9 year old is not at risk of covid why vaccinate him? It won’t stop him passing it on.

XmasElf10 · 14/12/2021 13:10

The vaccine is not approved by MHRA for use in under 12s yet. Due to the lower risk of Covid in the under 12s I am not surprised that the agency wanted more time to consider. Now that fDA and EMA have approved and there is real world evidence from a large body of administrations I’d expect to see approval soon.

Cosmois · 14/12/2021 12:39

I won't be vaccinating my kids for the benefit of others! I don't care how selfish that sounds.

TremoloGreen · 14/12/2021 12:34

Exactly. Don't think you understand how public health decisions are reached. School closures are not just political by any means.

If you want an example of how overall 'public benefit' decisions are used to make decisions in the UK's national vaccination programme, consider the Varicella vaccine which is approved for infant over 12 months but not adopted in UK for the general population (only those considered high risk for complication from chickenpox). Why? Because it's beneficial to keep chickenpox in the general population... for adults who have previously contracted chickenpox, being exposed to children with the condition gives an immunity boost that reduces the risk of shingles (which is much more likely to cause complications, peripheral nerve damage etc). Simply put, when it was costed, it's more expensive for people to have shingles than for children to have chickenpox, which is generally a mild disease (high-risk children excepted per policy).

Sorry if you don't like that, but that's exactly how it works... and isn't necessarily unreasonable IMHO. I think I already said that I feel my children are more likely to suffer harm from a patchy education/ limited social opportunities than from a COVID vaccination. At a population level you also have to think of harm to all childrens' education, social development, risk of abuse, risk of poverty because parents lose jobs/money due to lockdowns, being affected by parental mental health problems etc.

SaltedCaramelHC · 14/12/2021 07:45

you can when it's part of general health, including mental health.

SheikhMaraca · 14/12/2021 00:14

@TremoloGreen

I think we should vaccinate over-5s and I'm sure the recommendation will come in the next few months.

Data from the now millions of children aged 5-11 who have had the vaccine suggests cases of myocarditis are vanishingly rare and manageable where they do occur.

The risk of severe COVID may be low for children but the effects of repeated lockdowns and school closures on them also need to be taken into account.

I think I would probably get it for my primary aged children. I'd rather that than another couple of years of patchy education and social development, the last lockdown really affected my youngest. My only worry is that the uptake probably won't be high enough to prevent that anyway. Mine have missed so much school this year between lockdowns, self-isolating, year groups being closed down and then having COVID.

This is an unacceptable twisting of medical science.

You cannot take political considerations (school closures) into account when weighing up medical decisions (to vaccinate or not)

It’s shocking that people are so ignorant as to even consider it.

Unmerited · 13/12/2021 16:42

@Chely

Working with children has always been a muggy job though, why on earth you are now so bloody scared is stupid. Get your jabs and feel protected, do not think children should be forced to have a vaccine that will offer them little benefit just so you can feel better.
I agree though that it might have been unnecessary for that age group - if all of the adults who could have it had done so as soon as they were eligible.
Unmerited · 13/12/2021 16:41

@Chely

Working with children has always been a muggy job though, why on earth you are now so bloody scared is stupid. Get your jabs and feel protected, do not think children should be forced to have a vaccine that will offer them little benefit just so you can feel better.
Hmm, it’s almost as though something is different now, but what? Can’t quite think. Been on the news I’m sure 🤔
Unmerited · 13/12/2021 16:39

@Lion1618

As a primary school teacher, I'm not in the slightest bit worried about the little ones I teach passing on their germs to me. At no point before, during or since my training have I found it acceptable to treat them in that way. Perhaps you should ask yourself why you're still in this job if you're that horrified to be around them.
She didn’t even remotely say that.
beentoldcomputersaysno · 13/12/2021 16:38

Agree OP. The need is exacerbated by no other protections for this age group.

SloeFox · 13/12/2021 16:17

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

the ones who have died have largely already been very sick

^^
This comment really upsets me though. It should be offered at least to those with underlying conditions. Why on Earth does it matter less that children have died because they’re “very sick”? Their lives matter just as much.

I agree.
Chely · 13/12/2021 15:07

Working with children has always been a muggy job though, why on earth you are now so bloody scared is stupid. Get your jabs and feel protected, do not think children should be forced to have a vaccine that will offer them little benefit just so you can feel better.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2021 15:06

the ones who have died have largely already been very sick

^^
This comment really upsets me though. It should be offered at least to those with underlying conditions. Why on Earth does it matter less that children have died because they’re “very sick”? Their lives matter just as much.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/12/2021 15:05

I think it’s because they don’t really get sick with it

However, they are missing precious education by having to isolate when they get Covid, albeit mildly. So I think on balance it should be offered.

No one will make anyone give it to their child so I think it’s good to have the choice as it’s been found to be safe.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 13/12/2021 15:00

The JCVI haven't given advice on vaccinating 5-11 AFAIK @wasthataburp and the advice they gave for the 12-15 group was that the benefits marginally outweighed the risks for healthy children.

Hemingwayscatz · 13/12/2021 14:54

They don’t need a vaccine. They virtually never die, the ones who have died have largely already been very sick. My DC are under 12 and just had covid, bounced it off as easily as I did in my early 30s. It’s a mild illness for most people, children most of all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread