Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Get boosted...but still nothing for under 12s?

110 replies

Cutie101 · 12/12/2021 20:14

As a primary school teacher, AIBU to ask why on earth we still aren't vaccinating young children? My own child's year group has closed as almost half the year group have tested positive over over last week including a teacher (not omicron).
I have children hugging me, fingers up nose and all over everything all day every day, but still I am basically working in a petri dish. This is a disaster waiting to happen. This is crazy.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
curtains15 · 16/12/2021 14:25

I think you will be in for a shock op as when they do bring it in there will be a very low uptake.

Spruceifer · 16/12/2021 14:06

"And so it begins. All the “it’ll be a choice”! “Just give parents the choice!” people soon display their true coercive colours. My main concern is that it won’t be a true choice because people like you will get their way and access to society will become contingent on vaccination for even the youngest children. I would fully support other people who assess the risk/benefit decision around vaccination differently vaccinating their 5 year olds, but not if there’s a chance it’s going the way you want it to - if it’s not a real choice then none of them should have it (bar medical exceptions)."

Yes, precisely what I have been thinking, you can almost set your clock by how predictable it all is.. 😔

Spruceifer · 16/12/2021 14:05

"And so it begins. All the “it’ll be a choice”! “Just give parents the choice!” people soon display their true coercive colours. My main concern is that it won’t be a true choice because people like you will get their way and access to society will become contingent on vaccination for even the youngest children. I would fully support other people who assess the risk/benefit decision around vaccination differently vaccinating their 5 year olds, but not if there’s a chance it’s going the way you want it to - if it’s not a real choice then none of them should have it (bar medical exceptions)."

Yes, precisely what I have been thinking, you can almost set your clock by how predictable it all is.. 😔

SheikhMaraca · 16/12/2021 13:25

@TremoloGreen

Those who will not 'have a child vaccinated for others benefit', a genuine question:

Did you also refuse to have your child vaccinated for rubella?

When I was a child, we all routinely caught rubella, it was called 'german measles'. Its not harmful to children (its usually milder than chickenpox) but can have long lasting effects for adult women and devastating effects for developing fetuses.

The risk to the child from Rubella (and Polio, measles diphtheria etc) far outweighs the risk of the vaccine, so yes, the cost benefit analysis for the child themselves stacks up and my DC had all of them.

The fact that there were also benefits to others was a nice bonus.

My DC were born in the pre-meningitis vaccine era, but given what an awful disease it is, I would absolutely have given it to them too, even as a brand new, straight out of phase 1 trials vaccine. Although there is (I believe still now) incomplete long term data in its safety, I can’t envision a vaccine that would ever be as much of a threat to a child as the meningitis itself, so the cost/benefit would still stack up for me.

The point is, whatever logical gymnastics you do, there is simply no clinical benefit to a child from having a covid vaccine, so there is no justification to take the risk.

TremoloGreen · 15/12/2021 21:01

Sorry, we didn't all routinely get it (like chickenpox) but it was commonplace.

TremoloGreen · 15/12/2021 21:00

Those who will not 'have a child vaccinated for others benefit', a genuine question:

Did you also refuse to have your child vaccinated for rubella?

When I was a child, we all routinely caught rubella, it was called 'german measles'. Its not harmful to children (its usually milder than chickenpox) but can have long lasting effects for adult women and devastating effects for developing fetuses.

SheikhMaraca · 15/12/2021 11:05

@MabelsApron

I always find it strange when people say "if you don't like being at risk, leave your job", because if everyone did that, who'd teach their kids?
I think it’s more of a case of expecting teachers to get a grip, rather than leave their jobs.

It’s actually pretty concerning that the people teaching the next generation seem to have such a poor grasp of critical thinking and the evaluation of evidence.

Teachers are, by definition, of working age, and therefore in an age bracket where the CFR of covid is 0.15%.

There is simply no justification for this kind of hysteria, it must be clear why people are losing patience with teachers?

Imtryingveryhard · 14/12/2021 17:33

Maybe it was hoped enough over 12’s would take up the vaccine offer to avoid having to give it to younger children. Quash the spread etc. there have been instances of Covid in my primary age son’s class but he hasn’t caught it. Nits on the other hand are thriving! Thankfully he’s not caught those (yet).

MabelsApron · 14/12/2021 16:03

I always find it strange when people say "if you don't like being at risk, leave your job", because if everyone did that, who'd teach their kids?

Mojoj · 14/12/2021 16:00

Yeah, let's pump chemicals into young kids for a virus which, for them, is no more dangerous than a cold. Because it will stop them passing it onto adults, who are already vaccinated. Oh no wait a minute, vaccinated people can still pass it on....Get a grip. If you're a reacher, you pick up bugs from the kids. Don't like it? Get another job.

Angel2702 · 14/12/2021 15:59

Yes they should be vaccinated but at the moment the priority absolutely has to be boosters in age groups likely to end up in hospital. It isn’t the children putting NHs under pressure.

flapjackfairy · 14/12/2021 15:55

My 7 yr old has v complex medical needs and we are still not able to get him vacinated. We are back in lockdown effectively. Though in reality we have never truly left it !

RobinPenguins · 14/12/2021 15:52

So schools not closed to unvaccinated children, unvaccinated children just aren’t able to access them? It’s the same end result and it doesn’t leave people able to make a genuine choice.

Laila747 · 14/12/2021 15:51

I don’t understand why it’s not ALL secondary school children for a start.,.
My DS is the only one out of his friendship group of 8/9 kids who hasn’t had his jab because he’s 11 not 12. Surely it would have made more sense to just vaccinate all of them?

TremoloGreen · 14/12/2021 15:50

It's different to say that I hope schools will stay open for vaccinated children to saying I hope they close them to unvaccinated.

TremoloGreen · 14/12/2021 15:47

In case not fully clear from last post, I hope we can vaccinate as many people as possible (for whom it's safe) and stop the spread as much as possible so we can all get on with our lives. I think it's actually young people who are missing out the most by the current cycle of restrictions and lockdowns and school closures.

RobinPenguins · 14/12/2021 15:45

@TremoloGreen

I don't want to coerce anyone. I just don't want my children to miss any more school if they don't need to.

You're welcome to make your own choices. Just as I would have to trade off the risks of the vaccination against the risk to my child of missing out educationally, so would you. You might make a different decision - good for you.

The risks to children’s education come primarily from the policy response to the virus, not the virus itself. It is absolutely coercion to say that one group of 5 year olds - not adults, 5 year olds - would have to isolate and the other group wouldn’t. Under those circumstances I would have to have my child vaccinated, against my will, for them to be able to continue to receive an education and for me to be able to continue to work. That’s coercion.
TremoloGreen · 14/12/2021 15:42

I don't want to coerce anyone. I just don't want my children to miss any more school if they don't need to.

You're welcome to make your own choices. Just as I would have to trade off the risks of the vaccination against the risk to my child of missing out educationally, so would you. You might make a different decision - good for you.

FortniteBoysMum · 14/12/2021 15:42

Had my mum been a child and had the reaction she had it could alter their entire life.

FortniteBoysMum · 14/12/2021 15:41

There are a few sides to this. The ones who are vulnerable and the vaccine risks causing them harm ie my youngest son, those who have someone at home who is at a greater risk if they are not vaccinated( why my eldest was vaccinated to reduce risk to his sibling) and those who have no real benefit either way as low risk of serious illness without anyone at real risk at home. These jabs can have serious side effects. As I say my mum is still experiencing these several weeks on.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 14/12/2021 14:46

I think the risk to a child's wellbeing if they bring a virus home from school that kills their vulnerable sibling or parent is significant. You may not @FortniteBoysMum

RobinPenguins · 14/12/2021 14:43

@TremoloGreen

Well, if you're happy to have repeated school closures, class closures, teachers off sick/self-isolating, and regular periods of self-isolation for you and your child, then go ahead, don't vaccinate.

I only hope that when the vaccination is available for the over-5s that they keep the schools open for the vaccinated kids.

And so it begins. All the “it’ll be a choice”! “Just give parents the choice!” people soon display their true coercive colours. My main concern is that it won’t be a true choice because people like you will get their way and access to society will become contingent on vaccination for even the youngest children. I would fully support other people who assess the risk/benefit decision around vaccination differently vaccinating their 5 year olds, but not if there’s a chance it’s going the way you want it to - if it’s not a real choice then none of them should have it (bar medical exceptions).
gogohm · 14/12/2021 14:31

The jvci are considering currently and a decision is expected before Christmas according to the news today

liveforsummer · 14/12/2021 14:23

My dc currently have covid: both asymptomatic. The risk of the illness does not outweigh the risk of the vaccine in my mind. I Wouk the give them it even if it was offered though I assume there's a reason it hasn't been approved. I work in a class of 5/6 year olds and if I get it I get it. If I haven't caught it with dd sleeping in my bed breathing directly in my face all night and stealing my drinks though I doubt the dc wiping their nose on my sleeve at work will manage

FortniteBoysMum · 14/12/2021 14:12

@PastMyBestBeforeDate your right but that does not mean we risk our children suffering serious complications when the risks to them are low.