Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Prívate vs state Primary education

109 replies

ClumpyMascara · 12/12/2021 19:29

DH wants to send twin boys to private Primary school - he was privately educated and I wasn’t, he feels very passionately about it.

While I have no quibble with them going to private secondary, where I do believe you can see the benefits, I don’t see the point in private primary? We have great state primaries near us and the education they will get won’t be that different?

It just seems like a waste of money - we aren’t super well off but his parents are going to help (and agree with him)

Most of our friends have done state primary, private secondary with their children

OP posts:
BananaDrama25 · 12/12/2021 21:03

@AngelicaElizaAndPeggy it's not snobbish, purely observation. They are more confident, have wider interests and, in my experience, are usually more accomplished due to the huge amount of experiences they are exposed to. I didn't say it was a good or bad thing, just that they settle into our school life quicker.... which they do!

Make of it what you will but it's true!

edwinbear · 12/12/2021 20:59

DD (Y5) and DS (Y8) have been in private since nursery/reception, in a straight through school. It's been fantastic for them, small classes, they are both very sporty and the sports facilities are superb. Having their own swimming pool means even in nursery they had weekly swimming lessons. They've been able to compete against other schools since Y3, in netball, hockey, cross country, athletics, swimming, rugby, football, cricket etc etc which was important to us.

It's worth considering how much more competitive it is to get a private secondary school place - mine have to sit the same entrance exam as external candidates to go through to Senior, but it's virtually unheard of for a Junior School pupil not to pass, so there are essentially 60 places already allocated when external candidates take the exam. We didn't have to pay for tutoring. The wraparound is also brilliant (7.30am - 6pm) as the school realise that most families have two incomes to facilitate paying fees. Lockdown provision was outstanding, a full online timetable from Y1 onwards and they haven't fallen behind at all. There are very few behaviour problems, either disruption in class or with friendship groups. Feedback from teachers is detailed and regular and staff are always on hand to speak, if you e mail them, you will receive a response within 24hrs - usually much quicker than that.

I will echo a PP, in that SEN provision isn't great. Fortunately we haven't had to use it, but speaking to other parents, if there are mild needs, they are great, but they are not set up to deal with severe dyslexia/ASD.

It very much varies from school to school though, we looked at state and private and for us, there was no contest, but that's only comparing our local state schools to the privates and what we felt would best suit DC.

welshweasel · 12/12/2021 20:59

Same situation, went for state (outstanding) primary. 4 terms in and DS is starting at the local private school in January. He ended up in a class of 30, with significant behavioural issues in many of the children, and a complete unwillingness to differentiate work for more able pupils. He has barely progressed in the past year. I think we’ve been unlucky but taking him to visit his new school made our minds up really quickly, he said the children were kind and not violent!

cinnamonswirll · 12/12/2021 20:57

The only problem with waiting till secondary is if they need to sit an entrance exam, the state schools won't prep for this. Depending on the number of applicants and how selective the school is, they may not get a place.

If your child is able, I think state till 8 is ideal. Best of both worlds with local friends, part of community, etc. If your dc needs additional support or is likely to struggle then a smaller class will likely benefit them earlier.

seome1984 · 12/12/2021 20:56

I would consider the twin aspect also. Private school possibly 1 small class which means a very small pool of friendships. Perhaps less chance to be independent and autonomous from each other.

Barbie222 · 12/12/2021 20:33

Yeah I agree with you, I've not seen much that's better than state in my experience. I'd save for secondary.

samsalmon · 12/12/2021 20:28

Our local state primary is very sought after, good ofsted etc. The reality once we were in was quite a big let down and we took both kids out half way through. One was bored and had given up on a lot of areas of learning due to being totally uninspired, the other was just cruising along in a very disruptive class, not many friends etc. Best thing we ever did, there is no comparison between the 2 experiences. Both kids are much happier and getting an awful lot more out of their day to day experience. We’re very glad we weren’t still at the local school during lockdown, I know that was a very challenging experience for everyone but by all reports, it didn’t step up at all.

AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 12/12/2021 20:20

*19:59BananaDrama25

I'm SLT in a private senior school and I can assure your there is a massive difference between state and prep educated children. You can spot them a mile off at interview and they settle much better into school life*

What an absolutely ghastly and snobbish thing to say! I hope you are never 'SLT' at any school my children go to; I'd hate for someone who thinks like this to be anywhere near them.

Jessie75 · 12/12/2021 20:19

My eldest three daughters went to private primary school and are still reaping the benefit now at university. I’ve run out of money and got divorced and was unable to send my son the difference is just miles apart, the girls were able to do so much better at senior school because it had all the ground in the primary school done with them. I knew there was absolutely no way we were gonna be able to afFord all the way through so as I say we spent our money laying the foundations and I have absolutely no regrets.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 12/12/2021 20:18

We're sending my DS to a prep school as a way to pass the 11 plus and get a place at a grammar because the secondary schools here are rubbish.

If he was going to go to a normal state secondary then I wouldnt bother with prep.

You need to be aware on the quality levels of schools around you. Jist because they're state doesnt automatically mean they're bad, just like being independant doesnt make them automatically good.

Motheroftigers · 12/12/2021 20:17

I have 2 dc in prep primary. They have received a fantastic foundation level of learning and more. The class sizes are small and I can speak to a teacher on the day at the door if I need to. The school are very very helpful if there are any issues.

My reception child is flying through word cards and two books a week and has maths and English homework twice a week.

Whether they go on to grammar or private secondary they will start year 7 with al the tools and knowledge they need to sprint off and not struggle with holes in their education because state classes are just to big to deliver.

I have spent time in a state school as a TA, it was the main reason why I put them in private. The teacher was fantastic but the class had over 30 children in and there was very little actual bums on seats head down learning. You will be shocked at the amount of time wasted in getting 30+ kids organised.

The teacher was a star and she absolutely did her best but I could see why so many kids leave school not being able to read or write properly.

Investing in private primary is absolutely worth it.

But do your research on the school.

LGY1 · 12/12/2021 20:17

@Totalwasteofpaper our plan is similar. Local primaries are good. High school not so much. We are planning next house move on the basis of high school and putting the money into bigger house / their uni / their houses

Bringonsummer19 · 12/12/2021 20:15

If you earn northwards of £300k then go for private. The class size is amazing and if you are in a competitive area like south west London it’s really hard to get into the good secondary’s without having been helped to prepare.

If your below this sum then I would really think it through

Twilightstarbright · 12/12/2021 20:15

We ended up sending DS to a private primary after we couldn’t get him into any decent state schools. He’s in a class of 20 which is good, and has specialist teachers for music, art, PE, IT and drama. It’s a nurturing school and I’m really happy with it.

rossclare · 12/12/2021 20:14

@ClumpyMascara

I’ll point out that my husband is partially deaf and went to private because of better provision for this

While our boys don’t seem to have any SEN needs, he thinks if something comes up like dyslexia etc then the support would better from what he’s seen

I do t think we should worry about things that might not happen

My children are private (from Y4), it’s a prep, so they’ll stay until end of Y8. It’s the best thing we ever did.

They have lots of local buddies in our village (and I make a big effort to keep in touch with them), and we feel part of a strong community.

The education is amazing, but more so the opportunities to do extras.... tie dye, proper cooking, comic club, Forrest school etc etc.

However, based on the experiences of a few friends, I’m nit sure private is automatically better fir sen.....

Totalwasteofpaper · 12/12/2021 20:04

I believe unless you INCREDIBLY wealthy to the point a 100k here or there doesn’t matter…
if you want to set your kids up you are better off using the money to buy your twins starter homes/flats at uni or post uni vs pay for private education in primary if there is a decent state school option available.

Our plan is decent state primary and private or top state school (we bought our house specifically so these were options)

Bunnycat101 · 12/12/2021 20:03

We’ve got an excellent state primary that parents fight tooth and nail to get into and achieves great outcomes. My daughter is happy and thriving but I’ve recently been to look around the local preps and I’m considering a move at year 3.

Reasons for a move:

  • amazing facilities
  • music provision (no contest between
  • better sport (sport is good at our school compared to most primaries but more specialist provision and a pool at the private)
  • smaller class sizes and less social issues/behavioural problems *attached secondary is one of the schools we’d like for year 7 plus

Reasons to stay

  • saving money and lifestyle reasons
  • child is happy

The thing that will swing it is the level of behavioural issues in the class. There have been quite a few issues with some of the boys in her year which have disrupted her learning. If those issues escalate we’ll look at a move. The other things are nice to have but are a better offer than state can provide. Ultimately it comes down to opportunity cost of fees versus other experiences/uses of the money.

Amberflames · 12/12/2021 20:03

I think class sizes make a massive difference at that age. I just don’t think most state schools can compete on the level of attention kids get in private school, particularly in the earlier years.

Hoppinggreen · 12/12/2021 19:59

We went for State Primary and State Secondary largely based on the quality of schools available to us and we are glad we did.
Both DC experienced a wider range of friends
They both have friends from Primary and different friends from Secondary (in fact DS has integrated the 2)
Both were more streetwise than kids who had been at the school since age 3
DD is finding a large diverse 6th form college easier than some of her peers who had only ever experienced the relatively sheltered environment of 1 small school
We saved a lot of money
I know a lot of people in the community from the DCs time at Primary

There was no attainment gap for them either

BananaDrama25 · 12/12/2021 19:59

I'm SLT in a private senior school and I can assure your there is a massive difference between state and prep educated children. You can spot them a mile off at interview and they settle much better into school life

Chasingaftermidnight · 12/12/2021 19:55

Does the school you are looking at go all the way to sixth form? I had huge concerns about him going from pre school to sixth form in a tiny bubble and then crashing at uni. I’ve seen it happen to my friends and it isn’t always good for them.

Very much agree with this - I joined a school like this aged 13 and most of the kids who’d been in the school from age 3 really struggled after leaving school at 18.

Chasingaftermidnight · 12/12/2021 19:53

We’re in a similar position and have decided on the state primary for the reasons you say. It’s a great primary in a lovely setting and we know loads of parents whose kids are in it or have been through it and no one has a bad word to say about it, so it just seemed silly not to go.

(Also the private primary was single sex and we felt reception age was too early to be in single sex education).

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 12/12/2021 19:51

Agree with you OP- I went to a private school for both but the kids who went to a state primary and then joined my secondary in no way lacked ability and you couldn’t tell really who came from what primary. Save the money/ enjoy the money

LGY1 · 12/12/2021 19:47

My son went to private pre school & we would have considered primary if we saw the benefit, but we didn’t.
He has just started reception in a good local primary and all is going well. No regrets moving him.
I even had need to formally complain about the care at after school club & so did a few other parents, so private doesn’t necessarily mean best / perfect

Does the school you are looking at go all the way to sixth form? I had huge concerns about him going from pre school to sixth form in a tiny bubble and then crashing at uni. I’ve seen it happen to my friends and it isn’t always good for them.

follygirl · 12/12/2021 19:42

I'll echo what a previous poster said. There are good and bad private schools as there are good and bad state schools.

Both of mine have been in private since Reception, my dd is now in Year 13 so nearly at the end. Her school has been exceptional. She has grown into a confident, articulate, empathetic young lady and I couldn't be more delighted. My ds is in year 11. I didn't like his prep school where I felt they wrote him off in part due to his immaturity linked to him being a summer baby. Fast forward to his secondary school where he has truly blossomed, has made great friends, has grown in confidence and is self-motivated.

Would they have done as well at a state school, perhaps. I don't know and I can't answer that question but we are very happy that we chose their schools.